Starvation mode is a myth
Replies
-
Sigh.
Starvation mode is not kids in Africa. That is starvation.
What people call 'Starvation Mode' here is the metabolic slowdown from a reduced calorie intake over an extended period of time. It's a natural response that allows your body to capitalise on periods of Plenty to store food for reserve, in times of Famine.
There are no periods of Plenty in Africa.
Anorexics tend to start at low calories - around 800-900 and drop it as their weightloss slows(aka 'Starvation Mode') (read:not stops) down to dangerous levels, below what their body needs for basic functions like making your heart beat and breathing. It is at this point the energy starts to be taken from muscle and organ tissue to keep up with demand. This is Starvation.0 -
Nutrition, nutrition and nutrition is VERY important all of one's life and is especially important in seniors. Many older people unconsciously adopt a "starvation mode" diet because they get in a vicious cycle of eating less because of poor appetite, which cuts their energy levels and makes them eat even less. They lose their muscle mass as their bodies, starved for nutrients, begin to catabolize their muscles (called sarcopenia) which often leads to falls and bone breakage, which in turn, can be so debilitating, in the case of a broken hip, that they succumb to their injuries. Nutrition and exercise are especially important for seniors as a way of staying reasonably healthy until their bodies just quit. Studies have shown that seniors who are well-nourished and maintain an active lifestyle do not die a lot later than their poorly-nourished and sedentary age-mates. They just spend a lot less time being debilitated.0
-
Wow anorexia is a mental disorder. Not a diet.There are people dying from anorexia on a fairly regular basis. Super low calorie is not the way to go.0 -
Wow anorexia is a mental disorder. Not a diet.There are people dying from anorexia on a fairly regular basis. Super low calorie is not the way to go.
Where did the poster said anorexia is a diet?0 -
This is gonna get good, I can tell.0
-
It's a mental disorder that makes you restrict food intake to dangerous levels. Stop being so intentionally ignorant.
Wow anorexia is a mental disorder. Not a diet.There are people dying from anorexia on a fairly regular basis. Super low calorie is not the way to go.0 -
This is gonna get good, I can tell.
Yup...get the popcorn ready. That's a safe snack right?! LOL0 -
Doesn't exist. Your metabolism slows down due to leptin and thyroid hormones but it doesn't stop. Most people who starve often binge once in a while. If you are hyper dieted your body hyper compensates. For instance, after a body building comp due to water, salt and calories consumed I can put on 28lb in 4 days...0
-
Yay for science.Doesn't exist. Your metabolism slows down due to leptin and thyroid hormones but it doesn't stop. Most people who starve often binge once in a while. If you are hyper dieted your body hyper compensates. For instance, after a body building comp due to water, salt and calories consumed I can put on 28lb in 4 days...0 -
Doesn't exist. Your metabolism slows down due to leptin and thyroid hormones but it doesn't stop. Most people who starve often binge once in a while. If you are hyper dieted your body hyper compensates. For instance, after a body building comp due to water, salt and calories consumed I can put on 28lb in 4 days...0
-
Wow anorexia is a mental disorder. Not a diet.There are people dying from anorexia on a fairly regular basis. Super low calorie is not the way to go.
True. I thought about that after I posted, making a mental connection between starving and anorexia but not thinking it through. My fingers are faster than my brain sometimes.0 -
The topic may be over worked but I still have not seen any scientific proof of it - it is just anecdotal at best or an old wives tale at worst
You did not search very hard then0 -
Thanks for the tip, I always Wondered about that Myth as well just never looed it up.0
-
Registered Texas Dietitian in quotes below on starvation mode. In case you don't know, a Registered Texas Dietitian carries a license that allows him to work and regulate what people eat inside of a prison, hospital, elementary school, retirement home, and other such settings.
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/755899-registered-dietitian-in-tx-here-to-answer-questions?page=16The idea that your body's metabolism will slow down to such an extend that you will not lose weight on a large caloric deficit is complete myth. Some people can make it seem like a reasonable assumption citing metabolic processes, and hormone functions but the real world result is that eating less makes you lose weight. If you are overweight, you do not need to worry about "starvation mode"
Yes. I am a Masters level Registered, Licensed, Dietitian/Nutritionist and I concur. The idea that going below 1200 cals (or whatever someone suspects is their BMR) will cause them to go into "starvation mode" and stop losing and/or gain weight is not true. The reason super low calorie diets don't work for most people long term is that they cannot sustain the low intake and end up eating much more and essentially gaining back whatever they lost. Also, quick weight loss lends itself to loss of lean body mass along with fat, which in turn leads to a lower overall BMR. However the change in BMR is quite small as 1 lb. of muscle burns about 6 cals per day vs 2 for 1 lb. of fat. When the person inevitably returns to higher calorie eating, they tend to gain back fat and not the lost lean body mass (ie: muscle). However, taking in fewer calories significantly from what you burn over a period of time is what leads to desired weight loss.0 -
Regardless whether the starvation mode thing is a myth or not the problem I personally have with very low daily calorie consumption is that my body starts sending off humger signals that are extremely hard to fight and sometimes I end up losing it and eating something I regret just out of pure hunger. If I sustain my eating throughout the day it really makes a difference in the ease of being able to stave off those powerful hunger cravings around evenging time. Thats just me though.0
-
The topic may be over worked but I still have not seen any scientific proof of it - it is just anecdotal at best or an old wives tale at worst
You did not search very hard then
Would you like to explain the science?
Please, be my guest.0 -
The topic may be over worked but I still have not seen any scientific proof of it - it is just anecdotal at best or an old wives tale at worst
You did not search very hard then
Would you like to explain the science?
Please, be my guest.
Are you talking
1) stopping losing weight at any level of calories - that is not true
2) metabolic adaptation, or
3) loss of muscle mass over and above generally 'expected' on a non VCLD diet?
These topics have been discussed and studies showing for 2), some evidence (which is not that extensive I admit) and 3) that there is have been posted many times - hence my comment.0 -
In before the lock!
Starvation Mode is an overused and often misinterpreted term. There is a very real phenomena called adaptive thermogenesis that is the result of eating too little for too long. There are very real consequences in terms of permanent down regulation of metabolism and fouled up hormones but hey if that sounds like fun to you, knock you yourself out! :drinker:0 -
My name is Jacquilin ISOM and I have invented a product I know everyone can benefit from its called "Quick Fit". Quick Fit is an iron on adjustable waistband that allows you to take up at least 3 inches of slack in any garment's waistband. Quick Fit can be ironed into any garment's waistband for an instant secure fit. This product is great for men, women, and children. Quick Fit is very affordable! For a video tutorial visit youtube.com and type quickfitwaistband in the search engine or visit www.quickfitwaistband.com for more info. Thank you !
OMG what a great idea! Let me give you my address, full name, social insurance number and entire monetary worth to obtain enough of this product to get me through the rest of my days.0 -
My name is Jacquilin ISOM and I have invented a product I know everyone can benefit from its called "Quick Fit". Quick Fit is an iron on adjustable waistband that allows you to take up at least 3 inches of slack in any garment's waistband. Quick Fit can be ironed into any garment's waistband for an instant secure fit. This product is great for men, women, and children. Quick Fit is very affordable! For a video tutorial visit youtube.com and type quickfitwaistband in the search engine or visit www.quickfitwaistband.com for more info. Thank you !
yessss....thats what ive been looking for
Bahahhhaaaaaha!!! This just made my day!0 -
Registered Texas Dietitian in quotes below on starvation mode. In case you don't know, a Registered Texas Dietitian carries a license that allows him to work and regulate what people eat inside of a prison, hospital, elementary school, retirement home, and other such settings.
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/755899-registered-dietitian-in-tx-here-to-answer-questions?page=16The idea that your body's metabolism will slow down to such an extend that you will not lose weight on a large caloric deficit is complete myth. Some people can make it seem like a reasonable assumption citing metabolic processes, and hormone functions but the real world result is that eating less makes you lose weight. If you are overweight, you do not need to worry about "starvation mode"
Yes. I am a Masters level Registered, Licensed, Dietitian/Nutritionist and I concur. The idea that going below 1200 cals (or whatever someone suspects is their BMR) will cause them to go into "starvation mode" and stop losing and/or gain weight is not true. The reason super low calorie diets don't work for most people long term is that they cannot sustain the low intake and end up eating much more and essentially gaining back whatever they lost. Also, quick weight loss lends itself to loss of lean body mass along with fat, which in turn leads to a lower overall BMR. However the change in BMR is quite small as 1 lb. of muscle burns about 6 cals per day vs 2 for 1 lb. of fat. When the person inevitably returns to higher calorie eating, they tend to gain back fat and not the lost lean body mass (ie: muscle). However, taking in fewer calories significantly from what you burn over a period of time is what leads to desired weight loss.
I'm a family physician and I also agree.
I have been eating around 1200 calories a day or just under (roughly) since Jun 2012 when I was diagnosed with diabetes and have lost 25kg (55lbs) so far. No slowing down, no plateaus, no starvation mode. I havent even added much exercise yet - I have lupus and my endocrinologist was keen for me to get some weight off before hammering my joints with running or gym work. I am finding it remarkably easy because I have removed starchy high processed carbohydrates from my diet. If you are eating lots of fresh fruit and veg, whole grains, dairy, good fats and lean protein you can actually fit a LOT of food and snacks into 1200 calories. Now I am no expert and I bow to the dietitians on the boards here as far as their specialist knowledge, but I agree- if you eat well you can get enough nutrition in your diet. If you eat crap and processed food you can't.
So I agree - if you are actually STARVING your weight loss will slow as your body adapts, but for most of us here that isnt the case and 1200 is not a magic number at which you starve. BUT if you try and eat under 1200 or 1000 calories a day and you dont know what you are doing, you run the risk of nutritional defiiciency or just getting frustrated and pigging out. I am doing this for the rest of my life and have not cheated - so am seeing slow progressive steady weight loss. This is a lifestyle not a diet and if 1000-1200 works for me I (and my endocrinologist) are more than happy for me to be there.0 -
1 - doesn't exist
2- Metabolic adapation as I describe is the lowered release of leptin and so thyroid hormones
3 - Loss of lean mass is of course likely as its the most 'expensive' form of calorie consumpton that the body doesn't exist
My point was regarding the OP point which it seemed you were referring the starvation mode as existing.0 -
[/quote]
Many people eat 3000 calories a day and still dont get the nutrients they need. More calories does not equal more essential vitamins/minerals/nutrients!
[/quote]
Doesn't necessarily mean more nutrients but the odds of getting more nutrients while eating 3000 calories is SIGNIFICANTLY greater than the odds of getting enough while eating less than 1200 calories.
[/quote]
I am getting FAR MORE nutrients on my 1,200 cal diet than I did with 3 grand of pure garbage.0 -
Depending on your height/weight/age your body burns around 1200 calories a day on its own. Everything you do burns calories. So when you work out if you're eating less than 1200 cals a day, your body technically has no calories to burn so in theory it will burn fat instead, right? The problem is food is technically meant for energy, no food=no energy. No energy means you're damaging your metabolism and slowing it overall.
Here's something that may help you a little, its explaining starvation mode and how it happens over time not immediately. hope that helps answer your questions!
http://www.burnthefatblog.com/archives/2007/11/is-starvation-mode-a-myth-no-its-very-real-and-here-is-the-proof.php0 -
1 - doesn't exist
2- Metabolic adapation as I describe is the lowered release of leptin and so thyroid hormones
3 - Loss of lean mass is of course likely as its the most 'expensive' form of calorie consumpton that the body doesn't exist
My point was regarding the OP point which it seemed you were referring the starvation mode as existing.
It depends on the definition. No one uses it consistently here.0 -
I am getting FAR MORE nutrients on my 1,200 cal diet than I did with 3 grand of pure garbage.
I seriously doubt that. You have your calorie goal set at 900 per day. And you routinely burn most of that off. And 200 of those calories per day are from alcohol.0 -
awwww snap! nice.I am getting FAR MORE nutrients on my 1,200 cal diet than I did with 3 grand of pure garbage.
I seriously doubt that. You have your calorie goal set at 900 per day. And you routinely burn most of that off. And 200 of those calories per day are from alcohol.0 -
1 - doesn't exist
2- Metabolic adapation as I describe is the lowered release of leptin and so thyroid hormones
3 - Loss of lean mass is of course likely as its the most 'expensive' form of calorie consumpton that the body doesn't exist
My point was regarding the OP point which it seemed you were referring the starvation mode as existing.
It depends on the definition. No one uses it consistently here.
Thats a bit airy? What do you mean?0 -
I didn't realize that burning calories caused the nutrients you took from food to evaporate from your body before they could be absorbed. I'll stop exercising right away so I don't burn off my nutrients and become unhealthy.I am getting FAR MORE nutrients on my 1,200 cal diet than I did with 3 grand of pure garbage.
I seriously doubt that. You have your calorie goal set at 900 per day. And you routinely burn most of that off. And 200 of those calories per day are from alcohol.
ETA: she doesn't burn off most of the 900 calories she NETS either.0 -
I do believe in starvation mode mainly due to the fact that once your body isn't getting enough calories it starts to eat away at the body ie. Fat and muscle, now the body is not going to eat away at the fat first its going to eat at the part that gives it more fuel, MUSCLE, it doesn't matter whether you work out its still going to eat at muscle (hence why body builders go on big bulk because they know they'll lose most muscle mass when they finally cut which is why they have to cut and bulk continually) now its been proven muscle is metabolically active and per pound of muscle our body burns an extra 50cals, so while you starve your body and it starts to eat at your muscle per pound you lose that 50cals less a day your burning, so to me it makes sense that your metabolism slows down, tbh I just think people want an excuse to eat low cals, whatever makes you feel better, I'd never really judge anyone for it cause its each to their own, all I know is I'd much rather be realistic with my calorie goal, I've done low cal and it never worked for me0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.2K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 421 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions