People with regular huge calorie burns
elizabethis
Posts: 155 Member
I'm curious about folks who lose substantial amounts of weight through very vigorous exercise (cardio &/or heavy lifting). In the process, they might get very used to eating large quantities of food because they burn so much. What happens if something changes, such as an illness, injury, lack of time, lack of motivation....to keep up that former pace? Do they adjust their calories down and still maintain their weight? or is it easy to regain the weight because they got used to eating larger quantities? Has anyone struggled with this? I often consciously think about being moderate in my exercise for fear of this type thing happening to me.
0
Replies
-
The reason you eat more is because the high level of activity needs more fuel.
If I burn over 400 calories I want more food, if I'm ill or just relaxing I'm not as hungry.
I wouldn't worry about it, but also you don't need to do crazy nutso vigorous activity if thats not your thing.0 -
Bump! Good question I was wondering similar.0
-
I've thought about that. I try to do a moderate amount of exercise every day and maybe once a week ill burn over 800 calories in a day. Makes me feel good to push a burn once in a while. When I do, I only eat back a small portion of the calories and increase my water intake. That helps. I don't want to get used to a ton of food because I gain weight too quickly. Everyone knows their own body. Do what works for u. Good luck.0
-
I usually burn more than 900 calories per day with cycling. All I can say is that I am never full.0
-
I have worried about the same on occasion, but I know on the days where I'm pretty sedentary I eat less. Guess that is why I feel I will be tracking my intake for the rest of my life. I know how easy it can be to over do it on a consistent basis. Exercise less, eat less, exercise more, eat more. Viscous cycle. LOL I honestly worry more about muscle breakdown should I face an injury. With muscle breakdown I would also be burning less calories.
I wouldn't say I have gotten used to eating larger quantities, just know I need to in order to fuel my workouts. I honestly find it difficult some days to eat as much as I need to (today being one), but I find a way somehow in order to keep my macros in check.0 -
Thanks for the comments. I guess I am in the "moderate" camp - about life in general. ( I might be showing my age a little )0
-
I typically will adjust my diet if I am out of commish to not gain back much if any. HIT training though requires HI Eating....HA!!!0
-
I used to bike 2 hours and day and run for an hour and then lift. Then I broke my foot. I gained 40 pounds in 2 1/2 months and now that's why I'm here!
I wish I would have just eaten less during the 6 months that I couldn't really do anything but it was SO HARD!!! I should have joined MPF back then. Oh well! Now I have a vast knowledge of how many calories are in things and I know how many calories I burn doing stuff. These are good things to know about!
As long as you know, you shouldn't have an issue!0 -
This just happened to me. I was burning 5500-7000 calories a week when I got into a car accident and could not workout for about a month and a half other than walking. What I found was that I was not as hungry as I was when I was burning huge. After a massive workout I would be starving, stomach growling, had to have food. But when I did not workout it was not the same, I never felt that way. I found, during my lay-up, that I was eating about 100-200 more calories a day then perhaps I should have been- so closer to maintainance mode. I have not lost a pound since the accident, but I also have not put on any weight. That was a relief to me, because at my goal wieght I will still workout, but not like this. The past month has shown me that I will be able to maintain and handle it when my workout needs change.0
-
I became a long distance runner...spent my life at gym, on treadmiil, doing weights or on a trail. Lost 100lbs much in the way you stated. Long story short, just before going on holidays, I decided to do one last ultimate workout as I would be away from gym for a while...well It certainly was one last workout...I seriuosly injured my back showing off with a deadlift. Dumb.
That changed EVERYTHING. It screwed up my running, it was painful. I went off weights. I stopped working out but I didnt stop eating.
I gained the 100lbs back.
This time around I am trying not to be so extreme...yes you can power away the calories, but like you stated, if youve learned no food control in the process you are screwed once an injury or other life stress hits you0 -
I became a long distance runner...spent my life at gym, on treadmiil, doing weights or on a trail. Lost 100lbs much in the way you stated. Long story short, just before going on holidays, I decided to do one last ultimate workout as I would be away from gym for a while...well It certainly was one last workout...I seriuosly injured my back showing off with a deadlift. Dumb.
That changed EVERYTHING. It screwed up my running, it was painful. I w off weights. I stopped working out but I didnt stop eating.
I gained the 100lbs back.
This time around I am trying not to be so extreme...yes you can power away the calories, but like you stated, if youve learned no food control in the process you are screwed one an injury or other lifr stress hits you
And you're very well on your way. Way to not give up on yourself!0 -
I agree with the discipline required comments. If you aren't exercising as much, then definitely your body won't need the fuel (it helps me to think of calories as fuel, not something to be afraid of or overly excited about obtaining -- it seems weird, but like I said, it helps me). For me, personally, because I was a Marine, intense workouts are a way of life, most of the time. As a woman who just had her fourth baby and third c-section, though (and in my mid-thirties!), I'vesort of been dealing with the fallout from this issue since I was on bedrest for four of the nine months of my last pregnancy. I did try to be very good in my eating, but I still went from a major calorie burn, since I would PT in the morning, usually workout on my own at chow and do yoga at night to barely moving. I was only cleared to use the head and take a shower. Now, even though three of the six days I work out I'm doing 800+ calories, my metabolism still hasn't caught back up. Like I said, this is only my personal story and I'm sure everyone is different and has different experiences. Best of luck to you!0
-
Thanks for posting this topic! I burn 700-1000 calories 6 days a week and have to eaaat!! Haha. So, valuable info, thanks0
-
I usually workout for 4 hours/6 days a week. I typically burn 3000-4000 calories when I work out. On days I don't exercise I try to limit my calories to 1700. Because of how strenuous my workouts are I eat more on the days I workout. Usually 2000-2400ish. But I'm still eating less than my old lifestyle just eating whatever the heck I wanted. I do need more to fuel my workouts but I am not doing the mindless snacking. Exercise curbs my appetite for snacking. On my rest days from working out I struggle to control my snacking, eating from boredom. Sure, exercise gives me a little wiggle room with my diet. And if I don't work out then I have to be stricter. But I don't think that's any different than anyone else on here. I still log my food and watch what I eat. I don't just say eh, I burned 21,000 calories this week so I can eat whatever I want.0
-
The OP asks a fantastic question. That is precisely the reason one should base their weight loss goals around a sound eating plan, NOT around prolific amounts of vigorous exercise. Losing weight is about what you eat, not what you do.
The exercise you do should be about making a physical change in your body. Strengthening muscles and joints, enhancing cardiovascular fitness, increasing endurance capacity, building bigger or better looking muscles. These activities will burn calories, but the "burn" is not the reason to do them.
Note: the general confusion about this concept is what fuels my constant, futile hrm rants. Exercise is for fitness, eating sensibly is for losing weight. Connected, but different.0 -
It is not uncommon for this to happen. One must be conscious about maintaining proper equilibrium.0
-
Just adding my 2 cents..yes you get used to eating more. I'm injured right now and can't do my lifting or hard cardio. All I can do is walking. So I'm walking ALLOT and at the same time tightened up my diet. Still losing weight but I am much more concious right now of how much I can eat. But I do notice I'm not as hungry as when I was working out harder.0
-
i eat more on my rest days and less on my more active ones. i'm usually not as hungry on the active days anyway, so it all evens out. so i suppose if i stopped with the vigorous workouts, i probably wouldnt have any spikes in my hunger level since i wouldnt be needing as many calories
i'm never not motivate to work out.. injury wise i've been lucky enough to have never been seriously injured in 20 years of exercising, including 6 years of playing rugby. the one time i did get injured (rotator cuff) i worked around the injury and did rehab, so there was no rest.0 -
I do think about this from time to time... Wondering when i will no longer be able to burn 400-600+ calories in a day. I now the day WILL come. I will have to adjust my eating level to match my activity level. I would like to believe that once my activity level decreases i wont feel as hungry to need all the calories I'm currently used to having. I guess its the same principal to anyone that slows down on the amount they workout.. Calories in have to be equal to calories out to maintain.... Simple accounting.0
-
Im on 1200cal a day and I eat back some of my exercise calories. 4 days a week I burn 500-600 cal and I eat back maybe 150cal. Once a week I do a super session which I burn 900-1100cal and eat back 300-400.0
-
I just suffered a stress fracture in my right foot from (Irish) Dance...so I had to modify all of my other workouts and go easy (basic Yoga, rather than hard core stuff). I've gained weight...not a lot, but my clothes don't fit as well! Unfortunately my appetite was as high as ever and it was really hard for me to stop eating as much. I am back on track now with my foot...but now I'm kind of in a funk about it all :sad: I feel like I have to make up for the last 3 months, and I sort of lost my momentum!0
-
I can't afford the deficit of all those cals.
Some people begin their day at 4-5am to exercise though, that's hella dedication but you won't get me up before the sun except for the days I have an 8am class.
I haven't the drive to devote to such regular exercise, especially in the winter when I'd have to go to the dreaded, freezing, OUTSIDE to do vigorous exercising.
No thanks, I'll moderate my diet and stay curled up warm and happy in my blankets.0 -
I was burning 1000 - 1400 5 x week now around 600, i struggle to get over tdee some days.0
-
When I worked hard on my feet all day, I could eat 2000 a day and still lose a little.
Now I sit ALL day, and I maintain at 1400-1600.
I miss all that food! But being short and little, my body just doesn't need that much on it's own and I no longer have time to be running back and forth and lifting things 8 hours a day to earn more. It was nice when my job WAS my exercise!0 -
On Sundays I'm around 800 calories, Mondays over 1000 burned (Basketball game) and tuesday, wednesday and thurs between 500 and 800 generally (basketball practice, P90X). Normally after an 800-1000 burn the next day i'm ravenous! I train late at night so it hits me the next day and i feel like i could eat everything. I normally go over my food count by a bit on a tuesday and wednesday because of this.
If i was out with an injury i dont think i'd be as hungry so i'd be able to manage my normal daily amount easily.0 -
When I go for long bike rides or go trekking I end up with large calorie burns. These are not part of my current regular schedule but six months back it would not be abnormal to gave a 3000 or more calories burned Sunday.
While trekking or week long rides - if it is a long trip I'll end up losing a lot of weight because we do don't carry enough/eat at maintenance during those periods, eating 5000-7000 cals day when we are used to a third of that is hard! - Usually, the weeks that follow are recovery weeks and yes, the 10-15 pounds lost come back with friends. It is possible to control but takes a lot of effort.
The hunger settles down about 5-10 days after a big trip. Part of the reason I needed to lose was being a little too loose on the gains after some of these trips.0 -
Diet is the most important factor in weight control, and we adjust our calorie intakes to our activity level. If we workout less, our TDEE decreases and so we have to eat less to maintain.0
-
For years, I played soccer every day, or went for a 5-8 mile run, or played tennis. Never thought twice about what I ate. Then, I injured my knee and had surgery. I was out of commish for about one and a half years. I gained about 20 pounds.
I think it was mostly the dinners. I had been accustomed to second, and even third, helpings to make up my calories. Also, I was accustomed to only eating high calorie foods. But, I never was a big snack eater and I did not become one.
I have since lost that weight as I have started running again. But I do not really think you can exercise off weight. For some of us, at least, our body tells us strongly what it needs to weight and we eat to that. We may regulate with activity, a bit, but really it is what we eat.
It was not so difficult for me to take off the weight, even though I had been used to eating heavy and well for about 50 years, because I felt really uncomfortable being heavier. Until I had gained this weight, I still weighed about the same that I had in college.
I think our bodies regulate our weight, and for some of us, that is stronger than for others. I think research has show that, if you gain weight, the body tends to establish that new, higher weight as its base point and it does not go back down even if you lose weight, at least not for a long while.
That weight regulation is much more important than any exercise.0 -
I'm curious about folks who lose substantial amounts of weight through very vigorous exercise (cardio &/or heavy lifting). In the process, they might get very used to eating large quantities of food because they burn so much. What happens if something changes, such as an illness, injury, lack of time, lack of motivation....to keep up that former pace? Do they adjust their calories down and still maintain their weight? or is it easy to regain the weight because they got used to eating larger quantities? Has anyone struggled with this? I often consciously think about being moderate in my exercise for fear of this type thing happening to me.
As someone who's been through it: yes.
I'm usually training intensely on the bike for 10 to 12 hours a week, which amounts to around 6500 to 8000 calories burned from exercise each week.
I watch what I eat really closely. If I take an easy day on the bike, I don't eat as much that day. If I have a really hard day, I eat more that day.
When I stop training for whatever reason, I have to cut back on my eating immediately. When it's for any length of time (more than a week or so), I have to be really careful because all of my habits are geared around eating a lot more.
I managed to re-gain 12 pounds this spring/summer because of not paying attention after two injuries in a row.
I would never cut down on training because of a fear of what might happen to my weight if I stopped. That's like saying that someone should not get married for fear of divorce.0 -
The OP asks a fantastic question. That is precisely the reason one should base their weight loss goals around a sound eating plan, NOT around prolific amounts of vigorous exercise. Losing weight is about what you eat, not what you do.
The exercise you do should be about making a physical change in your body. Strengthening muscles and joints, enhancing cardiovascular fitness, increasing endurance capacity, building bigger or better looking muscles. These activities will burn calories, but the "burn" is not the reason to do them.
Note: the general confusion about this concept is what fuels my constant, futile hrm rants. Exercise is for fitness, eating sensibly is for losing weight. Connected, but different.
This makes good sense to me. If exercise is seen primarily as a means to grow your calorie allotment, I think there is danger ahead when trying to maintain weight - especially if your exercise has been a drudgery. Thank you for posting this.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions