We are pleased to announce that on March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor will be introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the upcoming changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

Question about exceeding my caloric recommendation.

cola4surf
cola4surf Posts: 15 Member
edited September 2024 in Health and Weight Loss
I started at around 145 and am down to 139. I wanted to loosed 2 pounds a week so MFP suggested that my net caloric intake be 1200. I generally exceed 1200 because I am starving but I still have lost some weight. Does anyone know if exceeding my net goal by 200-300 calories up to 3 times a week will affect my eventual weight loss? It seems to be working and I know I am consuming far fewer calories but I just wanted to check in with anyone else who might do the same.

I have read other posts where people state that they have a difficult time consuming that many calories (1200) and I am thinking, "huh?" I am generally famished. The diary is working because now I am only eating when I am hungry but I am definitely not having a hard time consuming 1200 calories. When I exercise, of course, it (calorie allowance) is more but the net is still around 1200.

I should also mention that I do exercise vigorously 4-5 times a week (spin class, core-board).

Any suggestions or personal experience would be appreciated. I am new to the site.

Replies

  • pkgirrl
    pkgirrl Posts: 587
    Question first, if you don't mind. Do you eat back the exercise calories from your spin class? Like in addition to the 200-300 you occasionally go over? If not, your probably still under eating, even with the slightly higher days.

    If you do, I wouldn't worry too much. You might not lose 2lbs a week, however, your body will be much happier to lose at a slightly lower rate, and is less likely to plateau down the road.

    I used to eat 1200 a day, strict, no exercise, and it worked really well at first. Then I started cheating a bit (having a few drinks on the weekends, or some junk with my boyfriend) but as long as I kept exercising, I would still lose at the same rate.

    After I got down about 10lbs, I hit a huge plateau, and after awhile of getting nowhere I decided to try p90x. I never actually followed the workout plan, but the nutrition plan has made a HUGE difference in the way I look at food. I've found, for me at least, where my calories come from is WAY more important than how many I eat. I can easily eat about 1800 a day, with treats a couple times a week, as long as its high protein, mod fat, low carb.

    I don't know if that's the same for everyone, but I think you should just give yourself a few weeks, and if your still losing at a rate your happy with, stick with it. If not, you can always re-evaluate and try something else =)
  • jranderson22
    jranderson22 Posts: 2 Member
    Hi,

    I have trouble myself staying within my allotted calories too, particularly when I want to have a glass of wine with dinner, which satisfies me, but not in the way that cures my hunger.

    I've lost about 15 pounds by using the daily calories as a guide that I sometimes go over (even though I always feel bad about it), but not being too nuts about sticking to it. I'm extra careful on the fat, and usually eat only half of my suggested amount, because I have high cholesterol.

    But, if you're exercising that much I'd suggest being more flexible with yourself week-to-week and just staying within 10-15% of your targeted calories for the week (your per day amount x 7) if you can.

    Best of luck,
    Josh
  • chelsinicole
    chelsinicole Posts: 37
    I am around your same weight, and i eat 1300 a day, sometimes more. I think this is okay for you to do, but try to stick to healthy foods and all that. I understand what you mean, Im starving too even after eating all my calories.
  • Angie789
    Angie789 Posts: 61 Member
    Giving the fact that you are pretty close to a healthy weight (if not there already - I don't know how tall you are), I don't think that it is reasonable to set your goals to lose 2 pounds a week. The closer you are to your goal weight, the slower it comes off. I would go back into MFP and reset your goals to 1 pound a week (or even 1/2 pound), and then eat at those calorie levels. It will give you more so that you aren't hungry all the time and have you losing at a rate that will be smart & sustainable for where you are.
  • cola4surf
    cola4surf Posts: 15 Member
    Hi pkgirrl,

    Yes, I definitely eat back the calories burned from exercise plus a couple hundred more. Since joining MFP and having to document my food intake, I have made much healthier choices. For example, even those extra calories are from eating wasa crackers with a veggies or two apples (sometimes cookies or beer too). This is why I am so glad to have found the site. I am making more of an effort to eat healthy and exercise more.

    Thank you for the feedback!
  • cola4surf
    cola4surf Posts: 15 Member
    Giving the fact that you are pretty close to a healthy weight (if not there already - I don't know how tall you are), I don't think that it is reasonable to set your goals to lose 2 pounds a week. The closer you are to your goal weight, the slower it comes off. I would go back into MFP and reset your goals to 1 pound a week (or even 1/2 pound), and then eat at those calorie levels. It will give you more so that you aren't hungry all the time and have you losing at a rate that will be smart & sustainable for where you are.

    Ok, that is great advice, thank you for taking the time to reply. I really appreciate it.
This discussion has been closed.

Categories