body weight vs lifting heavy-how often?

Love2lift72
Love2lift72 Posts: 157 Member
edited January 7 in Fitness and Exercise
I need some help in understanding rest periods with lifting. My problem is that I see and understand why it's important to have rest periods between lifting days. But then I see a post that says that body weight exercises are great. I'm finishing ChaLean Extreme in 2 weeks and want to get into lifting but I want to build up to doing more push ups every day too. Now aren't the rest periods as important with body weight exercises as well? And if so, is it ok to do sit ups, push ups, pull ups, etc every day?

Replies

  • Yogi_Carl
    Yogi_Carl Posts: 1,906 Member
    Hi - my angle on it is if you can do push-ups every day, you are not working with enough intensity; you need to step up the exercise. If you are able to do 3 sets of 10 regular pushups, try increasing the intensity:

    - by performing them slower - down to a count of two, hold the low plank for a one-count then push up to a count of one and repeat. you may find you can't do so many, which is ok - you have increased the intensity of the exercise.

    - or by increasing the difficulty of the exercise; pushups from your feet raised on a block, on a football, one hand on a football etc

    - by mentally contracting every muscle fibre as you perform the exercise. This becomes easier to focus on when you slow down the movements.

    By increasing intensity in this way, you should find you really can't do pushups the next day as your body needs to repair.

    Your body doesn't know whether it is pushing something external like a barbell or doing a bodyweight exercise. The trick in bodyweight exercises is to keep increasing intensity by making things increasingly difficult. It is a fascinating process. I'm quite addicted!

    I can't comment on weight lifting - hope someone else can help you out there.
  • Love2lift72
    Love2lift72 Posts: 157 Member
    Thanks and bumping to see if I get any other input.
  • wmagoo27
    wmagoo27 Posts: 201 Member
    I think C4RLO5 hit the nail on the head. Stress is stress, whether it's body weight or iron weight. Give your muscles time to repair and recover between sessions of training. Stressing a muscle every day will eventually lead to an injury if you do it for too long. Listen to your body and rest if you need it.
  • ilovedeadlifts
    ilovedeadlifts Posts: 2,923 Member
    I agree with C4RL05 to an extent. depending on the amount of pushups you're doing, you would need/want off days.

    With heavy lifting I typically train 3-4 days per week. You can still be active on your off days. Foam roll, work on mobility/flexibility, do light cardio, etc.
  • dave4d
    dave4d Posts: 1,155 Member
    I've read articles that have said to increase your ability to do exercises like pull-ups, push-ups, or dips, to do them every chance you can. It seems to go against the philosophy of rest periods. I'm not sure of the correct answer, but I do believe that it has to do with body weight exercises don't usually stress the system like heavy lifting does.

    If I have a sore muscle, I try not to work it for a day, or two, but part of my job requires shoveling, hammering, and sometimes, heavy lifting. I think the body will adapt, as muscle soreness doesn't last as long, or get so severe when you are used to doing certain jobs, or exercises. For proper muscular development, rest days are important, along with switching your routine so your body constantly needs to adapt to the changes being applied to it.
  • ilovedeadlifts
    ilovedeadlifts Posts: 2,923 Member
    For proper muscular development, rest days are important, along with switching your routine so your body constantly needs to adapt to the changes being applied to it.

    program jumping isn't really going to help you continue to make progress.

    yes it's good to cycle out some of your assistance excercises, but your programming should stay relatively the same. jumping from trend to trend is why people don't make progress.
  • dave4d
    dave4d Posts: 1,155 Member
    For proper muscular development, rest days are important, along with switching your routine so your body constantly needs to adapt to the changes being applied to it.

    program jumping isn't really going to help you continue to make progress.

    yes it's good to cycle out some of your assistance excercises, but your programming should stay relatively the same. jumping from trend to trend is why people don't make progress.

    I didn't recommend changing your whole program. Just enough that your body doesn't adapt to it. I agree, it is too hard to track progress when you are completely changing your program, too often. I always keep the main "bench mark" exercises in my program, but will change some of the other lifts around, occasionally. But even the main lifts, do change, by trying to either add weight, or reps. Therefore, the body still has to adapt to the new stress being applied to it.
  • ilovedeadlifts
    ilovedeadlifts Posts: 2,923 Member

    I didn't recommend changing your whole program. Just enough that your body doesn't adapt to it. I agree, it is too hard to track progress when you are completely changing your program, too often. I always keep the main "bench mark" exercises in my program, but will change some of the other lifts around, occasionally. But even the main lifts, do change, by trying to either add weight, or reps. Therefore, the body still has to adapt to the new stress being applied to it.

    Just making sure.
    I always wave the intensity/volume from week to week with the main lifts.
  • Love2lift72
    Love2lift72 Posts: 157 Member
    Thanks guys! All of that has been every helpful. I guess I was raised old school where pushups, situps, etc were done everyday to mean you were fit. LOL I have been doing them when they weren't part of my workout only when I wasn't sore so I guess I am on the right track. Time to cut back on extras and lift heavier. :)
This discussion has been closed.