Skip to content
  • Register

    • What is the correct comment reply procedure???

    Posts: 1,066 Member
    edited October 2024 in Chit-Chat
    If someone leaves a comment on my wall I would assume I'd just reply within the comment left on my wall...but I've heard people say "you're suppose to then reply on their wall" or seen that they'd reply back on the other persons wall.....whaa? That doesn't seem to make sense though. Why not just keep the convo within the first original comment.

    Welcome!

    It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.
    Sign In
    Register
    «1

    Replies

    • Posts: 1,012 Member
      You reply on their wall otherwise they have to keep checking your wall to see if you replied, and that's just rude to make them keep checkign your wall.
    • Posts: 4,716 Member
      Also be sure to comment in formal wear. With raised pinkie finger.


      We aren't animals here.
    • Posts: 1,012 Member
      Also be sure to comment in formal wear. With raised pinkie finger.


      We aren't animals here.

      But we are pets.
    • Posts: 2,086 Member
      I don't know what you are talking about, so -

      Good luck on your health journey!
    • Posts: 1,066 Member
      You reply on their wall otherwise they have to keep checking your wall to see if you replied, and that's just rude to make them keep checkign your wall.

      mmmhhmmm...i see. I know this ain't facebook but you'd think MFP would have some kidna notification that a reply was left.
    • Posts: 4,716 Member
      show previous quotes

      But we are pets.

      We make great pets.



      *name the band, 5 points*
    • Posts: 1,066 Member
      Also be sure to comment in formal wear. With raised pinkie finger.


      We aren't animals here.

      should i wear my top hat and monocle?
    • Posts: 2,072 Member
      Also be sure to comment in formal wear. With raised pinkie finger.


      We aren't animals here.

      *takes off Snoopy suit and kicks rocks*
    • Posts: 4,741 Member
      Follow up with an invitation private message to look at your wall for any other postings, and a note declaring your intent on wall posting.
    • Posts: 1,012 Member
      show previous quotes

      We make great pets.



      *name the band, 5 points*

      Porno for Pyros. easy peasy lemon squeezy.
    • Posts: 4,716 Member
      Porno for Pyros. easy peasy lemon squeezy.

      90's High Five!


      (that's where I high five you with a goatee and a flannel around my waist)
    • Posts: 16,414 Member
      If someone leaves a comment on my wall I would assume I'd just reply within the comment left on my wall...but I've heard people say "you're suppose to then reply on their wall" or seen that they'd reply back on the other persons wall.....whaa? That doesn't seem to make sense though. Why not just keep the convo within the first original comment.
      Unfortunately, this site doesn't send notifications when you reply to someone on your own wall, so you have to reply on the person's wall so the person gets a notification. It's just more likely to be seen that way.
    • Posts: 2,065 Member
      Just break up.
    • Posts: 128
      K I've never heard of replying on their wall... that's not a thing.
    • Posts: 1,849 Member
      show previous quotes

      mmmhhmmm...i see. I know this ain't facebook but you'd think MFP would have some kidna notification that a reply was left.

      They send you an email notice. Everytime someone comments on my wall post, sends me a message or friend request, or posts on my wall, I get a notice in my Yahoo account.
    • Posts: 65
      I have an internal conflict with myself on this issue on a daily basis. Lol.
    • Posts: 1,320 Member
      I don't know what is happening in this thread.
    • Posts: 1,035 Member
      we are supposed to talk to these people?
    • Posts: 71
      If someone leaves a comment on my wall I would assume I'd just reply within the comment left on my wall...but I've heard people say "you're suppose to then reply on their wall" or seen that they'd reply back on the other persons wall.....whaa? That doesn't seem to make sense though. Why not just keep the convo within the first original comment.

      Whenever someone posts a comment on my wall, I usually respond with a post on their wall. No big deal. That way they are sure to catch it.
    • Posts: 6,128 Member
      The only way that they receive a notification that you responded is if you reply on their wall. If you're having a conversation, I usually then just comment on my first posting on their wall. I do have to say, however, I sometimes forget and just post on their comment on my wall . . . but this ain't facebook.
    • Posts: 3,927 Member
      show previous quotes

      90's High Five!


      (that's where I high five you with a goatee and a flannel around my waist)

      don't forget your Doc Martins.
    • Posts: 1,090 Member
      K I've never heard of replying on their wall... that's not a thing.

      Haha, it's definitely a thing. That's what all my friends do. most of them anyway. Some of them need to learn I don't want to go check their profile every hour or so to see if they replied to me!! I won't name any names.... :grumble:
    • Posts: 16,414 Member
      we are supposed to talk to these people?
      WHAT???!!!
    • Posts: 16,414 Member
      show previous quotes

      They send you an email notice. Everytime someone comments on my wall post, sends me a message or friend request, or posts on my wall, I get a notice in my Yahoo account.
      Yes, but they don't get notifications when you reply on your own wall posts or things they posted on your wall. Only when you post on THEIR walls.
    • Posts: 1,089 Member
      show previous quotes
      WHAT???!!!

      thats just WRONG
      we are here for support, not chit chating
    • Posts: 372
      London calling. I am not sure any etiquette conversation can be had without cucumber sandwiches. With the crusts removed.
    • Posts: 4,375 Member
      I just follow Windy around and stalk her...
    • Posts: 1,066 Member
      i like turtles.
    • Posts: 16,414 Member
      I just follow Windy around and stalk her...
      How do you propose stalking without following someone around?
    • Posts: 8
      oh well this is new! good to know!
    This discussion has been closed.

    Welcome!

    It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.
    Sign In
    Register

    Quick Links

    Categories