If only I had known...
ms_tris
Posts: 82 Member
Let me preface this by saying, I only wish someone had said this to me at some point in my life of struggling with weight loss. I am not judging anyone and I know everyone is on his/her own journey. If I help even one person, then I am happy.
I have willpower of steel. I know how to "be on a diet." My first diet was when I was 14 years old. I decided, based on what I read, (this was around 1991) that fat was evil. I immediately cut out almost all fat. I was basically existing on green apples and wheat thins. I lost weight. 60+ pounds in 7 months or so. During my junior and senior year in high school, I threw up 5-6 times a day to maintain the weight I lost so quickly on my severe plan. I was young. There wasn't as much access to all the information we have today. It was not a good decision, in retrospect. To this day I have loose, saggy skin on my upper arms, upper thighs, and butt as a result of cutting out all fat and dropping weight so quickly. I spent the next 20 years in the same cycle: starve down on ridiculously low calories, then "celebrate" back up and start over. Would I pig out to gain the weight back? Not really. I would gain weight on an amount of calories that many people could eat without fear of weight gain, simply because my body was used to living on nothing.
The point of this topic: I wish that someone would have told me 20 years ago, 15 years ago, 10 years ago or even 5 years ago,
"Eat as many calories as you can while still being able to lose about 1-1.5lbs a week."
For every person who is dieting down on 800, 900, 1000, 1100 calories, it is true that you can lose weight quickly like this. But, you can have similar losses eating much more. Your body is tricky. Eat a tiny amount, it will adapt. It will get more efficient on the tiny amount. Then you reach your goal, decide you are awesome, start being "normal" again, and the weight starts coming back on. If you go into the weight loss process and just choose to eat a little more and lose a little less quickly on a higher (more sustainable) amount of calories, you are at least stacking the "keep the weight off" deck a little more in your favor. I am finally trying this approach and having success. I lose the same 1-1.5lbs a week eating 1500-1700 calories a day as I was losing in 2008 on 1000-1100 a day. I'm a much happier person now. :0) I also feel like when I reach my goal weight and eat "normal," the 1800-2000 calories a day will be perfect for me to maintain, not gain. I may even be able to eat more! That makes me happy!
Best of luck to everyone. Be patient, be consistent, be kind to yourself.
tristi
I have willpower of steel. I know how to "be on a diet." My first diet was when I was 14 years old. I decided, based on what I read, (this was around 1991) that fat was evil. I immediately cut out almost all fat. I was basically existing on green apples and wheat thins. I lost weight. 60+ pounds in 7 months or so. During my junior and senior year in high school, I threw up 5-6 times a day to maintain the weight I lost so quickly on my severe plan. I was young. There wasn't as much access to all the information we have today. It was not a good decision, in retrospect. To this day I have loose, saggy skin on my upper arms, upper thighs, and butt as a result of cutting out all fat and dropping weight so quickly. I spent the next 20 years in the same cycle: starve down on ridiculously low calories, then "celebrate" back up and start over. Would I pig out to gain the weight back? Not really. I would gain weight on an amount of calories that many people could eat without fear of weight gain, simply because my body was used to living on nothing.
The point of this topic: I wish that someone would have told me 20 years ago, 15 years ago, 10 years ago or even 5 years ago,
"Eat as many calories as you can while still being able to lose about 1-1.5lbs a week."
For every person who is dieting down on 800, 900, 1000, 1100 calories, it is true that you can lose weight quickly like this. But, you can have similar losses eating much more. Your body is tricky. Eat a tiny amount, it will adapt. It will get more efficient on the tiny amount. Then you reach your goal, decide you are awesome, start being "normal" again, and the weight starts coming back on. If you go into the weight loss process and just choose to eat a little more and lose a little less quickly on a higher (more sustainable) amount of calories, you are at least stacking the "keep the weight off" deck a little more in your favor. I am finally trying this approach and having success. I lose the same 1-1.5lbs a week eating 1500-1700 calories a day as I was losing in 2008 on 1000-1100 a day. I'm a much happier person now. :0) I also feel like when I reach my goal weight and eat "normal," the 1800-2000 calories a day will be perfect for me to maintain, not gain. I may even be able to eat more! That makes me happy!
Best of luck to everyone. Be patient, be consistent, be kind to yourself.
tristi
0
Replies
-
Good post! I agree that making a smaller transition from now to maintenance is going to be a key factor in not re-gaining this time.0
-
yep!
life is supposed to be enjoyed.
i don't understand how anyone can enjoy life if they are constantly hungry and irritable from lack of food.
everyone can lose weight and get fit without starving themselves. it's such an unnecessary torture that people put themselves through. :noway:0 -
YES0
-
YES
^this
ETA: For OP - :flowerforyou:0 -
Great post! If given the choice of losing weight and starving yourself or still losing weight and being able to eat more, why not choose the latter???0
-
Excellent. I concur :drinker:0
-
I completely agree!!! It makes so much sense, too. You should be proud of all the work you're doing. You look stunning, and I'm proud to know such a strong, wonderful woman0
-
Well said!!0
-
This is wonderful.0
-
i wish you had posted it on a Monday morning...we all need to bump this monday!0
-
I am 54 and have a very similar story. Years of starving myself and then rebounding when I became awesome. I am eating and losing at 1700-1800 cals a day now.
Thanks and I really hope the women who are eating below 1200 cals will read this and understand. :flowerforyou:0 -
Well said,0
-
"Eat as many calories as you can while still being able to lose about 1-1.5lbs a week."
Makes so much sense, it is almost hard to accept... that it could be so easy.
Thanks for this!0 -
Thank you for posting! :flowerforyou:0
-
YES
OMG! Your post got the queen of "No" to say yes. When I get to a computer, I'm going to have to read your post. It has to be fantastic or crank wouldn't have pposted a link in her newsfeed.
Just read it. OP, you are awesome. This should be read by every resolutionist noob on this site. It will save a lot of my friends from getting strikes when they are reported for being "mean" and "bullying" those people who post the "Eating 900 calories and still can't lose" posts. Slow down people. Do it right. You didn't get fat in a month. You shouldn't tryto get thin in a month either.0 -
YES0
-
Great post! I'm sure this will help quite a few people -- your post helped me by just reinforcing my recent decision to bump up my calories about 2 weeks ago from the MFP recommended 1200 calories. Thanks to Dan's post on "In Place of a Road Map 2.0 (Revised) 7/2/12" I think I finally saw the truth to this after so many other posters were saying the same thing & getting great results.
Again, "Thank You." I look forward to this journey of a much healthier & happier life! :flowerforyou:0 -
Amen!0
-
Good stuff! Thanks for sharing0
-
I agree wholeheartedly. I used to torture myself with 1200 calorie diets. Now I happily eat 1700 and lose at about the same rate, plus my hair stopped falling out. Sheesh, you'd think I would have seen that as a sign that I was doing something my body didn't care for...0
-
Eating more and losing weight has been the best kept secret! Thanks for spreading the good news to those who want to listen!!0
-
Because of how long I obsessed over my weight, I considered starving myself to get down. With the help of my mother (who specializes in weight loss and diabetes) we calculated my basal metabolic rate. It's quite low, ringing in at only about 1200. For me to lose weight, I don't think I can eat 1500 or more. I gain on that! I wish I could eat as much as all of you, haha.0
-
Thank you for posting this. While I don't struggle with this, I know several people who do. One is in and out of rehab (anorexia, not drugs) and the others exercise constantly and eat very little at meals. I'm sure there are many women and men that need to hear this. God made you beautiful, and while sometimes we ruin that with bad choices, it can be brought back without going to the extremes.0
-
Because of how long I obsessed over my weight, I considered starving myself to get down. With the help of my mother (who specializes in weight loss and diabetes) we calculated my basal metabolic rate. It's quite low, ringing in at only about 1200. For me to lose weight, I don't think I can eat 1500 or more. I gain on that! I wish I could eat as much as all of you, haha.0
-
I hope I don't sound like such a newbie but I have a question:
Does this also apply to someone who's not very active?
I ask this because I don't have a very active lifestyle and MFP calculated 1220 calories for me. I've been here for almost 2 weeks and I have lost 2.4 lbs but I always get confused with this whole low calorie thing.
:ohwell:0 -
Well said! :happy:0
-
Just did that. Wasn't that great either. I am very sedentary and although I am trying to fix that, a person who does not exercise does not need as many calories.
If you don't move, you don't need a lot of calories.0 -
Best post I've read in a long time. Congrats OP. Thanks for this, I think it will help a lot of folks.0
-
It took me a long time to realize you can't starve yourself. You do have to eat to lose weight. If you starve yourself it is no good emotionally or health wise. Well written blog.0
-
Awesome post and perfect time for me to run across this. I've been dieting down with really good success on very low calories. It's slowed up a bit and I didn't feel like I recovered from me workouts this past week as well as I'm used to so I know there's something going on. So I gradually upped me calories over the last few days and today I'm eating at -20% my TDEE. It feels like it's soooo much food trying to get 2000 calories in compared to what I was doing to myself before and it's made me feel kind of guilty ever since I went over what I would normally eat earlier this afternoon. So as I sit here consuming the last of my calories for the day it was nice to read this thread. Thank you!0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions