Cardio, before or after weights?
courtneydeewalk
Posts: 61
Hey everyone, forgive me if this has been talked about before... there are so many topics it is impossible to go through them all. My big question is... Should I be doing cardio before weights or after? I have heard some say before and others say after. Is there a difference, really? What would be the benefits each?? I feel like when I do cardio before that my heart rate stays higher through my entire workout and sweat constantly, if I do it after I tend to be able to lift heavier. Any opinions? Thanks!!
0
Replies
-
I do mine after, as you have already suggested if affects my lifting if doing it before.0
-
After...I always like to be completely fresh when I lift in order to give max effort and get the most benefit from my lifting session. I usually do cardio on my non lift days, but if I happen to do it on lift days, it's usually after...and usually a pretty unimpressive session because I'm already pretty much hammered ****.0
-
It depends on which is easier for you, I've heard arguments from both sides. Personally I like to use my weights before cardio because I am usually too tired to do anything but shower after the treadmill!
I also like to do circuit training to incorporate both and then get on the treadmill after that.0 -
I feel like when I do cardio before that my heart rate stays higher through my entire workout and sweat constantly, if I do it after I tend to be able to lift heavier.
It depends. What are your goals?
If you want to run a marathon, then do the cardio first, as the weight training is then simply an assistance exercise.
If you're looking to get stronger, then do the weights first.
If you want to lose fat while maintaining LBM, do the weights first.0 -
Hey everyone, forgive me if this has been talked about before... there are so many topics it is impossible to go through them all. My big question is... Should I be doing cardio before weights or after? I have heard some say before and others say after. Is there a difference, really? What would be the benefits each?? I feel like when I do cardio before that my heart rate stays higher through my entire workout and sweat constantly, if I do it after I tend to be able to lift heavier. Any opinions? Thanks!!
I actually do both. I do 15 minutes on the treadmille before strength training and 15 minutes on the treadmill after strength training.0 -
If I don't do my cardio before my weights then I won't do cardio at all because I am simply too exhausted and I just want to leave.0
-
I do my cardio first this makes me fight all the harder and really endure on my lifting. Let's me take it to a different level. But I lift for endurance more then anything.0
-
what's cardio?
JK, when I do both, I ALWAYS do weights first. I'm just wasting energy lifting if I lift after cardio.0 -
I do weights first because I feel like I need to be more alert of my form when lifting.0
-
Thanks for posting, I have been doing cardio first but maybe I should start lifting first. Maybe I will be able to lift more instead of feeling like a wimp!0
-
Depends on your goals. If you're looking to increase your strength/build lean muscle mass, do weights first. If your goal is to increase your cardio endurance, start with that. I don't usually do both at the same time (I usually alternate days) but when I do, I always do weights first.0
-
After, because lifting is more important.0
-
I used to always do it before because I liked to get my cardio out of the way. Then I would lift. I never noticed much of a difference in terms of how much or how long I would lift.
I worked with a personal trainer last year, who swore by cardio warm-up, then lift hard and heavy, and then cardio at a 6/7 effort out of 10. And of course, cool down. When I lift now, I work into it some cardio, such as burpies and bicep curls, so my heart rate is exploding and I'm sweating like crazy. Then, when I move to cardio, I don't even have to work as hard to still get in a great sweat.
Really, truly, it's up to your personal preference. Whatever is going to make you do both, do it that way. You can't get caught up in 'what the research says' or other people, because you won't stick to it unless you enjoy it.0 -
Thank you everyone! I really appreciate this input!! Please keep it coming!0
-
If you're focusing on strength gains: lifting first.
If you're focusing on running endurance and speed: cardio first
Depends on your goal really.0 -
I would go with after simply because I can do cardio after strength easier than I can do strength after cardio.0
-
After
Gawd I ran 1/4 mile the other day and tried to do 5 min rest then did powercleans - I couldnt catch my breath at all through the whole workout even with 2-3 min breaks.
Funny I ran 2 miles the other day and went inside and drank chocolate milk through a straw. NOT A DROP WAS SPILLED whaaa?!0 -
Altrernate days for me. Weights on Mon Wed Fri, Cardio - Tues Thurs Sat with Sunday rest. Seems alright and energy to go around althoughs eomtimes the legs take a beating. Just adjust intestity on them as needed for good recovery. Also 5-10 min light cardio before weights regardless for warmup.0
-
Just do it.0
-
I do it before. My heart rate is about 20 % higher during the weight lifting if I do a 20 minute warm up on the treadmill or elliptical. If I were in a bulk phase, I would do it after or not at all on lifting days.0
-
How about weights instead of cardio?
More seriously, I do cardio afterwards. If I slip and fall running because I'm tired, I get a scrape. If I screw up doing weights, I could end up under a 300 lb barbell.0 -
At this stage for me and my current goals, I do cardio first and really give it my all and then I'll go lift for while. I'm not trying to make any major gains at this point. When i read my current goal, I will switch it around and do weight lifting first and some light cardio if any at all last.
However, let it never be said that if you're lifting heavy, you're not doing cardio, because there are times I'm just as winded after doing a squat set or a deadlift as if I worked on the elliptical hard for 15 minutes.0 -
I do 10-15 minutes of elliptical or rowing machine as a warm up before lifting.0
-
I do mine at separate times, resistance training at the gym, cardio at home on my treadmill0
-
Hey everyone, forgive me if this has been talked about before... there are so many topics it is impossible to go through them all. My big question is... Should I be doing cardio before weights or after? I have heard some say before and others say after. Is there a difference, really? What would be the benefits each?? I feel like when I do cardio before that my heart rate stays higher through my entire workout and sweat constantly, if I do it after I tend to be able to lift heavier. Any opinions? Thanks!!0
-
My treadmill is right next to my home gym. I like to walk during my rest between sets. Lets my muscles rest but keeps my heart rate up then I walk more after my strength training.0
-
I think it's optimal not to do both lifting and cardio in the same session. By doing so, you invariably will perform worse on the activity you do last. But if you must do both at once, do the one which you consider to be the highest priority first.
There are usually two days a week in which I both lift and run, but on those days I always lift in the morning and run in the afternoon. This may not work with many people's schedules, but I find that I am able to maximize both workouts that way. Additionally, it is easier psychologically to do the workouts separately, as well as easier to give a maximal effort.0 -
I do 10 minutes before, either elliptical or bike, warm-up at a light resistance, then lift, then 30-45 minutes intense cardio after. Everyone is different, but I don't get sore muscles doing it this way.
Edited for autocorrect mayhem.0 -
As many have stated, the most important method is the one you stick with.
That being said, an understanding of how your muscles get energy may help.
Weight lifting is an anaerobic exercise. That means it doesn't use oxygen to provide energy. All of the energy comes from the glycogen which is stored in your muscles.
Cardio is an aerobic exercise. It combines oxygen with fat to provide energy, but it also uses glycogen. The more intense your aerobic exercise, the more glycogen is used. This is because the fat/oxygen method is relatively slow to provide energy and just can't keep up.
If you lift first, you will have less glycogen in your muscles. Therefore your body will be more likely to pull energy from fat stores instead of stored glycogen when you do the cardio. If you do cardio first you will burn off some fat, but mostly glycogen. So you will have less energy to lift weights, meaning you will get a less effective workout. In addition, you will burn less fat.
http://www.shapeyou.com/old/weights_first.html0 -
As many have stated, the most important method is the one you stick with.
That being said, an understanding of how your muscles get energy may help.
Weight lifting is an anaerobic exercise. That means it doesn't use oxygen to provide energy. All of the energy comes from the glycogen which is stored in your muscles.
Cardio is an aerobic exercise. It combines oxygen with fat to provide energy, but it also uses glycogen. The more intense your aerobic exercise, the more glycogen is used. This is because the fat/oxygen method is relatively slow to provide energy and just can't keep up.
If you lift first, you will have less glycogen in your muscles. Therefore your body will be more likely to pull energy from fat stores instead of stored glycogen when you do the cardio. If you do cardio first you will burn off some fat, but mostly glycogen. So you will have less energy to lift weights, meaning you will get a less effective workout. In addition, you will burn less fat.
http://www.shapeyou.com/old/weights_first.html
Very informative! Thank you ) I appreciate it0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions