Why do people chose to eat gluten free?
jenilia1
Posts: 12
I was newly diagnosed with Cealic Disease, so thats why I need to consume gluten unhindered now. Be that as it may I have known about a couple folks barring gluten from thier eating methodology by decision and I don't grasp why you might need to depending on if you had the decision to. Just inquisitive.
__________________________________________________________
eating gluten free benefits
__________________________________________________________
eating gluten free benefits
0
Replies
-
Hi - I am also a coeliac and I too find it difficult to understand why people would choose to eat gluten free ift hey don't have to! I know some people at intolerant to gluten and can see why they chose a gluten free diet, and I can understand the reason behind vegetarianism as a choice - but given freedom of choice I would readily eat gluten if i could.0
-
I was newly diagnosed with Cealic Disease, so thats why I need to consume gluten unhindered now. Be that as it may I have known about a couple folks barring gluten from thier eating methodology by decision and I don't grasp why you might need to depending on if you had the decision to. Just inquisitive.
__________________________________________________________
eating gluten free benefits0 -
I don't understand this diet fad either if you don't have a medical reason to be gluten free - as long as what you are consuming is healthy in the first place of course.
I did start getting a couple gluten free items the past couple months though, like bread. Only because I don't like eating processed carbs with a bunch of crap in them, & I don't like the texture of some whole grain stuff.0 -
Just because you havent been diagnised with a gluten allergy does it not mean that you are forced to eat it... SOme folks arent allergic to milk but decide to stay away from it
Perhaps they notice a difference in their digestive system when they leave gluten out...
maybe they have moral objections to gluten
maybe they just want to try something new....
having Celiac doesnt mean you have the right to be long-suffering alone....0 -
isn't that book "Wheatbelly" behind this fad? people are easily misled by junk science and that book is full of it.
http://noglutennoproblem.blogspot.com/2012/03/wheat-belly-busted.html
when it comes to the need to label some foods as "bad" so that all problems can be blamed on those foods, there is a term for that...
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orthorexia_nervosa
if people need to avoid gluten for medical reasons, then that's fine. but when people avoid it because they fear it and then blame it for all of their health problems, absent an actual medical diagnosis, then i think they are likely exhibiting orthorexic behavior.0 -
Supposedly gluten can cause side effects even in healthy people, or so they believe. My friend was told to try paleo by her chiropractor (i know right!) and she believes it has solved all of her ills. Of course it could just be that the gluten products and other non-paleo things were just highly processed and that was the root of it.0
-
For me and my wife we find that if we stick to gluten free, we fart much less! LOL!
I guess we have bacteria in our guts that thrive on gluten. When we eat it, we fart, when we don't, we dont!
So that's one reason why we chose to be gluten free, neither of us is coeliac.0 -
There are many reasons, i find it makes me feel bloated. I also find that it affects my skin, I suffer from Psoriasis.0
-
I also think that our bodies struggle to digest gluten0
-
I have IBS and get an upset stomach most of the time. so once I began gluten free I had less upset stomach days. my stomach is very sensitive.0
-
No idea. BUT my friend was having stomach issues (she is already really thin) and decided to cut out dairy and gluten to see if it would help and she dropped another 15lbs! And I thought, "Damn! I should try that!"0
-
I think the point of the post is its extremely hard to change eating habits. When I was younger I had a month gluten free due to suspicion of coeliac disease and it was difficult having to check what contained it, what didn't and then there's the price hike some supermarkets think they can apply to specialised food!0
-
I was diagnosed with hashimotos thyroiditis (autoinmune disease), and my doctor recommended to go gluten free, I have noticed a huge improvement in my digestion0
-
I have celiac disease. But I actually like eating gluten free.0
-
For some it's not a choice. I have psoriasis. Most books advise little to no gluten and or sugar, even though there is no scientific evidence to back that claim. Other than an eating disorder or other medical condition I don't know why anyone would choose to go gluten free. It's a huge learning curve0
-
Some people may not be allergic to gluten but they can be intolerant to it, just as many people can be intolerant to dairy or eggs.0
-
I am for the most part avoiding wheat and by implication similar grains, this came about because I discovered it can contribute to various forms of in-digestive issues. It comes down to the way wheat is broken down into sugar and it is the sugar which is causing the problem because it can in some ferment creating wind and or griping etc.
I discovered all this because I was introduced to the "low fodmap" system of eating, which in general is best followed with the help of a dietitian. (Low fodmap, sets out to address the issues of sugar absorption in its various forms) I also made reference to several IBS, irritable bowel sites. IBS seems to be a term which covers any food related issue from start to finish, from frequency to constipation some of which can be related to, guess what, sugar absorption issues.
For me this is just another pointer enabling me to progress towards good health only a few years ago I was racked with joint and muscle pain and that is another story0 -
If they don't medically need to (as diagnosed by a medical doctor, not as self-diagnosed or diagnosed by some new age practitioner), it's because they're following a trend and/or it's a good cover for an eating disorder and/or it's a superstition that developed because people do tend to lose weight when they cut out entire food groups.0
-
Why does it matter what other people eat? Why do some people feel the need to pour some thinly veiled scorn on folks that choose to eat in a way which has no impact on anyone else's life in any way? I don't know where this food bigotry came from but it's rife among weight loss/fitness communities and I think it's bizarre, unnecessary and totally non productive.0
-
I only care when they self-righteously insist that their thing is the One True Way and/or when they attempt to back it up with pseudoscience, which they often do. If someone says, "This is what works for me," and leaves it at that, then I have no problem.0
-
Why does it matter what other people eat? Why do some people feel the need to pour some thinly veiled scorn on folks that choose to eat in a way which has no impact on anyone else's life in any way? I don't know where this food bigotry came from but it's rife among weight loss/fitness communities and I think it's bizarre, unnecessary and totally non productive.
It's when people make unsubstantiated claims that they get challenged...and they should. The diet and fitness industry is rife with pseudoscience.0 -
I choose to eat GF since my wellness coach suggested that it might help with my asthma and it has. I can breathe so much better and I don't have to take the inhaler as often. Plus Rudi's GF bread is delicious!0
-
I also think that our bodies struggle to digest gluten
YOUR body might struggle to digest gluten, mine has no problem at all.
Op: some people have medical issues that prevent them from eating ANYTHING with gluten.
Some people feel better when cutting it out because they just feel better without it.
Some people believe the hype and they assume everyone should cut out gluten because they read something somewhere saying it's bad for us.0 -
Many people trying to lose weight come up with some sort of restrictive diet they like to follow - they say it makes them feel better, they're healthier and they swear by the diet. E.g. vegetarian, vegan, paleo, no-carbs, Atkins, no-gluten... I guess meat-avoidance can often have other reasoning behind it but it all achieves the same outcome - your overall pool of things you can eat decreases, so you eat less, and voila you get weight loss. For this reason the Atkins diet was very successful when it first got popular because there wasn't much you could eat, but these days there is so much Atkins-marketed food that people on an Atkins diet can easily stick to the diet while eating too many calories, and then they gain. In the early 2000s all you could eat was cheese and meat and it got old quickly, so it's no surprise that people lost so much weight on it.
My sister is Coeliac and finds it very frustrating that so many people choose to self-diagnose that the need a wheat-free diet, because in her case she can never ever eat gluten, whereas some people doing it for fun will still choose to eat gluten if they really want to. I have worked in a cafe where staff in the kitchen were *****ing about people going on gluten-free diets, and making jokes about sneaking flour into something just to trick them. If my sister ate that stuff she'd be violently ill, yet someone on a voluntary gluten-free diet would likely have no side effects. Gluten-free has become another fad and the problem with that is that people don't take an actual gluten allergy seriously, which can have disastrous consequences for those for whom it is a real problem.
That said, it is anyone's choice to go on a random diet but god help me I have known many many people through my work (nutritionist) who go on random restrictive diets only to find that it's boring and they eventually revert to a normal diet. It makes a mockery of real vegetarians when you know vegos who will still eat, same for vegans who will eat cheese, and gluten-free adopters who don't check labels and will still eat tasty foods with gluten in them when it takes their fancy.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions