Protein After Workout
AphelionPDX
Posts: 105
I am 5'5, 142 lb and just got done with a 60 minute cardio/strength training class where I burned 470 calories. Can anyone tell me how many grams of protein is optimal after my workout? I had a protein shake (25g protein) before my workout, but understand it's beneficial to consume protein after my workout as well. Thanks for your help, and I hope I'm posting in the correct forum!
0
Replies
-
Depends upon the type of workout... For cardio and light strength training not so much 20 to 30 grams will do it... (Muscle Milk or a Protein Bar) If you are doing serious weight training then 35 to 50 grams would be a good idea (Muscle Milk washing down a protein bar...)0
-
nutrient timing and supplements are unecessary. Just eat normally before and after and don't fret.0
-
I am 5'5, 142 lb and just got done with a 60 minute cardio/strength training class where I burned 470 calories. Can anyone tell me how many grams of protein is optimal after my workout? I had a protein shake (25g protein) before my workout, but understand it's beneficial to consume protein after my workout as well. Thanks for your help, and I hope I'm posting in the correct forum!
Gah!! I hate word problems!
0 -
I am 5'5, 142 lb and just got done with a 60 minute cardio/strength training class where I burned 470 calories. Can anyone tell me how many grams of protein is optimal after my workout? I had a protein shake (25g protein) before my workout, but understand it's beneficial to consume protein after my workout as well. Thanks for your help, and I hope I'm posting in the correct forum!
Gah!! I hate word problems!0 -
I am 5'5, 142 lb and just got done with a 60 minute cardio/strength training class where I burned 470 calories. Can anyone tell me how many grams of protein is optimal after my workout? I had a protein shake (25g protein) before my workout, but understand it's beneficial to consume protein after my workout as well. Thanks for your help, and I hope I'm posting in the correct forum!
Gah!! I hate word problems!
42...the answer is ALWAYS 42.
It's the answer to life, the universe and everything.0 -
I think anywhere between 20-40 grams is optimal. My understanding is that anabolic response taps around 40 grams.0
-
i've read that a full fat milk glass of is just as good as any protein shake but without all of the sugars, yes it has fat in it but no other addertives., like talked about here eat normal foods before training like chicken breast and Egg's, then afterwards have a glass of full fat milk (less if you don't like like semi skimmed etc) but the protein after a workout is just to assist the repair of muscles.
good luck but try that and see how you get on, if it does not work for you then stick to a shake before and after your workouts, but monitor your weight in either to see if you need it. you can allways just eat normally and take nothing extra and see what happens there too... all trial and error, we are all individual and eventually we will find what works for us.0 -
I'm a woman. I lift heavy. My post workout shake is ~32g of protein. Whatever helps you hit your protein macro.0
-
nutrient timing and supplements are unecessary. Just eat normally before and after and don't fret.
This.0 -
I am 5'5, 142 lb and just got done with a 60 minute cardio/strength training class where I burned 470 calories. Can anyone tell me how many grams of protein is optimal after my workout? I had a protein shake (25g protein) before my workout, but understand it's beneficial to consume protein after my workout as well. Thanks for your help, and I hope I'm posting in the correct forum!
Gah!! I hate word problems!
42...the answer is ALWAYS 42.
It's the answer to life, the universe and everything.
Based on StrikerJB looks like the answer is somewhere between 24 and 42. LOL0 -
Take in about 1g of protein per lb of LBM over the course of a day. Doesn't matter what the timing is.0
-
I think if you were working out fasted, it might be a bigger deal. Since that's not the case, I wouldn't worry about that quite so much. I'm always curious to see what others say...0
-
you eating to gain or to lose?
research shows carbs and protein together are better then one or the other alone. a ratio of 3:1 or 4:1 carbs to protein is supposedly optimal.
They sell dedicated 'recovery drinks' or 'post workout formulas' for this that are pretty pricey. They all use a refined sugar as the carb (because the idea is to play with the body's insulin response), so if that turns you off they may not be for you.
chocolate milk was used in some of the university studies that did research on protein/carbs post workout, so i cup or two of that would be a good alternative. these 3 ingredient pancakes also have a 3:1 ratio and are low fat (important for the insulin response) and are all natural ingredients. I'll make them after a workout if it wasn't very intense: http://undressedskeleton.tumblr.com/post/38657925508
I've seen formulas based on body weight to tell you exactly how many grams of carbs and protien to consume post work out. If i followed the suggestions, i'd be consuming 800 calories after ever workout. I'm trying to lose weight so that stright up does not support my goals. my post work out meal is about 210 cals, 10g protien, 40 gram carbs.
I've seen a lot of people saying that timing of meals is meaningless. I'd agree with them, EXCEPT in the case of post work out nutrition. Perhaps they are right, and all the peer reviewed journals are wrong, but as long as you are eating at your target calories and macros, its not going to hurt you, so what not do it on the chance that the research is right?0 -
Would someone's age play a factor in the equation. I'm 45, in my late 30's I noticed a big difference taking place in my body's ability to keep and build muscle. Fat was no problem for it.0
-
i've read that a full fat milk glass of is just as good as any protein shake but without all of the sugars, yes it has fat in it but no other addertives.
milks got 13g of sugar in it. the protein powder on my desk as 3 g0 -
Would someone's age play a factor in the equation. I'm 45, in my late 30's I noticed a big difference taking place in my body's ability to keep and build muscle. Fat was no problem for it.0
-
It's not worth the effort to calculate unless you are a serious heavy lifting body builder. Just eat normally.0
-
Doesn't matter when you get your protein just as long as you get enough thru out the day.0
-
Take in about 1g of protein per lb of LBM over the course of a day. Doesn't matter what the timing is.
Yup. ESPECIALLY if you're drinking a shake pre-workout, you REALLY don't have to have anything post-workout.
Only time I might recommend a post-workout shake is if you're working out fasted, and aren't eating anything for a long time post-workout. But that's pretty uncommon.0 -
is timing neccesary to build the body you want? of course not, doesn't mean it can't help significantly though.
probably better off doing your own investigation. I perfer listening to people with a bunch of letters after thier names instead of a bunch of time on thier hands, you could start here if you like:
http://oakbrooksc.com/docs/stager_chocmilk_study.pdf0 -
20 - 40 g of protein
add a little BCAA and Creatine for yoru body to help get this in to your muscle tissue.
add a little HGI carb (honey, etc) to spike insulin to help get this in to your muscle tissue.
good luck!0 -
I am 5'5, 142 lb and just got done with a 60 minute cardio/strength training class where I burned 470 calories. Can anyone tell me how many grams of protein is optimal after my workout? I had a protein shake (25g protein) before my workout, but understand it's beneficial to consume protein after my workout as well. Thanks for your help, and I hope I'm posting in the correct forum!
Gah!! I hate word problems!0 -
I was instructed to drink mine after my workout not before an dI'm taking abotu 23g per serving
I occasionally blend in a banana for extra creaminess!0 -
If the idea is to have the protein in your bloodstream to help you recover from the workouts, you would need to eat it before the workout, not after.0
-
If the idea is to have the protein in your bloodstream to help you recover from the workouts, you would need to eat it before the workout, not after.
supposedly you want it available in the blood stream within 90 min after a workout. I don't know how long whey protein is going to to take to digest, but dextrose and maltodextrin should be absorbed nearly instantly. dextrose is molecularly the same as blood sugar. those are the two carbs i put in my post workout drink.0 -
is timing neccesary to build the body you want? of course not, doesn't mean it can't help significantly though.
probably better off doing your own investigation. I perfer listening to people with a bunch of letters after thier names instead of a bunch of time on thier hands, you could start here if you like:
http://oakbrooksc.com/docs/stager_chocmilk_study.pdf
Thanks for that. I gave up on trying to argue "nutrient timing" here. I know what works. As a college athlete, no one would have ever said "as long as you get enough electrolytes during the day, you won't need any gatorade going into the 4th quarter during a game in 100 degree weather, water will be just fine."0 -
Take in about 1g of protein per lb of LBM over the course of a day. Doesn't matter what the timing is.
Yup. ESPECIALLY if you're drinking a shake pre-workout, you REALLY don't have to have anything post-workout.
Only time I might recommend a post-workout shake is if you're working out fasted, and aren't eating anything for a long time post-workout. But that's pretty uncommon.
http://www.jissn.com/content/pdf/1550-2783-10-5.pdf0 -
Thanks for that. I gave up on trying to argue "nutrient timing" here. I know what works. As a college athlete, no one would have ever said "as long as you get enough electrolytes during the day, you won't need any gatorade going into the 4th quarter during a game in 100 degree weather, water will be just fine."
lol good one.
its hard to find people on here that know the difference between an article in a magazine and emperical research from a peer reviewed journal.
I think people just get up in arms if something they don't personally do is suggested as possibly beneficial. They should just realize that no one is saying that anything is 'necessary', just that it might help some or even most people achieve thier goals.0 -
Take in about 1g of protein per lb of LBM over the course of a day. Doesn't matter what the timing is.
Yup. ESPECIALLY if you're drinking a shake pre-workout, you REALLY don't have to have anything post-workout.
Only time I might recommend a post-workout shake is if you're working out fasted, and aren't eating anything for a long time post-workout. But that's pretty uncommon.
http://www.jissn.com/content/pdf/1550-2783-10-5.pdf
^^yep.0 -
is timing neccesary to build the body you want? of course not, doesn't mean it can't help significantly though.
probably better off doing your own investigation. I perfer listening to people with a bunch of letters after thier names instead of a bunch of time on thier hands, you could start here if you like:
http://oakbrooksc.com/docs/stager_chocmilk_study.pdf
Thanks for that. I gave up on trying to argue "nutrient timing" here. I know what works. As a college athlete, no one would have ever said "as long as you get enough electrolytes during the day, you won't need any gatorade going into the 4th quarter during a game in 100 degree weather, water will be just fine."
It is not a valid comparison to compare protein systhesis for muscle recovery and rebuilding to electrolyte balance in an athlete exerting themselves for several hours, sweating and in 100 degree heat. It's apples and oranges. Not even close.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions