The quest for single-digit BF%
rkr22401
Posts: 216 Member
Seeking wisdom from from anyone out there that has actually achieved single-digit BF% (men) or mid-teens BF% (women), preferably those who started with significant fat to lose.
To focus potential replies: you know when you call tech-support and the person from the developing world on the other end is reading from a flowchart that begins "is you computer plugged into an outlet?" Well let's assume I'm way past that point and jump right into the deep end of the pool.
A little background: I started around 35+% BF. I'm now in the neighborhood of 15-16%. I've lost 58 lbs so far. I have done so by heavy compound lifting and eating lots of protein. I have managed to maintain lean mass so far. I have intentionally taken it slow...15 months of consistency so far. Friends and coworkers think I'm done and ask how I did it and how I'm maintaining. I am not done. I set a goal of <10% just because I like challenging goals and just to see if I could do it. I'm leaner than I have ever been in my life (I'm 43). I told myself I wouldn't post any before/after pics until my goal was achieved. I now have what could be described as a faint four-pack in flattering light, and my obliques are visible.
I recently started adding running to the mix (not jogging, not sprinting, but running at a pace that puts me at max HR after 2-3 miles). I'm following Lyle McDonald's fasted cardio protocol. I've avoided cardio up until this point, but I have a mud run in June. I'm keeping the distance in the 5k range and focusing on increasing speed rather than distance to resist catabolism. I limit the cardio to 2-3 times per week upon waking and I lift later in the day and on most non-cardio days (5 days lifting per week on avg). I typically do a push/pull split. I keep crazy hours that generally prevent whole-body lifting days.
I also recently started adding a big re-feed day every 2 weeks to attempt to balance hormones. I've experimented with low cal, high cal, low carb, IF, carb/cal cycling, TDEE - X% (usually for weeks or months at a time to give it time to work)...anything to keep the fat loss moving.
OK, enough about that.
I've come to appreciate that fat loss effort is logarithmic. Each successive 1/3 of total fat loss is 10X harder than the previous and eleventy billion times harder than the first. Initially weight loss is simply a matter of self-discipline, and burning more calories than you consume (simple, but not easy). The last 10-15 pounds; however, require OCD behavior. This is where I find myself.
I've lost 3 lbs of fat in the last 2 1/2 months, so it's still coming off, but at a tectonic pace (that's slower than glacial). I'm not in a hurry, but I'd like to achieve my goal in the next 4 months. At my current pace it may take close to a year to lose the last ~15 lbs. I'm ok with that, as long as I get there, but I'd rather not spin my wheels for months on end.
It seems to me that natural bodybuilders can successfully cut 15 lbs in 4 months without sacrificing lean mass. If any of you have personal experience in this area, I'm open to any suggestions, troubleshooting tips, or encouragement from those that have been there/done that.
Thanks in advance.
Rich
To focus potential replies: you know when you call tech-support and the person from the developing world on the other end is reading from a flowchart that begins "is you computer plugged into an outlet?" Well let's assume I'm way past that point and jump right into the deep end of the pool.
A little background: I started around 35+% BF. I'm now in the neighborhood of 15-16%. I've lost 58 lbs so far. I have done so by heavy compound lifting and eating lots of protein. I have managed to maintain lean mass so far. I have intentionally taken it slow...15 months of consistency so far. Friends and coworkers think I'm done and ask how I did it and how I'm maintaining. I am not done. I set a goal of <10% just because I like challenging goals and just to see if I could do it. I'm leaner than I have ever been in my life (I'm 43). I told myself I wouldn't post any before/after pics until my goal was achieved. I now have what could be described as a faint four-pack in flattering light, and my obliques are visible.
I recently started adding running to the mix (not jogging, not sprinting, but running at a pace that puts me at max HR after 2-3 miles). I'm following Lyle McDonald's fasted cardio protocol. I've avoided cardio up until this point, but I have a mud run in June. I'm keeping the distance in the 5k range and focusing on increasing speed rather than distance to resist catabolism. I limit the cardio to 2-3 times per week upon waking and I lift later in the day and on most non-cardio days (5 days lifting per week on avg). I typically do a push/pull split. I keep crazy hours that generally prevent whole-body lifting days.
I also recently started adding a big re-feed day every 2 weeks to attempt to balance hormones. I've experimented with low cal, high cal, low carb, IF, carb/cal cycling, TDEE - X% (usually for weeks or months at a time to give it time to work)...anything to keep the fat loss moving.
OK, enough about that.
I've come to appreciate that fat loss effort is logarithmic. Each successive 1/3 of total fat loss is 10X harder than the previous and eleventy billion times harder than the first. Initially weight loss is simply a matter of self-discipline, and burning more calories than you consume (simple, but not easy). The last 10-15 pounds; however, require OCD behavior. This is where I find myself.
I've lost 3 lbs of fat in the last 2 1/2 months, so it's still coming off, but at a tectonic pace (that's slower than glacial). I'm not in a hurry, but I'd like to achieve my goal in the next 4 months. At my current pace it may take close to a year to lose the last ~15 lbs. I'm ok with that, as long as I get there, but I'd rather not spin my wheels for months on end.
It seems to me that natural bodybuilders can successfully cut 15 lbs in 4 months without sacrificing lean mass. If any of you have personal experience in this area, I'm open to any suggestions, troubleshooting tips, or encouragement from those that have been there/done that.
Thanks in advance.
Rich
0
Replies
-
In lieu of a bump, a closely related follow-up question:
If the timeline is to be expected, it seems like it would make for some long bulk & cut cycles afterwards. Thoughts?0 -
Good luck achieving that goal, I really don't have any wisdom to impart, I hover around that 10-12% mark and would love to crack single digits, but I just lack the discipline to really take off that last little bit.0
-
As long as you are training with weights, it is very difficult to starve yourself enough to lose LBM. As you said, weight lifters prep for contests can drop an extreme amount of weight. A lot of it is water and often assisted with diuretics. I am seeking a similar final goal of being at or below 10% BF. I am almost 45 years old and just past 50 lbs lost with a current 16% BF. Unlike you, I have done it all with cardio because I find that I cannot lose weight and lift. My appetite becomes crazy and it is very difficult for me to keep myself at a consistent deficit. Also, cardio has always been my weak spot and I am taking the opportunity to strengthen my weaknesses first and then go to lifting as a finishing and long term workout. After losing 50+ lbs with very little resistance training, I have lost almost no LBM so I don't understand why people are frightened of cardio0
-
It is much harder to get to the single digits after losing a significant amount of weight than it is when it is just a small cut. Your body has already adapted quite a bit to cutting which will make it that much harder. Refeeds will help, but only a little bit.
If you are planning on gaining muscle as well, you will be much better off getting somewhat close, switching to bulking for a few months to really undo all the adaptations to cutting, then switch to cutting and go for it.
Remember though, most people underestimate their BF% by a bit, even if you try your best not to.
I haven't yet gotten to single digits, close though (legit 10.x's) on my last cut. Next cut I'm going for it. My intial cut from fat guy to trim (75 lbs) got down to about 13% (in hindsight, thought it was 10% at the time). 2 bulk cycles and about 9 months now since I finished my initial cut, at about 11% right now, going to start cutting again in April. Last time around the first month of cutting was easy peasy, it didn't start getting hard until about 6 weeks in, then my body started really fighting it, I discovered what it really means to be hungry (food fantasies, big meals are unfilling, snacks are unappealing as a means to combat hunger).0 -
It's very tough to do. Initially, I went from 200 lbs. to 165 lbs. eating right and lifting heavy consistently. I ended up in the 12% BF range with no significant difference in BF levels between 165 and 175 lbs. 165 was too skinny for my height, so I clean-bulked back up to 180 at around 15% BF. I gained some mass and I'm now cutting back to the low 170's to see if I can get leaner than I was on my first pass at weight loss. I plan to alternate bulking/cutting until I get to where I want to be.0
-
I'm in the same boat - Intersting to find out what advise is out there0
-
Rich...I couldn't have stated my predicament any better than you have. Although I've got my fatloss on a spreadsheet to a power curve, showing just how slow it has become. I'm at 11% (using the Navy estimating method) and hope to get to 9.5% some day.
I cut from 215 to 167 and achieved "skinny-fat" results. I'm just finishing Body Beast and it appears as though I've brought up my lean mass from 149 to 159. I needed a break from the calorie restrictions and ab obsession and Body Beast looked like a great diversion. This was a good detour to change my focus for a bit and adding mass was a great investment. I finish in 2 days and will post my results on that program and my journey in general.
I'm considering cycling between P90X and Body Beast until I achieve the desired results. I'm thinking I'll limit my carbs to 120g and my macros to 40(p)/ 30 (c) /30 (f) while on P90X and follow the Beast diet while on that program.
Great post...0 -
Bump0
-
This is what I needed to see today. I had lost over 200 lbs, and when still about 30 lbs away from my goal, I started lifting. For the past year, I have been frustrated as the lbs went up, but the inches stayed the same or dropped some (except where I have been adding muscle across the shoulders, chest and arms). I keep debating if I should stop trying to lift and cut my way to goal and go back on the Doctor's program (which was around 900 Calories a day, so it is impossible to lift and do the program) or if I should just keep going and expect it is going to take me 5 years to loose the last 20 lbs that should get be to within my goal of 9.9% bf.
It is funny, cause I am eating to lose about 2 lbs a week, and yet, the scale just keeps jumping around.
Glad to see I am not the only one struggling with this issue!0 -
Good post. I'm in the mid teens in BF% and I'd like to get to ~10%, but I'm having the same struggle. I think I'm starting to see progress though. I have been in maintenance mode for a few months and now I'm doing 3 days cardio, 3 days lifting a week on a moderate caloric deficit. Seeing some loss, but slower than it was when I lost alot of fat a year ago.0
-
don't eat carbs0
-
RH, you've done a lot of work so far congrats!
Apex, I've done low carb before and can do it again. I think I've gotten too content with a happy diet and incremental success, that I didn't want to push harder. I'll try 4 weeks under 50 g Carbs a day and see what happens. I'll need to find my potassium supplements...and some bacon.
Since my original post I've added an estimated 5 pounds of lean mass. I can bring up my LBM, but not without adding fat.0 -
Bump, you never know what wisdom the forums will provide today.
Tomorrow is one years effort of losing 46 pounds and putting back 14 in lean mass.
"Good enough" is the enemy of success. I've done well, but I'm bummed to have not met my ulitmate goal of single-digit BF% or 6 pack abs. I got to find the motivation to make this happen for my inner control freak.0 -
Seeking wisdom from from anyone out there that has actually achieved single-digit BF% (men) or mid-teens BF% (women), preferably those who started with significant fat to lose.
To focus potential replies: you know when you call tech-support and the person from the developing world on the other end is reading from a flowchart that begins "is you computer plugged into an outlet?" Well let's assume I'm way past that point and jump right into the deep end of the pool.
A little background: I started around 35+% BF. I'm now in the neighborhood of 15-16%. I've lost 58 lbs so far. I have done so by heavy compound lifting and eating lots of protein. I have managed to maintain lean mass so far. I have intentionally taken it slow...15 months of consistency so far. Friends and coworkers think I'm done and ask how I did it and how I'm maintaining. I am not done. I set a goal of <10% just because I like challenging goals and just to see if I could do it. I'm leaner than I have ever been in my life (I'm 43). I told myself I wouldn't post any before/after pics until my goal was achieved. I now have what could be described as a faint four-pack in flattering light, and my obliques are visible.
I recently started adding running to the mix (not jogging, not sprinting, but running at a pace that puts me at max HR after 2-3 miles). I'm following Lyle McDonald's fasted cardio protocol. I've avoided cardio up until this point, but I have a mud run in June. I'm keeping the distance in the 5k range and focusing on increasing speed rather than distance to resist catabolism. I limit the cardio to 2-3 times per week upon waking and I lift later in the day and on most non-cardio days (5 days lifting per week on avg). I typically do a push/pull split. I keep crazy hours that generally prevent whole-body lifting days.
I also recently started adding a big re-feed day every 2 weeks to attempt to balance hormones. I've experimented with low cal, high cal, low carb, IF, carb/cal cycling, TDEE - X% (usually for weeks or months at a time to give it time to work)...anything to keep the fat loss moving.
OK, enough about that.
I've come to appreciate that fat loss effort is logarithmic. Each successive 1/3 of total fat loss is 10X harder than the previous and eleventy billion times harder than the first. Initially weight loss is simply a matter of self-discipline, and burning more calories than you consume (simple, but not easy). The last 10-15 pounds; however, require OCD behavior. This is where I find myself.
I've lost 3 lbs of fat in the last 2 1/2 months, so it's still coming off, but at a tectonic pace (that's slower than glacial). I'm not in a hurry, but I'd like to achieve my goal in the next 4 months. At my current pace it may take close to a year to lose the last ~15 lbs. I'm ok with that, as long as I get there, but I'd rather not spin my wheels for months on end.
It seems to me that natural bodybuilders can successfully cut 15 lbs in 4 months without sacrificing lean mass. If any of you have personal experience in this area, I'm open to any suggestions, troubleshooting tips, or encouragement from those that have been there/done that.
Thanks in advance.
Rich
Rich,
Lyle has an article on his site (I want to say it's in one of the metabolism areas) where he actually talks about 2 women being identical (age,weight,etc). One was at that weight naturally, whereas the other one had dropped significant weight to get there. The one that dropped weight, actually has a lower maintenance then the one that "naturally" weights that much.
Now as far as sub 10% goes...
I mean what's your actual motivation for sub 10?
Realistically the only people that try to get that lean are contest bodybuilders, and even then it's not for the long term. You SHOULD have visible abs in the 10-12% range and even there it could be dependent upon pose and lighting.
Even pro bodybuilders creep up above 10% especially in the offseason, or when bulking.
Basically what I'm trying to say is that MOST people don't maintain sub 10, and it's rather difficult to get there to begin with.0 -
I did exactly one Physique contest in 2004. I got down to 15% bf at that time. I did not win anything, but it did teach me a lot about what it takes to get to that level.
If your budget is limited, your best spent money will be on Whey protein supplements 3-4 times a day (or more).
Don't worry too much about cardio. Endurance isn't the goal when reaching a very low body fat percentage. You'll need to do HIIT 4-6 days a week. Try to max out your heart rate when doing HIIT and don't go longer than 20 minutes. If you are going longer than 20 minutes you are doing it wrong. You should feel like vomiting or passing out after that 20 minute HIIT session.
Meal timing is very important. You are right when you mentioned being OCD about eating. You absolutely will feel insane when your alarm goes off and you just have to go pound down a protein shake. Don't let more than 3 hours go by without eating. Yes, wake up in the middle of the night and have a protein shake. Get whey protein in a variety of flavors so that you don't get bored. I also like to mix mine with flavored crystal light just for more variety.
You didn't mention your budget, but if you have some expendable income, look into supplementation to cut the fat. There are a variety of different thermogenic stacks out there that can be of assistance. Add in some BCAA's as well as creatine and some performance recovery formulas to help you keep as much of your hard won muscle as possible while cutting.
Still have some cash you want to throw at this project? Hire a personal trainer. Hire the man/woman who has trained award winning body builders. If (s)he can't give you references to athletes (s)he trained, don't waste your money. And for God's Sake, don't hire the in-house trainer at the gym! Mostly those folks are just there to keep noobs from hurting themselves on the equipment--(is your computer plugged into the wall?).
If you still have money left over, get something like Up by Jawbone. 24-7 monitoring of your biological functions will be helpful in making micro changes to your routines and diet for maximum results.
While you are checking your metabolic processes, get yourself into a Bod-Pod so that you have an accurate base line measurement of your body fat percentage. Repeat the Bod-Pod test twice a month until your goal is reached.
Also consider getting a resting metabolic rate test done as well. What you don't know may cause you to under or over eat. This will ensure that you are actually consuming the correct number of calories a day.
If you have crazy amounts of money to spend, look into HGH and anabolic supplements. Keep it legal though. I'm not advising that you use a controlled substance. If you do decide to go the controlled substance route, hire an exercise physiologist to help you. Some anabolic steroids are controlled because if they are used improperly they can be dangerous. I've seen some steroids used in a beneficial manner, but your trainer has to really, really know his chemistry and biology for it to work well.
I didn't do all of these things when I was body building. I spent about $1200 a month for 5 months to get myself down to 15% body fat. I had a high paying job that allowed me a lot of schedule flexibility back then (Home Construction GC, Spec houses mostly). I suppose that getting down to single digits is possible for less money, but I also imagine that it would take a very long time and a lot of muscle mass would have to be sacrificed.
I have a genetic issue that would prevent me from winning any physique contests without liposuction surgery. I hold all my body fat in my torso. Even at 15% body fat I still could not reveal a 6-pack. I had veins popping on my arms and legs, even on my lower abdomen, but I couldn't get a 6-pack thanks to my mom and dad. But you never know until you try, and I gave it the best possible effort that I could afford to give.
So that's how you buy your way to super low body fat. It can be done in 8-12 weeks if you have the cash.0 -
Rich hasn't back to his post, but I bumped it because I can relate to his frustration.
TheRealParisL, I sense some well meaning sarcasm; I bought the obese body one pizza at a time and I'm earning the one I have now. I just seem to be at the limits of my knowledge and seeking guidance. I hope you're suggestion that being healthy has to be expensive doesn't turn anyone off; I think your're suggesting I pay for my vanity and that is a fair dig in my book.
You and Medic2038 both have valid points. Why do we want it and how much effort are we willing to make?
Thanks for the responses and the cause for introspection. I guess I already knew the answer is and always has been to exercise, eat better and maintain a calorie deficit. The changes over the last 3-4 months have been extremely subtle; I was just looking for some motivation on a down day. My own fault, I should have never picked a calendar date for a goal.0 -
i have a buddy who is a natural bodybuilder, he told me he has to take diuretics to stay in that sub-10%. i've never been lower than 11 myself, and definitely have the same goal as you guys0
-
I've watched quite a bit of the documentary "I wanna look like that guy" (basically the parts I could see for free online). It attempts to display some of the fitness industry myths and try to really show what it takes to get to a very low body fat percentage. It's basically a look at a mid-20% body fat guy in his early 40's and taking him to bodybuilding contest quality shape. It was eye opening for me to see how difficult it really is to go from "pretty good shape" to contest shape.0
-
Huh, well I posted in this thread, a few months back. I see it here, a little update.
Lost all the fat gained my 2nd bulk, just dropped right off in 2 weeks. As per usual, the leaner you get, the more you realize your past estimates were too low. I'm pretty sure I'm within 3-4 lbs or so of the single digits, abs are starting to show decently when unflexed. Navy formula is LOL, says I'm 9%. Modified Y has me at 11.6%, that seems right.
By Memorial Day I'll be there.
My advice still remains, if you've lost a lot of fat, once you get into the visible abs when flexed range, start cycling short moderate rate bulks along with the cuts, letting them act as a refeed, cut long enough to cut past your leanest with each cut.
The first month of post-bulk cutting is easy. If you keep the bulks short and moderate rate, you'll drop the new fat fast.
If you are going to do refeeds instead, ditch the pig out day and instead do a 1-2 weeks at maintanence refeed. Your homones won't be fixed with one pig out. A longer refeed will at least fix things somewhat, though it won't undo slowed metabolism like bulking will.
I think most of the advice though in this thread is crap. There is nothing special about cutting into the single digits. What you have to fight is your bodies tendency to adapt to a deficit, lowering your metabolism, and your bodies hormonal warfare against starvation that gets much stronger as you get leaner and as you've been dieting longer. Fighting these things makes it very hard to cut to the single digits in a linear fashion from much higher. A few minicuts gets around this issue. Don't cut longer than 6 weeks or so without a long enough break from cutting that all cutting adaptations are undone (starting in the low teens). It takes longer, but it is never really hard and you don't have to sacrifice your metabolism or lean mass.0 -
That is helpful Waldo, I've been through 3 cuts and 2 bulks. Each cut seems to take me back to where I finished my last cut as far as waist measurements go.
I agree with your frustration regarding the navy method: I'll Google the Modified Y method. I look a lot different but I've been in the 10% by the Navy Method on 3 different occassions on each cut over the last 6 months. My lean mass estimates vary 3-4 pounds so I've been trying to use a trend/average to stabilize the estimates. But they drop a lot while cutting; not so much that I'm losing lean mass, moreso that it was overestimated.
I'm going to spend the rest of this month finishing this cut cycle and look at shorter bulking sessions. I think my cut cycles have either been too short or I've allowed too many calories, perhaps because I was overestimating my lean mass.
Thanks for the advice, it will give me something to focus on this summer/fall.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions