We are pleased to announce that as of March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor has been introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

Body fit media variation in calorie burn

mtforrester
mtforrester Posts: 2
edited January 15 in Fitness and Exercise
I just got the BFM link. Yesterday I worked out on the elliptical for 65 minutes in "fat burn" mode, so my heart rate didn't get much over 125. Good workout but not real strenuous. BFM said I burned 396 calories. Today I did elliptical on Rolling hills program for 65 minutes and exerted myself WAY more. I was drenched and felt like I had really burned a lot of calories. I synched up and to my surprise BFM said I burned about 250 calories. This cannot be accurate. Has anyone else had this experience? I want to be able to rely on the info I am getting, but there is no way I burned less calories today in my workout. Would love to hear other's feedback

Replies

  • mtforrester
    mtforrester Posts: 2
    Bump
  • rockerbabyy
    rockerbabyy Posts: 2,258 Member
    i havent had it happen with my BMF, but ive had it happen with my HRM. ive learned that the amount i sweat and perceived exertion dont always = more calories burned. also, the more you wear your bmf the more accurate it will be - it takes about a week for it really kinda "learn" your body.
  • Surisaddai
    Surisaddai Posts: 142 Member
    I use my body media band all day long. When I am going to do hard workouts I also put my heart rate monitor on to compare. I will usually log the calories my HRM says I burned during those work outs to mfp and then my arm band balances it out. I have noticed that once I added them on mfp, the arm band will not add the workout again, it will show something like "bodymedia adjustment 0". I use the body media info to estimate my loss during a whole week of work and it is usually pretty accurate, I hope that helps.
  • rileysowner
    rileysowner Posts: 8,359 Member
    I dont' have a BMF, but they are not specifically for recording times of exercise. They are a whole day activity monitor. As to the differences, I can't really say except that I seem to remember reading that it takes a while for the BMF to "learn" you as an individual. Through that time the numbers it gives for your daily calorie burn will vary and likely, from what I remember, start out a little high and then move lower. In the long run those numbers will be much more accurate than they are at first, or so I have heard.
  • amyoliver85
    amyoliver85 Posts: 353 Member
    Body Media Fit is not the most accurate way to measure your heart rate, unfortunately. If you are off of your bicep by even a smidgen, you will get an inaccurate reading. Also, it is my understanding that it's technology relies on your body heat to help give you a reading too. If your sweat got cold or your skin got cold, then it can mess up the reading. I have a friend who is a zumba teacher that has one and she never works out without her HRM on her too. I also have a fitbit and a BMF and I always still use my HRM when I work out. The difference between the two is astounding. To be honest, my fit bit actually comes out with a much closer to accurate reading of my exercise than my BMF.
  • Elleinnz
    Elleinnz Posts: 1,661 Member
    Body Media Fit is not the most accurate way to measure your heart rate, unfortunately. If you are off of your bicep by even a smidgen, you will get an inaccurate reading. Also, it is my understanding that it's technology relies on your body heat to help give you a reading too. If your sweat got cold or your skin got cold, then it can mess up the reading. I have a friend who is a zumba teacher that has one and she never works out without her HRM on her too. I also have a fitbit and a BMF and I always still use my HRM when I work out. The difference between the two is astounding. To be honest, my fit bit actually comes out with a much closer to accurate reading of my exercise than my BMF.

    ^^^^ this - when I was using my BMF I would still use my HRM for exercise, and not the BMF readings..... It does not read your HR, so not very accurate when exercising....
This discussion has been closed.

Categories