Endometrial Ablation vs. BCP - Pro/Cons/Personal experiences
I am 37, F. i had my tubes tied 12 years ago. I have been on continuous birth control (various types of pills) for ~ 10 years due to excessive cramping and heavy bleeding during my period. I was looking at endometrial ablation as an option. I want off of the birth control pills for various reasons - tired of pumping chemicals into my body and feeling like it isn't in control of itself, slow weight loss and zero sex drive.
In my research it looks like Novasure would be my best option but I have also seen a lot of horror stories where women have increased pain or "tugging sensations". I have also read of cases where it didn't work completely and you still have a period. I could live with that if it was light. I have also thought about either just stopping BCPs and seeing what happens or trying another type since I am going to a new doctor now. I had an OB/GYN suggest an IUD. I don't need birth control I just don't want to be doubled over in pain and feelig like I am hemmoraging 3 - 5 days per month!
I am looking for any input on this from anyone who has been through this themselves. Any input on the procedure or different types of BCP vs. how your quality of life was. I'm supposed to be near my "peak" but feel more like I'm "down in the valley"!
In my research it looks like Novasure would be my best option but I have also seen a lot of horror stories where women have increased pain or "tugging sensations". I have also read of cases where it didn't work completely and you still have a period. I could live with that if it was light. I have also thought about either just stopping BCPs and seeing what happens or trying another type since I am going to a new doctor now. I had an OB/GYN suggest an IUD. I don't need birth control I just don't want to be doubled over in pain and feelig like I am hemmoraging 3 - 5 days per month!
I am looking for any input on this from anyone who has been through this themselves. Any input on the procedure or different types of BCP vs. how your quality of life was. I'm supposed to be near my "peak" but feel more like I'm "down in the valley"!
0
Replies
-
I had Novasure done approximately 2 years ago and it is the best thing that I have ever done. I am 34 have 5 kids and after my last 2 kids my periods were horrendous. I cramped so bad and bled so much I would miss work all the time. I would bleed for 7 straight days heavily where it used to be around 4-5 and light at the end.
The procedure was uncomfortable, but managable with the pain meds, I was down for one day sleeping because of the vicodin (I do not tolerate meds well) I had some slight cramping after the procedure for a few days but it wasn't bad.
The Dr who did my procedure said the reason some people still bleed after having it done is because they have fibroids so they did an ultrasound before my procedure to make sure there were none there and some drs do not do this so that is something to consider. Today.. 2 years later.. I rarely cramp at that time of the month and it is for a short period of time. less than a day. about every 3-4 months I have a VERY light period.. It will last a day or two and be more like spotting. I am so glad I did the procedure and my insurance covered it.
I hope this helps!!0 -
novasure changed my life. One the best decisions I ever made. Haven't had a period since (55)0
-
thanks for the input! bump!0
-
I also had the ablation done about 2 years ago and I couldn't be happier. I've had no ill effects from it whatsoever. I get a "lite" period every other month that lasts a couple of days and no bleeding during the other months. This is such a relief compared to the horror I went through prior to the procedure. My doctor did tell me that sometimes you have to have the procedure re-done after 5 or 6 years, but I wouldn't hesitate to get it done again if I had to.0
-
Hi - sorry to hear you're having a rotten time.
Last year I was flooding and having to go home every month which was especially awful as I'm a primary school teacher!
I wasn't allowed BCP because of my migraines. So I had the nova-sure procedure under general anaesthetic. I had no pain afterwards (well - nothing compared to period pains!). The only uncomfortable part was when they used a camera to check that I had no fibroids 2 months prior to the procedure.
It was the best thing I ever did - I lose about 2 teaspoons a month - it's a breeze. I have a bit of pain, but nothing like what I had before!
I hope everything works out for you.
Be good to yourself
x0 -
I got the Mirena and my periods are very light, maybe once every four months and I don't have cramps. My sister and a lot of my friends have gotten the Mirena too, and they have all had the same effect.
the insertion is painful but it's only a minute.
Also, the hormones really don't act outside the uterus or in your blood stream to the same effect as BC. I did Depo provera and it really killed my drive, Mirena is great for the "peaks no valleys".
0 -
Wow. I need to make an appt with my doc to talk about having this done. I just recently got off of implanon (my TOM was lasting 30-40 days on it) and now we're waiting to see if my body can regulate itself, but remembering how they went before, it's still going to be 10-14 days of intense cramping and heavy heavy bleeding. I would love to feel normal for once in my life, and this sounds like it's exactly what I need! Thanks for the topic, OP!0
-
This sounds pretty drastic of a suggestion, but if you are done having children, or have no intention of having any, why not get a hysterectomy? I had one at 36, and I have to say it was the best decision I've made. I struggled for years with endometreosis, and finally a condition called adenomyosis (spelling??) so needless to say my pain was constant, and no relief was available, and believe me, I tried them all. Since then, I've suffered very little side effects, I still have one ovary so I am getting enough hormones. I'm not on any kind of supplement, I only have a few problems with my feet having hot flashes. (I know, weird, right?)
It was a difficult decision to come to, but in retrospect I would do it again.0 -
I had the Mirena and it was terrible for me. Although the hormones are supposed to be localized, they still can affect you, and for me they did, and very negatively. I was tired, irritable, angry. My anger would flash at the tiniest thing - not good with two little ones! I ended up removing it myself one day and do not regret that decision at all.
After googling Mirena and its side effects, I found out I was not alone on how it can effect your mood. However, many other women have had it and rave about it, so all to say that it works for some, but not all!
Ablation was recommended to me and i was hesitant to do it, but after reading this perhaps I will rethink it....!
Thanks for sharing this post!0 -
I had an ablation done three years ago under general anesthesia. BEST DECISION EVER!
I had my tubes tied 12 years prior to that and had suffered long, painful, floods every month and was sick of it. My Dr. suggested the ablation after discovering fibroids. After the initial two weeks of a slight discharge following the procedure I have had NO monthly visitor since. I do however notice slight mood changes and food cravings just as I did before but no more cramping or monthly period. Since it was three years ago, I don't really remember much (if any) pain following the procedure. I know they prescribed a pain med but I never got it filled so I must have just taken Tylenol for any pain. Had it done on Friday and was back to work on Monday.0 -
This sounds pretty drastic of a suggestion, but if you are done having children, or have no intention of having any, why not get a hysterectomy? I had one at 36, and I have to say it was the best decision I've made. I struggled for years with endometreosis, and finally a condition called adenomyosis (spelling??) so needless to say my pain was constant, and no relief was available, and believe me, I tried them all. Since then, I've suffered very little side effects, I still have one ovary so I am getting enough hormones. I'm not on any kind of supplement, I only have a few problems with my feet having hot flashes. (I know, weird, right?)
It was a difficult decision to come to, but in retrospect I would do it again.
A hysterectomy is major surgery and far more serious then an ablation. Prior to finding my doctor I swore up and down that I wanted a hysterectomy so that I wouldn't have to put up with the bleeding that I dealt with. An ablation is a much more mild procedure. Why have something so drastic if a more minor procedure will take care of what's going on?0 -
I had an ablation done three years ago under general anesthesia. BEST DECISION EVER!
I had my tubes tied 12 years prior to that and had suffered long, painful, floods every month and was sick of it. My Dr. suggested the ablation after discovering fibroids. After the initial two weeks of a slight discharge following the procedure I have had NO monthly visitor since. I do however notice slight mood changes and food cravings just as I did before but no more cramping or monthly period. Since it was three years ago, I don't really remember much (if any) pain following the procedure. I know they prescribed a pain med but I never got it filled so I must have just taken Tylenol for any pain. Had it done on Friday and was back to work on Monday.
Your experience sounds exactly like mine, only I had my tubes tied this past year (after the ablation). I forgot to mention that I still get the monthly PMS symptons even when I don't have my period.0 -
This sounds pretty drastic of a suggestion, but if you are done having children, or have no intention of having any, why not get a hysterectomy? I had one at 36, and I have to say it was the best decision I've made. I struggled for years with endometreosis, and finally a condition called adenomyosis (spelling??) so needless to say my pain was constant, and no relief was available, and believe me, I tried them all. Since then, I've suffered very little side effects, I still have one ovary so I am getting enough hormones. I'm not on any kind of supplement, I only have a few problems with my feet having hot flashes. (I know, weird, right?)
It was a difficult decision to come to, but in retrospect I would do it again.
Really can't afford time off from work (single income household) and don't want anything removed unless medically necessary. Not to that point yet. In the south Drs. tend to be hyster happy! Just wish my body could be more self regulating!0 -
Have you even been given an explination for your excessive bleeding?0
-
I want to say also that I do still get moody and have some cravings like before.. but it sure beats the flooding!! I would do it all over again. Some of these women say they had general anesthesia but I didn't.. I was given a pain med prior to the procedure and one for after.. I would have been terrified to go under..lol I'm a sissy that way.0
-
This sounds pretty drastic of a suggestion, but if you are done having children, or have no intention of having any, why not get a hysterectomy? I had one at 36, and I have to say it was the best decision I've made. I struggled for years with endometreosis, and finally a condition called adenomyosis (spelling??) so needless to say my pain was constant, and no relief was available, and believe me, I tried them all. Since then, I've suffered very little side effects, I still have one ovary so I am getting enough hormones. I'm not on any kind of supplement, I only have a few problems with my feet having hot flashes. (I know, weird, right?)
It was a difficult decision to come to, but in retrospect I would do it again.
A hysterectomy is major surgery and far more serious then an ablation. Prior to finding my doctor I swore up and down that I wanted a hysterectomy so that I wouldn't have to put up with the bleeding that I dealt with. An ablation is a much more mild procedure. Why have something so drastic if a more minor procedure will take care of what's going on?
I guess I am not sure what this procedure is. That being said, since my problem was specifically with my uteurus it was really the only option for me. Plus, that was never offered to me, maybe because it wasn't a viable option for me. Adenomyosis is damage to the lining of the uterus, and was only discovered AFTER they opened me up. I had a uterus the size of someone who was 6 months pregnant, so even if that procedure had been an option, I'm sure the doctor would've changed her mind once she saw that.0 -
Have you even been given an explination for your excessive bleeding?
no, no real explanation. they did ultrasounds to confirm that i didn't have fibroids or anything because I was spotting constantly for 3 - 4 months a couple of years ago. i thought it was odd because the tech said i had almost no lining, but was still spotting.0 -
Had it done 16 months ago... i still get pain, but almost no period to speak of...very awesome for the pool or beach, and not having plans/vacations ruined from 10 to 14 days of bleeding. i would do it again!0
-
I had ablation done about 4/5 years ago and it was great for about 6 months and then right back to where I was. I was one of the 20% that has little or no success. I ended up having a hysterectomy (uterus only) and it was the BEST thing I have ever done. Wish I had done it sooner. It is surgery and the recovery time was a week no activity and then only light activity for 6 weeks. 24hrs in the hospital and then home. I did well with that. It sounds like you have done your research so go with what will make you comfortable. Alot of women I know have had success, I was one of the unfortunate like I said. Not sorry that I did ablation first though.0
-
I had an ablation in 2005 and it was one of the best decisions of my life. I no longer have periods. I didn't have any problems during recovery and I was back to my job (heavy lifting) after a week. If I had it to do again, I definitely would.
Something to consider though, if you have fibroids, it doesn't stop them from going. Talk to your doctor about that. Last year I had a Uterine Arterial Embolization for fibroids. My recovery from that was hell. But, six months later, the doctors are very happy with my progress.
Ablations can also make finding uterine cancer more difficult. If you happen to get pregnant after it, it can be life threatening. Do some research and talk to your doctor. Best of luck to you!0 -
I had an ablation about 3 years ago. Best. Decision. Ever. I have fibroids and was told that at best my periods would be lighter. But they are gone. I was very lucky. And no cramping at all. I had very minimal discomfort after the procedure too. I'm a poster child for ablation. :P0
-
It's been almost 6 years since I had my ablation. No periods ever since. However, last year I did have some issues and had to have another laparoscopy for endometriosis and adenomyosis. So, yes, you can still have those problems after the ablation. Honestly, though, I know how to control mine and don't have any problems when I'm doing the right exercise. I've had issues for about 16-17 years and they all go away when I'm lifting heavy. If I stop lifting for whatever reason, then I end up having problems. Last year, I hadn't lifted weights seriously for about a year because of trying to drop muscle mass to do a kidney donation. I had surgery in August to remove the endometriosis and in September and October I was back in my doctors office to get pain killers for the adenomyosis still bothering me. They can fix the adenomyosis with a hysterectomy, but I didn't have the time to take off for the recovery at the time. After being ruled out as a kidney donor, I went back to my normal weight training in late September, early October. By November, my monthly pain was gone. I haven't had a problem since. So, while the whole not having a period for the last 6 years has been awesome, I would actually recommend heavy weight training for control of the problem first. I believe in it so much that when I get to my grad school in August, I'm planning on doing research on the effects of heavy weight training on the hormone profile of women. I believe that it can be an effective preventative treatment for PCOS, Endometriosis, Adenomyosis, and Estrogen Based Cancers and plan to do the research to prove it.0
-
Just this past Feb I had Novasure, a D&C, my left ovary removed, laproscopy, hysterscopy, and a 7cm cyst removed. If I'd had a job outside the house I could have gone back 2-3 days later. I don't know if Novasure is different now or if some had a different thing but my doc said that it's over 90% effective. I should have had 2 periods since then but nothing at all. I used to get cramps every day. I always felt like I was about to start my period even though I was pretty regular. Now that's gone too. I can't speak for long term results yet but I'm already very happy. Oh, and I'm 42.0
-
Bump0
-
I had the Endometrial Ablation December 5th - it was the absolute BEST decision I have ever made. I am 41 - with Thallsemia - so the doctors had me on the pill for years - my new OB/Gyn told me with the meds I was on, I was a walking stroke when combined with the pill - my husband had a vasectomy in 1996 - there was no need for me to suffer. I had so much pain and bleeding it was almost impossible to function before the pill.
I went in early in the morning for my surgery (yes this is minor surgery) - was in prep for about 1/2 hour - in the operating room for what I am told for about 10 minutes - then in recovery for an hour or so and back down to post care for another few hours until I regained all consciousness and could walk on my own.
I had almost no discharge, and what little I had lasted for about a day if that. I haven't had any bleeding since. I do have some cramping, but it is nothing compared to what I had to deal with for 25 plus years.
I know this isn't for everyone - if your partner has not been sterilized, then you need to use protection (unless your tubes are tied) - They would have performed tubal litigation, however there was no concern of pregnancy with my husband.0 -
Ablation (Novasure) rocks. Still have periods, but not the kind that leave me anemic! Very good decision.
Mirena was my other option, but I've never liked the idea of IUDs. Just personal preference.
Good luck and be fearless!0 -
Horrible experience with Novasure. After the procedure, I had fluid getting trapped in my uterus causing me TREMENDOUS pain. Ended up having to have a d&c in the emergency room. Because of the problems caused by the novasure, I ended up having a complete hysterectomy just two weeks later.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions