Am I going too fast? 9.2 lbs in three weeks but I feel fine

rozojc
rozojc Posts: 35 Member
Hello,

I started MFP 3 weeks ago (Feb 19th) and my weight has been going down ever since. I am, however, a bit concerned on whether I'm losing weight too fast... Just wanted to hear the thoughts of more experienced people on this matter.

Here's my scenario:

According to MFP I should have been eating (on my original weight of 97 Kg) around 1600 calories. Thing is, since my wife also started MFP and she is really petite, she has been eating 1200. Since I don't like the idea of eating more than she cans (at least in front of her), this has meant I have been eating probably an average of 1400 instead of 1600. Besides this, we have been doing some cardio (I need it) and most of the times I don't really eat back the calories I "gained" from cardio.

I feel fine, I haven't felt weak or anything like that. But, then again, I weighed myself today and my current weight is 92.2 Kg. That means I lost 4.8 Kg (9.2 lbs) in 3 weeks time.

Should I worry about this?

Replies

  • neanderthin
    neanderthin Posts: 10,266 Member
    If it ain't broke. You might want to look at adding weight bearing exercises and be mindful of your protein intake. While dieting muscle atrophy (wasting) occurs naturally effecting your lean body mass (gluconeogenesis) and metabolism (adaptive thermogenesis) so consuming more protein at say around 1g/lb/lbm would be my advice and about 3 sessions of weights a week.
  • Mokey41
    Mokey41 Posts: 5,769 Member
    You'll naturally lose faster the first week or two but 1400 does seem low for a man but 1200 is low for most women too. You might want to figure out your BMR's and try eating above that for a more realistic approach.
  • 55in13
    55in13 Posts: 1,091 Member
    I have yoyo'ed over the years and I can tell you the pros and cons of cutting way back from my perspective...

    The biggest pro is mental; you see progress almost right away and get past the frustration of the early part of a slow paced diet. Another is part mental and part physical - you get used to eating less. The first few days of cutting way back are hard for me. But a week or so in, I sometimes miss a meal by accident; just forgetting to eat. I quit feeling hungry as easily as I did before.

    The biggest con is that your overall diet is still broken, just in a different way. Now you are eating too little instead of too much. When you get to the weight you want, it is all too easy to adjust back to a diet with about the right amount of calories and then start gaining back because you allow yourself treats since you lost all that weight. That is what commonly happens to me. The other one is that after hitting milestones so quickly it is easy to ease up and allow yourself a few extras and then have them get out of hand. Again, something that has happened to me.

    Notice a pattern? Mostly mental stuff.
  • Francl27
    Francl27 Posts: 26,371 Member
    Well you're a man so you should be eating more. Maybe have an extra snack when she's not looking or something. Or even if she is. I don't think she'll be mad if you have a cup of plain yogurt that she can't have. But if you're eating under your goal and not eating back calories, you need to eat if you're hungry, or you'll never manage to sustain it. If you're not hungry and feel good, i wouldn't worry about it.

    Also, I lost a ton when I started too, then hit a plateau and it's slowed down a bit since. So it doesn't mean you'll keep losing as much long term.
  • rozojc
    rozojc Posts: 35 Member
    Thanks for your insight. I guess I will make sure I guet closer to the 1600 MFP tells me to eat, but will definitely not eat more than I feel comfortable with just to reach that number :-)
  • KaseyWolf
    KaseyWolf Posts: 122 Member
    Try adding in an extra healthy snack, or perhaps a slightly larger portion of what you and your wife are preparing for a meal. It doesn't have to be much. The fact that you are both doing it together is awesome!
  • rozojc
    rozojc Posts: 35 Member
    Yeah, I'm a lucky man :-)

    My wife just wants/needs to loose a couple of pounds. In my case I was literally starting at the obese level (right now I am on the overweight level officially) and I got some tests back that show I have a high colesterol. At that point we both decided we needed a healthier lifestyle (as opposed to ordering Pizza and having hamburgers every other day which was what we were doing).

    She even printed out a calendar for us to plan our meals with a "slogan" of "Because we love each other" :-)

    Last week we had no work (break), and I spent it cooking healthy stuff for us and trying out new recipes. It's been good so far!
  • Tom_Jones74
    Tom_Jones74 Posts: 108
    Last week we had no work (break), and I spent it cooking healthy stuff for us and trying out new recipes. It's been good so far!

    First off, congrats on the weight loss.

    Cooking new food is a great way to stay focused as you literally see what your food is made instead of reading a label. It's important to have different flavoured options when eating healthy. =)
  • bostonwolf
    bostonwolf Posts: 3,038 Member
    Hello,

    I started MFP 3 weeks ago (Feb 19th) and my weight has been going down ever since. I am, however, a bit concerned on whether I'm losing weight too fast... Just wanted to hear the thoughts of more experienced people on this matter.

    Here's my scenario:

    According to MFP I should have been eating (on my original weight of 97 Kg) around 1600 calories. Thing is, since my wife also started MFP and she is really petite, she has been eating 1200. Since I don't like the idea of eating more than she cans (at least in front of her), this has meant I have been eating probably an average of 1400 instead of 1600. Besides this, we have been doing some cardio (I need it) and most of the times I don't really eat back the calories I "gained" from cardio.

    I feel fine, I haven't felt weak or anything like that. But, then again, I weighed myself today and my current weight is 92.2 Kg. That means I lost 4.8 Kg (9.2 lbs) in 3 weeks time.

    Should I worry about this?

    I would suggest eating more. She's not you, you aren't her. What she eats should have no bearing at all upon what you eat.

    I suspect your losses will tail off a bit and that's perfectly natural. You always lose more weight the first few weeks where you really focus on it. Don't worry about it!
  • Kaylaef
    Kaylaef Posts: 194 Member
    Yeah, I'm a lucky man :-)

    My wife just wants/needs to loose a couple of pounds. In my case I was literally starting at the obese level (right now I am on the overweight level officially) and I got some tests back that show I have a high colesterol. At that point we both decided we needed a healthier lifestyle (as opposed to ordering Pizza and having hamburgers every other day which was what we were doing).

    She even printed out a calendar for us to plan our meals with a "slogan" of "Because we love each other" :-)

    Last week we had no work (break), and I spent it cooking healthy stuff for us and trying out new recipes. It's been good so far!

    This is so lovely and warmed my heart :) I wish my husband wasn't a junk-a-holic doesn't put on a pound butt face haha. He is very supportive though.
  • You're right on track. Keep up the great work!
  • tejasmh87
    tejasmh87 Posts: 91 Member
    Okay I have to add some cents :) being in your wife's shoes.

    First off, congrats on the teamwork!!! Losing weight is difficult even more so when you are changing your eating lifestyle. It is easier when your loved one is right next to you on the same page. :) My boyfriend-now-fiance' and I packed on some weight while dating and completely did a 180 on our habits.

    My fiance also has more calories he has to eat and he lost a whopping 65lbs in 10 months. My weight loss is another story. The fact that he could eat more than me didn't bother me either way. Now, what ticked me off (in a purely female-irrational way) was the fact that he dropped SO much weight constantly.

    I am very proud of him and his dedication to better himself...but dang I am jealous!

    I do get self-concious now that I am the heavier one in the relationship. The situation has led to some self sabatoge and awkwardness but again thats the female brain tripping me up. My man knows about it too and is always vocally supportive to give my self confidence a boost when I need it. We both are on the right track he's just a bit ahead of me. :) I don't mind the view at allll ;);) hehehe!

    I don't know how your wife reacts to things but I know my man and I had to have discussion about our weight loss and not only the physical changes but the mental and emotional ones too. I had plateaued for over a month and was in a negative mindset. Seeing him keep losing made me bitter and then I'd self guilt over that. I became too restrictive on my calories thinking that was my problem.

    Finally, I broke down and got a body media armband for an accurate caloric burn...turns out I burn alot more than I thought! I tweaked my diet and the weight began coming off again last week.

    The thing we realized was we both have to always have the the conversations going about our healthy journey as individuals and as a couple. He keeps tabs on me to make sure my head is in the game but not getting discouraged or overwhelmed. I keep my eye on him since his foot is out on medical and he can't run, which is rough. Positive teamwork = positive results.


    Just don't eat a Cadbury egg in front of her...she might throw something at you. ;)
  • cwolfman13
    cwolfman13 Posts: 41,865 Member
    Hello,

    I started MFP 3 weeks ago (Feb 19th) and my weight has been going down ever since. I am, however, a bit concerned on whether I'm losing weight too fast... Just wanted to hear the thoughts of more experienced people on this matter.

    Here's my scenario:

    According to MFP I should have been eating (on my original weight of 97 Kg) around 1600 calories. Thing is, since my wife also started MFP and she is really petite, she has been eating 1200. Since I don't like the idea of eating more than she cans (at least in front of her), this has meant I have been eating probably an average of 1400 instead of 1600. Besides this, we have been doing some cardio (I need it) and most of the times I don't really eat back the calories I "gained" from cardio.

    I feel fine, I haven't felt weak or anything like that. But, then again, I weighed myself today and my current weight is 92.2 Kg. That means I lost 4.8 Kg (9.2 lbs) in 3 weeks time.

    Should I worry about this?

    I would suggest eating more. She's not you, you aren't her. What she eats should have no bearing at all upon what you eat.

    I suspect your losses will tail off a bit and that's perfectly natural. You always lose more weight the first few weeks where you really focus on it. Don't worry about it!

    Personally, ^^^^

    My wife and I are doing this together too. She eats around 1,600 calories to lose about 1 Lb per week (plus eating back exercise calories). I gross around 2,150 - 2,200. We just have different portion sizes and I have a heartier (but still healthy) snack or two more per day.
  • KathrynKennewell108
    KathrynKennewell108 Posts: 72 Member
    Men are biologically different to women. Men naturally carry more muscle than women, hence the need for more calories, partically protein. You need to stay up around 1800, give or take, to make a successful job of it. Try and get in quality protein to make up the difference. If you find, conversely, the women who try and eat like men, you'll soon find them on places like here looking for ways and reasons why they need to lose this mysterious weight gain. You'll find roughly a 600 calorie difference between men's and women's nutritional needs. A mate of mine is a practising nutritionist on the Central Coast of NSW. Go to his website askshannon.com.au and ask him any nutritional questions you have. He puts out YouTube answers for all to benefit.
  • rozojc
    rozojc Posts: 35 Member
    Thanks everyone for all the answers! It's really really helpful!

    I think I might eat a bit more now, but will just stick to what MFP tells me to eat and see what happens :-)

    Hopefully both me and my wife will be able to post a success story at some point :-)