Skip to content
  • Register
    • We are pleased to announce that as of March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor has been introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

    Mayo or Miracle Whip??

    2

    Replies

    • Posts: 6,400 Member
      Miracle Whip (light)!!
    • Posts: 92
      Hellman's Real Mayo. Even now that I'm watching my calories. No substitutions. :)

      QFT
    • Posts: 42 Member
      Miracle Whip lite, must be an aquired tasted, but I love it. Less calories compared to Mayo.
    • Posts: 319 Member
      Avocado

      This whenever possible but if not Best Foods Real Mayo.
    • Posts: 636 Member
      mayo with olive oil!
    • Posts: 199 Member
      I grew up on Miracle Whip, its what my mother preferred. Then I learned the deliciousness of the mayo. Hellman's all the way for us. Full flavor, no light in our house.
    • Posts: 737 Member
      Mayo for sure.
    • Posts: 1,328 Member
      Hellman's or GTFO
    • Posts: 6 Member
      Mayo on sandwiches. I mean how much can someone put on a slice of bread? Mine is usually like 1/2 a tablespoon (if that). If I'm making chicken or tuna salad, I use a little mayo (2- 3 tablespoons depending on the amount I'm making) and mix it with nonfat plain greek yogurt. Yum!
    • Posts: 4,733 Member
      grew up with Hellmann's mayo, but Miracle Whip is much better.
    • Posts: 1,791 Member
      Miracle Whip! mmmmm now i want a BLT
    • Posts: 40 Member
      I usually stick with a light mayo and only 1 tbsp for 1 whole can of tuna type of thing. I have a jar of whipped dressing that's blue menu that I'm trying to go through before I go back to using mayo.
    • Posts: 103 Member
      I'm with ya. Hellman's Real Mayo all the way. If I'm going to indulge I like to make it good :)
    • Posts: 413 Member
      ON a sandwich? Miracle Whip...

      to dip French Fries in? Mayo...

      ^^THIS!
    • Posts: 1,059 Member
      Hardly ever so when i do I spurge on the real thing. When I was stationed in Germany I grew to love cheesey french fries dipped in mayo. Never found mayo in the states like I had in Germanay same as brats.
    • Posts: 736 Member
      Mayo for fries, Miracle Whip for sandwiches.
    • Posts: 824 Member
      Bring out the Hellmans!!!!
    • Posts: 126 Member
      Grew up eating Miracle Whip (thought it was mayo), but once I had the real thing, never went back!!! Hellman's Mayo all the way!!!!!
    • Posts: 107
      Miracle whip
    • Posts: 275 Member
      Mayo... hands down.
    • Posts: 498 Member
      Mayo, but I only eat it when it's mixed in stuff like tuna salad or egg salad. Miracle Whip is just plain gross.
    • Posts: 651 Member
      Hellmann's Real Mayonnaise... :D
    • Posts: 32 Member
      Neither...
    • Posts: 261 Member
      I normally love mayo (not miracle whip), but omg, when I found out how many calories are in a serving! Good grief! I have since found lower cal substitutes. Guacamole is an awesome, more flavorful sub, and low fat cream cheese is its milder cousin. Love em. I probably will not go back to mayo until I'm at maintenance.
    • Posts: 81 Member
      Hellmann's Real Mayonnaise!
    • Posts: 56 Member
      Miracle whip! I only use it for tuna salad and cole slaw. I use mayo in my potato salad. Mayo is too oily for me, but in potato salad I mix a lot of mustard into it and it takes the oiliness away. I don't eat either one on a sandwich. That's what mustard is for! LOL
    • Posts: 2,833 Member
      Yogurt instead of either.
    • Posts: 2,362 Member
      Either...but I use them for different things.
    • Posts: 244 Member
      hummus
    • Posts: 579 Member
      Miracle Whip on a fried egg sandwich. Heaven!
    This discussion has been closed.

    Welcome!

    It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.
    Sign In
    Register

    Quick Links

    Categories