Does walking work?
Katychla
Posts: 23 Member
So I've been perusing the net trying to get motivation to get back into shape. I rescued a dog from the shelter a few months ago, so I thought the best way to get a head start would be by walking her every day for an hour at a good brisk pace.
My goal is to work from 1 hr to 2 hrs, then to jogging or running. I'm surprisingly sore and it's not from having my dog with me because she heels very well.
But my problem is most of the forums I find say that walking is a waste of time and that I won't lose weight. It stands to reason that that's BS since ya know, it's cardio and gets the blood pumping and is far better than sitting at a desk all day.
I know I won't get super toned and I'll have to add in harder stuff later, but does anyone have any stories to share about walking as a workout?
My goal is to work from 1 hr to 2 hrs, then to jogging or running. I'm surprisingly sore and it's not from having my dog with me because she heels very well.
But my problem is most of the forums I find say that walking is a waste of time and that I won't lose weight. It stands to reason that that's BS since ya know, it's cardio and gets the blood pumping and is far better than sitting at a desk all day.
I know I won't get super toned and I'll have to add in harder stuff later, but does anyone have any stories to share about walking as a workout?
0
Replies
-
I wanted to start out to run so I did but I very quickly got shin splints. I still kept my diet and just walked for about an hour at a brisk pace. I have lost doing that. I still walk briskly a few or more times a week.0
-
Walking is the only exercise that I do. I have lost 15 pounds in a years time with a diet remake and walking. I know it would come off more quidkly if I did a more intense workout, but i don't want to risk injury - so I stick with tried and true.
When you decide that you want to tone up/bulk up/ get ripped, you will have to do more than walk.
Good luck to you, and enjoy your time outdoors with your pet. The sunshine is great for your mental health also!0 -
I know people who have lost weight by walking, so I think it works. The results won't be nearly as rapid as running, but, as you said, you're still burning more calories than you would be if you just laid down watching TV.0
-
Would love to see other peoples response to this post, as I'm definitely nowhere near being ready to start running.0
-
Yes. That's just about all I do. I work full time and commute to work. Leaves me little time for anything else.
I need to lift and work out for toning...that will happen soon.0 -
i have terrible joints, especially for an 18 year old, so i can walk briskly but trying to jog or run is too much for my knees and ankles to handle. i walk on a treadmill daily, between a 10 and 15(max) incline and 3.8-4.1 pace. varying from 30-60 minutes a day. I've lost 55 pounds doing this. i would disagree with anyone that says walking does nothing (:0
-
The say walking is just as good as running. It helps me.0
-
I walked on the treadmill at a pretty fast pace (usually got up to about 3.3 mph with a 12% to 15% incline) for an hour or two every day before I started doing circuit training back in January and I lost about 13 pounds in about a year. This was coupled with better eating choices of course.
So, yes, you CAN lose weight by just walking, it just won't come off as fast.0 -
most of my exercise is from walking. I walk as little as 15 min to as much as 3 hours depending on the day. Since September 1 2012 I have lost 46 lbs. I have been a walker for the last 17 years but it was only when I reduced my cals did I reall start losing. I lost 4.2 lbs in the first week on here at 1500 cals a day. I have 12 more to lose to have a healthy BMI. I hear walking is better then running its easier on the knees0
-
With a good diet, sure it does! Any exercise is better than sitting at a desk like you said.0
-
I used to do cardio and weight training but ran into some back issues. A year later, my weight had crept back up a bit so I got back on MFP with a calorie deficit and now have a puppy that I walk 5 - 6 times a day. I'm not getting my heart rate up into the optimal range but hey, the weight is coming off fine still. I say do what you can do. It's all good.0
-
Walking is my main source of fitness. I use a Fitbit and it tracks it for me. It is awesome to see my progress with my fitbit. If you are going to walk for excercise look into the fitbit. It also adjust my calories based on how many steps I do a day so it lets me know if I can eat more or not. I am down 43 pounds and the majority of it is from walking. I do some swimming (just got a swim membership a couple of weeks ago), dancing, and riding my bike. I watch what I eat. My legs are getting more toned and slimmer. I still have some work but I started my journey last June.0
-
When I was a little younger, I can attest that walking was the ONLY exercise I got. Walking at least a mile and a half round trip to school (No, this wasn't in the horse-and-buggy age either. I chose not to ride the school bus, and the two or three times I tried to ride my bike to school, the tires got popped as a "welcome" gift.)
With that said, I also have pics of that time. I was trim. Not skinny, not ripped, and not what the boys liked, but someone who liked the body she was living in. It wasn't until my family moved, and I started into the workforce as a "real" employee that I went sedentary, and started the long, fast slide to where I am now.
But, when I was walking every day (and, maybe biking on the weekends to visit a friend 7 miles or so away) I was trim. Even after that, the couple of times I started to seriously work on loosing weight, the first thing I did was add walking to the day. One of the first things that always happened for me (after the legs firmed up) was that the belly firmed. Walking, if you keep your posture good, and the arms swinging (even without weights) will work the core muscles quite nicely. And, when those muscles work, then the tummy area will start to shrink.
Granted, this was personal experience, but it happened several times for different weight loss attempts. (Read that DIET, not lifestyle changes).
Hope this helps.0 -
I saw this the other day and thought you might be interested OP.
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/929616-for-all-the-people-who-believe-walking-isn-t-exercise?hl=Walking0 -
of course walking burns calories. a 160 pound person walking 3 mph will burn 85 calories, or running 6 mph will burn 121. increase the distance to 3 miles and that person walking burns 255 calories. not a bad burn for one hour. (source: http://walking.about.com/od/calorie1/a/calorieswalkrun.htm)
walking is easier on your joints and heart and lungs if any of those are problem areas.
go and enjoy!0 -
in high school i pretty much walked every where. but i'm talking like hour walks to parties and the hour walk home at the end of the night.
i lost about 40lbs in 5 months. but i also wasn't eating much.0 -
As long as you get your heart rate up, you cannot leisurely walk and not break a sweat and it have any impact, I have lost almost 100 pounds and a majority of my exercise has been brisk walking, I cannot run for longer then a minute or so. Walking deff works!! :happy:0
-
I have lost over 95 pounds since July, and walking is my main exercise. I do some aerobics and watch what I eat, but most of my workouts have been walking. I am closing in on 900 miles since July! Good luck to you!0
-
a while back, i lost 30 pounds by walking, i later gained it back because i stopped exercising and started eating like crap again while i was i school.0
-
i have terrible joints, especially for an 18 year old, so i can walk briskly but trying to jog or run is too much for my knees and ankles to handle. i walk on a treadmill daily, between a 10 and 15(max) incline and 3.8-4.1 pace. varying from 30-60 minutes a day. I've lost 55 pounds doing this. i would disagree with anyone that says walking does nothing (:
Agreed. I'm 22 and I jog a bit, but I mostly walk. I have lost 40 pounds since November. I have Osgood-Schlatter in my left knee, so it's difficult to do much without irritating the heck out of it.0 -
In the past seven months, aside from shoveling snow (more times this winter than I care to think about), the only exercise I have gotten is from walking, either on the track above the gym at the local Y or on a treadmill. I wish it had been walking the dog on the county road, but not here in Wisconsin November-March. On the track I walk from 30 to 45 minutes at a pace of 4.0 to 4.5 miles an hour. On the treadmill I walk at a 3.5 mile an hour pace at an incline of 10 (of 15 possible). So I burn about 300-400 calories walking, 5 to 6 days a week. Does walking work? With a reasonable net calorie deficit and this exercise I have lost 38 pounds in 19 weeks, from early November to mid March. From 240 to 202 pounds. My blood pressure is now 118/66 with a pulse rate of 62 (essentially the same the last three times I took it). I sleep more soundly, feel much better,
I am convinced that there are three factors that will guarantee weight loss: a calorie deficit (but no less than 1,200 calories a day, I maintain a net of about 1,500), exercise to keep the metabolism up, and time. The most destructive factor to staying on track is expecting or wanting quick results, and getting down when the scale doesn't show constant improvement. Keep the calorie deficit, keep up the activity, and give it time. There is no real magic to it. Yes, walking is enough, at least for me.
All that said, and one more thing. Do it to live a more healthy life, make it a life-style change, for the rest of your life. Don't treat it as a "project" (read that "diet"). Many people think they will eventually reach some predetermined goal, and then celebrate and return to destructive ways. We have all done it. That is how I got to 240 pounds again. Never again, for me.
I wish everyone the success I have had this winter. :flowerforyou:0 -
Walking is a great exercise and lots of fun. A few things I suggest which help me burn extra calories (I burn about 600-800 a day) is I use a gymboss to regulate my speed and to help push me to keep going faster. I also use music designed to keep you going. I only listen to Christian music but they have all genres (http://www.amazon.com/Christian-Workout-Hits-Best-Songs/dp/B006P7I9MI/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1363924069&sr=8-1&keywords=christian+workout+music I have both 2012 & 2013 -- 2013 isn't as good as 2012 in my opinion and every now and then the music sounds like my gymboss which can be frustrating!)
They say adding ski poles increases your calorie burn too. I've never done this. I haven't lost a lot of weight, but I have built muscle. My recommendation is to start out walking and getting into the habit of exercising daily and then add some stregnth training. Lifting weights before you walk will increase your productivity.
I guess that's it.0 -
Walking is a fantastic workout. I used to walk during work lunches and it kept me in great shape at that time. Better fat burn, imo.0
-
Bump for later0
-
I think it works very well. Start with what you can comfortably do and slowly add distance and increase your pace. It is an exercise that you can do everyday of the week. That's how I started. After a couple of months, look into the C25k program to begin jogging/running.0
-
I walk everyday for at least 30 minutes and strongly believe it has some types of benefits. After I had my daughter I kept on some of the baby weight for months. I started to walk everyday for 40 minutes and the pounds were shedding off.0
-
Walking is better than nothing.. That's true.0
-
Thank you so much for the great responses, guys!! Keep em coming!0
-
I suggest finding a serene enjoyable place to walk
Someplace where you can enjoy the Trees, Birds, Flowers, Streams, Lakes
Less Traffic, especially just starting out
A Bike Path perhaps
Someplace with Hills
You can also find out if your community has a Group that get 2gether and do challenges together
Its Great Support
You'd be surprised how many Community Member's there are.0 -
most of my exercise is from walking. I walk as little as 15 min to as much as 3 hours depending on the day. Since September 1 2012 I have lost 46 lbs. I have been a walker for the last 17 years but it was only when I reduced my cals did I reall start losing. I lost 4.2 lbs in the first week on here at 1500 cals a day. I have 12 more to lose to have a healthy BMI. I hear walking is better then running its easier on the knees
I had the same experience. In May 2012 I decided to take responsibility back for my health. I think most of my weight loss is from diet changes, but I walk 6 days a week. During the week I go before work, usually for about 35 minutes. On the weekends, I'll get in at least one longer walk - usually anywhere from 5 to 10 miles. I think you actually need more discipline to be a "good" exercise walker - if you don't focus, it's easy to just dawdle along. I alternate through the week - a day at a steady, fast tempo (probably 3.75 mph), a day with good hills to give me more of a cardio push, a day with real hard intervals alternating with recovery, a slower day after the big weekend walk, etc. I bought the app Walkmeter and for me it's like a coach on the iPhone, and I like competing against my best times. I'm sure there are other good free apps that let you easily record your times and distance and so on if that helps motivate you. I also do some weights for my arms (lots of good Youtube videos: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fUPJnzxVEH8 is an example). I ran years ago and hated it. If you like walking, you'll stick with it! Good luck!0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions