Who in here believes with all thier heart.....
farmers_daughter
Posts: 1,632 Member
that stress makes you gain weight
makes you hold onto fat
keeps you from reaching your weight loss goals?
What facts or research do you have to back it up?
makes you hold onto fat
keeps you from reaching your weight loss goals?
What facts or research do you have to back it up?
0
Replies
-
I'm curious what people will say. I know how I feel about it, but I'm not going to search for the studies I've read over the years. Is this one of those I'm tired of people saying this and not showing proof posts?0
-
if you're a stress eater, you're going to eat, therefore you're going to gain. If you're not, you won't.0
-
Stress makes you gain weight?
Well, personally I think stress could make you gain weight if stress makes you over or under eat but I don't know about holding onto fat..
It'll be interesting to see responses.0 -
Stress increases cortisol levels IIRC.0
-
Stress increases cortisol levels IIRC.0
-
I believe it, never done the research to back it up but I know when I am stressed it seems like it's harder to lose weight. I don't know if its just the stress itself or the way it makes me feel that affects me in other ways. I have heard it though from a lot of the doctors where I used to work. There may be something to it...0
-
Stress increases cortisol levels IIRC.
Otherwise it's stress and being weak willed that allows you to stuff yourself because of your emotions.0 -
that stress makes you gain weight
makes you hold onto fat
keeps you from reaching your weight loss goals?
What facts or research do you have to back it up?
I think I've read that stress ups your cortisol levels and cortisol contributes to weight gain, but I think the larger issue will always be too much food going into the mouth.0 -
cortisol, sure.
stress can make you lose your focus...
When you're stressed and you don't get in some activity or your daily workout, then you can add the "didn't workout" guilt on top of your stress.
When I'm stressed, I really find forcing myself to get into the gym really helps.0 -
Stress doesn't "make" us eat, we "make" ourselves eat. Stress doesn't make us hold onto fat, our actions or inactions make us hold onto fat. I know stress can be a problem, or an excuse for us to over eat, but that's exactly what it is, an excuse. Finding other ways to deal with stress helps eliminate the eating because of stress. To me, it's being responsible for our actions. We can blame anything we want to blame, but it's ourselves that reaches for the piece of cake or quart of ice cream, not stress. This is just my opinion, and I'm not a Doctor but I did stay in a Holiday Inn Express once.0
-
Stress increases cortisol levels IIRC.
This. Higher levels of corsitol apparently contribute to where you gain fat also, have read somewhere that it can contribute to holding more weight around the middle.
Personally I suffered severe work stress a few years ago requiring 2 months off work, during that time I lost 35lb as it killed my appetite, so for me stress caused huge weight loss which brought its own problems.0 -
I believe that too I have tumors on my adrenial glads and am having a hard time losing weight because of the high level of cortizol I release when stressed It also caused my high blood pressure0
-
I think its more the reaction to the stress that causes these things. if your not careful you fall into a trap of eating or veging out to deal with the stress, or thats what I used to do. Now focus it into training, the more stressed I am, the more I go training, longer I stay at the gym etc.
Like others have said have heard it affects cortisol levels but main effect is the indirect psychological factors in my opinion that cause a lot of peoples weight gain for the stress.0 -
Stress increases cortisol which is affiliated with our fight or flight syndrome. When you are stressed your body goes into protection mode. Cortisol tries to minimize our pain sensory as if we were having and adrenaline or a sugar rush. This also will cause the body to store energy keeping you in the fight it flight syndrome so when you start binging on your favorite Ben and Jerry's cherry Garcia your body will choose to hold it rather than expell it0
-
I believe it is more so when you are stressed you are not watchful of what you eat which will cause you to gain weight. Eating to suppress the stress...0
-
Depends on how much stress. I get too stressed I lose weight because I stop eating and sleeping. And then of course I go quite insane.
I get slightly stressed (mostly from boredom or allergies making me feel like total crap) all I want to do is stuff my face.
I don't know or need to know the chemical components, the behavioral ones are sufficient.0 -
Stress raises cortisol levels. Cortisol is a steroidal hormone. Significantly raised levels of cortisol over long periods of time could have adverse effects on the body, including insulin resistance, weight gain, reduced bone density and a greater incidence of developing osteoporosis, weakened immune response and collagen loss is greatly expedited.
So yeah, I could see how stress could have adverse effects on health, including weight gain.0 -
well. DUH!., thats a no brainer....0
-
I've done research to find this out, the most detailed source I found was Jillian Michaels' book "Master your metabolism". She talks a lot about hormones (your endocrine system). She broke it down in simply (the others were too scientific). Certain hormones are released when you stress out (I forget all of them right now). It has to do wit the "Fight or Flight" response. Your body gears up to either fight to the death OR take off running to avoid danger. In order to give you the energy to do so, different hormones do different things. One shuts down digestion (who cares about digestion at a time like this!), another releases energy giving nutrients (i think some of it is where cortisol comes in), and some other stuff happens (i'm not looking at the book right now).
The problem is that in our society, the likelihood of us actually fighting or running away is lower. You're probably just going to sit there upset. So all these things have been released and shut down systems for you to just sit there. And it takes a longtime for your body to be like, "Oh, we're fine? Oh okay."
And aside from the medical reasons, I do notice it's easier to lose when you're happy or not stressed out all the time.0 -
Ok I'm going to have to look up cortisol because like many of you I've heard of it but don't really know what it is.
I like to think when people say "Oh you're stressed honey...thats why you haven't lost any weight....blah blah blah"
My personal opinion is that it's a cop out. But I'm also in a piss *kitten* mood and being incredibly hard on myself, which is funny...it's not working either. Just making me in a piss *kitten* mood.... :grumble:0 -
Stress doesn't "make" us eat, we "make" ourselves eat. Stress doesn't make us hold onto fat, our actions or inactions make us hold onto fat. I know stress can be a problem, or an excuse for us to over eat, but that's exactly what it is, an excuse. Finding other ways to deal with stress helps eliminate the eating because of stress. To me, it's being responsible for our actions. We can blame anything we want to blame, but it's ourselves that reaches for the piece of cake or quart of ice cream, not stress. This is just my opinion, and I'm not a Doctor but I did stay in a Holiday Inn Express once.
I don't think people are saying stress alone causes weight gain, but that it contributes. I didn't eat more because of stress. I ate less, same activity level and gained weight. With the help of therapist, I started learning how to cope with stress and my weight started to come off again. Its not always about having an excuse or blaming something else. I eat more cake and ice cream now and losing weight than I ever did while I was stressed.0 -
Cortisol is impacted by both mental and physical stress.0
-
Damn y'all are quick, I'm reading what you typed while I was typing.... so take my last post with a grain of salt.0
-
I am firm believer that stress inhibits weight loss. Trying to identify when you are stressed and then not acting on those impulses is the hard part.
Read this article.
http://stress.about.com/od/stresshealth/a/weightgain.htm0 -
Only if it causes you to go to the bar and stress eat & drink over your calories.0
-
And what do we do when we're stressed? Yep, we hit the bar!0
-
It is the cortisol levels that increase when stressed that helps you hang on to the weight. However, being a stress eater doesn't help. Personally, I have been in a constant state of stress since May 2012 and I have actually lost most of my weight during that time. For me, the stress was the wake up call to quit treating my body like **** and get serious about my health.0
-
Ok I'm going to have to look up cortisol because like many of you I've heard of it but don't really know what it is.
I like to think when people say "Oh you're stressed honey...thats why you haven't lost any weight....blah blah blah"
My personal opinion is that it's a cop out. But I'm also in a piss *kitten* mood and being incredibly hard on myself, which is funny...it's not working either. Just making me in a piss *kitten* mood.... :grumble:
When I first started, waaaay back when, I ate like 1300 calories a day and cardio'd for 2 hours a day. Lost a ton of weight. Then, my lease was expiring and I was trying to buy a house. I was also dealing with my kid's behavioral issues as a single parent, working a full-time job, going through a divorce, and going to school. Needless to say, my stress levels were elevated. In spite of that, I continued my normal diet and exercise habits. I stopped losing weight. Cortisol does impact weight loss.
Inevitably, I learned that along with my external stressors, my 1300-calorie diet was also not allowing me enough unsaturated fats. Unsaturated fats help to inhibit pesky weight-loss-interfering hormones like cortisol (there are others you should read about, i.e. grehlin, leptin, and others). I began to eat more ensuring I got those fats in. Weight loss began to move again, but it was still slow. It wasn't until the divorce was final and the house sale was closed that my weight loss really began to pick up momentum again.
If you are going through stuff and having a hard time losing, the best thing to do is say a few "Woo-sa's" and try your best to be persistent. Deal with your problems and stick it out.0 -
I disagree with all of the above. To lazy to support this atm lol. Ill come back later.0
-
During periods of extreme stress, I lose weight. I know other people who gain weight when they are stressed. I think that it has more to do with what you eat than anything else. When I'm stressed it kills my appetite.
This study shows that people who have a higher cortisol reaction to stress eat more when stressed than people who don't
http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0306453000000354
This study found that primates with chronically elevated levels of cortisol but without actual stress did not gain any statistically significant weight
http://www.jneurosci.org/content/19/6/2356.short
These studies seem to suggest that cortisol can cause you to want to eat more (stress eating) but will not actually make you gain weight. It is purely the act of consuming too many calories that causes weight gain.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.5K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 430 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions