Help please! Losing inches but not weight :(
amandacillin
Posts: 39 Member
I have been circuit training for 3 months and had my measurements done this week. I only lost 10 inches overall and lost 6 pounds overall. Is this normal? I am overweight so I expected much more to come off in the beginning. I have been meticulous with counting calories 1200-1400 (not making up net calories) and working out with a personal trainer 3xs a week and doing cardio on my own for 20-40 minutes per day when I'm not training. I don't plan on giving up anytime soon but should I make changes or is this good progress?? My trainer says I should expect even better results at my next weigh in at 6 months and said I did great the first 3 with my loss so why is the scale bothering me so much?!
0
Replies
-
Do you have a thyroid problem? I believe it is associated with slow metabolism. Also, how healthy are the calories you're consuming?0
-
You're doing great!!! Why are you so worried?! You're seeing results (and good ones)! Just keep going. You have to be patient. How long did it take you to put all that weight on? A long time. It will take you a while to get it off too. Also, it's not a bad thing for the inches to change and the scale NOT. It means you're changing your body composition. Losing the fat, gaining muscle, and getting fit!! Be happy with your success!!0
-
check out http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/912920-in-place-of-a-road-map-3-2013
I think you're not eating enough. read about BMR and TDEE and i think you'll find that it will help.
best of luck!0 -
id be more worried if weight was coming off but inches werent. so dont worry about it! 10 inches are great0
-
You are probly gaining some muscle, and remember, muscle weighs more!!! Scales don't tell the whole story0
-
What percentage of your diet is coming from simple carbs?
Sounds like your reshaping and dropping inches, but not getting into the stored fat due to carb overload.
I'm just taking a shot here, i'm not an expert by any stretch. I've struggled in the past with plateau effect.
Good luck!0 -
I have been circuit training for 3 months and had my measurements done this week. I only lost 10 inches overall and lost 6 pounds overall. Is this normal? I am overweight so I expected much more to come off in the beginning. I have been meticulous with counting calories 1200-1400 (not making up net calories) and working out with a personal trainer 3xs a week and doing cardio on my own for 20-40 minutes per day when I'm not training. I don't plan on giving up anytime soon but should I make changes or is this good progress?? My trainer says I should expect even better results at my next weigh in at 6 months and said I did great the first 3 with my loss so why is the scale bothering me so much?!
10 inches is A LOT! And some people tend to lose weight a little slower than others. Although, it may be that you're not eating ENOUGH calories. You need to make sure you're getting adequate caloric intake to build muscle and burn fat -- especially with circuit training.0 -
When you circuit train, you put on muscle and your body is way out of its "fat burning" zone, plus your calorie intake is too low. Don't focus on the scale moving, be happy you lost inches, that's what matters! People see the inches, the don't see the numbers.0
-
I am exactly opposite, my weight has dropped over 40 lbs since I stared on my journey but not lost tons of inches.0
-
Open your diary. Otherwise we are all guessing as to that half of the equation.0
-
Do you have a thyroid problem? I believe it is associated with slow metabolism. Also, how healthy are the calories you're consuming?
Yes, I have hypothyroidism but my levels have stayed normal for over 2 years. Also, I have eaten clean for the last 3 months. My personal trainer keeps telling me not to look at the scale and not to eat my net calories back so I'm wondering if I am not eating enough from what I read on here. All of the conflicting info is so confusing! I won't give up just don't really know what to do to get better results when I measure again in 3 months.0 -
Losing inches is good. Don't pay so much attention to the scale.0
-
It's not muscle on a 1200-1400 calorie diet, especially if exercise cals are not consumed.
Losing inches trumps losing pounds in my book. Who cares what the scale says - no one sees that number but me, but when I drop a whole pants size because of the fat and inches I've lost, people notice! I went six months without losing a pound, but did lose that pant size during that time due to all the inches that were quietly melting off.
Ignore the scale, embrace the tape measure, and if you're netting below 1200 calories, please eat more! Food is fuel!0 -
You are probly gaining some muscle, and remember, muscle weighs more!!! Scales don't tell the whole story
Sorry I just have a pet peeve about post like this...if you have 1 pound of muscle and 1 pound of fat would they not weigh the same? So the correct response is muscle takes up less space than fat. So if you are burning fat and replacing it with muscle then that takes up less space so you have lost size but not matter. Keep up the good work.0 -
If you are losing inches I wouldn't worry about the scale, that's awesome to drop 10 inches!0
-
Keep in mind if you are overweight and you are working out like crazy, you are burning fat (thus losing inches) and gaining muscle at the same time. Muscle weighs more than fat, so while you are losing all that fat (10 inches is awesome! great job!), you are stll gaining mass in the muscle you are building. This is not a bad thing at all. This is why I hate scales. I personally think it only matters how you look, not what you weigh. Don't worry about the scale, just focus on the fact that you have lost 10 inches, which is outstanding! This is a pretty normal phenominon, especially in women and if you lived a fairly sedentary lifestyle before. Keep doing what you are doing! You're making a ton of progress!0
-
Thanks for all of the encouragement. Physical Trainers are not cheap so the quicker I can get in shape the sooner I can quit paying her so I am willing to take all of the advice I can get. Reading the forums on here IS my motivation and I determined to not give up. I won't stop until it is all GONE! I am crossing my fingers that the next 3 months go even better, my endurance and strength has no doubt improved tremendously, if anything that is worth it also.0
-
Wait your personal trainer said DON'T eat back the exercise calories...hmmm...ok Me thinks you need to eat more...i know i know...the usual answer but I can't see your diary so I'm going with an edumacated guess
0 -
Best free advice I've gotten is all found right here: http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/937712-in-place-of-a-road-map-ver-3-0
Been eating according to the info there for over a year and have steadily dropped fat and inches, hit my goal weight, and will continue to eat this way for the rest of my life. Read it - good stuff.0 -
Progress is progress!0
-
I know it's frustrating to not see the number on the scale go down quickly but since you're losing inches, perhaps you should try tracking your body fat. You'll definitely see that number coming down!0
-
Throw out the scale! It's just a very small piece to a big puzzle. Don't get discouraged. Yes it's important to evaluate your overall health on a regular basis but it's not just weight, but measurements and body fat.
If you didn't realize it, you've done a lot in 3 months and you should be very proud of that!0 -
I would up your calories by a few hundred. And, try eating some of those calories burned back.0
-
Take inches over weight. You're doing amazing.0
-
Best free advice I've gotten is all found right here: http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/937712-in-place-of-a-road-map-ver-3-0
Been eating according to the info there for over a year and have steadily dropped fat and inches, hit my goal weight, and will continue to eat this way for the rest of my life. Read it - good stuff.
I will definitely check it out and apply it to what I am currently doing. Anything to improve. Thank you so much
0 -
You're doing great!!! Why are you so worried?! You're seeing results (and good ones)! Just keep going. You have to be patient. How long did it take you to put all that weight on? A long time. It will take you a while to get it off too. Also, it's not a bad thing for the inches to change and the scale NOT. It means you're changing your body composition. Losing the fat, gaining muscle, and getting fit!! Be happy with your success!!
Exactly. That's great. You have nothing to worry about.0 -
If I had to pick, I'd definitely pick losing inches over losing weight. But I do hope you get the weight loss too! You are on the right path.0
-
Best free advice I've gotten is all found right here: http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/937712-in-place-of-a-road-map-ver-3-0
Been eating according to the info there for over a year and have steadily dropped fat and inches, hit my goal weight, and will continue to eat this way for the rest of my life. Read it - good stuff.
I will definitely check it out and apply it to what I am currently doing. Anything to improve. Thank you so much
[/quote
helloitsdan knows what he's talking about.0 -
It's not muscle on a 1200-1400 calorie diet, especially if exercise cals are not consumed.
Losing inches trumps losing pounds in my book. Who cares what the scale says - no one sees that number but me, but when I drop a whole pants size because of the fat and inches I've lost, people notice! I went six months without losing a pound, but did lose that pant size during that time due to all the inches that were quietly melting off.
Ignore the scale, embrace the tape measure, and if you're netting below 1200 calories, please eat more! Food is fuel!
This accurately sums up my thoughts, and I think deserves an echo. I assume you are losing weight to look better, not weigh less. You probably aren't gaining a lot of muscle mass eating 1200 calories a day with your workouts. I would imagine you have a lot more water in your body right now than you did 3 months ago. This is why your weight loss hasn't been greater. If you are losing the inches, you are looking better. Eat a few more calories and you probably won't notice much difference in the scale, but you will find yourself building more lean body mass. More LBM means you look better!0 -
I have Hashimoto's...so I know your pain with thyroid issues. Our bodies lose weight and burn fat differently. Try cutting grains out and see how your body responds. I've cut them out for almost 3 weeks now as part of the Ultimate Reset and I'm dropping weight much easier now than I have been able to in the last 7 years or so. Another thing to look at is dairy.
Also, I don't think you are eating enough calories...0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions