Beware Calorie Errors
dbirty
Posts: 29 Member
It's recently occurred to me that due to average weight regulations, the calorie totals declared on a lot of products must be inaccurate and generally will give a lower value than you are actually eating. This is because companies are fined for selling too much product less than it's target ( declared on the packet ) weight usually meaning that on average they must give some more of their product away.
All this almost certainly means that you are eating more calories than you think you are. Over a period of time this could have a large effect on weight control.
All this almost certainly means that you are eating more calories than you think you are. Over a period of time this could have a large effect on weight control.
0
Replies
-
There's another post similar to this, here's the link I stole from it, in regards to calorie errors:
http://www.break.com/index/the-truth-behind-calories-24300670 -
Thanks for the heads up but I doubt if it would be much to worry about. If folk are under their cals on most days, then even having an extra 100 cals a day stuck on would mean your still burning cals up. Also over a period of a week a lot of folk will have a deficit in cals.
Last but not least if your loosing weight and doing well then your fine.....0 -
omg - did not know that.0
-
So, are you saying that they are listing less calories than they should per serving?0
-
If say a twinkie's serving size is 100g, quite often the twinkie you receive is 110g or whatnot...
So the calories are correct, the product is just more than stated serving size.0 -
Something to be aware of, and it's the reason I almost always log more calories than I actually ate.0
-
Probably, I don't know for certain but if you measure / weigh your food you obviously know for certain how many calories you are eating.0
-
Like everything it's all just estimates. Calories, BF%, BMR, TDEE, nothing is going to be exact and it doesn't have to be to lose weight.0
-
I always weigh my food, and rarely do I eat anything that comes in a per-portioned pack such as cereal bars etc... But this is a good point to make. Perhaps weigh your items and add on extra calories to what the package says as needed.0
-
Funny, but I suspected as much. I also wonder about the accuracy of the calorie counts that McDonald's and other fast food restaurants offer. I think they err on the low side.0
-
Funny, but I suspected as much. I also wonder about the accuracy of the calorie counts that McDonald's and other fast food restaurants offer. I think they err on the low side.
I do NOT trust restaurants at all. There is a whole lot of variations since they don't weigh anything. I always figure a restaurant meal from almost anyplace will have at the very least 100 extra calories.0 -
I always weigh my food, and rarely do I eat anything that comes in a per-portioned pack such as cereal bars etc... But this is a good point to make. Perhaps weigh your items and add on extra calories to what the package says as needed.
This. My food scale is such a HUGE help when figuring out my portions and such. I actually get more food from things like chicken, but I was eating wayyy too much peanut butter and apples. I have weighed a few protein bars and cereal bars just to double check and they came our right though. I try not to eat out much anymore, but at least living in Japan, they follow portion size and how much they are supposed to put on.
For example, I've worked at McDonalds for 9 years total in my life. You are supposed to put a sundae cup lid size portion of shredded lettuce on a sandwich and only 5 slivered onions, but I've seen the kids put very little lettuce or twice as much lettuce and a handful of slivered onions on a sandwich. That's not even counting the fact that our sauce guns for mayo, tartar, and mac sauce usually aren't calibrated correctly and you often get too much mayo or tartar and too little mac sauce (which most employees compensate for by doubling the squirts). In Japan, they adhere to the standards so I have faith that their calorie counts are more accurate than a McDonalds in the US.
Anyway, invest in a food scale and measure your portions because the calorie count is usually right, but the serving size of 1 cup is usually a little higher than the x amount of grams it gives you.0 -
Funny, but I suspected as much. I also wonder about the accuracy of the calorie counts that McDonald's and other fast food restaurants offer. I think they err on the low side.
I do NOT trust restaurants at all. There is a whole lot of variations since they don't weigh anything. I always figure a restaurant meal from almost anyplace will have at the very least 100 extra calories.
Hah...I just unknowingly kind of answered this statement from my personal experience.0 -
Funny, but I suspected as much. I also wonder about the accuracy of the calorie counts that McDonald's and other fast food restaurants offer. I think they err on the low side.
I do NOT trust restaurants at all. There is a whole lot of variations since they don't weigh anything. I always figure a restaurant meal from almost anyplace will have at the very least 100 extra calories.
Hah...I just unknowingly kind of answered this statement from my personal experience.0 -
Funny, but I suspected as much. I also wonder about the accuracy of the calorie counts that McDonald's and other fast food restaurants offer. I think they err on the low side.
I do NOT trust restaurants at all. There is a whole lot of variations since they don't weigh anything. I always figure a restaurant meal from almost anyplace will have at the very least 100 extra calories.
Hah...I just unknowingly kind of answered this statement from my personal experience.
I'm gonna go out on a limb and say you've never worked in the food service industry?0 -
When I worked at arby's, we weighed the roast beef per sandwich.0
-
This is true in restaurants for sure. However, mass production technology can easily produce thousands of products that are the same size - within a percent or so. There is a bigger margin of error in calories due to the way they round results.0
-
Funny, but I suspected as much. I also wonder about the accuracy of the calorie counts that McDonald's and other fast food restaurants offer. I think they err on the low side.
I do NOT trust restaurants at all. There is a whole lot of variations since they don't weigh anything. I always figure a restaurant meal from almost anyplace will have at the very least 100 extra calories.
Hah...I just unknowingly kind of answered this statement from my personal experience.
You think high school kids care about profit margins? No...they care about getting money and doing as little work as possible. They always stuck managers on shifts who were not assertive enough to do it properly. Plus, at my particular stores, they never even told us those standards until my last few months of working there. I also put together proper training documents for the store manager and she has never once utilized them even though it would make our store cleaner/more efficient/up to standards.0 -
Like someone said, nothing is perfect. Even you scale, down to grams isn't 100% accurate. Just set a deficit. Record what you eat and see what happens. Make an adjustment if you need to. I simply set my calories so low and exercised a lot and didn't have to worry about being off a few calories. Since I stopped actively trying to lose weight, I've upped my calories, over a few months, from 2100 to 2900 and I'm still not gaining weight....0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions