My body refuses to be fooled - is this possible?
Christinesunvrse
Posts: 3 Member
First attempt at weight loss, Weight Watchers, I lost 50 lbs. in a relatively short amount of time, 6 months. Had a baby, several months later went on WW again - followed a similar WW plan as before and lost 20 lbs. Fell off the wagon again, gained, tried WW again, lost 6 lbs. Keeping in mind that I ultimately returned to the weight I was before the first WW loss, and then some. Sooooo, I've tried various things like low carb diets, the 17 Day Diet - which is minimal carbs for the first 17 days and then going through various cycles of "tricking" your body over 2 more phases.
I think my body is tricked out. My body doesn't seem to be "falling for it" anymore. Is that possible? I eat very healthy, drink a ton of water and I jog/walk/circuit train for at least an hour every single day. Not losing an ounce.
I started MFP, I religiously track every single thing that goes into my mouth (I'm getting WAYYYYYY too much sodium, which I'm now starting to cut back on). I eat lots of white chicken, fish, tons of healthy veggies, approx. a gallon of water a day, a small amount of carbs but haven't cut them out completely. I just don't eat anything "white" except the white meats.
Any suggestions? Is it possible that my body is fed up with me tricking it?
I think my body is tricked out. My body doesn't seem to be "falling for it" anymore. Is that possible? I eat very healthy, drink a ton of water and I jog/walk/circuit train for at least an hour every single day. Not losing an ounce.
I started MFP, I religiously track every single thing that goes into my mouth (I'm getting WAYYYYYY too much sodium, which I'm now starting to cut back on). I eat lots of white chicken, fish, tons of healthy veggies, approx. a gallon of water a day, a small amount of carbs but haven't cut them out completely. I just don't eat anything "white" except the white meats.
Any suggestions? Is it possible that my body is fed up with me tricking it?
0
Replies
-
First attempt at weight loss, Weight Watchers, I lost 50 lbs. in a relatively short amount of time, 6 months. Had a baby, several months later went on WW again - followed a similar WW plan as before and lost 20 lbs. Fell off the wagon again, gained, tried WW again, lost 6 lbs. Keeping in mind that I ultimately returned to the weight I was before the first WW loss, and then some. Sooooo, I've tried various things like low carb diets, the 17 Day Diet - which is minimal carbs for the first 17 days and then going through various cycles of "tricking" your body over 2 more phases.
I think my body is tricked out. My body doesn't seem to be "falling for it" anymore. Is that possible? I eat very healthy, drink a ton of water and I jog/walk/circuit train for at least an hour every single day. Not losing an ounce.
I started MFP, I religiously track every single thing that goes into my mouth (I'm getting WAYYYYYY too much sodium, which I'm now starting to cut back on). I eat lots of white chicken, fish, tons of healthy veggies, approx. a gallon of water a day, a small amount of carbs but haven't cut them out completely. I just don't eat anything "white" except the white meats.
Any suggestions? Is it possible that my body is fed up with me tricking it?
it's pretty obvious to me that you really have no idea how/why your body gains or loses weight.
it's all about the calories. how much water you drink or not is irrelevant. what you eat is irrelevant. how long or how often you work out is largely irrelevant.
what matters is this... calories out > calories in.
the point of logging is to know whether or not you are meeting this relationship. you must log accurately though.
the first step is to understand your BMR and TDEE and what these are. once you do that, you can set yourself an appropriate calorie goal. then you can worry about meeting your macros. this is what determines your food choices. forget all that nonsense about "good" food or "bad" food or "healthy" food or "unhealthy" food.
get started here:
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/952996-level-obstacles-lose-weight-target-fat-easy
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/833026-important-posts-to-read
start reading. start learning. then put what you've learned into action.
the laws of physics cannot be changed and ultimately, your body MUST adhere to these laws. if you eat fewer calories than you expend, day in and day out, you will lose weight.0 -
How much are you currently eating? Your diary isn't open. Are you exercising?0
-
It would be easier to provide advice if your diary was open.0
-
Listen to Winner. It's all in the name.0
-
I can't see your food diary so I can't comment on what you are eating. But it is time to stop the gimmick diets. Weight loss isn't about a diet. It is about a lifestyle change. What ever you do to lose weight needs to be something you plan to sustain for the rest of your life. You can't just go back to "normal" eating once you hit your goal weight or you just gain it all back. So first recommendations no more Weight Watchers or other diet plans. Second is make your food diary public or add me as a friend so we can look at what you are eating and give you a better idea of what is going on.0
-
Sadly, weight loss pop culture has perpetuated this idea of "tricking your body" into shedding fat/losing weight or "kickstarting your metabolism". There's no such thing. The only thing that will positively affect your weight loss is eating at a small deficit from your total daily energy requirements (e.g. what your body needs to run efficiently) and exercise for body recomposition purposes. Anyone telling you differently is selling something.0
-
Eat less. Move more.0
-
Open your diary....then we can give more accurate advice.0
-
Do you use a scale to track how much you eat, or just guestimate?
I finally saw positive movement on the human scale after buying a food scale.0 -
I agree with everyone else. We need to see your diary to be able to give a fair assessment.0
-
Do you use a scale to track how much you eat, or just guestimate?
I finally saw positive movement on the human scale after buying a food scale.
I also agree with this. Many people guestimate on food and calories burned. I definitely saw better results after buying a food scale to accurately measure food and a Heart Rate Monitor (I have Polar FT7) to accurately count my calories burned. You can't always rely on the figures in MFP or on a cardio machine at the gym. They are just estimates most times.0 -
There are too many variables that may be at play here. First, we don't know your current height, weight, goals, etc.
Also, being that you may have been at a very low calorie diet for an extremely long period of time, you may have to reset to get your body losing again. This doesn't have anything to do with boosting or tricking, though. Given your history of fad diets, your body may have slowed down to meet the energy you were providing. If that has happened, then by increasing calories to meet MFP, there is the chance you could gain weight because of the rapid calorie increase.
What is the time frame of all those fad diets combined?0 -
First attempt at weight loss, Weight Watchers, I lost 50 lbs. in a relatively short amount of time, 6 months. Had a baby, several months later went on WW again - followed a similar WW plan as before and lost 20 lbs. Fell off the wagon again, gained, tried WW again, lost 6 lbs. Keeping in mind that I ultimately returned to the weight I was before the first WW loss, and then some. Sooooo, I've tried various things like low carb diets, the 17 Day Diet - which is minimal carbs for the first 17 days and then going through various cycles of "tricking" your body over 2 more phases.
I think my body is tricked out. My body doesn't seem to be "falling for it" anymore. Is that possible? I eat very healthy, drink a ton of water and I jog/walk/circuit train for at least an hour every single day. Not losing an ounce.
I started MFP, I religiously track every single thing that goes into my mouth (I'm getting WAYYYYYY too much sodium, which I'm now starting to cut back on). I eat lots of white chicken, fish, tons of healthy veggies, approx. a gallon of water a day, a small amount of carbs but haven't cut them out completely. I just don't eat anything "white" except the white meats.
Any suggestions? Is it possible that my body is fed up with me tricking it?
it's pretty obvious to me that you really have no idea how/why your body gains or loses weight.
it's all about the calories. how much water you drink or not is irrelevant. what you eat is irrelevant. how long or how often you work out is largely irrelevant.
what matters is this... calories out > calories in.
the point of logging is to know whether or not you are meeting this relationship. you must log accurately though.
the first step is to understand your BMR and TDEE and what these are. once you do that, you can set yourself an appropriate calorie goal. then you can worry about meeting your macros. this is what determines your food choices. forget all that nonsense about "good" food or "bad" food or "healthy" food or "unhealthy" food.
get started here:
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/952996-level-obstacles-lose-weight-target-fat-easy
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/833026-important-posts-to-read
start reading. start learning. then put what you've learned into action.
the laws of physics cannot be changed and ultimately, your body MUST adhere to these laws. if you eat fewer calories than you expend, day in and day out, you will lose weight.
:drinker:0 -
Fad diets don't work. Eating healthy, exercising, and maintaining a deficit of calories does. I know a lot of people disagree (and I'm not going to debate), but low carb diets just rob your body of half the nutrients it needs. Eating a healthy portion of "good" carbs (veggies, potatoes, popcorn, whole grains, etc.) is an important part of a balanced diet.0
-
Sadly, weight loss pop culture has perpetuated this idea of "tricking your body" into shedding fat/losing weight or "kickstarting your metabolism". There's no such thing. The only thing that will positively affect your weight loss is eating at a small deficit from your total daily energy requirements (e.g. what your body needs to run efficiently) and exercise for body recomposition purposes. Anyone telling you differently is selling something.
:flowerforyou:0 -
WATCH YOUR SODIUM INTAKE! You mention you have a lot of sodium to cut back on in your post.
Sodium makes you retain water and could affect your result when you weigh in.
Otherwise I agree with everyone above. You need to look at calories in VS calories out...and work out your BMR!
This will really help you out
0 -
OPEN YOUR FOOD DIARY!!!!!
PLEASE!!!!!
You already have the answer to your question. SALT We can only guess @ where you are getting it. My guess is that like others who complain of not losing weight, you eat almost nothing but pre-packed processed foods. When I got rid of the Sodium in my diet, I began losing 3 lbs/week.0 -
First attempt at weight loss, Weight Watchers, I lost 50 lbs. in a relatively short amount of time, 6 months. Had a baby, several months later went on WW again - followed a similar WW plan as before and lost 20 lbs. Fell off the wagon again, gained, tried WW again, lost 6 lbs. Keeping in mind that I ultimately returned to the weight I was before the first WW loss, and then some. Sooooo, I've tried various things like low carb diets, the 17 Day Diet - which is minimal carbs for the first 17 days and then going through various cycles of "tricking" your body over 2 more phases.
I think my body is tricked out. My body doesn't seem to be "falling for it" anymore. Is that possible? I eat very healthy, drink a ton of water and I jog/walk/circuit train for at least an hour every single day. Not losing an ounce.
I started MFP, I religiously track every single thing that goes into my mouth (I'm getting WAYYYYYY too much sodium, which I'm now starting to cut back on). I eat lots of white chicken, fish, tons of healthy veggies, approx. a gallon of water a day, a small amount of carbs but haven't cut them out completely. I just don't eat anything "white" except the white meats.
Any suggestions? Is it possible that my body is fed up with me tricking it?
Maybe instead of these tricks:
You need to try these tricks:
0 -
I think my body is tricked out. My body doesn't seem to be "falling for it" anymore. Is that possible?
I am not sure if this may be what you mean but some people have said that yo-yo dieters have a harder time losing each time they go on a "diet". This thinking is wrong (which I am super happy about). So your body isn't getting smarter in holding onto weight I promise.
Also, take pics/measurements!0 -
Weight watchers is a great program I was on it twice only stopped because of expepenses. You really need to get serious loseing weight is somthing you need to do for you and your loved ones it is a lifestyle change. so start keeping a diary and choose an exercise that you like and keep at it you are not alone. valey12340
-
First attempt at weight loss, Weight Watchers, I lost 50 lbs. in a relatively short amount of time, 6 months. Had a baby, several months later went on WW again - followed a similar WW plan as before and lost 20 lbs. Fell off the wagon again, gained, tried WW again, lost 6 lbs. Keeping in mind that I ultimately returned to the weight I was before the first WW loss, and then some. Sooooo, I've tried various things like low carb diets, the 17 Day Diet - which is minimal carbs for the first 17 days and then going through various cycles of "tricking" your body over 2 more phases.
I think my body is tricked out. My body doesn't seem to be "falling for it" anymore. Is that possible? I eat very healthy, drink a ton of water and I jog/walk/circuit train for at least an hour every single day. Not losing an ounce.
I started MFP, I religiously track every single thing that goes into my mouth (I'm getting WAYYYYYY too much sodium, which I'm now starting to cut back on). I eat lots of white chicken, fish, tons of healthy veggies, approx. a gallon of water a day, a small amount of carbs but haven't cut them out completely. I just don't eat anything "white" except the white meats.
Any suggestions? Is it possible that my body is fed up with me tricking it?
it's pretty obvious to me that you really have no idea how/why your body gains or loses weight.
it's all about the calories. how much water you drink or not is irrelevant. what you eat is irrelevant. how long or how often you work out is largely irrelevant.
what matters is this... calories out > calories in.
the point of logging is to know whether or not you are meeting this relationship. you must log accurately though.
the first step is to understand your BMR and TDEE and what these are. once you do that, you can set yourself an appropriate calorie goal. then you can worry about meeting your macros. this is what determines your food choices. forget all that nonsense about "good" food or "bad" food or "healthy" food or "unhealthy" food.
get started here:
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/952996-level-obstacles-lose-weight-target-fat-easy
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/833026-important-posts-to-read
start reading. start learning. then put what you've learned into action.
the laws of physics cannot be changed and ultimately, your body MUST adhere to these laws. if you eat fewer calories than you expend, day in and day out, you will lose weight.
^^AMEN0 -
Listen to Winner. It's all in the name.
Listen to winner and Concrete...it's all in the name.0 -
Instead of trying to trick your body, why don't you instead try following a tried and true method of weightloss: Calculating your bodies caloric needs and eating a reasonable deficit, tracking tne calories that you are consuming instead of an arbitrary point system, and follow an exercise plan.0
-
A healthy diet is more than just eating "healthy foods". It includes eating the right amount of calories and nutrients. Enough to fuel your body but not so much that you gain weight. Eating too low for a long time can lower your metabolism and make weight loss harder because what once was a calorie deficit may now be surplus or maintenance.
My advice is to stop with gimmicks and fad diets and just eat for nutrition. Eat protein, fat and carbs. Eat a variety of vegetables and fruits. Limit sugar and sodium and make your grains whole grains. Eat foods you enjoy. Food shouldn't be a trick. It should be fuel. Delicious, satiating fuel.0 -
Do you use a scale to track how much you eat, or just guestimate?
I finally saw positive movement on the human scale after buying a food scale.
I also agree with this. Many people guestimate on food and calories burned. I definitely saw better results after buying a food scale to accurately measure food and a Heart Rate Monitor (I have Polar FT7) to accurately count my calories burned. You can't always rely on the figures in MFP or on a cardio machine at the gym. They are just estimates most times.
yep, i agree with these, but ill add that you can periodically check your own heart rate at times during your workout if you dont have the funds yet to invest in a HRM. After doing this for a long time youll begin to kinda of know what it feels like when youre at 40/60/80%.0 -
I can't see your food diary so I can't comment on what you are eating. But it is time to stop the gimmick diets. Weight loss isn't about a diet. It is about a lifestyle change. What ever you do to lose weight needs to be something you plan to sustain for the rest of your life. You can't just go back to "normal" eating once you hit your goal weight or you just gain it all back.
This. Gimmick diets will do nothing but frustrate you. Get away from them! Don't do anything to lose weight that you aren't willing to do for the rest of your life.0 -
I love it when people ask for help, and then never come back! Makes me all warm and fuzzy feeling...0
-
Instead of trying to trick your body, why don't you instead try following a tried and true method of weightloss: Calculating your bodies caloric needs and eating a reasonable deficit, tracking tne calories that you are consuming instead of an arbitrary point system, and follow an exercise plan.
This. Stop the nonsense. Eat right - move more.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions