Creatine

RMX82
RMX82 Posts: 172
edited September 2024 in Food and Nutrition
So I just picked up some Body Fortress Super Advanced Whey Protein Powder and noticed that it has some creatine in it as part of their recovery formula. I'm currently doing P90X and figured this would be good to have after my workouts, and to help build up my protein levels. I'm planning on having two scoops a day.

My question is, is that if I am trying to lose weight, will the creatine in this product hurt my results? I use protein shakes as meal replacements sometimes when I am in a hurry. I know that body builders take protein powder all of the time, and I'm pretty sure that it won't hurt my results, but I was just wondering if anyone knowledgeable on this would have some better information? I count these shakes towards my daily caloric intake, so to me, if I count the calories in my shakes, and they fit in my day, that it wouldn't hurt my weight loss.

Not sure if this makes any sense, but I figured I'd ask to see if anybody could verify my thoughts, or steer me in another direction. I'm not really into meal replacement shakes like SlimFast or Ensure.

Replies

  • bjberry
    bjberry Posts: 665 Member
    Via Wikipedia:
    Final Analysis: Extensive research over the last decade has shown that oral creatine supplementation at a rate of 5 to 20 grams per day appears to be very safe and largely devoid of adverse side-effects [13] while at the same time, effectively improving the physiological response to resistance exercise, increasing the maximal force production of muscles in both men and women.[14
    Creatine supplements are sometimes used by athletes, bodybuilders, and others who wish to gain muscle mass, typically consuming 2 to 3 times the amount that could be obtained from a very-high-protein diet. A survey of long-time use gives the creatine content of several foods.[7]

    Some Warnings:
    The Mayo Clinic states that creatine has been associated with asthmatic symptoms and warns against consumption by persons with known allergies.[8]

    While there was once some concern that creatine supplementation could affect hydration status and heat tolerance and lead to muscle cramping, recent studies have shown these concerns to be unfounded.[9][10]

    There is less concern today than there used to be about possible kidney damage from creatine, although there are reports of kidney damage, such as interstitial nephritis; patients with kidney disease should avoid use of this supplement.[8] Similarly, liver function may be altered, and caution is advised in those with underlying liver disease although studies have shown little or no adverse impact on kidney or liver function from oral creatine supplementation.[11]

    In theory, creatine may alter the activities of insulin. Caution is advised in patients with diabetes or hypoglycemia, and in those taking drugs, herbs, or supplements that affect blood sugar. Serum glucose levels may need to be monitored by a health care professional, and medication adjustments may be necessary.

    Long-term administration of large quantities of creatine is reported to increase the production of formaldehyde, which has the potential to cause serious unwanted side-effects. However, this risk is largely theoretical because urinary excretion of formaldehyde, even under heavy creatine supplementation, does not exceed normal limits.[12]

    Hope that helps. :drinker:
  • Good question and hopefully someone way smarter than me will answer. My guess is that the creatine won't hurt the weight loss, except it would help with building more muscle through resistance training...so you may gain weight but I would guess it's the good kind! *shrug*
  • Hermit4Hire
    Hermit4Hire Posts: 197
    Notwithstanding the technical data provided above, I tried creatine several years ago. So this is just based on personal experience.

    Yes, it made me look bigger--an effect when muscles retain water.

    Yes, it took away all my vascularity, especially in the arms--again, muscles retained more water and I had difficulty keeping a "lean" appearance.

    Yes, it made me jittery--I think this is what the positive reviewers call "more energy." Didn't care for my energy that way.

    I quit after 2-3 weeks.


    EDIT: Rereading your post, if there's only a small amount of creatine within a whey protein powder, it's probably not going to have the same effects I experienced with a creatine powder.


    $0.02.

    Good luck.
  • RMX82
    RMX82 Posts: 172
    Hermit4hire-

    Yea, this is just creatine that is in a regular whey protein powder. It isn't a seperate creatine supplement. I think I would be taking 6g per day if I do 2 scoops of the protein powder. That's what I was worried about, I don't want to be on a "creatine" supplement, but it just happens to be included in my whey. I'm just worried that with the P90X and the protein shakes that I won't drop the weight, just start looking better. Which is fine, but I'd rather look better at 200, not 256, haha.
  • Hermit4Hire
    Hermit4Hire Posts: 197
    Cool then I wouldn't sweat it. If you don't like the results, you can always switch to a whey without the creatine blend.

    I too have a whey shake in the morning and a cassein shake at night as part of my daily calorie goal and I think it works great.
This discussion has been closed.