Cardio before breakfast

tommygirl15
tommygirl15 Posts: 1,012 Member
edited September 21 in Fitness and Exercise
My best friend suggested that I should do my cardio workouts first thing in the morning before eating breakfast if I want to lose the fat faster. I'm in the process of looking it up on the web a bit, but was just wondering if any agrees or disagrees with this method?
«1

Replies

  • jrich1
    jrich1 Posts: 2,408 Member
    I made the mistake of going to my spin class one morning on an empty stomach thinking my body would use what it has for energy.. I had 0 energy and barely finished the class.
    I would definately recommend eating something, I think I read that your body can only use so much stored energy at once
  • bellanean
    bellanean Posts: 220
    I dont like doing this. I eat something little to get my going before my morning work outs!
  • bellanean
    bellanean Posts: 220
    I dont like doing this. I eat something little to get my going before my morning work outs!
  • leesey1
    leesey1 Posts: 104 Member
    i normally eat a piece of peanut butter toast before i work out in the morning, that way i am not starving. if i eat before i work out i feel sick, or i end up feeling hungry afterwards. hope that helps!
  • PJilly
    PJilly Posts: 22,165 Member
    I like to eat a nice big breakfast an hour or two before my workouts.
  • krl523
    krl523 Posts: 53
    always eat..a carb is good before you workout and protein afterwards. You dont have to eat a full breakfast, but something is important....
  • I tried exercising one morning before ewating anything at all and got really light headed and felt very weak. I wold have to agree with the other in eating something to get your blood sugar levels going ( I assume mine was low which was why I was light headed)
  • tommygirl15
    tommygirl15 Posts: 1,012 Member
    So I guess no one here is really in favor of the cardio fast? I'm reading up about it and it's a bit controversial, the upside is that it will tap into fat stores but the bad news is that you can also lose muscle in the process. I guess I'll have to experiment a bit and see how it works for me, 'don't knock it 'til you try it' so to speak ;)
  • hkystar
    hkystar Posts: 1,290 Member
    When I do my walk/run in the am I do it before I eat. I have 1-2 cups of water, then I stretch and then I go. I have no problems but I eat something with protein as soon as I finish.
  • smuehlbauer
    smuehlbauer Posts: 1,041 Member
    I get up at 5:15 am during the week to go for my walks, or 30 Shred. I can not eat that early! Don't know why, just cant. I usually don't have my oatmeal until 8:30. But that's just me.
    Everyone's different.
    Find what works for you. As far as it burning the fat faster - I would assume that's a load of crud...
  • Jenks
    Jenks Posts: 349
    I did Zumba one morning without eating, it was the worse thing. I got dizzy, couldn't think straight, forgot the moves (I'm the instructor) my vision even got a little blurry. Everybody is different, but I wouldn't do it on purpose.
  • imagymrat
    imagymrat Posts: 862 Member
    So I guess no one here is really in favor of the cardio fast? I'm reading up about it and it's a bit controversial, the upside is that it will tap into fat stores but the bad news is that you can also lose muscle in the process. I guess I'll have to experiment a bit and see how it works for me, 'don't knock it 'til you try it' so to speak ;)

    you won't lose muscle if you are strength training, and you are eating a good protein enriched breakfast fterwards. The trick to not eating beforehand is to actually have nothing..not tea, not juice, nothing, your body has to use fat stores since it has no fuel from food to use as energy. It's a tried and true method, and it's helped quite a few of my clients including myself lose weight. If I have an early AM class I don't eat beforehand, it's really a personal choice. Good to see that you're researching it.
  • hkystar
    hkystar Posts: 1,290 Member
    you won't lose muscle if you are strength training, and you are eating a good protein enriched breakfast beforehand. The trick to not eating beforehand is to actually have nothing..not tea, not juice, nothing, your body has to use fat stores since it has no fuel from food to use as energy. It's a tried and true method, and it's helped quite a few of my clients including myself lose weight. If I have an early AM class I don't eat beforehand, it's really a personal choice. Good to see that you're researching it.

    thats not including water, correct?
  • LotusF1ower
    LotusF1ower Posts: 1,259 Member
    My best friend suggested that I should do my cardio workouts first thing in the morning before eating breakfast if I want to lose the fat faster. I'm in the process of looking it up on the web a bit, but was just wondering if any agrees or disagrees with this method?

    Some people can manage this, some can't. Personally, I have never tried it, mainly because I can't exercise first thing anyway, good grief it is all I can do to hobble to the toilet first thing and then the kettle, let alone pound away on the treadmill :laugh:

    The site below may interest you on this subject:

    http://medicmagic.net/exercise-before-breakfast-burns-fat-faster.html

    It says in the article that it does burn more fat even though the performance is decreased. An empty stomach means adrenaline levels are increased and insulin is low and the ratio is appropriate to break down more muscle fatty acid.

    :noway: - think I might force myself to try this now!
  • allstarmommy76
    allstarmommy76 Posts: 5 Member
    Hi, I personally love to go for my morning run first thing in the morning, but everyone is different. I like to get it done and out of the way first thing, especially with all the hot weather here lately. I vary a little during the colder months, of course, by running during lunch. Still prefer to get it done first thing. I tend to get lazy as the day goes by. LOL!
  • hroush
    hroush Posts: 2,073 Member
    I am usually starving right when I get out of bed, so I couldn't do this. I then have to run off and do other stuff throughout the day, so I work out at night. I like working out a couple hours before bed because then I don't have as many problems going to sleep as i am ready to crash. But then again, I am a night owl by nature, I'm sure my wife could do this if she wanted to as she is a morning person.
  • I think it depends on you and how you feel. I personally wake up and go straight to the gym, do not pass go. Even if I eat and wait an hour before working out I feel nauseous and uncomfortable. But everyone is different! Do what feels right for you! Although I have heard that working out in the morning kick starts your body a tad bit so you burn more calories and have more energy during the day, and working out too late at night could disrupt sleeping habits...but I say if you feel good, no worries! :)
  • jusniq
    jusniq Posts: 49
    I use to do this when I first started working out. After a couple mins into a good work out....I'd feel like I was just gonna fall over. Then I started eating a lil...just a lil before the work out, and it was okay for awhile, but every now n then I'd still get that feeling like i'm can't do anymore. Infact, just the last two weeks, i've put more into eating breakfast before I run out to the gym. I wouldn't recommend it.
  • PLUMSGRL
    PLUMSGRL Posts: 1,134 Member
    I think it depends on your work out-
    for me cardio first, then eat within an hour of compleation to burn
    weights/muscle training, protein-carb snack prior for energy (piece of toast with nut butter or almond milk)
    above all else, listen to your body!
  • kah78
    kah78 Posts: 376 Member
    I get up early and go. if I stop to get something to eat, I'll just keep eating. :-) This is working for me, and I'm 4 months in...if it stops working, I'll try changing it up. But, if it ain't broke, I'm not going to fix it. Whatever allows you to be consistent and feel good is probably what is right for you. Try it both ways and see which you like better!
  • ❤B☩❤
    ❤B☩❤ Posts: 634
    I tried to eat before doing one of my C25K days. I was uncoordinated (more so than usual!) and I just FELT heavier and not quite as quick on my feet. I know I should, but if I don't do as well eating before, what's the sense? I eat right away AFTER, tho!

    I agree with another poster that said, "Do what feels right for you!". :drinker:
  • thedreamhazer
    thedreamhazer Posts: 1,156 Member
    http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m0KGB/is_1_5/ai_n6097710/

    I've read up on this before, but I couldn't find the article I read on it that was really good. So, here's another. It basically says that yes, perhaps you burn fat more. However, you won't have as much energy, and won't be able to work out as long or as hard as you would if you ate an hour or two before. I've also read that not eating before a workout leads to your body breaking down more muscular type tissue for energy as opposed to fat reserves, and have a little sugar in your blood for instant energy allows your body to get at your fat reserves more effectively. But, this is just what I'm remembering, I'm not an expert.
  • KellyBurton1
    KellyBurton1 Posts: 529 Member
    I was on a plateau for 3 weeks and last week I got up early and went for a walk/jog for 30 mins. I lost 2 lbs in 5 days. I thought I would never be able to do it but I did.
  • lucifa73
    lucifa73 Posts: 110
    I eat a small banana around 6am and start at the gym at about 6.30am, have a protein shake around 8am once I'm done and showered then have a bowl of cereal (usually weetabix or shredded whear) at around half 9. I find if I don't have that first banana I can't push as hard in the gym and I feel dizzy when I'm done.
  • Amandac6772
    Amandac6772 Posts: 1,311 Member
    4:30 am is the only time I have to workout so I don't have time to eat, let it digest and then workout. It's always been fine for me but people are different. You just have to figure out what works for you.
  • p1nkpr1ncess
    p1nkpr1ncess Posts: 254 Member
    I think it just comes down to personal preference. I have always been taught that exercising with atleast a 2 hour gap from food would burn fat quicker than if I ate before.

    I don't eat before my morning workouts and I don't suffer the light-headedness or anything BUT I'm not hungry when I first wake up anyway and usually have a protein shake straight after my workout then have breakfast a couple of hours later.

    I deffinately think it has it's benefits working out before eating but if your body doesn't like it then just have a small snack before hand :)
    -x-
  • tommygirl15
    tommygirl15 Posts: 1,012 Member
    So I guess no one here is really in favor of the cardio fast? I'm reading up about it and it's a bit controversial, the upside is that it will tap into fat stores but the bad news is that you can also lose muscle in the process. I guess I'll have to experiment a bit and see how it works for me, 'don't knock it 'til you try it' so to speak ;)

    you won't lose muscle if you are strength training, and you are eating a good protein enriched breakfast fterwards. The trick to not eating beforehand is to actually have nothing..not tea, not juice, nothing, your body has to use fat stores since it has no fuel from food to use as energy. It's a tried and true method, and it's helped quite a few of my clients including myself lose weight. If I have an early AM class I don't eat beforehand, it's really a personal choice. Good to see that you're researching it.

    Oh you are a trainer? Nice :)
    What do you think about this? I do my fasting cardio and then I have a protein shake right after? Unfortunately I have to take the bus to the gym so it will take me a little longer to get home after the workout. What kind of stuff should I put in my bag to make available to eat right afterwards?
  • sbilyeu75
    sbilyeu75 Posts: 567 Member
    Please have some protein before you workout. My husband didn't a few weeks ago and passed out on the gym floor due to low blood sugar (he is not diabetic).
  • iplayoutside19
    iplayoutside19 Posts: 2,304 Member
    Like others of have said, this comes down to personal choice. I roll out of the rack, drink some water while stretching, and then get after it. Mostly because this is what I'm comfortable with. Only once have I experienced a huge blood sugar plummet, and that was after running for 45 minutes. So unless I'm going to do something that intense for that long I don't eat anything.

    So, if that's how you want to roll, by all means. If not, eat something.
  • canstey
    canstey Posts: 118
    The theory is that since you have no food in your system to use for fuel, your body will use more fat reserves than if you had eaten and your body would use more of the breakfast. Yes it is true that you will burn a few extra percentage of fat if you don't eat first. However they don't bother to tell you that it won't make a difference at the end of the day.

    You burned extra fat during the workout because you didn't eat. So after you eat breakfast your body goes about its normal energy consumption and voila, it gets its energy from breakfast instead of fat reserves because now breakfast is available whereas if you ate before exercising it wouldn't. Net result by lunch: no difference.

    The downside to this technique is what others have said; less effective workouts that burn fewer total calories and actually fewer total fat calories just to burn 65% of the calories from fat instead of 60% from fat. This is similar to the "fat burning zone" recommendation that you keep your intensity low to increase percentage of calories burned from fat high even though total fat calories burned is higher from more intense workouts even if the percentage is lower.
This discussion has been closed.