Just had to share....

Thats great! Congrats! As far as the calorie discrepancy, I would low-ball the calorie burn on the elliptical to about 450-500 p/hour because those machines are notorious for over estimating the burn...just for future reference! Good luck on your journey!

The machine is going by the standard 70 kg or 154 pound person. Since you weigh more, you will burn more then that. Congrats! Sounds like a great workout!

I just had to share...I am currently 232 and on my way to 120. 8 pounds in to the journey. Anyways, I just got done on the elliptical and did 60 minutes! Burned 656 calories! I SO wanted to quit at 30, but did not. I had a higher cal lunch so am working off those cals. I have P90X Yoga and X Stretch today (missed a day). Can not wait to see where the day ends.


Oh, one thing. MFP said 60 minutes elliptical should have burned me 954 cal and the machine said 656. Why such a difference?

Shannon the MFP site overestimates some of its exercise calories. From my own experience on those machines it is approximately 600 calories per hour, so in my opinion, the machine was correct. Ellipticals are also very similar in calories burned to treadmills and they are also around 600 per hour (of course depends how fast etc) however, 900+ calories per hour on either of those machines would be a hell of a lot and would require extremely fast running or movement.

Besides, 656 calories is superb and you should be very proud of yourself, just goes to show what you can do!!

WTG, you are definitely on your way x

Congrats on your good start. I ran across a website that has a calculator for elliptical exercise, based on your actual weight and other data about your work out. Here is the link:

http://www.caloriesperhour.com/index_burn.php

When the page comes up, look at the links toward the bottom and look for "Precor EFX 546 Elliptical Calculator." You should be able to get a good idea of what you burned, based on your actual data. Good luck. If you do this, how about a follow-up post to indicated how this calculator came in compared to the MFP data, and the data from the machine you were using?

The machine is going by the standard 70 kg or 154 pound person. Since you weigh more, you will burn more then that. Congrats! Sounds like a great workout!

She's right.

BTW, great job and dedication. I bet you feel great! I'm always so proud of myself when I pull through the "I can't" moments and turn them into "I can" moments!

Great job!

Awesome! My suggest would be to invest in a HRM (Heart Rate Monitor). That way you know what it really is that you have burned. I have found that sometimes MFP is right on and other times it is way off.