1200 Calorie People..How do you do it and stick with it?

13

Replies

  • I've been eating 1200 a day for about 3 weeks and lately I find myself having to add things to come close to 1200. I am never hungry. I guess it's because I'm eating very low calorie foods. If you find you are hungry I would suggest trying to find lower calorie replacements for what you're eating throughout the day. I've stopped eating anything past 10 pm(9 would be ideal but I start my day a little later) which hasn't been a problem now that I'm used to it. So that means my meals are closer together and I hardly have time to get hungry before my next meal. I think also I've realised I'd been planning meals that were bigger portions than I really needed. It's nice to get a better sense of what you really need to satisfy yourself (from the girl who could never finish what she ordered at a restaurant).
    I'm not sure if everyone does this but I plan everything the night before as opposed to logging as I go. Then I won't get stuck with no calories to spare :)
  • And the days that I have oatmeal for breakfast I am STUFFED for hours!
  • mariahmilan
    mariahmilan Posts: 28 Member
    I guess it depends on what you're eating.

    If you eat a big leafy green salad with a nice piece of fish that's a pretty awesome meal and banking about 250 calories. But if you have a peanut butter and jelly sandwich it can easily hit 500 calories.
  • mamadon
    mamadon Posts: 1,422 Member
    I've been on a 1200 calorie diet for five months. I would never go any lower than that however. If I exercise I eat those calories back. Some days it is easy and others hard, but I have lost almost 60 pounds, so it is worth it. We are all different and what works for me may not work for the next person. I agree with other posters though, 1200 is way to low for a guy.
  • Lochlyn_D
    Lochlyn_D Posts: 492 Member
    1200 calories is so low! You guys should really check out the EM2WL group (Eat More 2 Weigh Less) and calculate your TDEE, BMR and take a 15% cut from there. Huge deficits can actually inhibit weight loss.

    1200 may be too low for you but it is right for others. Don't judge unless you want to be judged yourself.
  • Liz_Mfp
    Liz_Mfp Posts: 172 Member
    1200 calories is so low! You guys should really check out the EM2WL group (Eat More 2 Weigh Less) and calculate your TDEE, BMR and take a 15% cut from there. Huge deficits can actually inhibit weight loss.

    What if your EM2WL and TDEE% comes out into the 1200's?
  • kaylather
    kaylather Posts: 5 Member
    Hi there,
    I am eating 1200 a day. Add me if you'd like to see my diary
  • bpwparents
    bpwparents Posts: 359 Member
    I average around 1300 a day as 1200 was just a little too low for me. My diary is open if you want to take a peek.
  • hsnider29
    hsnider29 Posts: 394 Member
    1200 calories is so low! You guys should really check out the EM2WL group (Eat More 2 Weigh Less) and calculate your TDEE, BMR and take a 15% cut from there. Huge deficits can actually inhibit weight loss.

    What if your EM2WL and TDEE% comes out into the 1200's?

    You must be calculating something wrong. I'm 32, 5'0 and 146 pounds. My BMR is around 1400 and my TDEE is somewhere between 1800 and 2000. Even someone that doesn't exercise is bound to have a higher TDEE than 1200.
  • Bekahmardis
    Bekahmardis Posts: 602 Member
    I eat 1200 NET and I believe that is the key. I eat between 1500-1900 calories per day and never feel deprived.
    Yes, this. I eat 1200 NET calories and let my FitBit tell me how many more calories I should eat based on the exercise I do for the day. My diary is wide open if you want to take a look. For me, it's all about how much protein I take in. The protein I eat each day keeps me full FAR longer than carbs do. Yesterday, I worked pretty hard and totally indulged - and didn't manage to eat back all of my calories even WITH 12 ounces of wine! LOL!
  • amyrcathey
    amyrcathey Posts: 8 Member
    I just started the 1200 calorie intake about 2 1/2 weeks ago. I have been going over by 200 calories or so. I also eat my exercise calories. I am doing okay with this... feel I can do it (by that I mean get to 1200 and maintain). My problem is that I am not seeing any results!! I've toned up some but no seeing weight loss.... so frustrating!!!

    The number on the scale does NOT reflect muscle gained or many other important factors. If you have toned up its because you are gaining muscle which is awesome and I'm sure you know that muscle weighs more than fat! Not losing weight is not always a bad thing and often times is a good thing (if you are exercising regularly.)
  • dittmarml
    dittmarml Posts: 351 Member
    I'm 5'1", 130 lbs., mildly active (though with a chronic connective tissue disease (genetic) so no heavy lifting; major joint disorders), and my TDEE is STILL around 1700.

    MFP set me at 1200 - I bumped it to 1250 and eat back exercise calories anywhere from 50% of them to all of them. When I'm not traveling and doing business lunches and dinners (aka, have little-to-no control of what's put in front of me) I lose about 1/2 pound/week which is a great, steady rate for me. When I do have control over my diet (even being able to make menu selections) I don't have any problem staying around 1250 NET. I'm a vegan, eat lots of veggies, whole grains, fruits - use a protein powder in the morning to make sure I get enough in my diet.

    All of the discussions on this thread and many others about whether 1200 is reasonable or don't really mean anything until additional information is presented about height, weight, activity level, age, etc.
  • hsgilly
    hsgilly Posts: 4
    I eat 1200 calories a day and exercise by walking between 2 and 3 miles a day at a moderate pace (about 17 minutes/mile). I'm not eating back my calories burned yet, because I still have some pounds to lose. When I hit my goal weight, I'm planning to try to end up with a net intake of 1200 calories, after eating back what I've exercised, and see how that goes. If I keep losing weight, I'll increase the calories. If I start to gain, I'll pull back again or change up the exercise.
  • __Di__
    __Di__ Posts: 1,658 Member
    1200 calories is so low! You guys should really check out the EM2WL group (Eat More 2 Weigh Less) and calculate your TDEE, BMR and take a 15% cut from there. Huge deficits can actually inhibit weight loss.

    1200 may be too low for you but it is right for others. Don't judge unless you want to be judged yourself.

    this ^

    That's all you hear on these boards now, "eat more to lose more" or "your body will hold onto the calories" or "you are not eating enough"........

    Then if you go to the fitness boards, it is "lift heavy" ..........
  • JenX15
    JenX15 Posts: 103 Member
    I eat 1200 NET and I believe that is the key. I eat between 1500-1900 calories per day and never feel deprived.

    THIS!!!!!!

    I started at 1200 cals a day, and I walked for 90 mins a day - giving me a NET of 700 ... the weight would not budge .... I was starving..... SO - my approach to this was - this is a lifestyle change and if I am miserable and starving half the time, no way this is going to stick. I upped my allowance to 1200 NET and voila! I am happy, not starving AND losing 1-2 per week :)

    I tend to log my breakfast, snack and lunch first thing in the morning since I know what I brought with me to work. I also log my mornign excercise - this way I can estimate what I am going to have for dinner and how hard I need to work at night. My averages are anywhere from 1300-1800 cals consumed daily. Some weekends are not great, but hey - this road is not a prison - it's life.

    GOOD LUCK!

    Feel free to friend me if you want to look at what my diary looks like. :)
  • p1ppers
    p1ppers Posts: 40 Member
    I eat 1200 NET and I believe that is the key. I eat between 1500-1900 calories per day and never feel deprived.

    RIght, I walk several miles each day, that is my only exercise really but I can burn anywhere from 400-800 calories so I always eat back at least half of that and sometimes if I'm hungry I'll eat it all back so my NET is still 1200 but I'm full all the time. I think it is important to eat things that fill you up also, I have carbs and proteins that seem to do the trick for me, not just high calorie sugary stuff (although I do like chocolate everyday!) May not be the most "healthy" diet, but it works for me an I've been losing weight for last 3 years (80 lb so far) and have no problem controlling my weight this way. I also eat every 2-3 hours, so I've always got some food on hand even if it is a string cheese or an apple with a bottle of water (crystal lite infused) nearby 9sometimes being dehydrated will make you FEEL hungry when you're really just thirsty). I think it's all about a balance for you to feel comfortable with so you might have to note in your diary when you are hungry and when you are satisfied and see what is different those days.

    Being hungry is not going to work for very long, why suffer when the goal is to be healthy and happy with your food choices for life. Good luck.
  • HS2305
    HS2305 Posts: 422 Member
    I generally find that as long as I plan my meals, it's easy to stick to 1200 calories a day. I try to make sure I factor in snacks and drinks as well so that I never feel like I'm depriving myself.

    Also try not to stress if you do go over 1200. At the end of the day s*** happens. Just try not to lose your motivation, work harder when you exercise and watch the calories a bit more for the rest of the week.
  • chloeobe
    chloeobe Posts: 72
    Lots of protein! I eat less that 1200 a day, this is an example of a day plan:

    Porridge w/almond milk and mauka honey (200 cals)

    Chicken breast (50g), Low fat cottage cheese and salad/steamed veg (300 cals)

    Hot chocolate or milky coffee made with almond milk and diet whey belgain choc protein shake (100cals)
    or banana (100cals)

    Chiken/Steak/Fish with stir fry/steamed veg (450 cals)

    Low fat greek Yoghurt, sugar free jelly and fruit (around 150cals depending on portion size)

    AND...you can eat back exercise cals as treats :)
  • Diamond05
    Diamond05 Posts: 475 Member
    I fill up on veggies, high protein and good fats. Im low carb so not much rice, pasta and bread. It's mainly lean meats , veggies and olive oil. I'm not starving at all, with these food you can get a decent amount to fill you up.
  • emstethem
    emstethem Posts: 263 Member
    Protein and lot's of it would be my suggestion...I don't count calories-I count carbs-- BUT, I have noticed that I eat WAY LESS calories in general by counting carbs instead of calories. Also, I would suggest eating REAL FOOD...not the packaged edible PRODUCTS (those products are not REAL FOOD) if you eat real food you will probably discover that you are more satisfied and eating less calories in general. Good luck to you!
  • martysa
    martysa Posts: 12 Member
    I'm on 1200 calories a day and i find that on the days i dont exercise, im starving. When i exercise and i eat back some of the calories i feel soooo much better and less hungry.
  • JustME1611
    JustME1611 Posts: 112 Member
    I do 1250 calories a day and burn about 200-450 with working out. Sometimes I eat back my calories sometimes I don't. I eat a small breakfast (cereal mostly), a decent lunch (salad, sandwich, or tuna), and then I eat pretty much what I want at dinner just watch my portions. I also have a couple of snacks in between. I'm never starving. I've lost 33 lbs and I tend to lose about 1-2 lbs a week.
  • Roxiehart9
    Roxiehart9 Posts: 32
    I just looked through your diary, and it look slike you are super high in carbs and quite low in protein. If you just started on this diet, it's going to take at least 4-5 days worth of discipline so your body can get used to this adjustment...but it looks like you went a little over yesterday, which i going to reset your body. Dieting and eating healthy is NOT easy. No one ever said it was. But if you truely want to do it, it's mind over matter. 1200 seems very low since your body needs at the very least 1200 calories to function every day just to walk, breath, pump blood...etc.

    Also, remember every calorie is NOT made equally. The low carb diets work for a reason. You are re-balancing your body and getting rid of excess insuline and glucose that you would need to lose weight or that is stopping yoru body from losing weight. when you have a large carb intake, you add more insulin to yoru body and it has to work to get rid of that before it can work on getting rid of your fat.

    Not all carbs are bad. But you want to take about 1-2 weeks to go super low carb, like between 50-100 carbs a day only then gradually put them back into your diet according to how yuor body reacts. Unforunately, I know my body eats and holds onto carbs, so I stay away from all processed carbs and only get them from fruits, veggies, and yogurt.

    If you ar eexercising, you are going to want to up your cal intake to about 1400-1600. At 1200 calories you'll loose weight for abou ttwo weeks but once your body adjusts to it, it'll stop losing weight. Then you'll have to drop to 1000 calories and eventually if you follow this pattern, you'll be eating 100 calories a day, which is obviously not going to happen.

    Always remember clean and original foods are much easier on the body to digest and turn to nutrients than processed foods. so if you have a 100 calorie pack of chips vs 150 calorie banana, the banana wins. Your body wants that WAY more than the chips.


    Good Luck! Everyone is different and it takes everyone different speeds to learn and get used to healthy living and dieting. Hope this helped!
  • TeaBea
    TeaBea Posts: 14,517 Member
    I do 1200 calories and only eat back my exercise calories on Sundays. I eat 3 meals and drink 1-2 protein shakes a day. I personally found the higher my protein intake that day, the less hungry I feel. I stay low carb, low fat and low sugar. I've lost 26.8 lbs this way since 4/13. I have a smart scale at home and calculates body fat, muscle and water.. I've increased my muscle and decreased my fat... I also drink anywhere from 1 gallon to 1.5 gallons of water a day. The water keeps me full! Good luck

    GAINING muscle mass and netting below 1200 calories 6 days a week ?...... um no. Home scales are not reliable for measuring muscle mass.... eating lots of protien is good .... but below your BMR ..... you would be lucky to hang onto existing muscle.

    Obviously a home scale isn't 100% and you are entitled to your opinion, but it is my opinion when done right you CAN lose just fat, keep your muscle and even possible gain some muscle. I keep my fat low so I tap my reserves and my protein high to keep my muscle. I base this on the fact my diet was designed by a body builder/personal trainer. This diet has been used by multiple clients and they are the proof. You lose your weight your way, and I'll lose mine my way.

    Again - look at the boards here ..... building muscle on a number less than your BMR ..... no way. Not just my opinion ... we just disagree.

    FAT does NOT make you fat .... very old school. My guess would be most of your PT's clients are body builders and not netting below their BMR. Very low calorie diets are the issue.... they are very hard on your body.
  • EricaahMcK
    EricaahMcK Posts: 5 Member
    I'm eating 1200 calories and exercising. I don't really eat breakfast and just have coffee(I know, don't lecture me). I usually have a shake or a salad for lunch. I don't eat bread or pasta or potatoes, but I occationally have some chocolate if I have some calories left over. I also try to eat things with lots of bold or full flavors so I'm not craving something when I've finished eating. One major change I made - I don't drink. I realized I was drinking too many of my calories with alcohol or just sugary coffee drinks, so I gave it up. I eat a lot of broiled meat and veggies. I find that protien leaves me feeling more full than a bowl of lettuce or celery though.
  • nuttingh
    nuttingh Posts: 65
    When I first joined MFP, I was hungry all the time at 1200/day. I exercised and ate about half of my exercise calories and was still hungry all the time. Then I changed my daily intake to about 1700/day, whether I exercise or not. I'm far better off and started losing again. I also started incorporating even more fresh fruits and veggies and proteins, which is what my body was craving. Now my daily intake is around 1200-1400/day without trying. When my body evened out with exercise, water, metabolism and healthier foods, it became easier to consume less calories without trying. It just took time for me and to find what my body was really craving.
  • nuttingh
    nuttingh Posts: 65
    Protein and lot's of it would be my suggestion...I don't count calories-I count carbs-- BUT, I have noticed that I eat WAY LESS calories in general by counting carbs instead of calories. Also, I would suggest eating REAL FOOD...not the packaged edible PRODUCTS (those products are not REAL FOOD) if you eat real food you will probably discover that you are more satisfied and eating less calories in general. Good luck to you!

    Agree 100% :)
  • JessicaMcguigan123
    JessicaMcguigan123 Posts: 52 Member
    If i eat heatlhy foods i find im not hungry, like nuts,vegtables salads, grilled chicken. If i eat a choclate bar or cheese sandwich, i will be hungry a couple of hours later!
  • PcShed
    PcShed Posts: 84 Member
    You should try intermittent Fasting
  • Francl27
    Francl27 Posts: 26,371 Member
    To repeat what's been said, it's supposed to be 1200 NET. Which means you often end up eating more. I'm close to 1200 NET every day (sometimes less when I'm really not hungry), I don't log exercise but probably burn 200-300 most days.