Frustrated...!!!
IronPhyllida
Posts: 533 Member
Hi all,
I'm a regular in the exercise department, I am that stage where I'm fighting the urge not to have rest days but know that I need them.
My issue today is, I cycled 26 miles yesterday and walked a further 6 miles, all part of my commute which is how I'm increasing my training, in total I burnt well over 2k calories (I wear a Garmin HRM).
I gained 100 grams. Which I know isnt much but for goodness sake, surely it should be the other way around?!
I am being careful with pennies and also I disaprove of too many energy drink due to high sugar content, but also aware that Protein intake has to increase.
Am I being naive in thinking that if I burn 2k cals, surely I should be able to pretty much eat what I want - by that I don't mean Pizza/Burgers/Sugary foods.
My aim is to lose weight so that I can run/race at race weight so I need to be 67kgs and I'm at a stubborn 73.9kgs. I've lost 6 kg's since November by increasing exercise and being more cautious re food. Although wine stays on the list.
I'm a regular in the exercise department, I am that stage where I'm fighting the urge not to have rest days but know that I need them.
My issue today is, I cycled 26 miles yesterday and walked a further 6 miles, all part of my commute which is how I'm increasing my training, in total I burnt well over 2k calories (I wear a Garmin HRM).
I gained 100 grams. Which I know isnt much but for goodness sake, surely it should be the other way around?!
I am being careful with pennies and also I disaprove of too many energy drink due to high sugar content, but also aware that Protein intake has to increase.
Am I being naive in thinking that if I burn 2k cals, surely I should be able to pretty much eat what I want - by that I don't mean Pizza/Burgers/Sugary foods.
My aim is to lose weight so that I can run/race at race weight so I need to be 67kgs and I'm at a stubborn 73.9kgs. I've lost 6 kg's since November by increasing exercise and being more cautious re food. Although wine stays on the list.
0
Replies
-
Did you eat back those 2k calories back? because it is possible your HRM is overestimating calories burned.0
-
Hi - no I didnt, I did eat more than I usually do but MFP said I'd eaten 2,084 cals when I could have eaten 3,370 (inc the 2,170 cals I burnt), the profile MFP has given me suggests I eat 1,220, which I can do but not when I'm burning that amount of calories...0
-
What I have learned is that weight loss is not instantaneous. Look at what happens over a month and you will see the results. Be consistent in your logging and don't starve yourself especially on days where you exercise a lot. Probably next week you will see the results of what you did. Weight also seems to come off in chunks rather than linearly, nothing for 9 days then the next day I can have dropped 2lb.0
-
Yes that is very true, thanks Sarah.
Also from a female perspective, the time of the month affects things but I was just astonished that there was not only no change, but an increase...
BTW I've been logging weight/fat/water percentages for about 6 years now, just havent been hugely consistent with food logging etc, specially with home made food...
Will report back
0 -
I always find my weight increases for a couple of days after a heavy workout, a long cycle or a two hour run. I believe this is due to the muscles holding the water and it always decreases again after this time. The best thing to do is weigh yourself a few days after such a hard workout to get a true indication of your weight. If you look it up you will find most peoples weight increases after a heavy workout due to the water, hope this helps.0
-
if you are working out that hard it is more than likely water retention....0
-
Oh I see... I've read that sometimes people have a day of taking more salt, bit weary of this but have you guys done this and how would you go about it as i'm sure you dont have teaspoons of salt...0
-
Not even going to say what my weight was today, let's just say I'M NOT HAPPY... And I cycled again so I've burnt 1k cals already...0
-
if you're actually burning that many calories through cycling you should be eating WAY more than 2000 calories. probably more like the 3000 mfp suggests. you will put yourself in starvation mode doing that (i learnt the hard way) lol.0
-
Odds are it is water retention, particularly if you have recently stepped up your exercise regimen. If you have any soreness after your cycling, that's a good indicator that you are generating micro-tears in your muscles (as part of the normal process of muscle building). Your body will cause inflamation and water retention at the site of the tears, resulting in a net increase in weight (but not fat) for two to three weeks. A lot of people get discouraged when this happens and give up before their body can adjust to the new exercise. Once it does, however, the weight will start to come off again. Give it a month before you decide that things aren't working. And you should definitely try to eat back you calories, particularly with burns that high.0
-
if you're actually burning that many calories through cycling you should be eating WAY more than 2000 calories. probably more like the 3000 mfp suggests. you will put yourself in starvation mode doing that (i learnt the hard way) lol.
But if I'm in starvation mode, wouldn't I be feeling weak whilst training?!0 -
Odds are it is water retention, particularly if you have recently stepped up your exercise regimen. If you have any soreness after your cycling, that's a good indicator that you are generating micro-tears in your muscles (as part of the normal process of muscle building). Your body will cause inflamation and water retention at the site of the tears, resulting in a net increase in weight (but not fat) for two to three weeks. A lot of people get discouraged when this happens and give up before their body can adjust to the new exercise. Once it does, however, the weight will start to come off again. Give it a month before you decide that things aren't working. And you should definitely try to eat back you calories, particularly with burns that high.
OK that does make sense, I notice that my ankles are slightly swolen so I do feel that I'm retaining water. I'll try to up my water intake and see if that will flush things through. So to speak.0 -
if you are working out that hard it is more than likely water retention....
this
why on earth would you weigh yourself the day after that much exercise!0 -
if you're actually burning that many calories through cycling you should be eating WAY more than 2000 calories. probably more like the 3000 mfp suggests. you will put yourself in starvation mode doing that (i learnt the hard way) lol.
But if I'm in starvation mode, wouldn't I be feeling weak whilst training?!
your training may not suffer straight away but if you keep up such an aggressive deficit it probably will eventually.0 -
I do a lot of cycling and running, I'm a semipro athlete.
2k seems a hell of a lot of calories for 26m bike and 6m walk. Garmin HRMs are notorious overestimators. My figures come out at more like 950 calories for 26m bike and 6m run. I'm 5'5 and 61kg0 -
I did a huge cycle on Saturday and my legs were still pumped yesterday to the degree that my trousers were noticeably tighter, that's not muscle and it's not fat - just the muscles recovering from being stressed.
Unfortunately the only way to accurately see your progress is to track everything you eat and your exercise over an extended period of time. My numbers never matched all the various calculation tools but by being consistent and making small adjustments I found the sweet spot for slow & steady weight loss and then weight maintenance.
As you are serious about your exercise you really want a small deficit over a long period otherwise your sports performance will be compromised.0 -
Usually after an intense workoout my weight will remain the same or increase then after a rest day drop 2-3lb.
Nothing to worry about just how the body works.0 -
I do a lot of cycling and running, I'm a semipro athlete.
2k seems a hell of a lot of calories for 26m bike and 6m walk. Garmin HRMs are notorious overestimators. My figures come out at more like 950 calories for 26m bike and 6m run. I'm 5'5 and 61kg
Agree with this comment that your burn numbers do seem too high - for comparison I typically burn 600/hour at 15mph on a hybrid bike. I'm 5'9" & 77kg.0 -
I weigh myself everyday at the same time before breakfast. I can't do it weekly etcif you are working out that hard it is more than likely water retention....
this
why on earth would you weigh yourself the day after that much exercise!0 -
I can do that calory burn as well for an hour on the bike, but I pushed hard (had a train to catch!), the same route varies from 650cals/hour to 850cals/hour on same settings on my HRM. When I started out when I was heavier i was doing just under 1kcals/hour. I'm 5'7" & 73kg.I do a lot of cycling and running, I'm a semipro athlete.
2k seems a hell of a lot of calories for 26m bike and 6m walk. Garmin HRMs are notorious overestimators. My figures come out at more like 950 calories for 26m bike and 6m run. I'm 5'5 and 61kg
Agree with this comment that your burn numbers do seem too high - for comparison I typically burn 600/hour at 15mph on a hybrid bike. I'm 5'9" & 77kg.
Also the run would be shorter timewise than a walk for 6m, so the burn would be lower.... Just saying
0 -
I weigh myself everyday at the same time before breakfast. I can't do it weekly etcif you are working out that hard it is more than likely water retention....
this
why on earth would you weigh yourself the day after that much exercise!
then you must realise that weight fluctuates? sometimes you'll be up, sometimes you'll be down! look at the overall trend for the week and month.0 -
I can do that calory burn as well for an hour on the bike, but I pushed hard (had a train to catch!), the same route varies from 650cals/hour to 850cals/hour on same settings on my HRM. When I started out when I was heavier i was doing just under 1kcals/hour. I'm 5'7" & 73kg.I do a lot of cycling and running, I'm a semipro athlete.
2k seems a hell of a lot of calories for 26m bike and 6m walk. Garmin HRMs are notorious overestimators. My figures come out at more like 950 calories for 26m bike and 6m run. I'm 5'5 and 61kg
Agree with this comment that your burn numbers do seem too high - for comparison I typically burn 600/hour at 15mph on a hybrid bike. I'm 5'9" & 77kg.
Also the run would be shorter timewise than a walk for 6m, so the burn would be lower.... Just saying
Keep in mind that the calories burned during a run are very different than during a walk: high intensity versus low intensity. Just because the walk takes a longer time doesn't mean you are burning more calories than a brisk run of the same distance; it is energy exerted not time spent!
I agree that the calorie estimate definitely seems too high-- and no doubt, you're dealing with water retention. I recommend keeping your mind on feeling good, staying active, and eating healthily. The weight will come off over time and you will be fit in the long run!0 -
Yes I do realise that, but from all the training I've done over the years, never have I done that much exercise in one day to get a weight gain...
I weigh myself everyday at the same time before breakfast. I can't do it weekly etcif you are working out that hard it is more than likely water retention....
this
why on earth would you weigh yourself the day after that much exercise!
then you must realise that weight fluctuates? sometimes you'll be up, sometimes you'll be down! look at the overall trend for the week and month.
It is gradually going down but havent let off the exercise, will see what it's like in a couple of weeks from doing the same amount etc.0 -
Some perspective - 100 ml of water weighs 100grams. The average coffee mug holds about 200ml. It could literally be something as simple as you having drunk half a mug more of water than usual. Seriously, go pour that out and look how easy it is to trick the scales into thinking you gained 100grams.0
-
Some perspective - 100 ml of water weighs 100grams. The average coffee mug holds about 200ml. It could literally be something as simple as you having drunk half a mug more of water than usual. Seriously, go pour that out and look how easy it is to trick the scales into thinking you gained 100grams.
LOL trust me, i weighed myself before having the 200ml cup of coffee, but it's not a biggie, I was just curious, not jumping off a building because of it....0 -
I have a garmin HRM.
I have also been in a science lab and had specific tests done for athletes by sports scientists.
I wore both pieces of equipment for the same test.
My HRM told me I had burnt 796 calories in the hour. The sciency equipment measuring energy expenditure told me I had burnt 514. Just saying like..... HRMs are not accurate.0 -
Also the run would be shorter timewise than a walk for 6m, so the burn would be lower.... Just saying
Not quite correct. There is a significant misconception that calorie burn is based solely on distance .....the old 1 mile of walking equals 1 mile of running.
http://www.runnersworld.com/weight-loss/running-v-walking-how-many-calories-will-you-burn0 -
Exactly!! The 6m run burns more not less!!0
-
You're absolutely right, when I started running and people were saying that, I just thought it can't be true as the effort in comparison was much more for the distance run...
Also the run would be shorter timewise than a walk for 6m, so the burn would be lower.... Just saying
Not quite correct. There is a significant misconception that calorie burn is based solely on distance .....the old 1 mile of walking equals 1 mile of running.
http://www.runnersworld.com/weight-loss/running-v-walking-how-many-calories-will-you-burn
Big bummer re calories burnt... Oh well it was still a good workout 0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions