Is 1200 calories enough for my age
gmsanderson
Posts: 8 Member
For a lady thats 4'11 at 266 lbs does 1200 calories sound like enough? Is there a web site I can go to get the calories I need? I'm 57 years old with bad knees. I have a staionary bike that I will start riding. I do good one week and overeat the next. I am really going to try much harder this time. I have to for my health.
0
Replies
-
I entered all of your info into this calculator and used 'lighly active- 1-3hrs a week of physical activity'
http://scoobysworkshop.com/calorie-calculator/
To maintain right now you would eat 2500 (lightly active) or 2200 (sedentary)
To lose you can eat 2000 (lightly active) or 1750 (sedentary)
Your BMR is 1800 so I wouldn't suggest eating under that. You should recalculate w/ this calculator every 5lbs down.
With this method you don't eat your exersise calories back. This is -20% so its for ~1lb/week loss.
GL! :flowerforyou:0 -
I entered all of your info into this calculator and used 'lighly active- 1-3hrs a week of physical activity'
http://scoobysworkshop.com/calorie-calculator/
To maintain right now you would eat 2500 (lightly active) or 2200 (sedentary)
To lose you can eat 2000 (lightly active) or 1750 (sedentary)
Your BMR is 1800 so I wouldn't suggest eating under that. You should recalculate w/ this calculator every 5lbs down.
With this method you don't eat your exersise calories back. This is -20% so its for ~1lb/week loss.
GL! :flowerforyou:
I agree with this. You will eventually work down to a lower amount, but I would say to be 266 pounds, you would have eating a lot at times. To drop way down would be really hard mentally and physically. Try and make it a healthy diet , eating good meats, and veggies and some carbs. As you lose weight, you will defiantly need less, but then you may find yourself more mobile, so maybe not that much less. Also move. I am younger, but have noticed I am more active and less sore as I have lost weight and eaten enough food. My issues are neck and shoulders, but I know weight hurts knees as well. Moving can be walking at the shops, gardening, really simple things, that don't hurt your knees too much. Good luck .0 -
Thank You0
-
I dont say this often but you need to hear it. OP, You are 57 years old and morbidity obese, both of which make a good combination of an early death. You should should seriously seek advice from a specialist because I have no doubt in my mind that you have a lot of bad stuff going on inside of your body. The average nutritional advice isn't what you want because there are no good options for someone in your situation.
There is no good healthy option for you, only bad ones. Create a big deficit to relieve immediate pressure and fat off of your organs or lose weight slow which in turn would do your body more harm because of the hazardous living condition you created inside of your body. At your weight you are most likely pre-diabetic or even full blown diabetic and everything in your body is choking from so much excess fat that that your organs are literally losing function. If you went and got an MRI this very moment, I wouldn't be surprised if they found a fatty liver and pancreas. Fatty liver leads to Cirrhosis, which means your liver could stop functioning. Having too much fat on the pancreas will block that organ's production of insulin, a cause of diabetes. Eating too many carbs in your state could be destroying the insulin receptors on your blood cells, pre-diabetes. Once all your insulin receptors are destroyed, you'll be classified as a full blown diabetic.
You have no good options. Only bad ones that should be discussed with a specialists.
.0 -
I dont say this often but you need to hear it. OP, You are 57 years old and morbidity obese, both of which make a good combination of an early death. You should should seriously seek advice from a specialist because I have no doubt in my mind that you have a lot of bad stuff going on inside of your body. The average nutritional advice isn't what you want because there are no good options for someone in your situation.
There is no good healthy option for you, only bad ones. Create a big deficit to relieve immediate pressure and fat off of your organs or lose weight slow which in turn would do your body more harm because of the hazardous living condition you created inside of your body. At your weight you are most likely pre-diabetic or even full blown diabetic and everything in your body is choking from so much excess fat that that your organs are literally losing function. If you went and got an MRI this very moment, I wouldn't be surprised if they found a fatty liver and pancreas. Fatty liver leads to Cirrhosis, which means your liver could stop functioning. Having too much fat on the pancreas will block that organ's production of insulin, a cause of diabetes. Eating too many carbs in your state could be destroying the insulin receptors on your blood cells, pre-diabetes. Once all your insulin receptors are destroyed, you'll be classified as a full blown diabetic.
You have no good options. Only bad ones that should be discussed with a specialists.
.
How do you figure she has "no good options"? Surely an option is to lose weight in a healthy way.0 -
How do you figure she has "no good options"? Surely an option is to lose weight in a healthy way.
Healthy is a general term that means something different to everyone based on anyone's current situation. She only has two options to lose weight, high deficit or low deficit. Losing weight slowly or what most people are advising her to do at TDEE-20% would mean a 2 to 3 year weight loss plan, essentially leaving her blood cells in a hazardous living condition for almost two years. However, losing weight fast or a higher deficit at 1600 calories max would relieve more immediate pressure faster but cause unknown problems that many people here seem to believe which I have given credit to since so many here recommend TDEE-20%. It is my opinion that she should create the highest deficit possible that keeps her energy needs in line for a normal day and not lose weight at the slowest possible rate for someone in her condition.
.0 -
How do you figure she has "no good options"? Surely an option is to lose weight in a healthy way.
Healthy is a general term that means something different to everyone based on anyone's current situation. She only has two options to lose weight, high deficit or low deficit. Losing weight slowly or what most people are advising her to do at TDEE-20% would mean a 2 to 3 year weight loss plan, essentially leaving her blood cells in a hazardous living condition for almost two years. However, losing weight fast or a higher deficit at 1600 calories max would relieve more immediate pressure faster but cause unknown problems that many people here seem to believe which I have given credit to since so many here recommend TDEE-20%. It is my opinion that she should create the highest deficit possible that keeps her energy needs in line for a normal day and not losing weight at the slowest possible rate for someone in her condition.
.
Are you a doctor? Or a dietitian?
She could easily lose 100 lbs in the next year, which would get her down to 166, a much better weight. I don't see how encouraging her to have a huge deficit will help, especially since that would mean she is more likely to gain the weight back.0 -
How do you figure she has "no good options"? Surely an option is to lose weight in a healthy way.
Healthy is a general term that means something different to everyone based on anyone's current situation. She only has two options to lose weight, high deficit or low deficit. Losing weight slowly or what most people are advising her to do at TDEE-20% would mean a 2 to 3 year weight loss plan, essentially leaving her blood cells in a hazardous living condition for almost two years. However, losing weight fast or a higher deficit at 1600 calories max would relieve more immediate pressure faster but cause unknown problems that many people here seem to believe which I have given credit to since so many here recommend TDEE-20%. It is my opinion that she should create the highest deficit possible that keeps her energy needs in line for a normal day and not losing weight at the slowest possible rate for someone in her condition.
.
Are you a doctor? Or a dietitian?
She could easily lose 100 lbs in the next year, which would get her down to 166, a much better weight. I don't see how encouraging her to have a huge deficit will help, especially since that would mean she is more likely to gain the weight back.
I could ask you the same question but I've said from the get go, for her to speak to a specialist and not get advice from the forums because of how serious her condition is. If she wants, link below to a dietitian.
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/forums/show/13105-ask-the-dietitian
.0 -
1200 does not sound like a good idea. So many people start out at 1200 and then have to bump it up either because they are starving all the time or because their weight loss stalls out. I started out with 1200 and lost a pound a week, but I was hungry all the time. After reading a ton of posts, I bumped it up to 1500. I still average a pound a week, but I am not really hungry. I don't do a lot of exercise, but I do try to walk 30 min a day. Sometimes it is two 15 min walks. We are about the same age. The extra weight is going to make it worse on you as you get older. I decided to get serious about my weight at my last physical when the doctor was quizzing me to make sure I would recognize the signs and symptoms of a heart attack. Jeez. Anyway, If you want to send me a friend request, I would be glad to do whatever I can to encourage you along the way. Good luck to you.0
-
How do you figure she has "no good options"? Surely an option is to lose weight in a healthy way.
Healthy is a general term that means something different to everyone based on anyone's current situation. She only has two options to lose weight, high deficit or low deficit. Losing weight slowly or what most people are advising her to do at TDEE-20% would mean a 2 to 3 year weight loss plan, essentially leaving her blood cells in a hazardous living condition for almost two years. However, losing weight fast or a higher deficit at 1600 calories max would relieve more immediate pressure faster but cause unknown problems that many people here seem to believe which I have given credit to since so many here recommend TDEE-20%. It is my opinion that she should create the highest deficit possible that keeps her energy needs in line for a normal day and not losing weight at the slowest possible rate for someone in her condition.
.
Are you a doctor? Or a dietitian?
She could easily lose 100 lbs in the next year, which would get her down to 166, a much better weight. I don't see how encouraging her to have a huge deficit will help, especially since that would mean she is more likely to gain the weight back.
I could ask you the same question but I've said from the get go, for her to speak to a specialist and not get advice from the forums because of how serious her condition is. If she wants, link below to a dietitian.
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/forums/show/13105-ask-the-dietitian
.
Yes, but I'm also not the one telling her the danger her cells are in and recommending a low calorie diet. I do agree that anyone looking to lose weight should speak with someone qualified first, but most people on this board know that doctors are not the best for that, but rather a dietitian or nutritionist.0 -
Too rapid of weight loss can pose plenty of healthy risks of its own. It makes no sense for her to ruin her metabolism and set herself up to gain it all back. While everyone should regularly be seeing a primary healthcare professional, I fail to see why she would need a specialist any more than anyone else on these boards.
I personally have been eating slightly above my BMR. The weight is coming off slowly, but steadily. More importantly, I am satisfied and rarely hungry and get to enjoy my food. Have a glimpse at some of the 1200 calorie people's diaries...I fail to see how a person (especially one who exercises) could subsist on what little they are eating. Fuel your body with the right foods and the right amount of them.0 -
I'm with AbsoluteNg.
The OP is in such a precarious position, she NEEDs a good professional evaluation.
1200 is not too low in her case. She has plenty of body fat to draw from - 1200 is only a bad idea once you get lower in weight.
It is "absolutely" more important for her to get those top 50 pounds off AS SOON as possible, and 1200 is a perfectly reasonably way to do it.
I lost 50 pounds on 1200, with lots of body fat, she is fine at that.
Op, go to 1200. See a specialist - this week. Good luck.
Morbid Obesity is called that for a reason. It will kill her.0 -
How do you figure she has "no good options"? Surely an option is to lose weight in a healthy way.
Healthy is a general term that means something different to everyone based on anyone's current situation. She only has two options to lose weight, high deficit or low deficit. Losing weight slowly or what most people are advising her to do at TDEE-20% would mean a 2 to 3 year weight loss plan, essentially leaving her blood cells in a hazardous living condition for almost two years. However, losing weight fast or a higher deficit at 1600 calories max would relieve more immediate pressure faster but cause unknown problems that many people here seem to believe which I have given credit to since so many here recommend TDEE-20%. It is my opinion that she should create the highest deficit possible that keeps her energy needs in line for a normal day and not losing weight at the slowest possible rate for someone in her condition.
.
Are you a doctor? Or a dietitian?
She could easily lose 100 lbs in the next year, which would get her down to 166, a much better weight. I don't see how encouraging her to have a huge deficit will help, especially since that would mean she is more likely to gain the weight back.
That's a popular theory but the most recent meta-analysis found people who dieted aggressively in the first several months were no more likely to regain the weight.
I really disagree that she has no good options. There are so many people on this site who have far more to lose and improve their health very quickly. In fact, I think quite the opposite is true: All her weight loss options are good! and even a 10% weight reduction is found to improve health.
OP, I would recommend that you go for some relatively quick weight loss at first. Studies find that very obese people lose more fat than leaner people with an aggressive diet; leaner people tend to lose more muscle. But that's not to say 1,200 is the right amount for you and I think it's not. You might try something more like 1,600 or a little higher. That's low enough to give you quick weight loss in these early months but it's high enough to help you stay on your eating plan. It's not helping you when you are following 1,200 one week and then falling off track the next.
I highly, highly recommend that you consult with a nutritionist, not because terrible awful things are going on in your body (which no one but your doctor and you would know so don't listen to people saying negative things out of total ignorance) but to help you adjust your way of eating in a way that will help you shed pounds more quickly (try googling "Not all calories are created equal" and you'll see the study that shows you in what way this is true), feel momre satisfied and really boost your nutrition.
YOu have MANY great options and you will probably adjust and modify those options many times along your path. Best of luck.0 -
Too rapid of weight loss can pose plenty of healthy risks of its own. It makes no sense for her to ruin her metabolism and set herself up to gain it all back. While everyone should regularly be seeing a primary healthcare professional, I fail to see why she would need a specialist any more than anyone else on these boards.
I personally have been eating slightly above my BMR. The weight is coming off slowly, but steadily. More importantly, I am satisfied and rarely hungry and get to enjoy my food. Have a glimpse at some of the 1200 calorie people's diaries...I fail to see how a person (especially one who exercises) could subsist on what little they are eating. Fuel your body with the right foods and the right amount of them.
The main thing she needs to get checked up on is if she is a diabetic and for that reason alone she needs to get tested. She might be a diabetic and not even know it. She's not young so her changes are high that she might have diabetes. Not knowing that you have diabetes and eating a lot of carbs can cause your legs to get chopped off, literally. I'm sure her doctor would refer her to a dietitian or some sort of specialist while she's there or she could ask for it.0 -
By the way, for the "in terrible danger, lose as fast as possible crowd," it's pretty dangerous to make assumptions about someone else's health based on such limited information. I was not as obese as OP is, but I started this just before I turned 59 and I was in the "severely obese" category--not the top of the three obesity categories, but not the bottom, either. I have a total of 78 pounds to lose to reach normal weight and I'm exactly halfway there after 5.5 months. But my blood tests before losing weight were sterling, my cholesterol levels beautiful, my heart tests perfect, my blood pressure 120/80. I didn't deserve all that good medical news with the weight I was carrying around, but there you have it.
That said, consulting professionals is a very good idea.0 -
To me, 1200 calories sounds too low. I am 5' 9.5 & I eat 1200 a day.0
-
By the way, for the "in terrible danger, lose as fast as possible crowd," it's pretty dangerous to make assumptions about someone else's health based on such limited information. I was not as obese as OP is, but I started this just before I turned 59 and I was in the "severely obese" category--not the top of the three obesity categories, but not the bottom, either. I have a total of 78 pounds to lose to reach normal weight and I'm exactly halfway there after 5.5 months. But my blood tests before losing weight were sterling, my cholesterol levels beautiful, my heart tests perfect, my blood pressure 120/80. I didn't deserve all that good medical news with the weight I was carrying around, but there you have it.
That said, consulting professionals is a very good idea.
You are a very reasonable person. I like you. I hope i wasn't being too harsh on the OP and I'm sorry if I was.0 -
You and I are the same age. My weight isn't quite as high as yours but I have no doubt that my health is being impacted by my weight. In addition, I too have bad knees. I have a goal to run some day, although I know that may not be possible given my knees. One thing I have found, and have committed to as a life long journey, is yoga. I personnally like hot yoga, but for some that may be to much. But yoga helps you in a variety of ways. I have improved balance, core strength, I am starting to see changes in my body shape, I feel better and mentally, I am at peace with my journey and the fact that my weight loss will not be a fast process but a lifetime process. Feel free to friend me, I would be happy to help you move towards a healthier you with as much support as I can provide.0
-
By the way, for the "in terrible danger, lose as fast as possible crowd," it's pretty dangerous to make assumptions about someone else's health based on such limited information. I was not as obese as OP is, but I started this just before I turned 59 and I was in the "severely obese" category--not the top of the three obesity categories, but not the bottom, either. I have a total of 78 pounds to lose to reach normal weight and I'm exactly halfway there after 5.5 months. But my blood tests before losing weight were sterling, my cholesterol levels beautiful, my heart tests perfect, my blood pressure 120/80. I didn't deserve all that good medical news with the weight I was carrying around, but there you have it.
That said, consulting professionals is a very good idea.
You are a very reasonable person. I like you. I hope i wasn't being too harsh on the OP and I'm sorry if I was.
"Like" button clicked ;7)0 -
I agree about getting medical advice....either a VERY GOOD doctor (and my experience in this area has not been good with doctors) or see a nutritionist. I started at 380 pounds but am 5"9. Looking back now I wish I had gone to a good doc and had blood tests as well as a physical to check everything so I had a "base". That said I was morbidly obese and apart from general illnesses (like regular UTIs, colds etc) and had no major issues. But i would get the blood tests and then presuming all is clear see a nutritionist. If the blood tests are not clear I am sure the doctors will have recommendations. Empower yourself with the knowledge of how your body is and also this will allow you to track your progress in more ways then just the scales. Best of luck0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 423 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions