Goal Weight?
shrinkingbrian
Posts: 171 Member
So far, I have lost 193 pounds (and counting). I'm 6-0 in height and 38 years old (male). I'm currently at 212 pounds with a BMI of 28.7. I am not sure what my goal weight should be. I'm thinking I want to be somewhere in the 185-200 range depending on my muscle mass. I lift weights consistently 6 days a week (alternating muscle groups each day) and also do lap swim and walking/hiking so I'm pretty active now. I try to exercise at least 2 hours a day and some days, I exercise 2.5 - 3.5 hours a day (morning: lifting weights/swimming; afternoon: walking/hiking). My waist is currently at 39 inches so I know I definitely want to lose more inches. I'm thinking of a BMI around 26-27 with an athletic/muscular build would be a good goal and keep working on reducing my body fat percentage. I don't want to be a body builder but a good physique would be nice. My next annual physical with my doctor isn't until November so I also plan to talk to my doctor about my goal weight. BMI says anything over 185 is "overweight" but I know BMI has lots of limitations, especially for those with lots of muscle. At age 39, I'm now in the best shape of my life but I want to continue to improve my fitness level. I would rather be 190-200 but more athletic and muscular. I'm thinking about taking out a new life insurance policy but underwriting requirements say I need to be under 200 or 209 (depending on the insurer) for the preferred plus rate. I'm not in the military but for most branches, the max weight is around 200 pounds for a 6-0 male. I'm thinking 200 is a good goal and then work on decreasing my body fat percentage. Any thoughts?
0
Replies
-
First, congratulations on your amazing weight loss!
I'm 6'2 and 178 pounds with a goal of 175, but I'm looking for more of a runner's physique, long and lean. I think if you were 200 pounds and had low body fat you would be an absolute beast -- you would look like a body-builder, not just "athletic." A better goal for your height might be 180-185.0 -
Brian,
I guess I'm not really sure what to tell you except that your final goal weight should be whatever you want it to be. As long as you're happy and healthy, don't necessarily try to fit into some chart somewhere. I'm 6'0" also, when I graduated from high school, I was 206 lbs, I went into the army 3 days later and graduated basic training at 208 lbs and in the best shape of my life (I was not a weight lifter, just in shape). When I retired from the Army I was probably around 225-230, but I passed the body fat tests, so I wasn't considered overweight. I'm shooting for 240, and may adjust that downward a little. Point is, you have done amazing, get to a weight that you are happy and healthy with and are going to be able to maintain.
Disclaimer: As always, I am not a Doctor/Nutritionist, nor did I play one on TV.....I have stayed in a Holiday Inn Express and I am a French Model on the Internet!0 -
So far, I have lost 193 pounds (and counting). I'm 6-0 in height and 38 years old (male). I'm currently at 212 pounds with a BMI of 28.7. I am not sure what my goal weight should be. I'm thinking I want to be somewhere in the 185-200 range depending on my muscle mass. I lift weights consistently 6 days a week (alternating muscle groups each day) and also do lap swim and walking/hiking so I'm pretty active now. I try to exercise at least 2 hours a day and some days, I exercise 2.5 - 3.5 hours a day (morning: lifting weights/swimming; afternoon: walking/hiking). My waist is currently at 39 inches so I know I definitely want to lose more inches. I'm thinking of a BMI around 26-27 with an athletic/muscular build would be a good goal and keep working on reducing my body fat percentage. I don't want to be a body builder but a good physique would be nice. My next annual physical with my doctor isn't until November so I also plan to talk to my doctor about my goal weight. BMI says anything over 185 is "overweight" but I know BMI has lots of limitations, especially for those with lots of muscle. At age 39, I'm now in the best shape of my life but I want to continue to improve my fitness level. I would rather be 190-200 but more athletic and muscular. I'm thinking about taking out a new life insurance policy but underwriting requirements say I need to be under 200 or 209 (depending on the insurer) for the preferred plus rate. I'm not in the military but for most branches, the max weight is around 200 pounds for a 6-0 male. I'm thinking 200 is a good goal and then work on decreasing my body fat percentage. Any thoughts?Brian,
I guess I'm not really sure what to tell you except that your final goal weight should be whatever you want it to be. As long as you're happy and healthy, don't necessarily try to fit into some chart somewhere. I'm 6'0" also, when I graduated from high school, I was 206 lbs, I went into the army 3 days later and graduated basic training at 208 lbs and in the best shape of my life (I was not a weight lifter, just in shape). When I retired from the Army I was probably around 225-230, but I passed the body fat tests, so I wasn't considered overweight. I'm shooting for 240, and may adjust that downward a little. Point is, you have done amazing, get to a weight that you are happy and healthy with and are going to be able to maintain.
Disclaimer: As always, I am not a Doctor/Nutritionist, nor did I play one on TV.....I have stayed in a Holiday Inn Express and I am a French Model on the Internet!0 -
I am sure the guys on here know what they are talking about..I just wanted to comment and say congrats on your success with your weight loss..that is amazing.
Second, for the above post..I completely love your disclaimer..made me smile today!
Keep up the good work all of you!!!0 -
Instead of going by BMI, I would try to see if you can get your body fat % measured. There are several different methods with several degrees of accuracy so the most important thing is to find one and stick with it. Calipers are great but you can't really use them yourself. There are hand-held devices and step-on scales that work ok but results can be affected by water retention.
There are also online calculators - again not 100% accurate but easy to do with some quick body measurements.
Best of luck with getting to your goal!0 -
Brian,
You and I are very similar. I'm 31, 6'1, starting weight of 343 and I've lost 145lbs. I came in under 200lbs for the first time since 8th grade just last weekend. My goal weight is 195. I picked 195 because I want to have a 5 pound buffer to 200. My proper weight for BMI is also under 189, but I don't care about BMI. It is much to flawed to put any weight in. I can say that being only 3 pounds from my goal weight my body still isn't where I want it to be. It's certainly much closer than it was, but I've still got work to do. That being said, I don't know how much I'll weigh when my body looks the way I want it to. I've still got some fat to lose around my mid-section and I still want leaner muscles. Therefore after hitting my goal weight of 195 I will still continue to eat at a deficit and workout like I do now. I'm not going to go up to maintenance calories yet. I won't go up to those permenantly until I've hit my goal body.
Good luck and congrats to you.0 -
Brian,
I am 6', 50 years old, 34" waist, BF of 17-19%, and have fluctuated between 184-195 over the last 2 years. I've always been a weight lifter so I would say I have more muscle in areas than a non-weight lifter (arms, chest, etc.). The BMI chart said I should be at 184 and I agree, I looked great at 184 but I knew 175-180 for me was achievable because I still had extra body fat to lose.
My recommendation is to get your Body Fat measured and try and get it into the teens (18-19%) before you set a specific goal weight. Mirrors and scales don't lie, use your own eyes to determine for yourself and not anyone else's weight, look, or BF%.0 -
Thanks everyone for the suggestions. Once I get to 190, I think I'll get my body fat percentage calculated. I can get a bod pod body fat testing for $35 near my house. I have used some online calculators for body fat percentage based on my measurements. i know I'm definitely not there yet but I'm getting closer to my goal weight. Right now, I'm more focused on my fitness goals rather than just numbers on a scale for weight loss. If I continue with my fitness goals, more weight loss will naturally come.
Here are my fitness goals:
1. Pass the minimum standards for the Marine Corps Fitness Test:
*3 mile run - 29:00 (done - ran 26:30 in June 2013)
*crunches in 2 minutes - 45 (need to test)
*pull ups – 3 (in progress - can do 10 reps with 55 lb spotter)
2. Complete a mile swim in under 35 minutes (US Masters Swimming - Masters Level 2) - currently at 38 minutes
3. Bench press 225 pounds - (in progress - currently at 185 pounds)0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.8K Introduce Yourself
- 43.9K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153.1K Motivation and Support
- 8.1K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 15 News and Announcements
- 1.2K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions