We are pleased to announce that on March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor will be introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the upcoming changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

Calorie limit

boridizzy
boridizzy Posts: 3 Member
edited January 28 in Health and Weight Loss
I've been reading some of the forums on here about how many calories people are eating, etc. I would love some help figuring out what my calorie limit should be. i recently returned to MFP after using LoseIt for some time. On Loseit I was set to lose 2lbs a week and they gave me a calorie limit of 1357. On here they give me a limit of 1200 to lose 2lbs a week. I am 5'5, 26 years old, 196lbs and I work out 5x a week for at least an hour burning about 600-1100 calories when I work out. I've been working out about 5x a week since last year but my weigh has just been stuck and seems to only go up if I "cheat", meaning I eat too many carbs or dairy, or eat out. Any help would be greatly appreciated. Thanks!

Replies

  • thisismeraw
    thisismeraw Posts: 1,264 Member
    I believe Lose It takes your exercise calories and adds them in already which MFP doesn't do (you eat your exercise calories back here).. but I could be wrong on how lose it does their calculations.

    I am the same height, age and weight as you. I wouldn't suggest eating only 1200 calories in a day. Your BMR will be around 1600 so 1200 calories, especially if you aren't eating back your exercise calories is too high of a deficit for you.
  • boridizzy
    boridizzy Posts: 3 Member
    Thanks Thisismeraw, thats exactly what I was thinking but my body has been feeling "fine" at such a low calorie. I've upped my calories now to 1549 after doing the harris benedict formula and my bmr rate. Now I just have to get used to eating more despite not being hungry lol. Would you suggest I eat back my exercise calories on top of this?

    And LoseIt allows you to eat back your exercise calories also, just FYI.
  • swampgeek
    swampgeek Posts: 23 Member
    You absolutely have to, your 1200 goal is Net Calories not calories taken in. I am 5'7 and started out at 196lbs. Taking a quick glance through my reports, on days that I am active and running I consume 1800+ calories those days.you have to be honest with yourself about 2 things, the true amount of calories you put in your body and the true calorie burn of your workouts.
  • thisismeraw
    thisismeraw Posts: 1,264 Member
    Thanks Thisismeraw, thats exactly what I was thinking but my body has been feeling "fine" at such a low calorie. I've upped my calories now to 1549 after doing the harris benedict formula and my bmr rate. Now I just have to get used to eating more despite not being hungry lol. Would you suggest I eat back my exercise calories on top of this?

    And LoseIt allows you to eat back your exercise calories also, just FYI.

    I have my profile set at 1lb per week and I eat my exercise calories back. I still lose most weeks. I have a heart rate monitor though which gives me more accurate calorie burns.
  • Christineb1
    Christineb1 Posts: 3
    I recently purchased a "fitbit" that I wear all day. I tracks my steps, calories burned, elevation climbed, and maybe something else. Fitbit syncs with myfitnesspal.com so I track food with MFP track walking/activities with FitBit and it lets me know how many calories I can have per day vs. how much activity I must do to stick with my 2 pounds per week weight loss goal. That is the only accurate way I know to really determine calories.
This discussion has been closed.

Categories