We are pleased to announce that on March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor will be introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the upcoming changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

Opinion For Heart Rate Monitor Please

babybs
babybs Posts: 48 Member
edited January 29 in Fitness and Exercise
I am in the market to move up from my simple pedometer to a heart rate monitor. I'm quite uneducated, could you help by suggesting a good model? Can you get a HRM that is also a pedometer? Or was that a stupid question :)

Thanks in advance.

Replies

  • KimKuz99
    KimKuz99 Posts: 3 Member
    I just bought a Polar FT4 and I've used it 6-7 times already. I love it. It is a fairly basic model and is easy to use. It does not have a pedometer with it though. There may be HRM's with pedometers but I'm not familiar with those. I did research here on MFP and read reviews at amazon.com. Do a search on MFP for HRMs and you should be able to be see many posts on this subject.
  • babybs
    babybs Posts: 48 Member
    Thanks KimKuz99, I'll do that.
  • megabyt23
    megabyt23 Posts: 580 Member
    I use the Polar FT4 model as well and like it a lot! It seems fairly accurate to me so far, and it's really easy to use. I just needed something basic that actually worked! haha
  • scrapjen
    scrapjen Posts: 387 Member
    Have you considered a Fitbit? It IS a pedometer, it is NOT a HRM, but it is a wonderful tool. You just wear it all day and it tracks everything (dedicated activity and just steps through the day). It is more advanced than a regular pedometer, taking into account your height/weight/age/sex to determine calorie burn, even steps per minute (to determine if you are walking or running).

    I have a HRM too ... but to me it is a bit of a pain to put it on each time (it's three pieces, the little monitor, strap and watch). I do several workouts a day, and I don't like to leave the HRM on all the time (I leave the Fitbit on all the time, even at night as it tracks sleep too). I do like the feedback from the HRM, but I've found my Fitbit is coming up with very similar numbers for my walks/runs (which is one of the reasons I picked up the HRM, I did want to double check the Fitbit numbers).

    A good HRM doesn't cost as much as the Fitbit ($99) but it is a really good option, especially as it syncs automatically, and syncs with MFP too!
  • STrooper
    STrooper Posts: 659 Member
    It depends upon how you wish to deal with data or what data you actually want. Do you mind a chest strap or will a finger or wrist based monitor be satisfactory.

    For example, if you wish to have a separate "watch" which might or might not download to a computer, there are options that allow for that.

    If you want one that monitors GPS AND heart-rate, you have options for that.

    Do you have a smartphone with Bluetooth technology (and what type of phone and which version of BT)?

    In my own case I have an Android phone which means that I have BT version 3.0 or "classical" BT. I bought a Zephyr HRM which has a chest-strap and transmits via BT to my phone. There is no proprietary software that the monitor needs to use and because the phone has a reasonably good GPS onboard, I can use the GPS functions in conjunction with whatever program I use.

    There is not a single app that gets it all. Endomondo is a relatively simple and easy program that monitors heartrate easily. But the calorie expenditure seems overpredicted. Runtastic Pro does a pretty good job but its GPS function leaves something to be desired and Runtastic seems unable to fix the GPS errors. There are many programs that are iPhone exclusive so I can't say anything about them.

    One of the most useful programs I use is the Digifit iCario program (now that it supports the Zephyr monitor) but even without a HRM the Digifit site has a wealth of information which you might consult to help you choose. The are partners with MFP as are Runtastic and Endomondo.

    I am quite happy with my Zephyr. My first one was defective and Zephyr replaced it once it became obvious that the issue was the monitor. I like the chest strap and it functions well.
This discussion has been closed.

Categories