Eating less than 1,200 calories?
amysue_208
Posts: 9 Member
I received some test results recently and it turns out I am intolerant to many different kinds of foods. I can't eat those foods I am intolerant to for at least 3 months. I can't eat gluton, sugar, rice, corn, and several different kinds of fruits and vegetables. I have been off those foods for almost a week and have been trying to eat a lot, but I consistently am getting below 1,000 calories.
I really want to lose weight and have been working on it for a long time, but I'm worried that I am not eating enough calories and that my body will just hang on to the fat because it believes I am starving. I also have been eating a lot of carbs and protein. I have been eating over my daily goal of carbs.
I will try to open up my food diary so you all can see what I have been eating and see how I can improve. I also really really want to know if eating less calories like this will hurt me or help me with my overall weight loss and health. I really am not trying to eat so low... It just seems no matter what I do, I can't reach my MFP goal. Also, I have a question about that.... Everytime I log my diary in, it says something like: "Oh, if you continue eating this much, you will weight 150 pounds in 5 weeks". Is that true? I don't know how reliable that is.
I really want to lose weight and have been working on it for a long time, but I'm worried that I am not eating enough calories and that my body will just hang on to the fat because it believes I am starving. I also have been eating a lot of carbs and protein. I have been eating over my daily goal of carbs.
I will try to open up my food diary so you all can see what I have been eating and see how I can improve. I also really really want to know if eating less calories like this will hurt me or help me with my overall weight loss and health. I really am not trying to eat so low... It just seems no matter what I do, I can't reach my MFP goal. Also, I have a question about that.... Everytime I log my diary in, it says something like: "Oh, if you continue eating this much, you will weight 150 pounds in 5 weeks". Is that true? I don't know how reliable that is.
0
Replies
-
I looked at the last 2 days and saw that you are starving yourself for protein and fats. If you include a decent helping at each meal, and add a couple of snacks in the day, you will do much better. Your portion sizes are also pretty small. Balance is the key, and there are many choices, even with limited diets.0
-
You really should go over this with your doctor. They can tell you what you -should- be eating since you have to restrict so much a lot better than we can since they know your situation better.0
-
You really should go over this with your doctor. They can tell you what you -should- be eating since you have to restrict so much a lot better than we can since they know your situation better.0
-
Can you not eat meat? Your protein levels seem pretty low. And we can recommend all the typical higher calorie items (avocados, peanut butter, etc.), but we have no clue what you can or cannot eat. I agree with discussing your diet with your doctor.0
-
Would it be a lot more helpful if I wrote down all the things I can eat?
Also, am I damaging my weight loss goal because I am not eating more than 1,200 calories? Can I still lose weight if I eat less? I'm not saying I want to eat less, I am just curious.0 -
I've had this issue too. Allergies and digestive issues for me. It's hard to understand the frustration unless you've been there. I'm overweight because of not eating enough but I also have arthritis and some activities are very hard. I can tell you that the only thing is helping me with the situation is weights. But get protein in you however you can if your going to do weights. Soy, whey, meats, nuts... any way you can. And increase your water intake with your protein if your using shakes. I'm lucky to be able to use some protein shake mixes. If you can do that... they are balanced properly. Muscle burns fat and increases metabolism, period. It's the reason the guys lose weight so much faster than we do. So if you can try to engage in some sort of muscle building activity until this allergy situation is fixed that will help a lot.0
-
I'll go with the earlier post that you may need to consult a nutritionist about this. I'll try to answer your questions since that's not the answer you're looking for on an internet forum.
1,200 isn't a golden number in MFP; in fact I would suggest you ignore it. You should use a TDEE (total daily energy expenditure) and BMR (Basal Metabolic Rate) calculator. Your BMR plus maybe 10% should be your calorie floor instead of 1,200. It's possible, but very unlikely, depending on your size/weight/age/activity level that you could fall under 1,200 (again, very unlikely).
Your calorie goal should be TDEE - 20% (which should still be a fair amount above your BMR). You can get MFP to adjust your goals by changing your rate of weight loss in your settings.
Moving on, you will still lose weight eating below 1,200 calories. The issue isn't so much weight as it is health in general. You may even experience more rapid weight loss (then plateau, then lose at a slower rate) depending on the precise level of the deficit. Again, this isn't a healthy route but I understand you have other circumstances affecting you.
At starvation levels your body will put the brakes on metabolism to preserve itself. Your body may start to break down lean muscle to make up the energy (calorie) deficit it is experiencing. Your general feeling of wellness may decrease as your energy level drops.
The weight loss projection by MFP follows the general rule that a 3,500 calorie deficit creates 1 pound of fat loss. This is based on a big assumption of consistent behavior (basically, net calories) and doesn't factor in metabolism changes. Is it absolutely correct? No. But it will continue to provide a reasonable estimate, barring any better available method.
As to your diet. I know you want to eat healthier but if you continue to run calorie deficits that low it's going to wreck your health worse than being overweight. I've seen studies arguing underweight is more dangerous than overweight (just that overweight is more endemic in our countries). Looking at your diary, it appears to be more of a lack of appetite from the quantities. Any possibility of hormone issues? I'll take some flak on this but you need to eat more (portions) and perhaps include some *relatively* "crappier foods" (if there aren't other issues). Crazy advice on MFP, I know.
50 grams of steak? Make it a 112-225 gram (4-8 ounce) steak serving. Mashed potatoes instead of green beans. Swap out your breakfast with a hot breakfast or a common kid's cereal. Pasta such as spaghetti with a meat sauce or a bowl of rice (hell, even fried rice if possible). Fat, protein, carbs - they are not bad things you need them. I would almost ignore sugars as you will get those without trying.
Those numbers are just targets and it's okay to go over/under within reason as long as your calories are near the goal at the end of the day. Can you still diet with health issues? I'm sure you can but I don't have all the facts, either.
I would still regard a doctor/nutritionist to be your best bet and worthy of the $$$. Best wishes.0 -
Would it be a lot more helpful if I wrote down all the things I can eat?
Also, am I damaging my weight loss goal because I am not eating more than 1,200 calories? Can I still lose weight if I eat less? I'm not saying I want to eat less, I am just curious.
The problems with eating less than your BMR (basal metabolic rate .... calories your body would use while sleeping) .....
"Weight loss" is both fat AND muscle .... your body is simply not getting all the nutrients it needs to maintain muscle..... too low in protein makes this more likely
Weight loss will stall & ptateau. I've done the low calorie dieting before. Plateaus really drove me crazy.
Lethargy ..... if you want to workout ..... not eating enough just saps all your energy0 -
My BMR is 1616 and my TDEE is about 2,500. I guess this means I should eat around 1,800 to 2,000 calories a day? Haha this may be hard. I can't have any gluten like wheat and oats; no sugar; no rice; no chicken; no MSG or preservatives (so nothing processed), and various fruits and vegetables.
I am about 15 pounds away from my goal. I know I will have a much harder time now because I am close to my ideal weight. Is there anything I need to do differently because I am so close? Also, I have been eating a lot of carbs in my diet. Will that stunt my weight loss, or does it even matter? And will eating red meat like steak all the time be bad for my health and also hurt me in my weight loss?0 -
Quinoa. High in calories, protein and gluten free.0
-
I received some test results recently and it turns out I am intolerant to many different kinds of foods. I can't eat those foods I am intolerant to for at least 3 months. I can't eat gluton, sugar, rice, corn, and several different kinds of fruits and vegetables. I have been off those foods for almost a week and have been trying to eat a lot, but I consistently am getting below 1,000 calories.
My question would be where did you go for your tests?
The `results` seem pretty much OTT.
What were your tests for?0 -
I saw no chicken, so eat beef and pork (BACON!)
I am also gluten free because of allergies, which I just found out I had last week. I am still able to hit my calories, but I know you are more restricted than I am at the moment.
Since your doctor recommended this (and also because I was recently diagnosed with food allergies), my insurance was required to book me an appointment with a dietitian. You could always ask your doctor if you could meet with one, and they could assess your allergies and give you some foods that you could have.
also, google search! It's amazing how I find stuff that is gluten free just by google searching, maybe you could type all your things in and see if you can find a website or a support center of same people with the same allergies you have. I'm sure you're not alone!0 -
Since your doctor recommended this (and also because I was recently diagnosed with food allergies), my insurance was required to book me an appointment with a dietitian. You could always ask your doctor if you could meet with one, and they could assess your allergies and give you some foods that you could have.
There is no mention of a doctor in the OP`s topic0 -
Sometimes people want to offer advice, they do not see the bigger picture.
This young girl has an eating disorder as do a lot of people on MFP.
Try to see the signs :frown:0 -
No, the 5 week prediction is not true.0
-
I have a gluten allergy and also stay away from carbs as I was such as rice (except for rice cakes), potatoes, corn, bread, pasta, even high sugar fruits and vegetables as I was also borderline diabetic. I stayed on a 1200 cal diet for 2 years under my doctor's guidance to lose my weight. I went through a nutritionist because it is difficult to maintain proper nutrition on less than 1200 calories and I don't use vitamins as I am also intolerant to vitamin C and B, ( I used to work in a vitamin plant and I somehow built an intolerance).My insurance paid for the nutritionist as I needed to lose weight and do it safely. You can check out my diary.0
-
wow NO I do not have an eating disorder!! I have only been on this diet for like less than a week and since I've never been on any kind of diet like this and since I've NEVER eaten not enough calories, I just didn't know what to expect.
I've been sick for over 4 years with some "mystery" disease. I had to be on IV treatments when I was 16 because I was extremely sick. I have pains all over my body and constant migraines. Sometimes I can't get out of bed because the pain is so severe. I also get severe sinus infections about every other week. I went to many specialists and the most they could tell me was that I have fibromyalgia or Lyme's disease. They basically told me: "Well, that's too bad. Sorry, there's nothing we can do for you". It's been tough because I did every kind of sport growing up and I played in high school too, but this sickness has just changed everything for me.
I went to a new doctor about a month ago and he had me do a blood test to just check and see if I had some of the more common food intolerances and the results came back that I did have a lot of intolerances. He told me my sickness could be caused by these intolerances and that I should try going off them to see how I feel.
I really am not trying to eat less. I am trying to adapt to this new kind of diet and I'm realizing sometimes I may not get enough because it's just hard to change my lifestyle. I do want to try to see if going off my supposed intolerances will actually make me feel better than I have in years. I'm just trying to do what I can to help myself.
I want to repeat that I do NOT have a food disorder.0 -
Try adding in some higher calorie options. I know dairy and nuts are often on the allergy list, but full fat dairy and nut butters are good options. Cook with oil. Try adding in some lean protein if you can. Avocados, full fat salad dressings, chocolate, lentils, oatmeal, granola, eggs, dried fruit, butter, mayo, brown rice, quinoa, etc. All sorts of stuff that you could add into your diet. Not sure what you can eat, but hopefully some of these you can add to what you're eating.0
-
Would it be a lot more helpful if I wrote down all the things I can eat?
Also, am I damaging my weight loss goal because I am not eating more than 1,200 calories? Can I still lose weight if I eat less? I'm not saying I want to eat less, I am just curious.
what food intolerance do you have? fructose/fructans? something specific?
most food intolerances are carb related. You should be able to get more than adequate calories from adding in proteins and fats and allowable carbs.
I can empathise as I have fructose/fructan malabsorption and also can't have sugar polyols. It took me ages to adjust because I was vegetarian at the time. No more
There is no reason why you cannot be eating however many kcals you need during each day.
Focus on the foods you CAN eat, not the foods you can't.0 -
I have multiple food allergies as well - mainly gluten, dairy (casein), and bananas. My diet is limited but by concentrating on using things like quinoa, fish, sprouted corn/ rice, as well as any veggie I can get my hands on with hummus, I can easily meet my 1200 calorie goal. Its a matter, FOR ME, of increasing portion sizes of the things I CAN eat, also, gluten free substitutes (such as hamburger buns and English muffins) are higher calorie than the typical versions. I can't have dairy, but I use coconut oil, olive oil and avocados to get my fats in. Pistachios and other nuts, if you can eat them, make a nice snack with what ever piece of fruit you CAN have. I had to work with a nutritionist for a month to get things straight. I would highly recommend it.
It also took a while for them to find my allergies were the cause of my issues. I full well understand your frustrations in this. I can tell you, again FOR ME, after a couple weeks, I felt SO much better (though not totally) and my migraines subsided for the most part. I hope you gain as much relief from your restrictions - it makes it worth the extra effort.0 -
My BMR is 1616 and my TDEE is about 2,500. I guess this means I should eat around 1,800 to 2,000 calories a day? Haha this may be hard. I can't have any gluten like wheat and oats; no sugar; no rice; no chicken; no MSG or preservatives (so nothing processed), and various fruits and vegetables.
I am about 15 pounds away from my goal. I know I will have a much harder time now because I am close to my ideal weight. Is there anything I need to do differently because I am so close? Also, I have been eating a lot of carbs in my diet. Will that stunt my weight loss, or does it even matter? And will eating red meat like steak all the time be bad for my health and also hurt me in my weight loss?
First, I'm sorry to hear about your condition. I hope things change for the better. I'll help any way I can.
BMR/TDEE
Correct, you should target 1,800-2,000. A little over or under isn't an issue as these are all based on some level of estimation. Stay above BMR but below TDEE to continue to lose weight. As you can now tell with your own homework, the 1,200 calorie figure isn't applicable to your situation.
It is unlikely that you will need to do anything different as you get closer to your target weight. It tends to get harder the more weight you lose, however. As your weight drops so will your TDEE/BMR figures (weight is part of the computations). Your TDEE will also change if your activity level changes (more/less exercise and other strenuous activities).
WEIGHT LOSS
Carbs will *not* stunt your weight loss. In the simplest terms, weight loss is almost entirely due to eating less calories than your TDEE.
Net calories < TDEE = Weight Loss
Seriously, it can be made that simple. It can also be made incredibly complex depending on how much you want to micro-manage or if you have more extreme goals (like getting "ripped"). But the complexity is mostly for health, not weight reasons.
Since your dilemma involves insufficient calories I suggest you find an efficient way to get there (calorie goal). Obviously, that goes with consideration of your food restrictions. It doesn't matter if you get to your calorie goal via carbs, protein, or fat (aka Macro-nutrients) for the very short-term. Once you've found a reasonable way to get to your calorie goal (at least above BMR) , then worry about managing and balancing your macro-nutrients.
HEALTH
In other words, don't let yourself starve because that's what falling below the BMR is doing. Once you've got a grip on keeping yourself fed (calories) then start to make yourself healthy (nutrients). You will need carbs, fat, and protein in proper amounts to stay healthy. Later, manage micro-nutrients (Google).
FOOD
Make a trip to your organic/health food section. Maybe make a field trip to a Whole Foods type grocery. As you can tell, a lot of people can relate to your food restrictions (although, not necessarily the condition).
Gluten-free products are very common as this isn't an entirely uncommon issue (see Celiac disease). Check the health food isle of your grocery store. You already found Bob's Red Mill Gluten-free Oats. You can also try Gluten-Free Rice Krispies. Google "gluten-free diet" for a lot of great resources.
Note that unprocessed rice is normally gluten-free.
Sugar. Depends on the specific allergy/issue. Sucrose? Fructose? Glucose? Sugar substitutes not based on sugar such as nutra-sweet or sweet-n-low may work if sucrose is an issue. I would be wary about Splenda/sucralose since it's actually based on real sugar if that's the case. Stevia is a maybe/maybe not and may be a concern if fructose is a problem.
MSG and preservatives. Health food shopping either in a whole food type grocery or careful shopping in a regular grocery.
Seek out items with higher calories for now to get to your calorie goal. Steak has fat and protein. Cereal has carbs, fiber, and many other nutrients. It can be done. Input questions you have into Google such as "What can I eat that is Gluten free?".
Hopefully, this gives you a starting point. Good luck.0 -
Thank you all so much! I really really appreciate it. I've just felt lost trying out a totally new diet! I have noticed some issues finding gluten-free things because most gluten-free things have rice! And I can't have rice! haha so frustrating......
I guess for the time being I will try to just eat a ton of food to try to get my calories up haha!0 -
I wonder if it's possible to just eliminate like half of the foods I'm intolerant to for 3 months and then eliminate the other half? Do any of you know anything about this kind of thing?0
-
Try making a list of each group of foods you can eat ie protein, veggies, fruits, carbs, dairy, fats. From that you should be able to start making meals by looking up recipes. Allrecipes.com has a search feature by ingredients. You can always substitute ingredients that are on your do not eat list.
Also, I would follow your doctors orders and cut all those things out. It'll be easier later if he wants you to try and incorporate one new food in at a time.0 -
I wonder if it's possible to just eliminate like half of the foods I'm intolerant to for 3 months and then eliminate the other half? Do any of you know anything about this kind of thing?
You're in uncharted territory for yourself. You know how you're feeling better than anyone else. Considering these items appear to be intolerances, rather than allergies, I don't see any reason you can't feel your way through it.
Not all intolerances are equal and the best method may very well be some trial and error. You may be able to cope with some intolerances. Eliminating the items that appear to give you the most trouble as a priority seems reasonable.
You've made it this far, after all.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions