Does Driving Actually Burn Calories?

2

Replies

  • ForumLurker
    ForumLurker Posts: 36
    I've seen people log some weird stuff, like "Cooking or food preparation."

    I'm guilty of logging cleaning as exercise. :smokin:
  • favhrnstr
    favhrnstr Posts: 55
    Could it be driving, as in the driving range? Golf?

    They have "Golf, using power cart" in the database. Maybe I don't understand golf, but it doesn't seem like there's a lot of work involved in driving a cart.

    This is to distinguish it from using a push-cart for your clubs or carrying your clubs (where you average 6-7 miles in 18 holes). Even if you use a golf cart, there's still swinging the club and a fair bit of walking.

    Thanks for the explanation. :smile:

    My pleasure! I log golf if I use a cart. I do NOT log the 30-min drive to the club! Ridiculous. The only reason to do this is if you are calculating every calorie you burn in a day rather than estimating it?
  • CallMeCupcakeDammit
    CallMeCupcakeDammit Posts: 9,377 Member
    Could it be driving, as in the driving range? Golf?

    They have "Golf, using power cart" in the database. Maybe I don't understand golf, but it doesn't seem like there's a lot of work involved in driving a cart.

    This is to distinguish it from using a push-cart for your clubs or carrying your clubs (where you average 6-7 miles in 18 holes). Even if you use a golf cart, there's still swinging the club and a fair bit of walking.

    Thanks for the explanation. :smile:

    My pleasure! I log golf if I use a cart. I do NOT log the 30-min drive to the club! Ridiculous. The only reason to do this is if you are calculating every calorie you burn in a day rather than estimating it?

    I really don't know, you mean like FitBit people do? I've only ever logged intentional exercise, but I drive a stick, maybe I should log driving! :bigsmile: I had no idea a golf course was that big. That explains why I felt like I was going to die, when I had to walk from one end to the other the day I volunteered at a tournament!
  • staps065
    staps065 Posts: 837 Member
    Now calm down! I'm not going to log my 7 hours of driving in lieu of an actual workout but isn't this interesting?

    Calories Burned Driving a Car

    Driving requires energy. Moving the wheel, using your feet to operate the pedals and turning your head all require calories to power the body. According to CalorieLab.com, on average, a person weighing 150 lbs. will burn about 68 calories an hour driving. A person who weighs 120 lbs. will burn about only 55 calories an hour driving, while a person weighing 220 lbs. will burn about 100.

    Variables

    Calories burned per hour goes up with certain types of cars and certain types of driving. A 150-lb. person driving a bus, heavy truck or tractor burns about 136 calories an hour, and that same person driving a race car burns about 340 calories an hour. Driving a truck, including loading and unloading, will burn about 374 calories an hour, about the same amount in a Whopper Jr. from Burger King.

    Weight Loss and Driving

    Unfortunately, truck driving does not lend itself to weight loss. While the number of calories required to drive a truck is higher than those required to drive a car, a study by the Centers for Disease Control shows that 73 percent of truck drivers are overweight and more than 50 percent are obese. This could be because driving long distances can be boring and eating breaks up the monotony. For instance, a Pew Research poll showed that 41 percent of car drivers had eaten a meal while driving in the last year.

    Read more: http://www.ehow.com/about_5452973_calories-burned-driving.html#ixzz2ZRy1l8Uo
  • dancinmama
    dancinmama Posts: 47 Member
    I wear a BodyMedia Fit monitor....you burn calories 24 hrs a day, even when sleeping. that said, I have noticed an extra calorie burn when driving..not a lot though.
  • PinkNinjaLaura
    PinkNinjaLaura Posts: 3,202 Member
    I don't log my driving as an activity, but I will say after a tough leg workout I may say a few bad words to my clutch at the stoplights.
  • __Di__
    __Di__ Posts: 1,658 Member
    I've seen where people have added calories burned from driving and it is even in the Cardiovascular Exercise database. Do you really burn calories driving? I have a long day trip tomorrow (about 7 hours to destination) and wonder if I'll actually burn while driving. Opinions? Fact? Fiction?

    Thanks!

    The only calories you would burn whilst driving would be the calories you would have burned anyway just sitting on the couch.

    I fail to see how anybody could seriously log this as exercise with calories burned next to their entry, what exactly is it in driving that would burn any calories I wonder?
  • A_Fit_Mom
    A_Fit_Mom Posts: 602 Member
    Definitely not something I would log. I don't log anything except actual exercise. So I don't log cleaning, cooking, walking while shopping.... Etc. For me, that is all extra and is a bonus.
  • poohpoohpeapod
    poohpoohpeapod Posts: 776 Member
    we burn calories by breathing, should it count toward activity hell no!
  • jillybean0123
    jillybean0123 Posts: 238 Member
    I actually do track driving but not for the extra bump in calories. I wear a FitBit all the time and if I don't track it, it counts the bumps in the road (and you feel all of them in an ambulance and Oklahoma roads are terrible) as steps. I only want it to track the steps I actually take so I have to log my driving time.
  • 3foldchord
    3foldchord Posts: 2,918 Member
    Well, yes, because you burn calories every minute of every day. EVERYTHING burns calories.

    I suspect that driving doesn't burn many more calories than sitting down, however, especially if you drive an automatic, so I wouldn't be inclined to log it.
    ditto
  • Blesmols
    Blesmols Posts: 35 Member
    I'm a former professional truck driver. I lost fifty pounds of the 160 I lost during my trucking career. I can't swear it was the driving, though. I kept a stepper in front of my bunk and used it for an hour a day. LOL I will say that being in the air ride seat will jostle a body all over, and I think stress factors into the loss, too. It depends some on if you manage not to snack while driving. :) There was, however, a point where I was driving a flatbed and chaining that big boy up burnt TONS of calories. While I was doing that, I quit doing any outside exercise activity and could eat an entire yellow sheet cake over the weekend without gaining weight. I was hauling cable reels to and scrap from a dedicated account, so in fourteen hours I might chain/unchain the whole flatbed eight or so times a shift. Add to it much snow and very cold temperatures for part of the year, and it burned calories like a mad thing to do it!
  • TheBaileyHunter
    TheBaileyHunter Posts: 641 Member
    I wonder about this sometimes as my heart rate goes up every time I'm trapped behind some asshat that is going less than the speed of traffic in the fast lane with their left blinker on (and no where to turn left to) while talking on their cell phone...so basically every weekday, twice a day, for an hour each way..

    So I guess it's not driving I'm wondering about the calorie burn but the stress of it. :-)
  • Melissa11412
    Melissa11412 Posts: 145 Member
    Lol'd @thread title, just had to come in and see what's going on. I would assume driving does burn calories, but I wouldn't depend on it or count it.
  • Pamela_in_Progress
    Pamela_in_Progress Posts: 197 Member
    Could it be driving, as in the driving range? Golf?

    They have "Golf, using power cart" in the database. Maybe I don't understand golf, but it doesn't seem like there's a lot of work involved in driving a cart.

    This is to distinguish it from using a push-cart for your clubs or carrying your clubs (where you average 6-7 miles in 18 holes). Even if you use a golf cart, there's still swinging the club and a fair bit of walking.

    Thanks for the explanation. :smile:

    My pleasure! I log golf if I use a cart. I do NOT log the 30-min drive to the club! Ridiculous. The only reason to do this is if you are calculating every calorie you burn in a day rather than estimating it?

    I really don't know, you mean like FitBit people do? I've only ever logged intentional exercise, but I drive a stick, maybe I should log driving! :bigsmile: I had no idea a golf course was that big. That explains why I felt like I was going to die, when I had to walk from one end to the other the day I volunteered at a tournament!

    I was referring to driving the "golf ball" with a club at the driving range... no motorized vehicle involved. lol Which I still wouldn't think would burn a lot of calories unless were doing it for an extended period of time... but then again... I'm not a golfer.
  • favhrnstr
    favhrnstr Posts: 55
    Could it be driving, as in the driving range? Golf?

    They have "Golf, using power cart" in the database. Maybe I don't understand golf, but it doesn't seem like there's a lot of work involved in driving a cart.

    This is to distinguish it from using a push-cart for your clubs or carrying your clubs (where you average 6-7 miles in 18 holes). Even if you use a golf cart, there's still swinging the club and a fair bit of walking.

    Thanks for the explanation. :smile:

    My pleasure! I log golf if I use a cart. I do NOT log the 30-min drive to the club! Ridiculous. The only reason to do this is if you are calculating every calorie you burn in a day rather than estimating it?

    I really don't know, you mean like FitBit people do? I've only ever logged intentional exercise, but I drive a stick, maybe I should log driving! :bigsmile: I had no idea a golf course was that big. That explains why I felt like I was going to die, when I had to walk from one end to the other the day I volunteered at a tournament!

    I was referring to driving the "golf ball" with a club at the driving range... no motorized vehicle involved. lol Which I still wouldn't think would burn a lot of calories unless were doing it for an extended period of time... but then again... I'm not a golfer.

    You'd be surprised. It's not like running, of course, but an hour on the driving range is like a low-impact anaerobic workout. You can definitely feel it the next day if you're not used to it. (And MFP has a separate "driving range" entry.)
  • maca416
    maca416 Posts: 142 Member
    If you didn't burn calories while driving you would have just crashed & died, if you burn cal's sleeping you burn them driving but exercise it's not :)
  • Melissa22G
    Melissa22G Posts: 847 Member
    :huh:
  • peeaanuut
    peeaanuut Posts: 359 Member
    Could it be driving, as in the driving range? Golf?

    They have "Golf, using power cart" in the database. Maybe I don't understand golf, but it doesn't seem like there's a lot of work involved in driving a cart.

    This is to distinguish it from using a push-cart for your clubs or carrying your clubs (where you average 6-7 miles in 18 holes). Even if you use a golf cart, there's still swinging the club and a fair bit of walking.

    Thanks for the explanation. :smile:

    My pleasure! I log golf if I use a cart. I do NOT log the 30-min drive to the club! Ridiculous. The only reason to do this is if you are calculating every calorie you burn in a day rather than estimating it?

    I really don't know, you mean like FitBit people do? I've only ever logged intentional exercise, but I drive a stick, maybe I should log driving! :bigsmile: I had no idea a golf course was that big. That explains why I felt like I was going to die, when I had to walk from one end to the other the day I volunteered at a tournament!

    on the fitbit, generally there are 3 ways to remove steps that were counted while driving. 1 is to have it charging while driving, 2 is to use the android app if you have an andorid and 3 is to log a driving time. What this does is shows the burn it calculates before exercise as your regular activity level you set. So if you set your fitbit ot sedentary and you would burn 10 calories for 10 minutes (obviously a made up number) but thats what it will log. It isnt taking or adding any calories towards the end result. The reason its logged is that during that time it will remove any stairs, distance and steps calculated.

    For example. From 6-6:30 if I sat like a bump on a log with a sedentary setting, the fitbit would calculate X amount of calories burned as regular activity. now if I drove during that time and wore it, it would log steps, stairs, distance based on the steps and extra calories it calculates by doing those activities. So you log 6-630 as light driving and it removes everything but the basic X calories as if you were a bump on a log.

    My solution, I just keep the dongle in the car. never have to charge it at home as long as I charge it while in the car. It doesnt do any logging when charging and the website assumes bump on a log calories and not added activity.
  • _Waffle_
    _Waffle_ Posts: 13,049 Member
    I'm alive. How many calories does that burn?
  • peeaanuut
    peeaanuut Posts: 359 Member
    also, i do log driving as an additional activity when I am at the track on the weekends. 20 minute sessions, 40-50 gear changes on a 6 puck sprung clutch every lap in 100 degree weather is certainly a workout, especially without power steering. Of course I counter that workout with beer and nachos after each session. lol
  • belinus
    belinus Posts: 112 Member
    It could be something coming in from a device like FitBit. That is one of the reasons I ended up returning the device because it was overly sensitive to such things.
  • Blesmols
    Blesmols Posts: 35 Member
    Well, I do think stress contributes to weight loss. However, if it was an absolute contributor, after the hundreds of thousands of miles I drove in 5 years, I'd have been a toothpick. LOL
  • jdabyers
    jdabyers Posts: 1
    This makes sense, I have noticed a spike in my burned calories when I drive 70 -80 mph through traffic; safely of course. My body media registers it as moderate activity almost equivilent to walking up flights of stairs.
  • Francl27
    Francl27 Posts: 26,371 Member
    This makes sense, I have noticed a spike in my burned calories when I drive 70 -80 mph through traffic; safely of course. My body media registers it as moderate activity almost equivilent to walking up flights of stairs.

    Or maybe it's just from the movement of the car affecting your bodymedia.

    I had a friend on MFP adding a 300 calorie burn for driving 90 minutes, and she swore she lost more weight on days she drove a lot, I about died laughing.
  • lauraashley09
    lauraashley09 Posts: 182 Member
    Seriously....? How overboard do some people go with this?
  • janine2355
    janine2355 Posts: 628 Member
    I've seen where people have added calories burned from driving and it is even in the Cardiovascular Exercise database. Do you really burn calories driving? I have a long day trip tomorrow (about 7 hours to destination) and wonder if I'll actually burn while driving. Opinions? Fact? Fiction?

    Thanks!
    That sounds like hogwash. If that were true, I shoud be 100lbs, with all the driving I do! lol!
  • Sreneesa
    Sreneesa Posts: 1,170 Member
    Wow, really?

    I'm totally adding my calorie burn from breathing!

    LMAO!!!

    Okay. I'm going to add my calorie burn from typing this response on OP's post! :laugh:
  • heybales
    heybales Posts: 18,842 Member
    That's not in the database - someone added it themselves because I'd suggest they don't understand the concept of how MFP works, and must think you have to add in all your daily life.

    Check out their logs - do they have sleeping, watching TV, sitting at desk, ect also?
  • ittybittybadonkadonk
    ittybittybadonkadonk Posts: 11,634 Member
    yesterday was a perfect example of this for me ....I have a fitbit ....I was on the road from 4:30am to about 3:00pm and my fitbit gave me exercise calories of 200 and something .....so I disconnected my fitbit from Mfp ...since I do tdee-20% method and exercise is included in this method
This discussion has been closed.

Categories