Open diary, question
SisterhoodoftheShrinkingPants
Posts: 474 Member
Okay, so Im really picky about which types of carbs I eat, its from a food plan I did YEARS AGO which helped me to lose over 80 lbs in 8 months. II loved the results so I've incorporated it into how I eat now (mostly). I basically avoid white flour completely. I eat carbs like rye bread, corn tortillas, etc. On occasion I eat white bread but generally I avoid it and I keep my carb cals to around 100 cals per meal.. Now here's the thing. Most days I am on point with my macros (and over too) on everything EXCEPT carbs. And I am looking for ideas to boost my carb intake without changing my eating too terribly much. I really like how I eat. The problem is that I recently read that if you dont get enough carbs in your diet you can have side effects such as losing your hair. And I have been losing hair since I started MFP. Ive ruled out thyroid and some other factors, and the only thing thats really STANDING out in my diary is that I dont eat enough carbs. Should I start having less open faced sandwiches and opt for two slices of bread? Or is there a supplement I could take? I dont know what Im doing wrong to have such a low carb count. I eat carbs. Any tips?
0
Replies
-
bump for help0
-
0 -
Your diary does not seem to be open.0
-
Carbs are not the enemy.
But if you're happy with how you eat...why change it?
What are you trying to ask? I'm confused.0 -
I don't get what you are asking.
If you need to increase your carbs, increase them, if you usually eat 1 slice of bread, eat 2, if you eat brown rice, eat a little more...0 -
let me open my diary, thought it was..as for the other comments, it makes sense to just eat more carbs but then my other macros go up too, and those are always over already. Idk maybe it is confusing and Im so tired I dont even get it now lol. I guess I dont understand why my carbs are so low? I thought veggies were carbs too.0
-
Your carbs don't look *that* low to me...I have more carbs left over than you do at the end of the day (I checked over the past week) and I am not actively trying to reduce carbs. I would check in with your doc to see what's going on.0
-
I don't understand. You eat over 100 carbs per meal from what I have read, Even if not, from what I have seen your carbs are well over enough to keep you out of ketosis.
Carbs are 4 calories a gram. Things like oatmeal, rice, etc have carbs with very little from the other macros. If anything, carbs are the easiest to get. If you find your macros are off, you may need to focus on getting in your other macros once you up your carbs.0 -
i don't know about you but i go though phases where i lost alot of hair because of the seasons so if it more then that type of seasonal lose might be best to check with your doctor.0
-
You're carb count doesn't look all that low to me. Have you considered other possible causes for hair loss, such as vitamin and mineral deficiencies?0
-
Fruit and veggies are carbs, too, however, there's not as much carbs in them as something starchier like a couple slices of bread, that being why your carb value isn't being reached, most likely. I do suggest trying to have more carbs, and that I know of there's no supplement for that; you'll just need to reach that macro by eating actual food. Do what you usually do avoiding white breads etc. but just have more of the things you do eat that have carbs, like tortillas and anything else you normally eat. Foods like bread do have small amounts of protein in them, so if you reach your carb goal but then are -10 in protein, it's really not that big of a deal. MFP's setting for protein has always been a bit low anyway. Long story short, aim to get closer to that carb goal eating the carbs you like to eat. If in the meantime your other macros are exceeded just a bit, it shouldn't hurt you that much. Eventually you'll figure out how to get the carbs into your meal plan with exceeding the other macros.
0 -
You may want to consult a doctor about the hair loss, if it is extreme. It could represent a serious health problem. DH and I are using less carbs than usual, but haven't cut them out. We're not having symptoms like yours. We have gone on no carb diets for long periods of time in the past without hair loss. Good luck.0
-
crap, Ive been looking and looking for causes. Its really disturbing, could just be my age (35). I see my doc aug 5th. I looked up hair loss in forums and someone suggested low carb and I noticed thats the one macro Im usually under on. I would say my diet is low carb. (100 cals per meal) But maybe thats not it. Thanks.0
-
I agree with these posts.... your carb count is not too low in my humble opinion. And you are right, mostly from good sources! If I were to critique anything in your diary it would be your coffeemate creamer! chemicals and empty calories! But your question had to do with the tie in to hair loss and carbs which I doubt is the source. Yep, check with doctor! 0
-
Fruit and veggies are carbs, too, however, there's not as much carbs in them as something starchier like a couple slices of bread, that being why your carb value isn't being reached, most likely. I do suggest trying to have more carbs, and that I know of there's no supplement for that; you'll just need to reach that macro by eating actual food. Do what you usually do avoiding white breads etc. but just have more of the things you do eat that have carbs, like tortillas and anything else you normally eat. Foods like bread do have small amounts of protein in them, so if you reach your carb goal but then are -10 in protein, it's really not that big of a deal. MFP's setting for protein has always been a bit low anyway. Long story short, aim to get closer to that carb goal eating the carbs you like to eat. If in the meantime your other macros are exceeded just a bit, it shouldn't hurt you that much. Eventually you'll figure out how to get the carbs into your meal plan with exceeding the other macros.
Thank you 0 -
crap, Ive been looking and looking for causes. Its really disturbing, could just be my age (35). I see my doc aug 5th. I looked up hair loss in forums and someone suggested low carb and I noticed thats the one macro Im usually under on. I would say my diet is low carb. (100 cals per meal) But maybe thats not it. Thanks.
Low carb is below 100 grams of carbs per day. From what I've seen, you are over that.0 -
You may want to consult a doctor about the hair loss, if it is extreme. It could represent a serious health problem. DH and I are using less carbs than usual, but haven't cut them out. We're not having symptoms like yours. We have gone on no carb diets for long periods of time in the past without hair loss. Good luck.
Ok. Its weird, because I noticed its a side effect for many who have gastric bypass surg, which I havent had. The solution for those people was to increase fat and protein. I have NO Problem there lol. I am giving my body what it needs to make hair, its just...not there. I will try upping my carbs and see if this works. If my choices are obese or bald, I guess Im going wig shopping 0 -
I agree with these posts.... your carb count is not too low in my humble opinion. And you are right, mostly from good sources! If I were to critique anything in your diary it would be your coffeemate creamer! chemicals and empty calories! But your question had to do with the tie in to hair loss and carbs which I doubt is the source. Yep, check with doctor!
ha ha you spotted my major weakness :P0 -
crap, Ive been looking and looking for causes. Its really disturbing, could just be my age (35). I see my doc aug 5th. I looked up hair loss in forums and someone suggested low carb and I noticed thats the one macro Im usually under on. I would say my diet is low carb. (100 cals per meal) But maybe thats not it. Thanks.
Low carb is below 100 grams of carbs per day. From what I've seen, you are over that.
Ok you're stating whats healthy right? MFP is saying to eat 335 carb and Im at 150. so thats half of what MFP is telling me to eat. Thats from yesterday. Thats my real question I guess, why is MFP saying to eat 335? is it a problem Im at half? is that why im losing hair? you see my question? 0 -
crap, Ive been looking and looking for causes. Its really disturbing, could just be my age (35). I see my doc aug 5th. I looked up hair loss in forums and someone suggested low carb and I noticed thats the one macro Im usually under on. I would say my diet is low carb. (100 cals per meal) But maybe thats not it. Thanks.
Low carb is below 100 grams of carbs per day. From what I've seen, you are over that.
Ok you're stating whats healthy right? MFP is saying to eat 335 carb and Im at 150. so thats half of what MFP is telling me to eat. Thats from yesterday. Thats my real question I guess, why is MFP saying to eat 335? is it a problem Im at half? is that why im losing hair? you see my question?
MFP tends to be low on protein and high on carbs. I've personally changed my protein goals to almost twice what MFP recommends and same fat, which would put carbs at around the same as what you get0 -
crap, Ive been looking and looking for causes. Its really disturbing, could just be my age (35). I see my doc aug 5th. I looked up hair loss in forums and someone suggested low carb and I noticed thats the one macro Im usually under on. I would say my diet is low carb. (100 cals per meal) But maybe thats not it. Thanks.
Low carb is below 100 grams of carbs per day. From what I've seen, you are over that.
Ok you're stating whats healthy right? MFP is saying to eat 335 carb and Im at 150. so thats half of what MFP is telling me to eat. Thats from yesterday. Thats my real question I guess, why is MFP saying to eat 335? is it a problem Im at half? is that why im losing hair? you see my question?
MFP tends to be low on protein and high on carbs. I've personally changed my protein goals to almost twice what MFP recommends and same fat, which would put carbs at around the same as what you get
Ok. I see. Well, I think Im going to have to see a nutritionist soon. Its all a little confusing to me still. I have definitely lost weight eating like I am, but Ive lost A LOT of hair too I'll update after I see my doctor, I think she said if I was still losing she'd send me to a dermatologist. 0 -
Your diet definitely wouldn't be considered low carb. Low carb is considered to be at most 100g PER DAY, not per meal. Most people that say they do low carb eat less than half of that so I don't think your hair loss can be attributed to a low carb diet.0
-
Your diet definitely wouldn't be considered low carb. Low carb is considered to be at most 100g PER DAY, not per meal. Most people that say they do low carb eat less than half of that so I don't think your hair loss can be attributed to a low carb diet.
why do you guys keep saying 100 GRAMS per meal? is one slice of bread at 70-100 cals Grams? you guys are confusing me.0 -
I never said I ate 100 grams per meal and my diary doesnt reflect that. I mentioned I keep my carbs to 100 CALORIES per meal. Not the same thing calories/grams correct or no? Id like to understand/0
-
Low carb is less than 50gr PER day of carbs...
That means that most of the carb intake come from fruits and veggies as every piece of bread has around 10 gr of carbs.. For example, yesterday, your carb intake was 186 gr per day.. which is more than three of the recommended carb intake to reach ketosis.
That-s what they're talking about,0 -
I dont want to eat less than i already am. i think i may not be getting enough as it is. thanks though everyone!0
-
If it makes you feel better.... I'm losing a lot of hair right now too.. but mostly I give it to the seasonal changes... A couple of months ago I didn't lose hair at all and now I'm like a cat..
So it might be that.0 -
Jelly :bigsmile:
I know it sounds weird, but for a glossy coat and healthy nails, get some gelatin into your diet now and then.
If your nose goes moist though, then it's too much :drinker:0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions