Size 12 to Size 0 (with ridiculous photos)

1235

Replies

  • smantha32
    smantha32 Posts: 6,990 Member
    I don't think you look fat in any of those pictures. :flowerforyou:
  • JenniBaby85
    JenniBaby85 Posts: 855 Member
    I love your outfits! *Just thought I'd put that out there* congrats on your success!
  • IpuffyheartHeelsinthegym
    IpuffyheartHeelsinthegym Posts: 5,573 Member
    as far as Success threads go, this is by far the worst case of responses I think I have ever seen. I am sorry that people choose to be ridiculous, OP. That said, I do love your attitude. Keep shining.
  • radcliff17
    radcliff17 Posts: 22 Member
    I think a size 12 is anything but fat. It's healthy. A size 0 is not. Congrats on the weight loss, but I really don't think you needed to lose that much. You look a bit anorexic now.

    :noway:

    say what? really? people are different sizes, I used to be a size 12 too and now I'm a size 2 or 4, but my body fat comp is still 24% so yeah, I still need to lose weight. Don't project on other people. I currently weight 131, I'm 5'1" and at 133 my BMI is considered overweight. I get it is just your opinion, but this is a success thread. OP did a great job and is happy with her results, who are you to knock her down?

    Totally agree!
  • RoadsterGirlie
    RoadsterGirlie Posts: 1,195 Member
    You look amazing. Please, please please don't let anybody else here tell you otherwise.

    Great job!
  • RoadsterGirlie
    RoadsterGirlie Posts: 1,195 Member
    I think a size 12 is anything but fat. It's healthy. A size 0 is not. Congrats on the weight loss, but I really don't think you needed to lose that much. You look a bit anorexic now.

    Thanks for your support! I hope you have a happy, healthy day! :)

    OP, your attitude is as beautiful as you are :) This was a great response to the above poster's completely inappropriate and mean-spirited response.

    Completely agreed. I need to take notes from the OP. I love your attitude - you are beautiful inside and out.
  • lauraleighsm
    lauraleighsm Posts: 167
    You were never fat. I think some of the negative responses came from the amount of food you were eating, but your diary is now closed. Congrats though. You always looked beautiful!
  • chubby_checkers
    chubby_checkers Posts: 2,352 Member
    as far as Success threads go, this is by far the worst case of responses I think I have ever seen. I am sorry that people choose to be ridiculous, OP. That said, I do love your attitude. Keep shining.

    This. OP, congrats on your accomplishments and hard work. And good on you for not letting the bitter, old biddies bring you down. :heart:
  • FauxAngel13
    FauxAngel13 Posts: 156 Member
    OMFG!!!! so amazing! Great job and brilliant effort on your part for staying with it!!! I started at 167lb aiming for 110lb... 125lb so far, so excited for the types of results that are possible!!!
  • FlaxMilk
    FlaxMilk Posts: 3,452 Member
    OP, you are pure class! I love it. I'm a shortcake too and look my best around a 0-4, depending on the brand. I think you look great.
  • RoadsterGirlie
    RoadsterGirlie Posts: 1,195 Member
    You truly are pure class. 100% all the way.

    You are a far better woman than I am at this moment. I am currently being skinny shamed in another thread, and I have not been nearly as nice as you.
  • tjthegreatone
    tjthegreatone Posts: 324
    To be honest I think the concerns are legitimate.

    I had a look through her diary and although most days aren't logged, on the few days that are logged, she is eating 1000-1200 calories. Now it's difficult to get a true idea of what her average calorie intake is like, but unless she had eaten a lot on the other days not logged and wasn't particularly hungry on those days, I don't see why, at goal, she is eating so little.

    For MOST people, that caloric intake is not sustainable long-term. But I accept that we are all different, and do I have friends (who are small and skinny) who eat that little normally.

    OP congrats on your success, and I hope that now you are at goal you'll be eating more in a day, as unless you are completely sedentary you will continue to lose weight.
  • RingTailedFox
    RingTailedFox Posts: 53 Member
    My nutritionist has me at 1250 cals a day. We are slowly adding 50 cals every two weeks. Thanks for your concern!
  • ketoclysmic
    ketoclysmic Posts: 3
    Thanks for sharing...I love inspirational stories.

    May I ask why you are still eating so few calories? I browsed through your diary and it looks like you have a lot of low-calorie days (especially considering the frequency and intensity of your workouts mentioned earlier in this thread). Is there a point where you will begin eating at a maintenance/muscle building level, or do you have more weight to lose? Does your nutritionist have any input as to when you can go back to a maintenance level of caloric intake?

    I ask because we are the same height, and although I don't want to weigh less than 125 lbs., I am curious to know more of your story so I can compare it to my own.

    Thanks,

    K
  • RingTailedFox
    RingTailedFox Posts: 53 Member
    As I stated previously, I put on a couple lbs when I switched birth control. I've only 2 lbs to get back to where I was. With my personal trainer, I am working on reducing my body fat % and gaining muscle. I've been working with my nutritionist since I went vegan and I feel that I'm in good hands.

    Once my personal trainer and I shape this body of mine into a lean, mean muscle machine, I can start my maintenance level (around 1500-1700 cal on a rotating schedule).
  • RingTailedFox
    RingTailedFox Posts: 53 Member
    Thanks for sharing...I love inspirational stories.

    May I ask why you are still eating so few calories? I browsed through your diary and it looks like you have a lot of low-calorie days (especially considering the frequency and intensity of your workouts mentioned earlier in this thread). Is there a point where you will begin eating at a maintenance/muscle building level, or do you have more weight to lose? Does your nutritionist have any input as to when you can go back to a maintenance level of caloric intake?

    I ask because we are the same height, and although I don't want to weigh less than 125 lbs., I am curious to know more of your story so I can compare it to my own.

    Thanks,

    K

    Hey! No fair! You're at the same caloric intake girl!
  • Txracy
    Txracy Posts: 78
    I'm also 5'3 and a size 0. I'm very, very small framed (even compared to other small-framed people). I'm 106 lbs, and my body fat percentage is (very recently) 18%! I eat a bare minimum of 1460 calories per day, on sedentary totally lazy days where I literally only leave my desk to go pee. Most days I'm at 1700-1800, and days I run or lift, there is almost no way I can do less than 2000 calories. In fact, I'm pretty sure I need to increase my calorie intake at this point, because I'm finding myself hungry more often than not (I blame the weights, I'm always starving after a heavy lifting session). 1250 would make me want to curl up and die, LOL! (And hey, beer/alchol is part of my diet too, no shame in that!)

    You look great, and you looked great in ALL in the pictures! Just because you are not what every single person aspires to look like doesn't mean that you shouldn't feel proud of yourself. Some women like a really muscular look, and if people said, "Ew, you look like a man *barf*" that would be beyond rude. We all have different personal preferences about how we wish our bodies looked. And all of those preferences are valid.
  • Txracy
    Txracy Posts: 78
    Just read your latest responses, and I'm also working on gaining muscle! (I swear it's harder for us petite people)
    Your projected "maintenace" calories are about the same as mine (1700ish), LOL (though, I suppose it would be, right?)
  • ketoclysmic
    ketoclysmic Posts: 3
    Thanks for the info...while I'm not qualified to dispute the information from your personal trainer and nutritionist, seems like something doesn't quite jive. It's pretty difficult to lean down or put on muscle when you're eating at a deficit. In my experience, most trainers would want you to eat more calories and not worry about the final two pounds before upping your intake - especially if you are looking to lean out, you're going to gain muscle and your weight will go up anyway. Size matters, not the number on the scale, and all that.

    It's none of my damn business, actually, so never mind. Your story just seems so eerily close to mine. We're the same height, and probably close in age. I've weighed between 115-165, and everything inbetween. I was a vegan for many years, and suffered from anemia and other health problems from poor nutrition. I also struggled with severe body image issues, borderline anorexia, and chronic depression. It has taken me years, and years, and years to overcome these body issues and I still struggle.

    I guess I'm just worried about you, even though I don't know you. But hey, like I said - it's no skin off my nose. Good luck with your goals and be safe.
  • linsey0689
    linsey0689 Posts: 753 Member
    love it! great job :)
  • RingTailedFox
    RingTailedFox Posts: 53 Member
    Thanks for the info...while I'm not qualified to dispute the information from your personal trainer and nutritionist, seems like something doesn't quite jive. It's pretty difficult to lean down or put on muscle when you're eating at a deficit. In my experience, most trainers would want you to eat more calories and not worry about the final two pounds before upping your intake - especially if you are looking to lean out, you're going to gain muscle and your weight will go up anyway. Size matters, not the number on the scale, and all that.

    It's none of my damn business, actually, so never mind. Your story just seems so eerily close to mine. We're the same height, and probably close in age. I've weighed between 115-165, and everything inbetween. I was a vegan for many years, and suffered from anemia and other health problems from poor nutrition. I also struggled with severe body image issues, borderline anorexia, and chronic depression. It has taken me years, and years, and years to overcome these body issues and I still struggle.

    I guess I'm just worried about you, even though I don't know you. But hey, like I said - it's no skin off my nose. Good luck with your goals and be safe.

    Thanks, sweets. I do appreciate it. I'm sorry to hear that you've had such struggles. I watched my mom go through a lot of that, too. I know that while it doesn't go away, it does get better, especially with a good support network.

    Have you tried an iron supplement? I found a really great vegan one that doesn't upset my stomach. If you don't have one, I highly recommend it!
  • tjthegreatone
    tjthegreatone Posts: 324
    Thanks for the info...while I'm not qualified to dispute the information from your personal trainer and nutritionist, seems like something doesn't quite jive. It's pretty difficult to lean down or put on muscle when you're eating at a deficit. In my experience, most trainers would want you to eat more calories and not worry about the final two pounds before upping your intake - especially if you are looking to lean out, you're going to gain muscle and your weight will go up anyway. Size matters, not the number on the scale, and all that.

    It's none of my damn business, actually, so never mind. Your story just seems so eerily close to mine. We're the same height, and probably close in age. I've weighed between 115-165, and everything inbetween. I was a vegan for many years, and suffered from anemia and other health problems from poor nutrition. I also struggled with severe body image issues, borderline anorexia, and chronic depression. It has taken me years, and years, and years to overcome these body issues and I still struggle.

    I guess I'm just worried about you, even though I don't know you. But hey, like I said - it's no skin off my nose. Good luck with your goals and be safe.

    I agree with this. I'm a bit dubious about these professionals you're hanging out with as what they are doing doesn't fit with received wisdom (and documented observations). I don't see how your personal trainer can expect you to build muscle on 1250 a day. You will be leaner if you continue to lose weight and may appear more toned for that reason. But you are female, very slim and vegan (and probably eating very little protein) so the odds for muscle building are not in your favour.

    As for your nutritionist, upping your caloric intake slowly might be sensible so you don't get rebound weight gain but 50 a week is very conservative to say the least. All a bit puzzling.
  • Microfiber
    Microfiber Posts: 956 Member
    I read the entire thread :happy:

    Congratulations on your weight loss :flowerforyou:
  • sparkly86
    sparkly86 Posts: 520 Member
    wow, congrats! you look amazing and super beautiful! ahhh i want to look like that, if only i could close my mouth!
  • knucklesammie
    knucklesammie Posts: 196 Member
    awesome job! i'm inspired! i am 5'3" also and got up to around 140. no one really noticed (except my mom, that sweet woman) so i am sure if i posted dressed progress pics people would react the same. but like you i carried the weight mostly in my face, waist, and also my thighs. you look amazing! and i agree you looked amazing before! i'd love to get down to where you are at! will keep pushing, thanks for the motivation!
  • lauraleighsm
    lauraleighsm Posts: 167
    I went to a nutritionist who maxed me out at 1300 calories too and at the time, I was a vegetarian. I could not follow her diet for even one day! I found my naturopath to have more nutritional advice then a nutritionist. I wanted to learn about alternate sources of proteins and the nutritionist just kept bringing up soy products, which I didn't want to do.

    Anyway, you look great!
  • tjthegreatone
    tjthegreatone Posts: 324
    I feel bad that I came across as judgemental.

    I don't think the OP is too thin/anorexic/anything negative. She looks good and healthy, and more importantly she is a beautiful woman at any weight (no amount of weight loss can buy you that)

    I got curious about the hulabaloo with the diary, had a look and saw what people were concerned about. Now, I don't think anyone is going to have a look at this thread and think 'the only way I'd ever look that good is to eat that little'; and in retrospect she has it all under the care of a nutritionist and personal trainer who she puts faith in, so it wasn't fair of us to judge her on this score when she is following received advice.

    I just wish so many nutritionists/dieticians weren't guilty of putting clients on unnecessarily low-calorie diets. Maybe my view is unorthodox but I see food as not just fuel. There's an emotional and hormone-driven aspect to eating (in my opinion this is good!) and rigorous diet regimes tend to override this.
  • brynnsmom
    brynnsmom Posts: 945 Member
    I think you look awesome!!!
  • stephanj
    stephanj Posts: 898 Member
    My nutritionist has me at 1250 cals a day. We are slowly adding 50 cals every two weeks. Thanks for your concern!

    You rock, and seem like a really fun person! Good job :-)
  • emlott88
    emlott88 Posts: 75 Member
    Congratulations!!! You look awesome, and obviously a lot of hard work and dedication (not to mention self control) went into your progress. I only hope I am even half successful as you are!

    And to people who are ribbing this poor girl for starting her journey at 150. Sorry, but I am 5'2 and was 147lbs when I went to the doctor 3 weeks ago (which started this whole journey) and was told I was overweight and that I had to make big changes in my life. I was borderline hypertension and the doctor specifically told me that it was time to go on a weight loss plan. I have to go back in 3 months with a 10lb weight loss to get back into a healthy range for my height. I'm currently a size 10. A size 10 at 5'2 is not good if your body is used to being a healthy weight (my 'healthy weight' that my body always stabilised at was 135lbs).

Categories

Do you Love MyFitnessPal? Have you crushed a goal or improved your life through better nutrition using MyFitnessPal?
Share your success and inspire others. Leave us a review on Apple Or Google Play stores!