Moving into maintenance but still want to tone up

walkwallfall
walkwallfall Posts: 18 Member
edited November 12 in Goal: Maintaining Weight
Not sure how to title this but I reached my goal weight. I'm 125 at 5'5" which is IMO a good healthy weight. However, I still want to tone up and lose belly flab and such. I am very active and am on my feet most of the day, plus I exercise 5-6 times a week usually vigorously. MFP says to eat 1900+ to maintain but if I want to tone will eating that much make it hard to keep toning up? Or can I tone by simply exercising/weight training?
«1

Replies

  • mep0430
    mep0430 Posts: 37 Member
    I'm getting to the same point and I decided to work with a trainer at Planet Fitness. So far, I've been very happy with it because I need structure and it helped to have him design a program for me that would help with my trouble areas.
  • walkwallfall
    walkwallfall Posts: 18 Member
    What kind of plan are you on?
  • IreneAdler221
    IreneAdler221 Posts: 185 Member
    I'm also 5'5 and in maintenance(130 lbs). I've had great success w/ strength training. I eat 2100 cals and exercise 6 days/week. There is nothing wrong w/ eating maintenance while working on body recomposition, but be prepared for a small initial weight gain while upping your cals and/or strength training.
  • walkwallfall
    walkwallfall Posts: 18 Member
    Will your weight go back down after the initial change?
  • DonnaW_78
    DonnaW_78 Posts: 76 Member
    I'm the same - I'm basically at goal weight but want to lose some fat in some areas & tone-up. I'm too scared to up my cals (I'm on 1460) in case I put on. I barely come up to the 1460 a day as it is. Confused???
  • IreneAdler221
    IreneAdler221 Posts: 185 Member
    It might. If you gain a few water weight lbs from strength training it most likely will. As for upping calories, here is a good post that explains why you might gain a few lbs. when you start eating maintenance- http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/1071202-why-you-gain-weight-if-you-eat-more-than-your-cut
  • taso42
    taso42 Posts: 8,980 Member
    Tone usually translates to maintaining muscle mass while decreasing fat. Train and eat accordingly.
  • DonnaW_78
    DonnaW_78 Posts: 76 Member
    Thanks Irene :)
  • MercenaryNoetic26
    MercenaryNoetic26 Posts: 2,747 Member
    Leangains has worked for me. I've been maintaining 120 since March, but def not as fat as when I started. Clothes fits better, so know I'm leaner. I have best results when following as close as possible ( that includes calorie cycling). Anyway, that's (the) method that's working for me.
  • lilyp91
    lilyp91 Posts: 22 Member
    I'm still in weight loss mode; however, strength training and working your core are just plain good for you whether you are trying to lose or not. I am training for a marathon right now, so my workout schedule is pretty aggressive which means I eat a LOT and still seem to be losing weight (I.e. Today, I ran twelve miles and I've still got to eat 1,515 calories in order to net 1,350 for the day). If you are netting the calories you're told to each day AND strengthening, there isn't anything to worry about. You WILL get toned and, bonus, you'll burn calories more efficiently when you aren't working out. Strength training along with cardio is just a win-win. This is a good time to measure yourself so that, even though the scale may or may not change, you'll see the results as inches melt off. Having said that, I HIGHLY recommend the Physique 57 DVD series (I got mine online). It's tough-as in swear at the TV your first few times tough-but, wow, you will see and feel results!!!
  • lilyp91
    lilyp91 Posts: 22 Member
    PS: Muscle weighs more than fat. If you're trim and toned, looking the way you want to, does it matter what the scale says?
  • tomcornhole
    tomcornhole Posts: 1,084 Member
    PS: Muscle weighs more than fat. If you're trim and toned, looking the way you want to, does it matter what the scale says?

    1 lbs of muscle = 1 lbs of fat. One lbs of muscle takes up less space than one lbs of fat.
  • tomcornhole
    tomcornhole Posts: 1,084 Member
    I'm currently doing what you want to do. Been at maintenance for 5 months now. Started by just figuring out how much to eat to maintain my weight. That took a couple of months. Then I started weight training with free weights. Didn't gain anything but had to up my calories to continue maintenance. I am now seriously strength training and stopped all cardio. Been maintaining my weight but my waist is now smaller and I am much leaner. I have lost 1% - 2% body fat.

    This is not the most efficient way to go about a recomp, but it fits my goals right now. Come winter, I will bulk up to 195 lbs (currently at 185 lbs) and then cut back down to 10% BF in the spring. Should look like the hulk at that point.

    To sum up, you must strength train. Progressively heavier weights. Do the compound lifts: squats, deadlift, bench, overhead press. Watch your body transform into a lean machine.

    Tom

    TomBF20130710.jpg

    Bottom 2 images are both at 185 lbs. I think I am at 13% in the bottom right one. I am even leaner than the bottom right one now and still at 185 lbs.
  • taso42
    taso42 Posts: 8,980 Member
    @tomcornhole - absolutely stellar work mate!
  • Fitfully_me
    Fitfully_me Posts: 647 Member
    Not sure how to title this but I reached my goal weight. I'm 125 at 5'5" which is IMO a good healthy weight. However, I still want to tone up and lose belly flab and such. I am very active and am on my feet most of the day, plus I exercise 5-6 times a week usually vigorously. MFP says to eat 1900+ to maintain but if I want to tone will eating that much make it hard to keep toning up? Or can I tone by simply exercising/weight training?


    Your questions point out 2 different desires. Scale weight & lower body fat %.
    You are at your desired scale weight, but your body doesn't yet look the way you want it to. Because of this, I wouldn't say you are ready to enter maintenance mode. Maintenance suggests that you desire to keep things as they are. You don't. You're still looking for change. Being "toned" as you've used it here refers to the appearance of muscle definition. This will only be achieved by lowering your body fat %. Perhaps at this time its best to shift your focus away from a certain number on the scale, and see where that number is once your body has the look you desire, then focus on maintaining what you've achieved.
  • honeysprinkles
    honeysprinkles Posts: 1,757 Member
    I feel like the only way to do that and stay at the same weight is to lose fat and gain muscle at the same time, which I don't think is possible.

    I am in a really similar position as you though, I am 5'6" and 124 and still want to lose some fat on my stomach and my thighs. My goal is to lose fat and try to maintain my muscle mass that I already have so I can lower my bf% but I don't see a way to do that without losing a few more pounds.
  • minijuggernaut
    minijuggernaut Posts: 98 Member
    Lift weights. Heavy ones. The results you seek will follow.
  • jobrian1984
    jobrian1984 Posts: 19
    @Walkwallfall

    Daily caloric intake:
    12 x 125 = 1,500 calories
    Protein-250g
    Carbs-63g-125g-181g (cycle carbs) cycling your carbs will make your calorie intake fluctuate daily.
    Fat-31g
    Sugar no more than 45g
    Sodium-no more than 1,500mg

    Don't use MFP calculations.

    Week 1: 3X10*
    Week 2: 3X8*
    Week 3: 3X5*
    Week 4: 3X2*
    Week 5: 3X12*
    Week 6: 3X15*
    Week 7: 3X20*
    Week8: 3X25*
    *=drop set (makes 4th set)

    Weeks 2-4 you are doing less reps but adding more weight.

    Weeks 5-8 you are doing more reps but less weight.

    A droop set: immediately after you finish your last set, rack the weight. Rest 10-15 seconds then pick the weight up till failure, immediately drop the weight by 20-40 percent and go to failure again.
  • jobrian1984
    jobrian1984 Posts: 19
    I feel like the only way to do that and stay at the same weight is to lose fat and gain muscle at the same time, which I don't think is possible.

    I am in a really similar position as you though, I am 5'6" and 124 and still want to lose some fat on my stomach and my thighs. My goal is to lose fat and try to maintain my muscle mass that I already have so I can lower my bf% but I don't see a way to do that without losing a few more pounds.

    Tighten up on your nutrition and have a solid workout plan. Ignore the scale. You can lose 2-3 lbs of body weight but gain 2-3 lbs lean body mass, which essentially means you would weight the same.
  • originalcookiemonster
    originalcookiemonster Posts: 278
    Eat at maintenance according to your TDEE and lift heavy weights.
  • aetzkorn14
    aetzkorn14 Posts: 169 Member
    Lift weights. Heavy ones. The results you seek will follow.

    Dido!! Lift heavy always even females. You get better results faster and burn a lot more calories. I am still in weight loss mode but I have already begun the lifting and you grow to love it. There is always a body part sore and I have a hard time taking a rest day.
  • pkw58
    pkw58 Posts: 2,038 Member
    I am all about staying the same weight but losing fat and gaining muscle.. I am on a personal two year commitment to get there.
  • lilyp91
    lilyp91 Posts: 22 Member
    PS: Muscle weighs more than fat. If you're trim and toned, looking the way you want to, does it matter what the scale says?

    1 lbs of muscle = 1 lbs of fat. One lbs of muscle takes up less space than one lbs of fat.

    You're 100% correct. I meant to say that muscle is denser than fat; hence, you can be smaller than the person next to you but weigh more.
  • walkwallfall
    walkwallfall Posts: 18 Member
    Not sure how to title this but I reached my goal weight. I'm 125 at 5'5" which is IMO a good healthy weight. However, I still want to tone up and lose belly flab and such. I am very active and am on my feet most of the day, plus I exercise 5-6 times a week usually vigorously. MFP says to eat 1900+ to maintain but if I want to tone will eating that much make it hard to keep toning up? Or can I tone by simply exercising/weight training?


    Your questions point out 2 different desires. Scale weight & lower body fat %.
    You are at your desired scale weight, but your body doesn't yet look the way you want it to. Because of this, I wouldn't say you are ready to enter maintenance mode. Maintenance suggests that you desire to keep things as they are. You don't. You're still looking for change. Being "toned" as you've used it here refers to the appearance of muscle definition. This will only be achieved by lowering your body fat %. Perhaps at this time its best to shift your focus away from a certain number on the scale, and see where that number is once your body has the look you desire, then focus on maintaining what you've achieved.
  • walkwallfall
    walkwallfall Posts: 18 Member
    Not sure how to title this but I reached my goal weight. I'm 125 at 5'5" which is IMO a good healthy weight. However, I still want to tone up and lose belly flab and such. I am very active and am on my feet most of the day, plus I exercise 5-6 times a week usually vigorously. MFP says to eat 1900+ to maintain but if I want to tone will eating that much make it hard to keep toning up? Or can I tone by simply exercising/weight training?


    Your questions point out 2 different desires. Scale weight & lower body fat %.
    You are at your desired scale weight, but your body doesn't yet look the way you want it to. Because of this, I wouldn't say you are ready to enter maintenance mode. Maintenance suggests that you desire to keep things as they are. You don't. You're still looking for change. Being "toned" as you've used it here refers to the appearance of muscle definition. This will only be achieved by lowering your body fat %. Perhaps at this time its best to shift your focus away from a certain number on the scale, and see where that number is once your body has the look you desire, then focus on maintaining what you've achieved.
    [/




    I guess my worry is that im now going below what a healthy weight my dr said was for me. BUT I would like to decrease some more fat and tone more. So does that mean I need to keep eating with a lower calorie diet?
  • walkwallfall
    walkwallfall Posts: 18 Member
    Not sure how to title this but I reached my goal weight. I'm 125 at 5'5" which is IMO a good healthy weight. However, I still want to tone up and lose belly flab and such. I am very active and am on my feet most of the day, plus I exercise 5-6 times a week usually vigorously. MFP says to eat 1900+ to maintain but if I want to tone will eating that much make it hard to keep toning up? Or can I tone by simply exercising/weight training?


    Your questions point out 2 different desires. Scale weight & lower body fat %.
    You are at your desired scale weight, but your body doesn't yet look the way you want it to. Because of this, I wouldn't say you are ready to enter maintenance mode. Maintenance suggests that you desire to keep things as they are. You don't. You're still looking for change. Being "toned" as you've used it here refers to the appearance of muscle definition. This will only be achieved by lowering your body fat %. Perhaps at this time its best to shift your focus away from a certain number on the scale, and see where that number is once your body has the look you desire, then focus on maintaining what you've achieved.
    [/




    I guess my worry is that im now going below what a healthy weight my dr said was for me. BUT I would like to decrease some more fat and tone more. So does that mean I need to keep eating with a lower calorie diet?
  • nxd10
    nxd10 Posts: 4,570 Member
    I am finding that I have to do different exercises to tone now that I'm thinner. I spent the weekend putting up a ceiling and insulation and all of a sudden I felt (not in a bad way) my abdominal muscles. My arms and legs had been in great shape but I hadn't been working my abs specifically and I have to. Especially since that's where the last blub came off and all those muscles are loose.

    It's like after you have a baby. Those muscles also hold up your back.

    I have a standing desk at work but was thinking about getting one of those pilates balls to sit on because they are supposed to strengthen your core muscles. I have one now for my kids on the computer.
  • balancedbrunette
    balancedbrunette Posts: 530 Member
    Some interesting comments on here. I'm also at the point of maintenance now however, still want to work on my body shape. It is quite contradiction because i've read some comments where people say you're not at the point of maintenance if your not happy with your body and are still looking to reduce bf. Thing is I don't want to get any thinner I just want to reduce the BF on my tummy area a bit more.

    So guess right now i'm working on upping my cals to maintenance and taking up strength training, i'm starting a strength class tomorrow for 6 weeks which shows women how to do it properly etc so looking forward to it. :)
  • rovernio
    rovernio Posts: 157
    you shouldnt pay too much attention to weigh, just look in the mirror to know if you are satisfied
  • Fitfully_me
    Fitfully_me Posts: 647 Member
    Not sure how to title this but I reached my goal weight. I'm 125 at 5'5" which is IMO a good healthy weight. However, I still want to tone up and lose belly flab and such. I am very active and am on my feet most of the day, plus I exercise 5-6 times a week usually vigorously. MFP says to eat 1900+ to maintain but if I want to tone will eating that much make it hard to keep toning up? Or can I tone by simply exercising/weight training?


    Your questions point out 2 different desires. Scale weight & lower body fat %.
    You are at your desired scale weight, but your body doesn't yet look the way you want it to. Because of this, I wouldn't say you are ready to enter maintenance mode. Maintenance suggests that you desire to keep things as they are. You don't. You're still looking for change. Being "toned" as you've used it here refers to the appearance of muscle definition. This will only be achieved by lowering your body fat %. Perhaps at this time its best to shift your focus away from a certain number on the scale, and see where that number is once your body has the look you desire, then focus on maintaining what you've achieved.
    [/




    I guess my worry is that im now going below what a healthy weight my dr said was for me. BUT I would like to decrease some more fat and tone more. So does that mean I need to keep eating with a lower calorie diet?

    Not necessarily. I will refer you this calorie calculator that can help give you a better idea of how you can go about losing fat/gaining muscle. http://scoobysworkshop.com/calorie-calculator/
    There's an option to select your goal. Gain muscle/lose fat is one of those options. This will give you a better idea not only of where your caloric intake should be, but also your macros.

    Your desires match mine, and I've recently adjustment my intake and exercise strategy to achieve these goals. No results to offer yet, but there are plenty of folks here who've had success.
This discussion has been closed.

Categories