How should strength training to lose weight and tone up go?

So I am trying to lose weight and tone up. I do strength every other day Mon, Wed, and Friday. I was wondering....Should I train one area each day or do all over strength each day? What is better and what are the ups and down of each? I do 30 minutes of cardio on those days too. Tuesday and Thursday I do 45 minutes of just cardio. I rest Saturday and Sunday. I do something family wise Saturday whether it be hiking, biking, or a simple walk to the park with the family. I eat 1200 calories and day and eat back the calories I burn. I hope I am taking the right approach. Now I just need to know if I should working different body parts per strength training?

:smile:
Thanks,
Chrystal

Replies

  • JNick77
    JNick77 Posts: 3,783 Member
    So I am trying to lose weight and tone up. I do strength every other day Mon, Wed, and Friday. I was wondering....Should I train one area each day or do all over strength each day? What is better and what are the ups and down of each? I do 30 minutes of cardio on those days too. Tuesday and Thursday I do 45 minutes of just cardio. I rest Saturday and Sunday. I do something family wise Saturday whether it be hiking, biking, or a simple walk to the park with the family. I eat 1200 calories and day and eat back the calories I burn. I hope I am taking the right approach. Now I just need to know if I should working different body parts per strength training?

    :smile:
    Thanks,
    Chrystal

    It's a good question but it would better put as, "how should you eat to lose bodyfat, and strength train?". When it comes to getting tone it starts with the diet, but really any fitness goal starts with diet; diet dictates your outcome. Make sure you start with a safe diet deficit that will allow your body to lose bodyfat without putting your metabolism at risk for becoming suppressed or slowed. You can just do a straight-forward diet when you watch your macro's and make good "clean food" selections. Paleo foods are always a good choice (i.e. Sweet Potatoes, Red Potatoes, Chicken, lean beef, green veggies). Or you can try something like Carb Back-Loading (CBL).

    From an exercise perspective, typically lifting heavier weights for lower volume will provide the best strength gains while preserving more muscle mass during a deficit. If you're a beginner without a trainer or knowledgeable friend then look-up Starting Strength, StrongLifts 5x5, or New Rules of Lifting.
  • taso42
    taso42 Posts: 8,980 Member
    You don't strength train to lose weight. You eat (in a calorie deficit) to lose weight.
    The reason to strength train is to gain strength, preserve or gain muscle, preserve or gain bone density, improve fitness.
    For a novice, the most time-efficient way to get results is by doing the full-body compound lifts and by following a tried and true program.
  • Alehmer
    Alehmer Posts: 433 Member
    Of course, the more muscle you have and the more efficient your system is, the higher your Basal Metabolic Rate, and the more you burn all day long.

    But yes, food is the most important for fat loss, with strength training being an important supplement.
  • WendyTerry420
    WendyTerry420 Posts: 13,274 Member
    If you're strength-training, then how are you getting enough protein in your diet on only 1200 calories? Or is that net calories after eating back your exercise calories?

    Anyway, in New Rules of Lifting for Women, it says that if you are trying to lose fat, then to keep your deficit around 300 calories. That makes it easier to get enough protein to repair your muscles.
  • mndamon
    mndamon Posts: 549 Member
    I prefer doing body area splits on each day but circuit training your whole body can be just as effective. It's mostly about preference hoenstly. People can swear up and down that one way is better but that's just what worked for them. Lifting heavy is the way to go regardless. There's been a ton of great mentions on that New Rules book that Wendy mentioned, I'd check that out.
  • FrnkLft
    FrnkLft Posts: 1,821 Member
    It depends largely on your goals. I hit everything twice a week, but that means I am in the gym 5 days a week. It requires a lot of dedication, and more than anything else a certain level of enjoyment to get you there everyday.

    If you're toying with how many days or what to do, I highly recommend Stronglifts 5x5. It has you doing 3-4 compound lifts per session (these are the basic lifts that should be at the center of any strength/toning routine, they hit EVERY muscle in your body), and has a steady plan for increasing your weight that starts out with the bar so it's very managable.

    NROL4W is good too, and the book has great info, but I find the actual routine is a little more complicated (read: not worse or better).

    The best part about it is that you could do the prescribed 3 times a week (optimal), or you could do less depending on what your week looks like. Each session has the same lifts, and it's a total body workout.
  • JNick77
    JNick77 Posts: 3,783 Member
    Anyway, in New Rules of Lifting for Women, it says that if you are trying to lose fat, then to keep your deficit around 300 calories. That makes it easier to get enough protein to repair your muscles.

    That's an interesting comment and I just lost a little respect for that book. You can't really say eat 300 less calories per day to lose weight. For somebody like me 300 calories less per day could actually work but for somebody who's maintenance calories are around 1200 then 300 could be excessive. One's maintenance calories are specific to them and it's very hard to generalize; one's activity level plays a huge role into how much they eat. Calorie deficits are then typically based on a percentage of their maintenance calories with it usually being in a range of 10% to 20% (generally speaking). If 1,200 calories is TRULY your maintenance calories, then it would be wise to start at say -120 calories (10% less / 90% of maintenance) and go from there.
  • PriceK01
    PriceK01 Posts: 834 Member
    You don't strength train to lose weight. You eat (in a calorie deficit) to lose weight.
    The reason to strength train is to gain strength, preserve or gain muscle, preserve or gain bone density, improve fitness.
    For a novice, the most time-efficient way to get results is by doing the full-body compound lifts and by following a tried and true program.

    Taso is correct.
  • lorigem
    lorigem Posts: 446 Member
    So I am trying to lose weight and tone up. I do strength every other day Mon, Wed, and Friday. I was wondering....Should I train one area each day or do all over strength each day? What is better and what are the ups and down of each? I do 30 minutes of cardio on those days too. Tuesday and Thursday I do 45 minutes of just cardio. I rest Saturday and Sunday. I do something family wise Saturday whether it be hiking, biking, or a simple walk to the park with the family. I eat 1200 calories and day and eat back the calories I burn. I hope I am taking the right approach. Now I just need to know if I should working different body parts per strength training?

    :smile:
    Thanks,
    Chrystal

    Since you're strength training M W and F, I'd do Total Body compound lifts. If you wanted to do isolated lifts, you could do them more often (working each area once a week).
  • Labrum3
    Labrum3 Posts: 25 Member
    Thank you everyone for your input. I will take a look at the articles you guys have mentioned. I am trying to lose weight but also gain muscle and strength, something I really lack in. My main concern I have is losing my mid section from having kids a few years back plus gain muscle in all other areas. After I lose the belly I would really like to be as fit as I can be. I eat 1200 a day in calories burn 300 in cardio a day not counting strength, and then eat back 300 calories. In my diet yesterday I ate a total of 1500 calories 1200 then 300 back from cardio. I had 76 grams for the day in protein. I currently do the weight machines at Planet Fitness. I use the bicep curl, tricep curl, chest press, pull-down, leg press, glutes, adduction, and adbomnial crunches as strength each being 3 reps of 12.