Advice from switching away from clean eating...

thinking_thinly
thinking_thinly Posts: 143 Member
edited February 3 in Health and Weight Loss
Basically I have spent the last 12 months eating fairly cleanly, even going so far as going vegan at one point, and currently on the Mediterranean diet. However, I just have come to the conclusion that I like food. I like clean food, I like "dirty" food, I like it all...

Have you found it just as easy to loose/maintain or harder? I feel as though by eating "clean" i have more self control over what I eat, but it is getting to the point where my mentality towards food is becoming a bit disordered...on the other hand, I feel that by eating more "junk" food that I can go completely over the other side and undo the almost 100lb weightloss I have achieved! I just want to eat like a human being! :/

Replies

  • RAGGEDYANN1970
    RAGGEDYANN1970 Posts: 115 Member
    i am not really sure i understand what you are asking. i guess from what i gathered, my response would be, once per month, take a day and eat anything you want, "dirty" bad foods, etc.
  • Achrya
    Achrya Posts: 16,913 Member
    Eat what you want. There are many people with huge weightloss numbers who eat what the like, within their calories goal. It won't stall you or reverse you progress, but eating what you enjoy and not thinking in terms of clean/ dirty might make you happier. Eat, track, enjoy.
  • Serah87
    Serah87 Posts: 5,481 Member
    I just eat food!! *see ticker below*
  • wild_wild_life
    wild_wild_life Posts: 1,334 Member
    I agree it can be easier to overeat processed food. Cause a lot of times it tastes better :). It's "processed" specifically in order to taste better so we will buy more of it. I think restricting yourself from what you really want will only cause a rebound effect (at least it does for me). Labeling a food as off limits is a sure way to crave and go overboard on it. Finding a middle road between restricting and binging is what it's all about. Processed food won't make you gain weight if eaten in moderation to satisfy hunger.

    ETA -- Congrats on your loss, that is amazing!
  • unFATuated
    unFATuated Posts: 204 Member
    I do understand what you're saying. A little bit of junk seems to set up the craving for more (for me it depends what it is).

    Have you looked up the IIFYM (If It Fits Your Macros) philosophy? It basically sets you up with a goal for the intake of carbs, fats and protein for each day and you can eat pretty much whatever you want, as long as it allows you to hit the numbers for the day. So there are people who will make icecream, pizza etc fit their macros for the day by planning other types of foods around it. It's worth a look and reading about - it does make you feel like a 'normal' person, while still watching what you're eating. It takes planning (usually meal planning and pre-logging and not just grabbing whatever you feel like when you feel like it).

    I don't know if I've explained that very clearly, but many people I know find it really beneficial and less limiting than clean eating, especially once they've reached their goals.
  • AllonsYtotheTardis
    AllonsYtotheTardis Posts: 16,947 Member
    I eat what I want. Sometimes that's "clean", sometimes it's "dirty". Hasn't hindered my progress at all.
  • Ninkyou
    Ninkyou Posts: 6,666 Member
    I personally don't restrict any foods. I fit it into my calorie goals. I still consistently lose weight every week.

    So you want a chocolate chip cookie. Eat that sucker and work it into your day, guilt free. As long as you're in a calorie deficit, you'll lost weight.
  • gmallan
    gmallan Posts: 2,099 Member
    Why not just amke it your goal to eat mostly healthy (or clean if you'd prefer) with 20% allowance for treats. Aim to hit your macros whether the food is "clean" or "dirty". If you are hitting your macros you won't be able to fit in a whole lot of junk anyway.
  • rwam
    rwam Posts: 13 Member
    http://www.cnn.com/2010/HEALTH/11/08/twinkie.diet.professor/index.html

    This was an interesting article, not sure if you have seen it, the point was just that it is always calories consumed vs calories burned. Maintaining a healthy life means that you must come to terms with living in a world with all kinds of food. The problem for me is that ho-hos are high in calories and cupcakes make me want more cupcakes so I have to find a way to limit my access to them.

    So, who wants to split a package of twinkies with me?
  • SLLRunner
    SLLRunner Posts: 12,942 Member
    Basically I have spent the last 12 months eating fairly cleanly, even going so far as going vegan at one point, and currently on the Mediterranean diet. However, I just have come to the conclusion that I like food. I like clean food, I like "dirty" food, I like it all...

    Have you found it just as easy to loose/maintain or harder? I feel as though by eating "clean" i have more self control over what I eat, but it is getting to the point where my mentality towards food is becoming a bit disordered...on the other hand, I feel that by eating more "junk" food that I can go completely over the other side and undo the almost 100lb weightloss I have achieved! I just want to eat like a human being! :/

    I know the feeling. I used to think certain foods were good and certain foods were bad. I used to think if I ate something "bad", I couldn't stop and would gain all my weight back.

    What I'm learning is that no foods are good or bad. I don't avoid any foods except those I have intolerance to (soy, dairy). I am sensitive to sugar, so I go really easy on sweets. I am caffeine intolerant and decided to cut out 99% caffeine, so I don't drink caffeinated sodas but do have one cup of tea in the am and decaf coffee.

    I was obese for most of my life, then when I turned 40 I joined a gym and signed up with a personal trainer. He taught me how to eat properly and exercise, and he told me, 'Log your food. You will be doing this for the rest of your life." My highest weight was about 220 in my early twenties, but I managed to lose down to about 190. That's the weight I was when I was 40. It took me several months to get to about 150, where I was for a long time.

    About five years ago when I stopped logging and started eating more again and gained back about 30 lbs over the last five years. Now, I've lost 20 of that and I'm ten pounds to my weight goal.

    I see my renewed eating habits as a way of life. It's about making choices. I can have that low fat 450 calorie ginger pumpkin muffin, but do I really want to put that into my body (especially with all that sugar). I could eat half and save the rest for another day, or I can cut it into fours and share with others. I choose not to eat it at all because I'd already planned my eating and exercise plan for that day, and all that sugar makes me feel edgy and hungrier.

    However, I went to a party a few weeks ago and I had sweets.I knew I'd be going to a party where I would eat more so I saved some calories for the event. I did not go over my calorie limit that week and I ended up losing a few pounds anyway.

    The concept that I'm still not used to, which I heard from my trainer all those years ago, is that you have to make sure you are properly fueled. That means when you exercise, you have to make sure you are getting enough "gas" to keep yourself running at normal speed. Fuel is another word for food.

    Finally, no food is good or bad as long as you eat it in moderation (and you're not allergic or sensitive to it). :smile:
  • 2aycocks
    2aycocks Posts: 415 Member
    You can eat healthy food without doing the Vegan stuff, which if extremely unhealthy. If I had to only eat that mess, I'd starve! Try eating a regular healthy balanced diet, but give yourself a break sometimes. You can have a treat without blowing your weight loss. Just dont eat 5 pieces of cake instead of 1 small one.

    We all love crap! So eat a little crap once in a while. A ball game just wouldn't be a ball game without a big ole crap filled hotdog!
  • jdm_taco
    jdm_taco Posts: 999 Member
    I find it much easier to meet any of my fitness goals when I do not exclude any foods because im not as miserable and its less likely I will binge.
  • jadedone
    jadedone Posts: 2,446 Member
    I eat clean-ish because I think it tastes better. But I started eating clean in like 2000. And look, I am still here.

    If I feel like having some fritos? I am not going to die. But I prefer to stick with ingredients I can pronounce as often as possible.

    Eat clean because you want to. Not because you think it is a magic panacea for weight loss. It isn't. I am living proof. (On the flip side, I do have excellent blood work. Even when my weight was higher.)
  • SteelySunshine
    SteelySunshine Posts: 1,092 Member
    I ate a lot of "bad" food today. I would log it, but I don't want it in my database, so what happens at the State Fair stays at the State Fair. Anyway, point is I didn't even come close to my calorie goal today and that was with a mess of junk food. Granted this day was a accumulation of several days of intense walking as was making sure I can locate my classes among other things in prep for getting ready for school. But, that is kind of the point, if you move more and burn more you can eat more and it doesn't matter what it is as long as you are in a deficit.
This discussion has been closed.