Can I eat the calories I didn't eat yesterday?

thedeepblue
thedeepblue Posts: 20
edited September 21 in Health and Weight Loss
So I am new to this. I had 300 calories left over when I went to bed last night. I am starving today and have almost eaten all my calories for the day. I barely have any left for dinner. Can I eat the calories I didn't eat yesterday and still lose a pound this week?


Also, I see challenges on the message boards about losing 20 pounds in 4 or 6 weeks? How are these people doing it?

Thanks for your help. Danielle

Replies

  • KarenBorter
    KarenBorter Posts: 1,157 Member
    Oh how I WISH ... Sorry to say, but every day is a new day and a new reset .... but that's also a good thing when you go over.
  • gambitsgurl
    gambitsgurl Posts: 632 Member
    Can you work in more exercise today to offset your calorie totals?
  • Amarillo_NDN
    Amarillo_NDN Posts: 1,018 Member
    if that were the case, then I would eat the cals from last year as well. *wnik*
  • sgp329
    sgp329 Posts: 184
    if that were the case, then I would eat the cals from last year as well. *wnik*

    And that would make two of us :laugh:
  • ♥_Ellybean_♥
    ♥_Ellybean_♥ Posts: 1,646 Member
    Go for a walk, bike ride, pop in an exercise video - that will give you extra calories that you can eat. Sorry no taking from yest.
  • ashlee954
    ashlee954 Posts: 1,112 Member
    Actually yes you can. You just need a 3500 cal/week defecit to lose one pound. It is actually a good thing to fluctuate your calories- more than goal one day, less than goal another. It keeps your metabolism guesssing so your body doesn't know what's coming next. I used to be a nutritionist and this worked everytime when we had our patients on diets. It is also how I lost 12 lbs in 5 weeks. Good luck!
  • trickyfoxster710
    trickyfoxster710 Posts: 151 Member
    I agree with ashlee954. But about the 20+ lbs loss in a few weeks, a lot of these people are 100+ over weight so they lose really quickly in the beginning. Just remember this is not about every body else it is about you. Give yourself challenges and goals and always try and one up yourself and the lbs will come off!
  • jrich1
    jrich1 Posts: 2,408 Member
    Actually yes you can. You just need a 3500 cal/week defecit to lose one pound. It is actually a good thing to fluctuate your calories- more than goal one day, less than goal another. It keeps your metabolism guesssing so your body doesn't know what's coming next. I used to be a nutritionist and this worked everytime when we had our patients on diets. It is also how I lost 12 lbs in 5 weeks. Good luck!

    i agree mathmatically it would even out
  • gambitsgurl
    gambitsgurl Posts: 632 Member
    if that were the case, then I would eat the cals from last year as well. *wnik*

    And that would make two of us :laugh:

    I had a stomach virus 2 years ago and I HAVE to been good for 5000 worth of chocolate :D
  • nehtaeh
    nehtaeh Posts: 2,849 Member
    Agreed with Ashlee954 as well. While I wouldn't say its ok to take leftover calories from last month, or even last week, it would be ok for yesterday. However, I don't think I would get in the habit of doing this as you can easily start wanting to eat more and go over more often.

    I believe the WW system is set up to let you use points you've accumulated that week that you didn't use earlier that week. Same idea really, just in terms of calories.

    If you can add more exercise, that would be your best way to go.
  • redefiningmyself
    redefiningmyself Posts: 476 Member
    As far as calories go, I look at each day as a new beginning, and I don't think you can eat the day before calories, or save up for a day in the future. But that's just my belief.

    I've taken off 21 pounds in the last 5 weeks. This is how I did it....

    I followed recommendations from my doctor only. I don't bother with any other diet methodology. (tried many in the past and failed.)

    -I eat Breakfast, lunch dinner, and afternoon snack and a late evening snack.
    -Each meal is around 400cals, with snacks being 100-200 each. Total for the day averages around 1300-1500.
    -Every meal is 50% veggies, 25% carb, 25% lean protein.
    -I drink 10-14 cups of water a day. (anything else I drink I do not count as water, but quite frankly, I'm already in the bathroom so much that pop, teas, coffees etc do not interest me most days)
    -I keep away from caffiene and alcohol most days.
    -I exercise every day, even if its only 15 minutes. Although most days are between 45minutes - 1 hour.

    Also, I listen to my body, if I'm tired I try to rest more. If I'm hungry I eat something (usually veggies).

    So far its working. I've dropped a lot of weight, feel great, and never feel hungry or deprived. this is looking like the first sustainable plan I've ever been on - I am sincerely hoping that turns out to be true.

    Best wishes on your weight loss journey!!!
  • melodyg
    melodyg Posts: 1,423 Member
    I agree with Ashlee too. It is all about a deficit over a week of time... so if I go a hundred calories over or so on one day but I am under the rest of the week, I don't worry about it. I also agree that it is a good idea to get in some exercise as a first step. Exercising always makes me seem to be *less* hungry too.

    I don't know how those people on the challenges do it either... I have over 100 pounds to lose too but it took me 4 months to lose 20 pounds (I do have settings at 1 lb/week but usually eat under, so theoretically I should be losing about 1.5/week... yeah, right, not happening).
  • maurierose
    maurierose Posts: 574 Member
    I agree with a few of the people above - as long as it's from the day before, and you're starving, I would go ahead and eat those cals, or a portion of them. Try to get high-protein foods in (you'll need less to make you feel more full) and high-fiber healthy choices, and by all means, it's early in the day, exercise to earn more if you can (which means you'd eat less of yesterday's cals!).

    As for the high weight losses per week, as mentioned above, many people have lots of weight to lose.... if you're not too far off your goals, you're going to have slower progress than someone else may have who is starting off with a lot to lose. The important thing is to lose YOUR weight in the healthiest way possible (1/2 to 2 lbs a week), as you'll keep it off and do much better that way.

    Hang in there, and keep trying :smile: :flowerforyou:
  • Motleybird
    Motleybird Posts: 119 Member
    Yes, I tend to do it about once a week or so. I wouldn't go back more than a day, and I'll only go over if my body is really telling me it's hungry. Don't make a habit of it, but don't stress over it either. It does average out.
  • Thanks for all the great advice Everyone. I do plan to workout today. I workout 5 times a week for an hour. That will get me 400 extra calories for today.

    Some of your comments are really funny.
  • kaitimae
    kaitimae Posts: 727 Member
    Actually yes you can. You just need a 3500 cal/week defecit to lose one pound. It is actually a good thing to fluctuate your calories- more than goal one day, less than goal another. It keeps your metabolism guesssing so your body doesn't know what's coming next. I used to be a nutritionist and this worked everytime when we had our patients on diets. It is also how I lost 12 lbs in 5 weeks. Good luck!

    This! I agree! Jillian Michaels says this too, in one of her books. Or at least she says to focus on weekly calories, and divide them up so you are not taking in exactly the same each day.
  • tam8374
    tam8374 Posts: 270 Member
    Actually yes you can. You just need a 3500 cal/week defecit to lose one pound. It is actually a good thing to fluctuate your calories- more than goal one day, less than goal another. It keeps your metabolism guesssing so your body doesn't know what's coming next. I used to be a nutritionist and this worked everytime when we had our patients on diets. It is also how I lost 12 lbs in 5 weeks. Good luck!

    I agree.. Weight watchers had a similar idea when they introduced their flex plan. You had 35 additional points to use during the week for either one big meal or broken up over the week or not at all. but you couldn't carry over points week to week. Each new week it reset. Used or not used. You can't stockpile over periods of time.

    I am also going to be adding my height to my signature.. Good IDEA! I often wonder myself.
  • robin52077
    robin52077 Posts: 4,383 Member
    I also agree with ashlee, trickyfoxster, jrich and others.

    It's called zigzagging your calories.

    For a rough example, say you are given 1500 a day...

    you could do 1500, 1200, 1600, 1300, 1800, 1400, 1700 in a week's time. That is still 1500 a day, but if you aren't as hungry one day and really hungry another , this works great.
    It also shakes things up a bit to help prevent plateaus.
    You do NOT want to do the same thing day in and day out with your eating OR your exercise.

    As long as you stay around the right number on AVERAGE, then you will still be losing over time.
  • Mindful_Trent
    Mindful_Trent Posts: 3,954 Member
    Your body doesn't reset at midnight (or whenever you go to bed). I agree that you can't keep track and eat calories from weeks ago, but if you're under that much one day (300 is a lot!) then you shouldn't feel guilty about eating a little extra the next, especially if you're eating healthy foods. The important thing is that you consistently stay within a reasonable calorie range (I try for +/- 50 to 100 of my goal, including most of my exercise calories). I try not to leave too many calories available, but I also try not to go over by too many. You're rarely going to eat exactly your goal - it all averages out.
  • I also agree with ashlee, trickyfoxster, jrich and others.

    It's called zigzagging your calories.

    For a rough example, say you are given 1500 a day...

    you could do 1500, 1200, 1600, 1300, 1800, 1400, 1700 in a week's time. That is still 1500 a day, but if you aren't as hungry one day and really hungry another , this works great.
    It also shakes things up a bit to help prevent plateaus.
    You do NOT want to do the same thing day in and day out with your eating OR your exercise.

    As long as you stay around the right number on AVERAGE, then you will still be losing over time.

    This sounds like really good advice!
  • tagging for later.
  • KarenBorter
    KarenBorter Posts: 1,157 Member
    I think our calories fluctuate anyway in regard to the amount we are "allowed" to eat based on our level of activities. My workouts aren't consistently X amount of calories and so I am "naturally" jumping around. I don't think it's a good idea to get into the habit of thinking "oh, I had 300 calories left over from yesterday so with workout I can eat 700 calories today" ... But again, mileage may vary what works for one may not work for all ...

    Listen to your body, I think that's the best advice anyone can give. :)
  • Actually, I worked with a guy who used this sort of diary system to lose over 50 pounds-but he averaged his calorie intake over a week.
    If he had a huge party to go to over the weekend he would save up a few hundred calories a day by eating less and working out a bit more so he could be free to eat the barbeque and have a few extra beers. He lost a lot of weight-so it seemed like it worked. My only complaint with this program is that it totals out days and doesn't have a function to let you average out a week.

    I'm not an expert, but I can't see why not. I've seen diet plans that look at weekly calories, having lower calorie days balanced by higher calories. Some say it's good, keeps your body from getting stuck into a rut. As long as you aren't eating a ton one day and nothing the next.
  • DeeZaster
    DeeZaster Posts: 18 Member
    Just remember this is not about every body else it is about you.

    So true. Don't watch how much other people are losing.. We're not all made the same, and we wont all lose the same. The fact that we're trying is the only thing holding us all together! We are a support Network, not a Competition! :)))

    PS: Just eat the extra calories.. I think its Ok to indulge here and there- come on.. If you're too strict you will never stick with it in the long run! You need to be able to be flexible to an extent.. Just don't make excuses to why you can pig out or whatever. Be realistic. A few hundred calories extra isn't going to kill you, you just gotta do a few extra jumping jacks or whatever to make up for it.

    Google how to burn 100 calories fast and do a few of those when you have days like this and need to go over. Don't punish yourself either though. Just go with the flow! :))
  • LotusF1ower
    LotusF1ower Posts: 1,259 Member
    Actually, I worked with a guy who used this sort of diary system to lose over 50 pounds-but he averaged his calorie intake over a week.
    If he had a huge party to go to over the weekend he would save up a few hundred calories a day by eating less and working out a bit more so he could be free to eat the barbeque and have a few extra beers. He lost a lot of weight-so it seemed like it worked. My only complaint with this program is that it totals out days and doesn't have a function to let you average out a week.

    I'm not an expert, but I can't see why not. I've seen diet plans that look at weekly calories, having lower calorie days balanced by higher calories. Some say it's good, keeps your body from getting stuck into a rut. As long as you aren't eating a ton one day and nothing the next.

    I have to confess I have saved up calories for the weekend on more than one occasion.

    This whole business is a life-changing plan, therefore planning for parties, dos and BBQs are always going to happen if they were a regular occurrence before the weight loss plans. This time though, it is different because whereas before people would stuff their faces all week and then party on at the weekend, now, because of correct eating,exercise and control, they can save for the parties.

    This comes into its own during maintenance.
  • one day isn't going to run you into the ditch. and if you can exercise to earn the additional calories that is best.
    know that when you do this, if you weigh daily, you will have more of a roller coaster on the scales. this is OKAY...just don't use that to judge what you eat/do that day. the scales IMO should be a tool, not the deciding factor.

    also...lets look at WHAT you are eating. yes it is about the calories. what you chose to eat WILL make a difference. the bulk and water from low calorie veggies and fruits will help fill you up way before a hunk of low fat cheese. and will not cause your blood sugar to spike and crash like high calorie rice/bread/pasta. the more veggies you eat, the fuller you will feel.

    it's all about balance that works for YOUR body.

    and 20 pounds in a month is not good unless you have a100+ pounds to lose.

    shoot for healthy food choices...fresh and not processed, and you will achieve your goal.
  • sarahliftsUP
    sarahliftsUP Posts: 752 Member
    Yes and no. I chose to look at everyday as a 'new' day. It goes on how I'm feeling rather than just looking at the numbers. But I must say, zig zagging my calories seems to work. Try it and see what happens for you.

    If I were you, I would exercise for a good 45 minutes to an hour to earn some more calories and aim for things that are high in protein. That way you are more satisfied. If by the end of the day, you are over by a little bit, no big deal. It may actually work out to your advantage. I was kicking myself for going over one day, so really monitored my calories the next day and lost weight. It just really depends on the demands of your body that day.
  • Cina04
    Cina04 Posts: 609
    Sometimes I do...

    Well more like if I go over my daily intake - I know that my cals burn from the previous day or week that I didn't consume back will cover it =)

    This is another reason why I don't log my cals from cleaning (aka daily activities I should be doing anyways as a SAHM/W). i look at these as my safety net cals.

    I had days were I went over my cals and still seen a loss the next day =)
  • iAlly
    iAlly Posts: 66
    Theoretically yes you can use yesterdays deficit as long as over the long term you eat less calories that you need.

    But it is a good idea to try to earn the extra calories you need if you can.

    Most importantly I'd say allow yourself some occasional days when you go a little over the limit

    Sometimes life just takes over, a party or a big meal or a stressful day at work and you end up eating more calories than you are supposed to.

    Allow that to happen. Don't feel guilty and most certainly don't feel like you've failed or that you can't do it because if you start to think like that then next thing you'll find yourself 6 months later standing on the scales wondering how you managed to put it all back on.

    All the best.
    Ally
  • CDresp
    CDresp Posts: 201 Member
    Actually yes you can. I often will save (bank) calories (or points) for a couple of days if I know there is a special occasion coming in a few days that I don't want to be stressing about while I am supposed to be enjoying the event. That is not enjoying life. Do this just for a week only.
This discussion has been closed.