Which items are/aren't worth making at home?

I like to cook. I've noticed a few things that are notably cheaper and healthier to make at home. For example: bread and pasta products, all kinds of sauces, pickles, pesto, hummus, roasting a huge hunk of meat and slicing instead of buying deli meats, etc...

However, I've also found a few things that taste the same as store bought or aren't economical/healthier to make at home. My big ones are butter and Asian dumpling wrappers (homemade are indisputably better, but my time is worth something....maybe will do this more when I have minions...err, I mean, kids.)

What are your "worth its" and "not worth its"?
«1

Replies

  • thinking_thinly
    thinking_thinly Posts: 143 Member
    Bread: ain't nobody got time fo' that!
  • pastryari
    pastryari Posts: 8,646 Member
    Bread: ain't nobody got time fo' that!

    For shame.
  • HeidiCooksSupper
    HeidiCooksSupper Posts: 3,831 Member
    Bread takes no time at all if you do no-knead or stretch-and-fold, the latter being my method of choice. Most of the time, you are ignoring it.

    Homemade broth and soup are definitely worth it. Also draining cheap yogurt to get Greek.
  • herblackwings39
    herblackwings39 Posts: 3,930 Member
    Home made bread and pizza doughs are easy, cheap, and if you do an overnight fridge rest are fairly fuss free.
  • gmallan
    gmallan Posts: 2,099 Member
    I've tried making thigs like wraps and tortillas. Not worth the time IMO. Lots of stuffing around rolling them thim enough and cooking them one-by-one
  • TribeHokie
    TribeHokie Posts: 711 Member
    Home made bread and pizza doughs are easy, cheap, and if you do an overnight fridge rest are fairly fuss free.

    qft

    Especially considering you can freeze the dough for use later. I'm about to make a massive batch of pizza dough this weekend that I will freeze in individual portions which will last me at least a month (I have pizza at least once a week)

    In general, if it is easy and a lot cheaper to make myself then I will usually do it. Or if I hit upon a magical flavor combo that doesn't exist in stores, like balsamic mayo made with olive oil. Yum.
  • Csuvetmed
    Csuvetmed Posts: 36 Member
    Bread takes no time at all if you do no-knead or stretch-and-fold, the latter being my method of choice. Most of the time, you are ignoring it.

    Homemade broth and soup are definitely worth it. Also draining cheap yogurt to get Greek.

    Yes, agreed! I totally forgot to mention homemade stocks and soups, which is crazy because they're my favorite and most used. I also don't really think tortillas are that time-consuming as others have mentioned, but I also really don't like the texture of store-bought ones, so homemade are worthwhile to me!
  • Mouse_Potato
    Mouse_Potato Posts: 1,513 Member
    My Chuy's knock-off creamy jalapeno ranch dip. It's awesome, but it makes a huge batch which is way more dip than I need to be eating before it goes bad. Plus, I can drive ten minutes and buy an 8 ounce container with a bag of chips for just a couple of dollars. Well worth the trip.
  • kimmymayhall
    kimmymayhall Posts: 419 Member
    I do a lot of baked goods from scratch- bread, pizza, crackers, scones, etc - but specialty things like baguette, croissant, bagels, puff pastry I'll buy. Hamburger buns were a little much. I've made a lot of condiments but mustard never worked out. I haven't attempted butter or yogurt yet. BF used to brew beer but no longer and I'm not interested enough in it myself. I enjoyed making marshmallows, but unless you are doing flavored it seemed more trouble than it's worth. Some candies are worth it though. If something can be made at home without too much special equipment, eventually I'm going to work up enough crazy to attempt it. But sometimes I am lazy.
  • Robin_Bin
    Robin_Bin Posts: 1,046 Member
    Key Lime pie and doughnuts... actually they may not be that hard to make, but I can buy and eat just a single serving, if I made it... I'd eat too much. :wink: So don't tell me if they're easy.
    Actually I used to use the mini graham crusts and put key-lime flavored yogurt in it. Not quite the same thing, but pretty good.
    Unfortunately I know how easy fudge is to make. :sad:
    Another thing I like to let restaurants fuss with (and shouldn't eat often) is eggs Benedict... some restaurants have slightly healthier versions... they still have the Hollandaise sauce, but salmon instead of ham or spinach garnish... yum!
  • TribeHokie
    TribeHokie Posts: 711 Member
    Key Lime pie and doughnuts... actually they may not be that hard to make, but I can buy and eat just a single serving, if I made it... I'd eat too much. :wink: So don't tell me if they're easy.
    Actually I used to use the mini graham crusts and put key-lime flavored yogurt in it. Not quite the same thing, but pretty good.
    Unfortunately I know how easy fudge is to make. :sad:
    Another thing I like to let restaurants fuss with (and shouldn't eat often) is eggs Benedict... some restaurants have slightly healthier versions... they still have the Hollandaise sauce, but salmon instead of ham or spinach garnish... yum!

    I've mastered eggs Benedict (and poached eggs in general) because I crave it too often and usually at random times (read: drunk food). It really isn't too hard once you get the hang of it and if you use a sauce mix.
  • EDesq
    EDesq Posts: 1,527 Member
    Bread: ain't nobody got time fo' that!


    WOW!!! THIS is one of the Most Important things a HEALTHY person should make at home. Buy a Bread Maker, you will soon learn that (1) There are ONLY 6 Ingredients to make Bread (NOT the 15+ in store bought), (2) Real Bread tastes different, it is NOT that chemical laden cotton ball that you buy in those bags. :noway:
  • nyssa1231
    nyssa1231 Posts: 120 Member
    we make bread, yogurt, chutney, pickles, baked goods, dressings, soups, and a lot of other things at home from scratch. it's totally worth it. i'm trying to think of more, but it's 5:30 a.m. :)

    luckily, we have this amazing olive oil and balsamic vinegar store by our house, so the sky's the limit when making salad dressings, roasted veggies in olive oil, etc. i bought a bottle of pre-made salad dressing so i could keep it in the fridge at work, and i thought i was going to vomit when i tasted it. now i just make some dressing for my salad at home and put it in a little container and take that to work with me.

    homemade bread is one of the best things ever! we lived in spain for a long time, and, when we got back, one of the many things i missed was my daily trip to the bakery. here, it's inconvenient to go to a (good) bakery every day, so i learned how to make it at home. we bought a bread maker on craigslist for $20, and we have fresh homemade bread all the time. i'm still working on mastering a basic baguette!
  • Dauntlessness
    Dauntlessness Posts: 1,489 Member
    My husband and I can some food, make microbrew, mead and hard cider, regular apple cider, smoke some meats and make our own sausages. Most of the jams and jellies we make are for Christmas gifts this year. I am going to try to make homemade vanilla extract and some sparking cider too. You wouldn't believe the baskets of food we have planned for friends and family this year...haha

    I highly suggest making your own sausages because big companies put a lot of "body parts" that you wouldn't normally eat in theirs. Same with meat, no nitrates!

    If you have a garden, you can your own tomato sauces, pumpkin puree, pickles, zucchini, soups, jams, jellies, apple butter, apple sauce, salsa, dilly beans, beets, cranberry sauce, ketchup and much more. I know its a pain in the butt but if you take 2-3 weekends to do it, you'll save a ton of cash throughout the year and have organic/good food. The initial investment of the jars isn't too bad. It runs about .70-1.20 a jar depending on how big they are. Once you have them, we are talking like .10-.30 a jar with next years batch.

    I like making my own bread even if its from a mix. The only gluten free bread I like is "Glutino favorite bread mix".

    I am a baker so I make all my own sweets, icing, frosting and cake mixes. Totally worth it once you realize how easy it really is.

    We make our own simple syrup and real brewed tea for drinks throughout the week. I still drink kool aid though...haha

    I made potato chips a few weeks ago! OMG, so much better than normal ones....and super simple. We are talking literally 10-15 minutes to do. http://www.budgetsavvydiva.com/2012/09/homemade-chips-recipe/

    Thats all I got for now.
  • cheddar2000
    cheddar2000 Posts: 43 Member
    Tapioca pudding, I use stevia instead of sugar to keep the carbs lower than the store bought since my honey has diabetes and this is one of the I gotta have it weaknesses. But it is a pain to make so I only make it one in a while.
  • trisH_7183
    trisH_7183 Posts: 1,486 Member
    A shorter list would be ,what is not better home made?
  • SailorKnightWing
    SailorKnightWing Posts: 875 Member
    I work from home so I tend to cook from scratch A LOT. That being said, there are quite a few things I get in packages because they don't taste better enough than packaged to justify the labor involved making them:

    -Most pasta. I have a pasta machine that I haven't mastered and it does taste really good, but it's not for every day because it takes up so much space and makes a mess with the flour. The ravioli is unbeatable, though.

    -Most bread. Things like banana bread or beer bread are nice and easy, but I don't eat bread enough to justify spending the time needed to knead and let rise. I grew up on terrible bread machine bread so I won't eat it anymore. I have a nice bakery 10 minutes away so I tend to get my bread there if I get it at all.

    -Gnocchi. Boy, that takes forever.

    -Spaghetti sauce, kinda. I start with a jar and mess with it until it's unrecognizable.
  • harleygroomer
    harleygroomer Posts: 373 Member
    I do recipes for NON-cooking people and here area few tricks--BREAD?? all stores carry the frozen dough--defrost that puppy and bake your bread, rolls, sweet rolls. Cookies?--it is cheaper to buy a pack and bake them--kids never know the difference. Gravy? Get the pk and make it with half water and half skim milk--people will think you have slaved over it. Mashed Potatoes--use the instant bugs with milk and unsalted butter (always use unsalted butter). And here is my quick quick GO-TO recipe for red beans and rice. One pk of polsa kielbasa chopped up, fry it in a LARGE dutch oven slightly, add 4 cans of kidney beans, 1 cup of salsa, and 4 cans of water. Cook that until hot and serve over rice--get the success bag rice. Corn brad? use a box mix--no one will tell. And my favorite trick for nasty can peas? add a pinch of curry powder as it gives them a sweeter flavor. And the best trik I have for ground turkey is that you MUST stir stir stir while you cook until it is into small grains and then add 1 Tbs of Italian seasoning to it. It is wonderful in lasagna, spaghetti whatever. I prefer turkey now to beef. I have a very busy life, yet like to cook, so I stood back one day and thought around the box on some of these MUST do's for homecooking---is easy.
  • Francl27
    Francl27 Posts: 26,371 Member
    Everything is worth making from scratch, it's just a matter of time. Personally i don't bother making pasta, bread, crackers, tomato sauce etc (plus I'd probably destroy a homemade loaf of bread in 10 minutes and this way I don't have to do math to figure out the calories).
  • Val_from_OH
    Val_from_OH Posts: 447 Member
    I like to cook. I've noticed a few things that are notably cheaper and healthier to make at home. For example: bread and pasta products, all kinds of sauces, pickles, pesto, hummus, roasting a huge hunk of meat and slicing instead of buying deli meats, etc...

    However, I've also found a few things that taste the same as store bought or aren't economical/healthier to make at home. My big ones are butter and Asian dumpling wrappers (homemade are indisputably better, but my time is worth something....maybe will do this more when I have minions...err, I mean, kids.)

    What are your "worth its" and "not worth its"?

    I LOVE to cook, but oh my gosh - almost everything on your list is a not-worth-it for me! Especially the bread and pasta. I buy pasta for $1/lb, and bread for $2/lb. Given that either of these would take me at least 30 minutes to make, I can easily say that my time is worth more than that. I also don't have a pasta machine, and I have proven that I have 0 skills with a rolling pin, so I can't imagine that an endeavor like that would end well...

    Since we don't have a garden (we don't own any property), making homemade tomato sauce, pesto, etc. is really expensive. I do it sometimes as a treat, but not as a cost/time savings.

    The things that I make from scratch are just normal dinner-type foods. Grilled chicken, homemade chicken tenders, long grain rice, stir-fries, sloppy joes, chili, etc,. I try to use as much fresh vegetables as possible, but resort to frozen if I have to, and canned tomatoes. I don't often buy commercial sauces (except lite soy), I'll either make my own or just season with spices. I make my own BBQ sauce sometimes, but it uses ketchup as a base, so I'm not sure if that counts.
  • sumeetg37
    sumeetg37 Posts: 108 Member
    Cut pasta, I'll make sheets no problem, but anything that has to be cut by the pasta roller is out. Took me like 4 hours to deal with a lb of pasta. I can buy fresh pasta for fairly cheap around here. Also anything deep fried. I hate dealing with all the left over oil, I'd rather pay somebody to do it for me. Plus I don't really like my house smelling like a chicken wing for a week after.
  • RivenV
    RivenV Posts: 1,667 Member
    Bread: ain't nobody got time fo' that!
    ea2.gif

    To actually contribute to the conversation, I would say that the daily coffee/tea drinker would be better served by doing this him or herself at home. Not only is it less expensive (usually), but you can also customize your drink to your exact specifications (for those who are so very particular). This takes a lot of the guess work out of logging, as well.
  • padams2359
    padams2359 Posts: 1,093 Member
    I make most things from scratch. Pasta, not so much. I use to, but the machine is a pain to clean. Roasted Red Bell Peppers are definately cheaper to make at home. I buy 5 or 6 large peppers and roast them in the oven. Chop them up, and freeze them in ice cube trays. 1 cube is about 1/2 of a regular size peppers. Store great in the freezer. I have lemon and orange trees. I juice them, and freeze them in ice cube trays. 1 cube is 1/2 lemon. I have juice for healthy marinades all year long. Just opened the last bag from last year. If you do not have trees, buy a large bag of them when they are 10 for a $1. Invest in a food vacuum sealer. I am on my third one in 5 years, and if this one died tomorrow, I would go out and buy a new one. You can save cheese for months. I make very large batches of pasta sauce and use a hand blender on it. Freeze it in various container sizes for pizza sauce or to add to previously cooked ground beef for spagetti sauce. I pop it out of the containers and put it in vacuum bags. No freezer burn. Buy a rib rack, these are the things I buy when I get income tax return, slice them into nice size steaks and vacuum seal. The steaks last for a year with no freezer burn.

    I will never for get the day my son came home from school and came running into the house totally excited. He was about 7. I asked him was was wrong. He said, "Dad, did you know they have mashed potatoes in a box?" I could not help but laugh. He was amazed. I always made them from scratch. I also made all of their baby foods until they were 6 months old. It was easy at that point. That is when you are giving them carrots everyday, then squatch, etc. to check for allergies before moving to something else.
  • Ice cream. Butter. Mustard. Jelly. Wine. Bread. Toothpaste. Body lotion. Ketchup. Cheesecake. Pie. Whipped cream. Souffle. Pickled okra.

    Honestly-once i started growing my own food it has dawned on me that EVERYTHING is better when you make it yourself. So much so, i have sourdough starter and apple cider vinegar i made under my cabinet as i type.

    Getting milk goats and dairy cows ASAP.
  • WinoGelato
    WinoGelato Posts: 13,454 Member
    My Chuy's knock-off creamy jalapeno ranch dip. It's awesome, but it makes a huge batch which is way more dip than I need to be eating before it goes bad. Plus, I can drive ten minutes and buy an 8 ounce container with a bag of chips for just a couple of dollars. Well worth the trip.

    Can you share this recipe? I've been trying to find one. Unfortunately I live a few states away from the nearest Chuy's so I need to find a homemade alternative...
  • Confuzzled4ever
    Confuzzled4ever Posts: 2,860 Member
    Everything is worth making at home.. it tastes better!

    unless you are talking money-wise. then buy nutella, don't make it.
  • chubby_checkers
    chubby_checkers Posts: 2,352 Member
    Just bumping this to remind myself of all the great stuff that I should make. :drinker:
  • Loulady
    Loulady Posts: 511 Member
    51IfsYK5YGL._SX260_PJlook-inside-v2,TopRight,1,0_SH20_.jpg
  • stealthq
    stealthq Posts: 4,298 Member
    Bread: ain't nobody got time fo' that!


    WOW!!! THIS is one of the Most Important things a HEALTHY person should make at home. Buy a Bread Maker, you will soon learn that (1) There are ONLY 6 Ingredients to make Bread (NOT the 15+ in store bought), (2) Real Bread tastes different, it is NOT that chemical laden cotton ball that you buy in those bags. :noway:

    Where are you buying bread? Plenty of purchased choices out there these days without preservatives, etc. Not that I care about how many ingredients are in the food myself, but if that's what you want, you can find it.

    Let me modify what I would have said.

    Nobody who works has time to make the bread and pizza dough that I would want to eat. Oh, and I don't have the right oven, either. I'm not talking quick breads, those I'll make.

    When I want bread, I want crusty baguettes, authentic sourdoughs, ryes, etc. Yes, I am a huge bread snob. You're not making those in any bread machine and have them turn out right. I've made baguettes, and while I can get the flavor right, even with baking stones and steam the texture just isn't the same. Close, but for $3-5 I can get even closer to exact at the market 10min away.

    And the pizza dough is a no-brainer. People spend years developing their own recipes for the pizza doughs I like and need a wood or coal fired oven to bake them right, anyway. For those, I go to the restaurant.
  • FitCurves444
    FitCurves444 Posts: 169 Member
    Sushi.

    Nuff said.