NonGMO Whey Protein not costing out the *kitten*
dafoots0911
Posts: 347 Member
Does anyone know where to purchase a quality whey protein that's not the cost of a mortgage...lol. It's a shame that we have to pay such high prices to NOT consume chemicals.
The ones I've seen are extremely expensive and once you do purchase them they are only half way full.
The ones I've seen are extremely expensive and once you do purchase them they are only half way full.
0
Replies
-
Not sure if serious? Whey protein is from milk --- and I'm pretty certain we don't have genetically modified cows, so all whey is going to be non-GMO.
And, like breakfast cereal, whey is sold by weight, not volume. So yeah, it settles in the package. It's still cheaper per scoop than a steak (though not as tasty).0 -
What do you consider to be expensive? I'm using a great one right now - Jay Robb's whey protein - the vanilla flavor. I got it at GNC for $20 or so...probably cheaper directly from his website or Amazon, but I only use one scoop per day (tehre's 11 servings in a 12-oz bag), it's delicious and is a great protein to use - no sugar, no fat!0
-
Not sure if serious? Whey protein is from milk --- and I'm pretty certain we don't have genetically modified cows, so all whey is going to be non-GMO.
And, like breakfast cereal, whey is sold by weight, not volume. So yeah, it settles in the package. It's still cheaper per scoop than a steak (though not as tasty).
Shhhhhhh, let's still blame Monsanto0 -
I use whey factors double chocolate and have been very happy with it. It's pretty inexpensive on vitacost.com and their shipping is super quick.0
-
Really? Even the cows treated with growth hormones or antibiotics?Not sure if serious? Whey protein is from milk --- and I'm pretty certain we don't have genetically modified cows, so all whey is going to be non-GMO.
And, like breakfast cereal, whey is sold by weight, not volume. So yeah, it settles in the package. It's still cheaper per scoop than a steak (though not as tasty).0 -
Really? Even the cows treated with growth hormones or antibiotics?Not sure if serious? Whey protein is from milk --- and I'm pretty certain we don't have genetically modified cows, so all whey is going to be non-GMO.
And, like breakfast cereal, whey is sold by weight, not volume. So yeah, it settles in the package. It's still cheaper per scoop than a steak (though not as tasty).
What does GMO mean?0 -
Maybe I should have said without the chemical additives and fillers, i.e., aspartame, sucralose, modified whatever or enriched whatever. I know they say small amounts is harmless, but what if you consume 2 to 3 protein drinks a day?0
-
Check on line esp bulk suppliers two are purebulk and truenutrition.0
-
Maybe I should have said without the chemical additives and fillers, i.e., aspartame, sucralose, modified whatever or enriched whatever. I know they say small amounts is harmless, but what if you consume 2 to 3 protein drinks a day?
And the dosage of said ingredients would be?0 -
Thank you. There are artificial flavors. I guess that's just the way it is now.Check on line esp bulk suppliers two are purebulk and truenutrition.0 -
Not sure about the non-GMO piece, but I have used several and prefer Isolates. Best value I have found are products from Body Fortress (I use both the Super Advanced Whey and the Super Advanced Isolate). In the BF Isolate 92% of calories are from protein (30 grams/serving), you get over 35 grams of protein per dollar, and it costs about $0.85/serving. The BF Whey has a lower % calories from protein, but even better cost per serving and cost per gram of protein. Tastes good too.0
-
...and you can get the BF Whey from Walmart ($16 for 2 pounds). I get the BF Isolate from Amazon at $22 for 2 pounds.0
-
Maybe I should have said without the chemical additives and fillers, i.e., aspartame, sucralose, modified whatever or enriched whatever. I know they say small amounts is harmless, but what if you consume 2 to 3 protein drinks a day?
If you are concerned about nutrition you should just maybe have a larger variety of food sources.0 -
I am not using protein for all meal replacements. Some days I have one for breakfast and after working out. I'm just trying to cut out as much of the chemicals in my diet as mentioned before as possible. It seems most protein powders have plenty of artificial ingredients in them. The few times of week I do have a couple of protein shakes, I would like to eliminate the artificial ingredients as much as possible, and I see no nutritional value in those ingredients. I truly believe they do more harm then they could ever do good.Maybe I should have said without the chemical additives and fillers, i.e., aspartame, sucralose, modified whatever or enriched whatever. I know they say small amounts is harmless, but what if you consume 2 to 3 protein drinks a day?
If you are concerned about nutrition you should just maybe have a larger variety of food sources.0 -
I use a soy protein powder it only has the following ingredients: Soy protein isolate, fructose, natural and artificical flavors, and soy lecithin. 20g of protein per serving and only $10 for 14 servings. I drink it mixed with ice coffee.it comes in vanilla and chocolate and available at walmart0
-
Really? Even the cows treated with growth hormones or antibiotics?Not sure if serious? Whey protein is from milk --- and I'm pretty certain we don't have genetically modified cows, so all whey is going to be non-GMO.
And, like breakfast cereal, whey is sold by weight, not volume. So yeah, it settles in the package. It's still cheaper per scoop than a steak (though not as tasty).
The title was "NonGMO". GMO = Genetically Modified Organism. Hormones and antibiotics do not genetically modify the cow.
Any dairy products you consume - unless you specifically source dairy that does not use hormones and antibiotics - is going to potentially contain traces amounts of these compounds in the milk. Or in the meat, if you eat beef.
Most soy (in the USA at least) IS GMO. You can thank Monsanto for that one.
Thing about protein powder is it is by definition a highly processed food. The protein is isolated from the source (milk, soy, eggs, whatever) and dried down. In other words, it is taken away from the hormones, antibiotics, other proteins (like casein) etc. If you get an isolate, it is further purified away from other stuff, and you get more protein per serving. Hydrolysates are even more processed to break the long proteins down to smaller parts.
Thing is, if if you have a pure protein powder, it is pretty much going to taste like crap. They have to add stuff back to it to make it palatable, as well as making sure it will dissolve easily, have a good shelf life etc. Bottom line is - if you are going to have a powder, it is going to have some things added. You are just going to have to read the labels and see what is acceptable to you. And maybe figure out that a little bit of added lecithin to help it resuspend in your blender bottle isn't going to kill you. Or, eat real food.0 -
I use Now Foods Organic Whey Protein. The only ingredients are organic whey and organic soy lecithin (pretty difficult to find one without lecithin, and all the non-organic lecithins, soy or otherwise, *are* GMO as far as I know).
19g protein and 19 servings per container and I don't know what price level is out the *kitten* so I can't comment on that part--I use it more for convenience and not that frequently so cost wasn't as much of a determining factor for me.
Taste-wise, I pretty much have to add some carby goodness to it to make it edible (bananas and chocolate work great).0 -
OMG I love you for posting this! I just bought mine last night and wanted to cry! Not to mention I was already buying groceries at Whole Check (Whole Foods).0
-
Ok, just to FYI - I use ON Gold Standard Whey & Body Fortress - ATLEAST TWICE A DAY, sometimes up to 3 times a day w/ gym use. I drink it w/ unsweetened ALMOND milk & water.
Have been doing this for MONTHS and I'm fine. Peachy.
ON Gold Standard I get online for 27.99 (2lb) 49.99 (5lb) and BF @ Walmart for $16.0 -
Soy lecithin is what OP is probably trying to avoid in the first place.I use a soy protein powder it only has the following ingredients: Soy protein isolate, fructose, natural and artificical flavors, and soy lecithin. 20g of protein per serving and only $10 for 14 servings. I drink it mixed with ice coffee.it comes in vanilla and chocolate and available at walmart
I use Blue Bonnet whey. The 2 lb. tub is about $40. I know, not cheap. It's lasted me a long time, though. (I don't drink it everyday.)0 -
I buy mine at the drug store when it goes on sale. It's usually $15 to $ on sale. Not on sale is like $39. It's called BodyLogix. You should check out the nutrition stores where you live. Sometimes they have stuff on sale and offer discount cards. My brother bought a large container for $19 (without his discount and not on sale it would have been $60). Walmart, Meijer etc sometimes has cheaper stuff.0
-
The title was "NonGMO". GMO = Genetically Modified Organism. Hormones and antibiotics do not genetically modify the cow.
Any dairy products you consume - unless you specifically source dairy that does not use hormones and antibiotics - is going to potentially contain traces amounts of these compounds in the milk. Or in the meat, if you eat beef.
Most soy (in the USA at least) IS GMO. You can thank Monsanto for that one.
Thing about protein powder is it is by definition a highly processed food. The protein is isolated from the source (milk, soy, eggs, whatever) and dried down. In other words, it is taken away from the hormones, antibiotics, other proteins (like casein) etc. If you get an isolate, it is further purified away from other stuff, and you get more protein per serving. Hydrolysates are even more processed to break the long proteins down to smaller parts.
Thing is, if if you have a pure protein powder, it is pretty much going to taste like crap. They have to add stuff back to it to make it palatable, as well as making sure it will dissolve easily, have a good shelf life etc. Bottom line is - if you are going to have a powder, it is going to have some things added. You are just going to have to read the labels and see what is acceptable to you. And maybe figure out that a little bit of added lecithin to help it resuspend in your blender bottle isn't going to kill you. Or, eat real food.
Richard, thank you so much for your response. It makes so much sense to me now and I appreciate you explaining it in terms I could understand. Have a great day.0 -
Been drinkin protein powder since 1991..........I've died 3 times true story0
-
QUOTE:
"Not sure if serious? Whey protein is from milk --- and I'm pretty certain we don't have genetically modified cows, so all whey is going to be non-GMO.
And, like breakfast cereal, whey is sold by weight, not volume. So yeah, it settles in the package. It's still cheaper per scoop than a steak (though not as tasty).
Really? Even the cows treated with growth hormones or antibiotics?"
That would be recombinant bovine somatotropin (rBST), recombinant bovine growth hormone (rBGH), or artificial growth hormone that you are trying to avoid then.0 -
So you want a whey protein but nothing artificial or having chemicals.....................................yet whey protein is a processed product (regardless of brand) and when through a chemical extracting process to do it.
Just to mention that the majority of all protein powders are manufactured by a 3rd party manufacturer with a very high chance that their raw materials are coming from out of the US (usually China) and regulations on the materials are closely watched. So even the "pure" and "clean" protein powders would more than likely have traces of other chemicals that shouldn't be there in the first place.
If you fear artificial chemicals and additives, you're best suited to just eat whole food protein.
From clinical studies, the chemicals you fear don't really pose any threat to health if used in moderation.
A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness industry for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition0 -
Buy your own cow, churn some cream then hit it up in the food processor to separate the butter and whey
Or just buy the cheap stuff and don't worry about it.0 -
Optimum Nutrition has a Natural Whey. Doesn't say nonGMO but doesn't have artificial colors, flavors or sweetners. Thank you all for the responses.0
-
Optimum Nutrition has a Natural Whey. Doesn't say nonGMO but doesn't have artificial colors, flavors or sweetners. Thank you all for the responses.
I get what you're saying -- you just want the best quality protein powder you can get without all the fillers. I use NOW whey protein isolate, unflavored. I put it in shakes usually with spinach or kale, a banana, blueberries, almond milk, and maybe some stevia for sweetness if you need it. But I've also put it in pudding or coffee. It can be pricey when bought in small amounts, but I usually order in bulk on Amazon. :bigsmile: 0 -
Optimum Nutrition has a Natural Whey. Doesn't say nonGMO but doesn't have artificial colors, flavors or sweetners. Thank you all for the responses.
Ah, marketing. How I love you.
Dollar to donuts you do not need to worry about GMO in whey... Or any of that other stuff.
Uses stevia a "natural" sweetener.0 -
Optimum Nutrition has a Natural Whey. Doesn't say nonGMO but doesn't have artificial colors, flavors or sweetners. Thank you all for the responses.
I get what you're saying -- you just want the best quality protein powder you can get without all the fillers. I use NOW whey protein isolate, unflavored. I put it in shakes usually with spinach or kale, a banana, blueberries, almond milk, and maybe some stevia for sweetness if you need it. But I've also put it in pudding or coffee. It can be pricey when bought in small amounts, but I usually order in bulk on Amazon. :bigsmile:
BS.
It has gum and sugars added... Not that it matters.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.2K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 421 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions