Walter White vs Tony Soprano?

Options
NormInv
NormInv Posts: 3,303 Member
edited February 4 in Chit-Chat
Who wins on an all out fight? Im gonna go with Mr White cuz he's got the brains. But Tony had a bigger team.
«1

Replies

  • BigDaddyRonnie
    BigDaddyRonnie Posts: 506 Member
    Hmm....I don't know about that. But I cannot deny the Heisenberg brains. What needs more credit is Tony was not inferior, only more reactive than calculated.
  • mayaocean
    mayaocean Posts: 355 Member
    Tony, why is this even a question? :laugh:
  • DopeItUp
    DopeItUp Posts: 18,771 Member
    Walt of course. With an incompetent idiot for a partner he still took out the biggest drug empire around while running circles around the DEA and the mexican cartel. And hell, singlehandedly took out a neo-nazi camp by himself despite being in the final stages of cancer. Tony's crew would all be dead from ricin poisoning before they even knew there was a battle coming.
  • BigDaddyRonnie
    BigDaddyRonnie Posts: 506 Member
    This is a great question that I have found myself pondering consistently since first reading!

    The biggest difference I see is Tony was known by EVERYONE. Walt/Heisenberg was known only by a select few. Both cause elements of fear in many different ways.
  • taunto
    taunto Posts: 6,420 Member
    Who wins on an all out fight? Im gonna go with Mr White cuz he's got the brains. But Tony had a bigger team.

    Tony Sopranos can make better offense, White can make better defense and with the right timing and supplies make a better offense that will completely own Soprano. But in an all out fight, unless theres ample supplies to make a bomb or something and a warning about the fight happening before hand, Tony will punch white till his bones start looking like granulated salt.
  • NormInv
    NormInv Posts: 3,303 Member
    Tony got emotional. For example, in one episode, he's crying in his car over a girl listening to...oh girl, I'd be in trouble if you leave me now....we never saw such moments with Mr White.
  • CristyinMiami
    CristyinMiami Posts: 61 Member
    I'm all for Walt.
  • NormInv
    NormInv Posts: 3,303 Member
    Who wins on an all out fight? Im gonna go with Mr White cuz he's got the brains. But Tony had a bigger team.

    Tony Sopranos can make better offense, White can make better defense and with the right timing and supplies make a better offense that will completely own Soprano. But in an all out fight, unless theres ample supplies to make a bomb or something and a warning about the fight happening before hand, Tony will punch white till his bones start looking like granulated salt.

    don't mean person to person. Walter apparatus vs Tony apparatus
  • dylanafghjkl
    dylanafghjkl Posts: 76 Member
    Tony got emotional. For example, in one episode, he's crying in his car over a girl listening to...oh girl, I'd be in trouble if you leave me now....we never saw such moments with Mr White.
    WHERE IS THE MONEY SKYLAR???????? WHERE IS THE REST??????
  • calibriintx
    calibriintx Posts: 1,741 Member
    If they're just thrown in an empty room together, Walt is a goner. If they're set up Iron Chef style with supplies to make weapons, poison, smoke screens, etc. to prepare, Tony doesn't stand a chance.
  • AprilMae1975
    AprilMae1975 Posts: 726
    Tony is overweight and Walt has cancer.....head to head I think Tony would take Walt just based on how many times he got beat up in BB. I would be rooting for Walt though.
  • SpookyElectric
    SpookyElectric Posts: 56 Member
    Got to be Walt. Everyone under-estimates him.... he would know Tony's moves before Tony did!
  • caspergirl7
    caspergirl7 Posts: 590 Member
    No contest Walter White!!
  • taunto
    taunto Posts: 6,420 Member
    Who wins on an all out fight? Im gonna go with Mr White cuz he's got the brains. But Tony had a bigger team.

    Tony Sopranos can make better offense, White can make better defense and with the right timing and supplies make a better offense that will completely own Soprano. But in an all out fight, unless theres ample supplies to make a bomb or something and a warning about the fight happening before hand, Tony will punch white till his bones start looking like granulated salt.

    don't mean person to person. Walter apparatus vs Tony apparatus

    Oh like a long-term gang war or something? Walter of course.
  • new_beth_2013
    new_beth_2013 Posts: 109 Member
    Any man who can repeatedly show himself in his tighty whiteys and STILL be Heisenberg wins in my book.
  • arghbowl
    arghbowl Posts: 1,179 Member
    Tony sits on Walter. Game over.
  • PetulantOne
    PetulantOne Posts: 2,131 Member
    Walt of course. With an incompetent idiot for a partner he still took out the biggest drug empire around while running circles around the DEA and the mexican cartel. And hell, singlehandedly took out a neo-nazi camp by himself despite being in the final stages of cancer. Tony's crew would all be dead from ricin poisoning before they even knew there was a battle coming.

    QFT!!
  • Jersey_Devil
    Jersey_Devil Posts: 4,142 Member
    tony. for real?

    tumblr_mkov2xcjCP1rzv2gno1_400.gif
  • NormInv
    NormInv Posts: 3,303 Member
    One point for Tony is that they need showed him in an impossible situation that stretched belief. Walter though came through several situations that were really stretching including last episode.
  • sarantonio
    sarantonio Posts: 880 Member
    As an Italian woman, I am highly offended by the notion of some p*$$¥ chem teacher that cooks meth even being compared. Brains, yes, but too many morals. Siamo Italiano. Siamo como se dice? Oh yeah, badass
  • NormInv
    NormInv Posts: 3,303 Member
    hi
  • sarantonio
    sarantonio Posts: 880 Member
    Uh....me? Hello.
  • PaleoChocolateBear
    PaleoChocolateBear Posts: 2,844 Member
    If we're talking just one on one old fashioned street fight then Tony, but if just sneak attack war using your brain then Walter White because of the **** he knows how to make from bombs to trunk machine guns
  • Alluminati
    Alluminati Posts: 6,208 Member
    As an Italian woman, I am highly offended by the notion of some p*$$¥ chem teacher that cooks meth even being compared. Brains, yes, but too many morals. Siamo Italiano. Siamo como se dice? Oh yeah, badass
    irregardless-thumb.jpg

    Walter White. Cause he's really smart.
  • sarantonio
    sarantonio Posts: 880 Member
    As an Italian woman, I am highly offended by the notion of some p*$$¥ chem teacher that cooks meth even being compared. Brains, yes, but too many morals. Siamo Italiano. Siamo como se dice? Oh yeah, badass
    irregardless-thumb.jpg

    Walter White. Cause he's really smart.

    We hire people to be smart
  • Alluminati
    Alluminati Posts: 6,208 Member
    As an Italian woman, I am highly offended by the notion of some p*$$¥ chem teacher that cooks meth even being compared. Brains, yes, but too many morals. Siamo Italiano. Siamo como se dice? Oh yeah, badass
    irregardless-thumb.jpg

    Walter White. Cause he's really smart.

    We hire people to be smart

    I'm doing this while reading your posts
    italian-speaking-mode-on-meme.jpg
  • sarantonio
    sarantonio Posts: 880 Member
    As an Italian woman, I am highly offended by the notion of some p*$$¥ chem teacher that cooks meth even being compared. Brains, yes, but too many morals. Siamo Italiano. Siamo como se dice? Oh yeah, badass
    irregardless-thumb.jpg

    Walter White. Cause he's really smart.

    We hire people to be smart

    I'm doing this while reading your posts
    italian-speaking-mode-on-meme.jpg


    FYI one hand means you want to eat.... two hands and a shoulder shrug means "what the f@*k are you thinking"
  • NormInv
    NormInv Posts: 3,303 Member
    Walt made more money!
  • NormInv
    NormInv Posts: 3,303 Member
    Both wives were nagging.....behind ever great man is a nagging wife.
  • sarantonio
    sarantonio Posts: 880 Member
    Is it money or power thats the real win?
This discussion has been closed.

Categories