Diet coke and Coke Zero
Replies
-
I prefer the real full calorie, full sugar, full TASTE Coke to the diet mess. But like all other things, it is ok in moderation, but don't go overboard. I wouldn't have a Coke or Mello Yello everyday...I personally have it with my cheat meal during the week.
In addition to all the nasties listed above, the artificial sweeteners also have neurological effects and can actually enhance dementia in people with things like Alzheimer's and Parkinson's. I didn't realize that until someone told me about it last week, and when I looked it up in peer reviewed scientific articles (not just so-and-so said so on the Internet which is 90% crap anyway) I found out it was true. So if it affects people who are already seeing signs of neurological disease, I bet the diet soda crap affects the rest of us too but we just don't see it...
Besides, the real thing tastes better. I would much rather have real sugar than something with so many side affects that losing weight goes to the bottom of my totem pole of issues.0 -
Think about your long term health when drinking chemically sweetened beverages. Here are a couple of articles you might be interested in reading.
Diet drinks increase ones pallet for overly sweetened foods/drinks:
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/39543011/ns/health-diet_and_nutrition/
Health risk of diet and regular sodas:
http://www.reuters.com/article/idUSN2339241420070723
http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/34040.php
I take the articles regarding aspartame causing cancer with a "grain of salt". I on occasion drink diet beverages, maybe 1-3 times a month. I do limit what type of artificial chemicals I put in my body. If it's produced synthetically and there's no nutritional value then your body/liver has to work harder processing these chemicals out of your system. If you are drinking 1-3 diet sodas a day then there's a significant chance for these chemicals to build up in your body. Remember, you can't sacrifice the health of your inside for that of your appearance. Make your inside happy and healthy and it will flow to the outside.
Good luck to you on your journey.0 -
I prefer Coke in My Rum and Coke. Otherwise, I don't drink pop.0
-
Gotta agree with those who talk about the bad chemical sweeteners in diet sodas. From a chemical standpoint, you're actually better off drinking the regular stuff, though obviously it's not a better choice from a weight-loss standpoint. Drinking diet pop and other chemically sweetened drinks may offer you "zero calories," but they do not offer you "zero side effects." These companies want people to stay hooked to their product because it gives them a lifelong customer - same with McDonald's, hence the reason they start marketing their product to children about as soon as they can walk. You say you "cannot" give up the diet sodas, but I have to tell you that those chemicals are not good for your body, and the very best way to hydrate yourself is by drinking a lot of water.
Also - aspartame can affect the hormones that control your appetite, so just an FYI there. It can throw things off balance and make you produce more of the hormone that incites hunger and less of the hormone that tells you that you're full.0 -
Also, an interesting documentary on the topic is called "Sweet Misery." It is all about aspartame and talks about all of the "issues" that went on behind the scenes regarding the government/FDA jumping through hoops to be able to deem it as safe for public consumption. Sounds a little propaganda-ish, but it makes you think.0
-
I drink diet pepsi alot 2-3 cans a day. but i have heard that it can effect your wieght loss something about hte carbs and it keeps u blotted. i know i went 2 weeks without one pop and i felt so different and i lost like 4lbs..but i just can't give it up either i get this really bad headache.0
-
Wow, this topic really scares me. I ONLY drink diet drinks and coffee. After I developed ab eating disorder in 2007, i was too scared to drink anything with calories or sugar, and it just stuck with me. Even though im not as restricting when it comes to my diet, i still cannot get myself to drink anything regular. I just hate how sugary it tastes and it leaves that sugary coated feeling in my mouth. Eugh. Diet pop is just so crisp, fresh, and bubbly. I honestly don't think I will ever give up diet pop. If that's what kills me, so be it I guess haha,. At least I dont smoke cigarettes.0
-
I think diet sodas (and sodas in general) are OK in moderation. As long as you go into something with your eyes open, you can avoid some of the pitfalls.
Caffeine does leach calcium and iron, and other nutrients from your body, so you might want to take a multivitamin or extra supplements.
Also in studies on lab rats, rats that were fed artificial sweeteners were fatter than those who weren't. But that's because they ate more. For some reason, artificial sweeteners increase your craving for sweets, and keep you from getting satisfied. This is one of the reasons why you should drink diet drinks in moderation, and make sure that you are not overly restrictive or overly allowing sugar in your diet.
There are a lot of other small side affects to take into consideration. But as long as you keep it in moderation, it shouldn't hurt you that much. Take it to the extreme, and you'll have to put in a lot of work to compensate.
Caffeine is the most addictive substance known to man (yes, its more addictive than heroine). So if you want to quit all together, you have probably 2 options. Quit cold turkey and feel miserable for about 2 weeks, or slowly wean yourself off.0 -
If it's the bubbles you love and you want to cut back to just one a day, you could drink flavored carbonated water. 0 calories, 0 sodium, 0 sweeteners. I can't stand artificial sweeteners. They have a bitter aftertaste for me, so I drink the carbonated water for my bubble fix (La Croix or Mendota Springs in the US).0
-
If it's the bubbles you love and you want to cut back to just one a day, you could drink flavored carbonated water. 0 calories, 0 sodium, 0 sweeteners. I can't stand artificial sweeteners. They have a bitter aftertaste for me, so I drink the carbonated water for my bubble fix (La Croix or Mendota Springs in the US).
another carbonated water i LOVE is the (gasp) Walmart brand American Clear or whatever it is. They only cost like seventy cents for a bottle with 32oz in it! Key Lime is the BESTTT0 -
another carbonated water i LOVE is the (gasp) Walmart brand American Clear or whatever it is. They only cost like seventy cents for a bottle with 32oz in it! Key Lime is the BESTTT
Doesn't that have artificial sweeteners in it? I have had it in the past, but the aftertaste kills me.0 -
I was JUST researching this issue the other day. I think there are studies on both sides. I decided to cut out diet sodas 3 weeks ago because I thought it was worth a try. I also cut out alcohol and fast food. I work out 5 days a week, sometimes a 'work-out' is just walking my dog. I've lost 7-8 lbs in three weeks following this strategy. I think it basically boils down to 'eat less, move more.'
Something that helped me kick my coke zero habit (2-3 a day) was the crystal light packets you put in water. Also, the Nestea Diet Green tea is really good. Target has Sugar Free Hawaiin Punch packets in their dollar aisles so I stock up on those b/c the Crystal Lights are expensive!
Another tip is try to hold off on drinking the diet soda during the day (or limit your drinking) and then let yourself have it at night as a 'dessert.' That way you're tricking your body into thinking it's getting something good and you feel satisfied and are less likely to crave a sweet.
Disclaimer: I'm NOT a professional trainer or health expert, I'm just your average joe and these seemed to help me and I thought I'd share just in case! (this is the first time I've ever 'blogged' before, sorry if it's long!)0 -
I am a Diet Coke fanatic too and used to drink 2 or 3 a day. But it definitely makes me a lot hungrier. Since the beginning of October, I have been allowing myself 1 non-water beverage a day, whether that be a Diet Coke, a coffee from Starbucks or a beer. On top of that I have been making myself drink at least 8 glasses of water a day. I find that the water really curbs my appetite and I have been feeling so much healthier since I quit drinking so much soda.
It's kind of a weird system, but it really works for me0 -
i love diet pepsi...0
-
For me, coke zero:
- helps my craving for sweet things
- fills me up when I'm hungry in between meals so I can last until dinner time
- gives me something zero cal to drink whenever out with friends who are all drinking alcohol
- is my 2 or 3 times weekly 'treat' to make me feel good
and there I was, thinking I was being good avoiding the sugar that would rot my teeth... but sigh, it's the carbon now is it?
Darn. Might have to cut down and give up on Coke Zero eventually...sigh haha.0 -
I say one step at a time. Get to where you are able to manage your new dieting routine first, then start to cut back on them, then only allow yourself to have it once in awhile. I have actually found that after almost 4 weeks I don't really crave coke zero like I used to, weird huh? I have started putting bottled water in the freezer for 30 mins and the ice cold water is a nice treat to have.
Anyway - I think your reasoning for drinking it is sound.....although all the chemicals in it really isn't good for the body - but what IS good for the body nowadays!0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions