How often to weigh?

2»

Replies

  • shapefitter
    shapefitter Posts: 900 Member
    I only own a set of kitchen scales.
  • aklove907
    aklove907 Posts: 118 Member
    I like to weigh once a week on Saturday morning before I eat breakfast. I like seeing more of a change! Good luck in your loss!
  • Naomi0504
    Naomi0504 Posts: 964 Member
    Every single day, it's a habit :smile:
  • mollyb1018
    mollyb1018 Posts: 17
    Once a week for me! Saturday mornings. :o) I can fluctuate between 3-5 lbs. per day. It's nuts! So, I like to weigh once a week under the same set of circumstances to get an accurate idea of how I'm doing. I used to be obsessive about it, NOT GOOD! Drove me nuts.
  • NyssaDuck
    NyssaDuck Posts: 50
    I weigh every single day after I've woken up (I can't say morning, sometimes I don't wake up in the am) and have been to the bathroom. Always naked, on the same tile and all. It doesn't bother me seeing fluctuations though I don't see many of them. I've started only officially recording once a month however (on the 29th, along with measurements).
  • qtgonewild
    qtgonewild Posts: 1,930 Member
    when i first wake up and again before bed. weigh in here every monday.
  • achaye
    achaye Posts: 3
    once a week. Every Saturday morning after the gym and after using the washroom and before breakfast
  • Deborah100660
    Deborah100660 Posts: 45 Member
    You should weigh yourself no more than weekly. Daily weight can fluctuate with fluid weight. Weekly is more accurate. Pick a day, weight yourself first thing in the morning, wearing the same thing (underwear etc). Monitor the changes in your body and not the number on the scale. Measure and record your body measurements. Do this monthly to see changes. You can also get an inexpensive pair of body fat calipers to monitor the changes in your body fat. I am 5'5" and at my most fit was a size 4, but I weighed 150 pounds. My body fat was 16% which is low. At the time, I was body building. 22% body fat is a healthy body fat for most females. I weigh 153 now and am a size 8, my body fat is 20%. You can see by the changes in my weight and body fat that I gained inches when I stopped working out regularly. What you really want to lose is body fat and to gain muscle. Muscle burns more calories. The number on the scale doesn't mean a whole lot. You can add me as a friend if you wish.

    Deborah Berger
  • SilverclawMoonmist
    SilverclawMoonmist Posts: 5 Member
    My advice to you would be once a week, after using the bathroom and before you've eaten anything. Personally I weigh in every Saturday, that way I can kind of gauge how I've done overall for that week. Weighing yourself every day may cause unnecessary anxiety or depression because your weight can fluctuate between 2 and 3 pounds a day. As far as appearance, it is also helpful to pay attention to waistline and other measurements, such as around the thighs, hips, and butt. This way you are not going solely by the numbers on the scale (because, I'm sure you know already, muscle weighs more than fat), and mistakenly thinking that you have gained fat, when in reality you have traded in that fat for muscle. I wish you luck on your weight-loss journey, and no matter what the scale says, be confident. It really does help with weight-loss believe it or not :)
  • ihammen
    ihammen Posts: 55 Member
    every time I'm in the vicinity of the scale, haha. I only count the first one in the morning though.
  • FreyasRebirth
    FreyasRebirth Posts: 514 Member
    I only really have 15 lbs to lose, and I'd probably be happy if only 10 came off. I tried the whole never weighing myself, that's how I gained the weight without noticing it. I thought I had gained a "few" pounds (3-4) when I had really added a dozen. I'm not really sure how many I should expect to lose in a week.

    I also measured myself today and remember my waist and hip measurements from a few years ago. At the minimum I'd like to lose enough around my thighs and hips be able to wear the clothes I already own. It sucks wearing maternity clothes and pajama pants all of the time.
  • toholio
    toholio Posts: 46 Member
    I only own a set of kitchen scales.

    Then you're going to have to portion yourself out and weigh each section.

    On the plus side, cutting your legs off results in permanent weight loss.
  • AndyOSC
    AndyOSC Posts: 3 Member
    Daily weighing is probably the worst thing you could do for your self confidence, just because of how much your weight can fluctuate based on random things.

    I can't agree. Since making it a part of my morning routine it's become just another part of the day. I know if I've eaten too much (calorie-wise) the day before, and I can sort of predict the results.

    ...though I might skip weighing if I had a particularly excessive cheat day the day before. ;)
    Then you're going to have to portion yourself out and weigh each section.

    On the plus side, cutting your legs off results in permanent weight loss.

    HA!
  • IsaacHudson
    IsaacHudson Posts: 33 Member
    I strongly disagree with the notion that weighing yourself weekly helps balance out fluctuations.

    Logically, weighing yourself more often is the best way to deal with fluctuation.
  • toholio
    toholio Posts: 46 Member
    I strongly disagree with the notion that weighing yourself weekly helps balance out fluctuations.

    Logically, weighing yourself more often is the best way to deal with fluctuation.

    Indeed. If you weigh weekly you're just as likely to weigh on a day with an upward fluctuation and those fluctuations can be as big as an entire weeks weight loss. If you weigh daily you can actually see the fluctuations.

    I can see why people who get obsessive don't want to weigh daily but there's nothing wrong with it if you aren't prone to that.

    Another option is to get some fancy wifi scales. Since they log the weight online automatically you don't have to think about it as much. Some mornings I get on the scales, get weighed, then get off again without actually looking at the number.
  • 424a57
    424a57 Posts: 140 Member
    I strongly disagree with the notion that weighing yourself weekly helps balance out fluctuations.

    Logically, weighing yourself more often is the best way to deal with fluctuation.
    HackDiet.png

    I agree. Here is an example. You can see the daily weight measurements fluctuate quite a bit, but math smooths it out. If I just looked at the first and the last, they are the same. But, looking at the trend shows progress. Sometimes see that progress is the only thing that keeps me doing the next day.
  • albertine58
    albertine58 Posts: 267 Member
    I jump on the scale like twice a day! It's unnecessary obviously, but I do it when I get up and when I get home at the end of the day- if I don't sleep well I retain water in the morning, so I sometimes see a lower number in the evening. It motivates me so I do it!

    I track my daily weight on www.skinnyr.com. I like seeing all of my body's fluctuations- it helps me understand water weight, sodium and alcohol's effect on body water levels, etc. I feel more in tune with my body! Even though I'm not thrilled when I see a higher number, I don't get upset because I know I've been doing everything right; I know my loss will show up on the scale within a few days.

    If I only weighed once a week, I'd feel like my entire existence boiled down to that number on that one Wednesday or whatever- which is silly! I think that would make me MORE obsessive. Now I hop on the scale, if there's a loss, YAY, if not, I carry on with my day and think, "I'm sure I'll lose a little by tonight or tomorrow!" It keeps me motivated- I get excited even over 0.2 lbs which I think is a good thing.
  • Goal179
    Goal179 Posts: 314 Member
    I asked this same question a couple of weeks ago and I got a bunch of different answers. Honestly, a case can be made for all three methods, never weighing-just measuring and taking pictures, weighing once a week and weighing daily. So I do a combination of all three. I weigh myself every day and track it just to see how I am trending and to get an idea of how food is moving in and out of my body. Going up in weight from day to day can help me understand if I am taking in too much salt also. But once a week, on Sundays, I do my official weigh in that I actually record on MFP to determine my actual weight loss. I also take pictures every two weeks and I measure every two weeks. I get motivation from all three sources. BUT I will say this, if you are like me and tend to "freak out" when your weight fluctuates up a little bit, you better skip weighing daily because it could be discouraging. Hope that helps.
This discussion has been closed.

Categories