Hard time eating 1,200
lastfingtime
Posts: 6
Hello! I made this account a while ago but havent used the community forums and really havent lost too much weight (just a pound or two). One of the reasons for this is I have a really hard time eating under 1,200. Its just too little for me to function off of! So I changed my settings under my goals from losing 2 pounds a week to losing 1 pound a week. I thought cutting my weekly goal in half would mean I'd get to eat a bit more, but mfp is still saying I should eat 1,200 per day if I want to lose only one pound per week! I dont get it. If I change my goal, shouldnt my caloried change? I am thinking something is wrong with mfp's computing system? I'd love to figure out a way to eat a bit more and still lose weight. Basically every day I end up going over 1,200, and then I feel like such a failure that I went over I count the day as "lost" and just eat whatever I want. I delete all my entries for the day and tell myself I'll start over tomorrow. Gah. I'm terrible at this.
0
Replies
-
Try to drink more water it will help you feel fuller and eat things with High Protein Like nuts or Lean meats.
I try eating eggs in the morning, and that helps me to feel fuller.
also if your having a hard time staying with in calorie range, see if its because the meals you choose will put you over you want to save at lease 300calories for snacks jic you get hungry.
and have most of your meals around 300 calories.
dont be mad at your self for going over this is a proces and it takes time to get used to!
keep logging and keep up the good work!0 -
Someone who is only looking to lose 16 lbs should be aiming for .5lbs lost per week.
Also, the lowest MFP will recommend is 1200. So even if you needed to eat 800 calories per day to lose 2lbs per week, MFP would still recommend 1200 calories since that is the lowest that is generally considered "healthy" (though this is debatable). That is why it didn't change when you upped your calories.0 -
Thanks for the reply- I should have mentioned I'm a vegetarian. Eating meat isn't something I will ever do (I know this complicates things). I have a hard time finding a whole meal that is under 300 calories- most of mine are 500 calories meaning I only get two meals a day and then a couple hundred are for "snacks," like one apple or one banana. Im so hungry eating this way.0
-
ok thanks,mcroew1016- I didnt know this. That explains why it didnt up my calories0
-
Have you lost weight at all? Depending on your height and daily activity level, you could probably eat more than 1200 calories and still be able to lose weight. The key is to be patient.0
-
Even if you don't eat meat, nuts, beans and whey protein are good ways to get protein in.
Full disclosure, 1500 is super hard for me. I don't think I could ever to 12000 -
Try using this website to calculate your calories. It might give you something more realistic!
http://scoobysworkshop.com/accurate-calorie-calculator/#results
0 -
The calories MFP recommends is based on the info you put in. You probably put sedentary as your activity level, which you are likely not. Also, you should be eating back 1/2 to all your exercise calories. Add me if you like.0
-
Try using this website to calculate your calories. It might give you something more realistic!
http://scoobysworkshop.com/accurate-calorie-calculator/#results
^^^THIS!0 -
I have actually had this app, different accounts (deleting then getting back). I've had this one for a while now, and my eating habits have never been like they are now (recently) i'm suddenly less able to control what i eat haha. if i just want to maintain my weight (as i dont really want to lose any) at 8 stone which is what i am now, how many calories do you think i can eat? I've set it to 1200 but I've been eating more like 1400 a day this week or 2. I am 5 foot 50
-
Hello! I made this account a while ago but havent used the community forums and really havent lost too much weight (just a pound or two). One of the reasons for this is I have a really hard time eating under 1,200. Its just too little for me to function off of! So I changed my settings under my goals from losing 2 pounds a week to losing 1 pound a week. I thought cutting my weekly goal in half would mean I'd get to eat a bit more, but mfp is still saying I should eat 1,200 per day if I want to lose only one pound per week! I dont get it. If I change my goal, shouldnt my caloried change? I am thinking something is wrong with mfp's computing system? I'd love to figure out a way to eat a bit more and still lose weight. Basically every day I end up going over 1,200, and then I feel like such a failure that I went over I count the day as "lost" and just eat whatever I want. I delete all my entries for the day and tell myself I'll start over tomorrow. Gah. I'm terrible at this.
Do not eat under 1200, please. Eat. Eat healthy. You're not meant to eat under 1200, especially if you're working out. Please. I'm 5'1" on a good day and consume around 1500 calories, some days more. Hell, I probably should be consuming even more with how much I work out. Your body needs the fuel. I used to think less calories would help me lose, but really it's just a slower unhealthy progression.
Check out info on your BMR and TDEE for how much you should be eating:
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/931670-bmr-and-tdee-explained-for-those-needing-a-guide
Also,
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/1115782-i-eat-1700-and-lost-weight-real-results0 -
Sometimes 1200 calories just isn't for everyone. Or counting calories for that matter. For me, staring at the computer and plugging in my food all the time actually made me more hungry because I was constantly thinking about food. I would tend to then go over my "goal" intake, feel like I failed myself, and gorge in whatever. Like you, I would say, "I'll try again tomorrow" but they cycle continued and I'd have a good week, then a bad week, then a bad week, then an ok week.....It wasn't working for me. I decided to only log my weight and exercise and eventually just my weight.
I am also a vegetarian, well moving towards vegan, and so I understand what you mean when you say it's hard to put meals together. It's definitely a process and takes time. For me, my biggest success has come from mostly cutting out animal products (I eat cheese, etc but only a tiny amount and not everyday). Usually I eat as many fruits as I want until I'm full (for breakfast, usually in the form of 30-48 oz of fruit smoothies), a huge salad for lunch (whole head of romaine, handful of spinach, handful of mixed greens, green onion, 1/2 pint of grape tomatoes, small zucchini and 1/2 cucumber) with 2T of what ever dressing I want (thinned out with about 2T water). By dinner I'm usually still full and grab a tea saucer as my dinner plate. I fill it with whatever is for dinner and as much as will fit on that tiny plate and enjoy. I probably eat around 2000 cals with minimal organized exercise and continue to lose weight. I think for my body, it understands clean, whole foods better and so the body spends less time digesting the food, giving it more time to burn fat, even if I'm not doing much.
Those are just some of the things I have done and seen success. I have an idea of what the calories are, but I don't physically input them. If your body is telling you you're hungry after 1200 cals, then you probably are. Fill up on F/V and don't worry about their calorie content. No one has ever gotten fat eating fruits and veggies.
Good luck. You will find what works for you and when you do, the weight will fall off.0 -
thank you0
-
Not knowing what you are eating, I can only suggest you check your portion size on your rice, potatoes and pastas. If you're used to eating large portions of starches as fillers, it could be disproportionate to your proteins and fats, which are what is going to make you feel satiated.0
-
I'm veggie too and eat 1200 plus some of my exercise calories. Things like stir fries or eggs and mushrooms fill me up. I always have 3 meals and a snack.
I struggle to balance calories if I eat pasta or rice portions or have wine.0 -
Hi I'm Beth and I just got back on this site after being off it for 6 months. I've lost a total of 18 lbs and have another 30 lbs to go to be at my goal.
I started drinking a lot of water and now I go to the gym 4 days per week. I also have trouble eating all of the calories0 -
aim for .5lb a week. What about exercise do you do any? If so do you eat back any exercise calories, that can help.0
-
I find that eating enough protein and fat is key to staving off hunger. I don't really watch my macro totals, but I find that I'm consistently over the recommendation for fats and proteins and under the recommendation for carbs, and I do just fine at 1200 calories. I'm a lazy b____, so I don't exercise, so it's a reasonable tally for me. And some days I might go up to 1300 if I just want another snack. When I eat too many carbs, it just makes me hungrier. I don't avoid them entirely though, I'm not doing Atkins or anything.0
-
and exercise. 1200 is your baseline, if you exercise 100, 200, 300, 400 calories a day, you get to eat those. So an aerobics class for an hour gives you almost 500 extra cals to eat bringing you up to 1700.0
-
When I changed my weekly loss from 2 pounds to 1 pound it actually switched to 1420 or 1570 kcals - I can't recall which was, because it depends on the level of activity you set either.
If you're at the beginning 1200 might be way too little, try eating 1500 and it should work. You're still at a deficit, no way you could gain weight.
Anyway I'm also a vegetarian, if you need any idea for less than 500 kcals meals!0 -
If you're looking for good protein sources that are veggie I recommend FAGE 0% greek yogurt or Chobani.
I get about 10 170g tubs of Fage every week and ALWAYS use them. In one 170g pot there is 97 calories, 4g carbs/sugars and 18g of protein!! It tastes great too
Anyway 1200 is quite low, thats what it gave me and I custom set mine to 1440 which is much easier. I have a binge eating disorder and 1200 would make me binge every week.0 -
Thanks for all the replies. I've decided to ignore mfp suggestion and manually up my calories to 1,400. 1,200 really just isnt working for me. As for the questions about settings I had it set at moderatly active and my goal was to lose 1 pound a week. I realize at 1,400 calories i'll lose slower but that is fine with me as long as it is working!! As far as excersze I usually do yoga 3-4 times a week for 1 and 1/2 hrs, but acording to mfp that only burns about 160 calories, so its really not a calorie-significant excersize. I do it more for the mental benefits.0
-
I also started on 1,200, thinking mfp advice was accurate and calculated and educated. I dropped water weight fast, but was ravenous, angry, dehydrated, tired and 'fluey'. It was ****e.
After lots and lots of reading I used scooby calculator to work out my TDEE (google it)- and now eat TDEE-20%. It's ALOT more than 1,200, but I also came to the quick realisation that eating isn't failure, that 'dieting' shouldn't be punishment and that this is something I need to sustain forever- I'm not going to sustain 1,200 forever, that's for sure.
Also, I looked at my macros and protein- I was also vegetarian, but have since started reintroducing some fish back into my diet- protein shakess, zero fat chobani greek yoghurt, eggs and quinoa are things I eat EVERY day- eating protein satisfies me and I find I eat less and more healthily over all.
Don't do your body an injustice by eating 1,200. Eat more, exercise, lift heavier, build muscle, burn fat!0 -
It looks like this person gave up, the account is now showing as deactivated.0
-
I really like to eat. The more I exercise the more I can eat. If you eat healthy food such as fruits and vegetables you can almost eat so much you will pop and not worry about it.
See, I know this but I too enjoy the burgers and fries and pizza. I am just getting started but it is gonna be worth it to feel good and I can still have goodies within reason but stick with good choices the majority of the time.0 -
On my low cal days, I set the goal of hitting bodyweight in protein (very filling), starting mainly with protein source and vegetable (2 cups of spinach is only 20 cal). After imputing that and calculating, plus exercise there is always leftover calories. Use the leftover for fun stuff, and take a multi vitamin in case I missed anything. For instance a chicken breast is approx 200 cals, this means you could eat five plus a salad with each meal (without adding in earned exercise calories). That is probably way more then you want to eat, so lets say 3 meals with a protein vegetable base, approx. 700 calories, leaving 500 to play with (without exercise added). When on a low cal day, watch out for fruit, bread, and high fat, it will zap your calories without being very filling. That being said, I recently had a philly cheese steak on a low cal day, Just make it fit. Dieting doesn't have to be miserable. That works for me, maybe it will help you. Best of luck reaching your goals0
-
I've been trying to eat 1200 calories for 2 weeks. I end up at 1400-1600calories. Haven't lost a lb.0
-
Pack your meals with protein. Protein is what fills you up. There are a lot of vegetarian protein alternatives. Try finding a vegetarian fitness group on Facebook or something for great ideas and motivation. I started using Herbalife back in May and have had great success with it. And now that my stomach is smaller, it's easier to not over eat and my food selections are healthier because ice learned about better nutrition along the way.
When you go over on calories, use that as motivation to up your activity. Get a pedometer so you can track all of your activity and log it. You'd be surprised at how much you burn with just regular walking around (to the printer at work, the bathroom, etc). We don't log that type of activity and so we forget about it. I just got a Fitbit and was surprised how much I burn just by living. Lol
You're off to a great start by posting here and asking questions. You can do it, stay confident in yourself!0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions