Help please - not losing

Hi

I've been logging on MFP for 50 days now and I'm not seeing any changes in my appearance or weight loss. I was hoping for a bit of advice (not too harsh) on what to do and whether anyone else is in the same boat. I'm by no means giving up but I am disappointed at my results.

I'm 5'4" 58.5kg

I run once a week, swim once a week and have started stronglifts 4 weeks ago which I'm doing 3 times a week

My net calories is set at 1200 but I just eat when I'm hungry. I'm not usually that far from 1200 but I have recently starting to eat 1300-1400 cals (unless I'm having a bad day!!!)

I have recently changed my macros but I'm not yet achieving that. I do know that my sugar is on the high side - so this could be the cause.

I have lost 0.5 kg so far which is quite poor but I thought if my appearance improves then I wouldn't be as bothered about the scale. But neither is shifting.

I have opened my diary which I don't normally do so please take a look

Thank you

Replies

  • Jacquit1980
    Jacquit1980 Posts: 10 Member
    are you drinking enough? i cant see many drinks on your diary, increase your water intake, and increase your protein it is harder for your body to digest so has to work hard and with training you are probably toning up and muscle weighs more than fat, i measeure my self every week as well so if i dont lose lbs i lose inchs :)
  • Jit7
    Jit7 Posts: 75
    Thanks for replying cakeys

    I drink mainly water which I don't always log

    Granted I could drink more but I don't think I am dehydrated, which you can normally tell by the colour of your urine.

    I will try to drink more to see if that makes a difference

    I am not measuring myself but my clothes fit exactly the same....a bit too snug!!!

    I was thinking about the muscle theory but I've only been lifting for 4 weeks. I can't really build significant muscle in that time. Plus I'm still on light ish weights. Heavy for me though
  • albertine58
    albertine58 Posts: 267 Member
    Start taking measurements - if you're doing everything right, you're probably losing inches but not pounds on the scale because you're building muscle. You're already at the midpoint of your healthy weight range for your height (I know because I'm 5' 4" too!) so expect any fat loss to be very slow. I imagine you're already quite trim and trying to improve your physique, but the benefits from your workouts won't be as great if you're in a high calorie deficit. Read articles about building muscle as a female- many will tell you to eat 150-200 calories OVER your maintenance calories (probably ~2000) with a lot of protein and see what happens to your physique. You'll get much more muscle-building benefit from your workouts. This is what most bikini competitors seem to do! I don't think you should be focusing on weight loss- rather track your macros and focus on fueling for building muscle. Then you'll start to see those muscles poke through soon enough!
  • melaniecheeks
    melaniecheeks Posts: 6,349 Member
    What are your goals? You're already at a healthy weight, so any more losses WILL be slow. If it's shape you're more concerned about, up your strength training.
  • Jit7
    Jit7 Posts: 75
    Yes I do have a healthy BMI but I think (not tested) my body fat is on the high side - too many wobbly bits. Hate my stomach and thighs.

    I would be happy if I don't lose kg's but my clothes fit better but not seeing that yet. I guess I will measure just incase I have even a cm win!

    I don't think I am trim - I would never wear a bodyfit dress due to too many bulges and hate the bikini on me

    I just read that lifting heavier weights would reduce the body fat but perhaps its still too early after just 4 weeks of lifting. I increased my protein level but struggling to reach that at the moment.

    Thanks for your advice
  • iceqieen
    iceqieen Posts: 862 Member
    My net calories is set at 1200 but I just eat when I'm hungry. I'm not usually that far from 1200 but I have recently starting to eat 1300-1400 cals (unless I'm having a bad day!!!)

    I think you answered your own question. If your target is X and you are eating Y then you are not hitting your target. Log everything you eat accurately (use a foodscale) and stick to your target for at least a few weeks, then reconsider targets..
    I have recently changed my macros but I'm not yet achieving that. I do know that my sugar is on the high side - so this could be the cause.

    Focus on getting your protein and fats in, then worry about the rest. You are at a healthy weight so what you are looking to do is shift the weight from fat to muscle, not lose a bunch of weight.. protein + lifting is your best friend in that regard.


    On your target calorie number, I agree with albertine58 that you should reconsider the number. If you are not ready to build, at least consider eating at maintenance and focus on fitness. Your clothes will start to feel looser if you are making progress in fitness.
  • Jit7
    Jit7 Posts: 75
    @ Melanie

    My weight goal is 50kg which I think for my structure would be ok

    Appearance wise, my goal is quite usual. A toned body with flat tummy. I don't necessarily want big muscles but it would be nice to change from my "pipe cleaners" as my husband calls my arms. Thats from no upper body strength!

    Fitness wise, I don't really have specific goals. Just to have stamina to run/swim and be able to lift a decent amount

    Yes that it is what I read too that strength thraining improves shape. This is why I started stronglifts 4 weeks ago. I am doing 3 workouts a week. Started light and slowly working my way up.
  • One very glaring thing I see is you are not getting enough protein on ANY day the past week. At first as you start exercise, you should be building muscle and not seeing much in the way of loss is typical. Not eating enough protein could stretch this phase out a lot longer, never allowing your muscles to recouperate adequately. I would add another daily session of some kind of aerobic exercise, maybe just walking 30mins/day and then eat those calories in protein additions to every meal, maybe an egg with your oatmeal, larger portion of chicken, add a small tin of sardines or fish in there somewhere, cottage cheese with a meal, or a whey protein shake addition, just make sure to make your protein goals at least when you are increasing exercise. What do you do for 87 calories/day btw is that walking? Cornflakes every breakfast I consider kind of junk food btw, and switching to something like oatmeal and an egg, or cottage cheese, would give you a lot more protein and not shift calories too much so you may not even have to increase exercise much or at all to stay even.

    You are also not eating all your calories, I think I counted an additional 500 calorie deficit roughly in the weeks I looked at, which in addition to the lack of protein could also stall you (too high a deficit while trying to build).

    As always, double checking your settings, and weighing your portions is also important when you are trying to find the issue.
  • Jit7
    Jit7 Posts: 75
    @ iceqieen

    Thanks for your advice

    I was closely following the 1200 level for the first 2-3 months and nothing changed. Then lost 0.5kg when I started stronglifts and then nothing since

    I am logging everything that I eat as accurately as possible its just the water intake that I sometimes forget. I log even when having a bad day. I just haven't changed the net calorie level. Not sure whether I should change it to 1300 or 1400. Using the calculators that have been recommended, my light workout level is at 1700 calories so eating at around -15%. I'm not sure if I have done this correctly.

    Ok so I will try to have more protein. I have bought a choc protein shake powder but I'm not a big fan of it. I do struggle to eat a lot of natural protein but will start to increase that

    Thanks again
  • Jit7
    Jit7 Posts: 75
    @ solong.. (sorry long name)

    Thanks for looking at my diary

    Protein is definitely my weakness. I really struggle. I will definitely be increasing that however I can.

    Cornflakes has been my cheat breakfast for a while. I do try to have porridge for breakfast with honey and cinnamon (yum) but a) run out of time and b) its getting hot in Brisbane so the cold milk is better. Thats no excuse though - I will change this.

    The 87 cals is just 10 minutes warmup on the eliptical before I start the stronglifts workout.

    Do you guys think if I changed my net cals to 1300 it would be ok?
  • melaniecheeks
    melaniecheeks Posts: 6,349 Member
    Good protein sources;

    meat
    fish
    chicken
    eggs
    Greek yoghurt
    cheese, especially cottage cheese
    beans and pulses
    nuts.

    Try yoghurt and berries for breakfast - add some flaxseed.
  • melaniecheeks
    melaniecheeks Posts: 6,349 Member
    Oh, and after having a look at your diary, make sure that the items you're choosing from teh database are correct - there's rice and potatoes in there showing as zero carbs.
  • _Zardoz_
    _Zardoz_ Posts: 3,987 Member
    You're eating more than to think. Check your logging. Weigh and measure everything
  • EvgeniZyntx
    EvgeniZyntx Posts: 24,208 Member
    First I noticed that your logging suggests that you are not weighing your food. Try that to assure that your bowl of cereal is 70g and not 90g, etc. these things add up.

    Second, you are close to objective. Changes will be slow. Accept it and work with that. They will come. Promise.

    Third, Stronglifts is a great program but you are just learning during the first months. Take pictures now, you will see a difference but it takes time. Take pictures. Progressive loading to an effective weight, if you are doing SL correctly takes 2-3 months. Oh, and did I tell you to take pictures? Yeah, the mind lies.

    Fourth, changing your calories should be fine, going up a hundred should not make a large difference either way, it should be at a level that you do not struggle to meet and that you can be consistent long term - so even 200-300 higher makes sense, especially if you are active and want to work on performance in your activities. Note - weight will fluctuate. Don't panic.
    Good luck.
  • Jit7
    Jit7 Posts: 75
    @ melanie

    I didn't realise that I had chosen items like that - good spot
    I did an elimination diet for my skin prior to starting mfp and I was eating a lot of eggs for protein. It helped with sugar cravings too. I kind of got sick of them but will put them back in regularly.

    @ fatdoob

    Thanks for replying - I will make more effort to be accurate

    @EvgeniZyntx

    Yes I comfortable that it will be slow. As long as it happens!! I hate taking pictures, makes me feel crap, but if it helps to see differences I will just have to pluck up the courage

    I have checked my form and had a bit of help with SL from my husband and the PT at the gym. I've had to correct a few things but think I'm on track

    I think I should change the net calories on my profile. I will see how that goes.

    Thanks
  • Snow3y
    Snow3y Posts: 1,412 Member
    Have you been eating back calories that you burnt from exercise?
  • Snow3y
    Snow3y Posts: 1,412 Member
    looking at your diary... You only get in 4-5g of fiber a day? That's really really not good, the average female should get in at LEAST 15-20g a day, focus on eating carbs that are unprocessed and whole.. Such as whole wheat bread, whole wheat pasta, allbran flakes etc
  • Jit7
    Jit7 Posts: 75
    @Tyronne

    I will monitor my fiber intake. However i have to say i only eat wholewheat or wholegrain bread, high fibre pasta and even brown rice. I eat fresh not processed ready meals. Fussy husband so cook most days from scratch unless we're eating our

    Will monitor though

    Thanks