1200 cals of junk (outta control pms)

I know some will be annoyed with this question, sorry. But I had been staying at my 1200 cals and doing well. That is until That Time Of The Month came around. I am out of control with the junk, but still keeping under 1200 cals. Weird I know.
I'm going from a warm brownie, to chocolate milk, to ritz crackers to more chocolate milk. I know this will pass as it always does at this time. And it's hard to weigh myself now because of bloating.

My stupid question is will staying under the calories matter if it is junk food? I am well aware this is counter to everything necessary to be healthy, but I am like a mad woman with food at this time. Does anyone else feel it is more difficult to stay on track at TTOTM?

Replies

  • JoRocka
    JoRocka Posts: 17,525 Member
    nope.

    that's the technical answer. Doesn't matter what you eat- as long as you are under.

    NOW. here's the rub.

    It's MUCH MUCH harder to stay under calories when you eat "junk" food. You aren't filling your body with stuff it can utlize- it's typically lop sided- carb sugar crap- so by the end of the day you're still hungry and need some protein.. and then you eat more- because you're still needing something.

    When I get sick- all I want is soup- grilled cheese- and then ice cream. I want NOTHING else. And I do my best to stay at/around calories- but it's harder because my diet is less balanced than normal.

    As long as you are only eating 1200 calories of brownies all day.. you're fine.
  • FrankiesSaysRelax
    FrankiesSaysRelax Posts: 403 Member
    nope.

    that's the technical answer. Doesn't matter what you eat- as long as you are under.

    NOW. here's the rub.

    It's MUCH MUCH harder to stay under calories when you eat "junk" food. You aren't filling your body with stuff it can utlize- it's typically lop sided- carb sugar crap- so by the end of the day you're still hungry and need some protein.. and then you eat more- because you're still needing something.

    When I get sick- all I want is soup- grilled cheese- and then ice cream. I want NOTHING else. And I do my best to stay at/around calories- but it's harder because my diet is less balanced than normal.

    As long as you are only eating 1200 calories of brownies all day.. you're fine.

    This. Although I'm sure you could eat a lot more than 1200 and still lose.. but that's not relevant to the question at hand.
  • 3laine75
    3laine75 Posts: 3,069 Member
    ^ what she said.

    haha this is me every weekend - (by the time i've had my breakfast (at about 2pm :D) i'm left with about 500 cals) don't worry about it.
  • wendyg311
    wendyg311 Posts: 239 Member
    Whew! Thank you for taking my question seriously.
  • You can also feed what your body is craving using healthier food. There are many charts that will help you match your cravings to healthier alternatives. You can use those to help target your personal cravings.

    When I am craving chocolate for example I mash an avocado with cocoa powder and add some raw powdered sugar (not icing sugar, but that might work too). The avocado ads a creamy texture, the cocoa adds the chocolate flavour, and the sugar offsets the bitterness. I add enough that it would be like bittersweet bakers' chocolate. It also packs great nutritional value so I'm not going back again and again.

    If I want chips what I am usually looking for is crunch, vitamin E, and salt so I might have a few salted almonds, either with my chocolate avocado concoction, by themselves, or with some frozen greek yogurt (the texture is better than frozen regular yogurt).

    The other key is to not eat blindly. Take the time to weigh, measure, and record your food. Drink a cup of tea or glass of water.

    You also burn an extra 5% in the 5-7 days leading up to, and the first few days of, your cycle. So a week with an extra 80 calories or so.
  • JoRocka
    JoRocka Posts: 17,525 Member
    You can also feed what your body is craving using healthier food. There are many charts that will help you match your cravings to healthier alternatives. You can use those to help target your personal cravings.

    When I am craving chocolate for example I mash an avocado with cocoa powder and add some raw powdered sugar (not icing sugar, but that might work too). The avocado ads a creamy texture, the cocoa adds the chocolate flavour, and the sugar offsets the bitterness. I add enough that it would be like bittersweet bakers' chocolate. It also packs great nutritional value so I'm not going back again and again.

    if you crave chocolate... just eat the chocolate. My bowl of ice cream or square of chocolate is an equal amount of a calories as an avocado is.
  • I hear you sister. I'm pmsing at the moment and ate a plate of Nando's for dinner. Woops and it's weigh day tomorrow. Blurggg
  • Francl27
    Francl27 Posts: 26,371 Member
    Are you really surprised that you're craving stuff and binging if you're only eating 1200 calories with 64 lbs to lose? This is exactly why 1200 calorie diets usually don't work. But if you can stay under 1200 calories just eating junk, good for you I guess.
  • Okay, I can't help but respond to this because I think you deserve a good answer. This is based on my own experience, but I really strongly believe that not all calories are created the same. I eat 1200 calories of junk and I'm gaining weight the next morning. 1200 calories of fruits, veggies, unprocessed stuff... I might lose a lb or 2 over night. It's pretty much water weight, but it's still discouraging to see the bulge the next day.
    JoRocka was right to a certain extent. You eat the junk and it will leave you still feeling unsatisfied, but honestly if you eat 1200 cal of junk and that's it... I find it VERY hard to believe you will be losing weight, if you do.. it will be difficult.
    Exercise goes a long way too, water and lots of exercise (and by exercise I mean like body weight/toning that you can do at home...push-ups, vertical leg lefts, lunges)... that time of the month, I usually just eat what I want, TRY to stay reasonable with it and then just get back to it afterwards.
  • Alluminati
    Alluminati Posts: 6,208 Member
    Okay, I can't help but respond to this because I think you deserve a good answer. This is based on my own experience, but I really strongly believe that not all calories are created the same. I eat 1200 calories of junk and I'm gaining weight the next morning. 1200 calories of fruits, veggies, unprocessed stuff... I might lose a lb or 2 over night. It's pretty much water weight, but it's still discouraging to see the bulge the next day.
    JoRocka was right to a certain extent. You eat the junk and it will leave you still feeling unsatisfied, but honestly if you eat 1200 cal of junk and that's it... I find it VERY hard to believe you will be losing weight, if you do.. it will be difficult.
    Exercise goes a long way too, water and lots of exercise (and by exercise I mean like body weight/toning that you can do at home...push-ups, vertical leg lefts, lunges)... that time of the month, I usually just eat what I want, TRY to stay reasonable with it and then just get back to it afterwards.

    Huh?
  • Cindyinpg
    Cindyinpg Posts: 3,902 Member
    Are you really surprised that you're craving stuff and binging if you're only eating 1200 calories with 64 lbs to lose? This is exactly why 1200 calorie diets usually don't work. But if you can stay under 1200 calories just eating junk, good for you I guess.
    This was my thought as well. Maybe try upping your calories a little and incorporating treats more often. It will make the journey far easier and more pleasant. And no foods are junk, some are more nutrient dense than others, but they all can be incorporated into a healthy lifestyle and you will still lose weight if you eat at a calorie deficit. Period. I've lost 121lbs in 15 months and I have ice cream everyday.
  • wendyg311
    wendyg311 Posts: 239 Member
    The 1200 cals was the # provided by MFP. I really do well outside of these few days. Perhaps it is something to consider, to up the calories when I know this time is coming with REAL food, and still incorporate some treats so I don't feel like I am depriving myself
  • Mongognom
    Mongognom Posts: 123
    If you eat it every day you wont get all vitamins and minerals, but once in a while? Once in a while I eat 1900 calories in a day, which is my maintenance number of calories.
  • Cindyinpg
    Cindyinpg Posts: 3,902 Member
    If you eat it every day you wont get all vitamins and minerals, but once in a while? Once in a while I eat 1900 calories in a day, which is my maintenance number of calories.
    Meh, I eat 'junk' everyday and still hit my macro/micro/fiber targets. It can be done with a bit of forethought.
  • ashleyapplewhite
    ashleyapplewhite Posts: 83 Member
    Okay, I can't help but respond to this because I think you deserve a good answer. This is based on my own experience, but I really strongly believe that not all calories are created the same. I eat 1200 calories of junk and I'm gaining weight the next morning. 1200 calories of fruits, veggies, unprocessed stuff... I might lose a lb or 2 over night. It's pretty much water weight, but it's still discouraging to see the bulge the next day.
    JoRocka was right to a certain extent. You eat the junk and it will leave you still feeling unsatisfied, but honestly if you eat 1200 cal of junk and that's it... I find it VERY hard to believe you will be losing weight, if you do.. it will be difficult.
    Exercise goes a long way too, water and lots of exercise (and by exercise I mean like body weight/toning that you can do at home...push-ups, vertical leg lefts, lunges)... that time of the month, I usually just eat what I want, TRY to stay reasonable with it and then just get back to it afterwards.

    This is totally me, except I believe the processed "junk" has more sodium than natural, whole foods, which is why you see the gain. I also believe drinking plenty of water is important- the more water I drink, the less I crave processed junk, and then less fluctuation I see on the scale. But, everyone is different, and everyone's body reacts differently.
  • You can also feed what your body is craving using healthier food. There are many charts that will help you match your cravings to healthier alternatives. You can use those to help target your personal cravings.

    When I am craving chocolate for example I mash an avocado with cocoa powder and add some raw powdered sugar (not icing sugar, but that might work too). The avocado ads a creamy texture, the cocoa adds the chocolate flavour, and the sugar offsets the bitterness. I add enough that it would be like bittersweet bakers' chocolate. It also packs great nutritional value so I'm not going back again and again.

    if you crave chocolate... just eat the chocolate. My bowl of ice cream or square of chocolate is an equal amount of a calories as an avocado is.

    It's not about the calories for me. I use exercise to deal with the pain so I usually have a significant calorie deficit. It's about the nutrition, or nutrient make up. If I eat straight chocolate (especially milk chocolate) I keep going back again and again and it really mess up my blood sugar. If I have the avocado mixture it gets rid of my craving and keeps my blood sugar fairly stable.

    But yes in general chocolate and ice cream are phenomenal...especially together.
  • hookilau
    hookilau Posts: 3,134 Member
    You can also feed what your body is craving using healthier food. There are many charts that will help you match your cravings to healthier alternatives. You can use those to help target your personal cravings.

    When I am craving chocolate for example I mash an avocado with cocoa powder and add some raw powdered sugar (not icing sugar, but that might work too). The avocado ads a creamy texture, the cocoa adds the chocolate flavour, and the sugar offsets the bitterness. I add enough that it would be like bittersweet bakers' chocolate. It also packs great nutritional value so I'm not going back again and again.

    if you crave chocolate... just eat the chocolate. My bowl of ice cream or square of chocolate is an equal amount of a calories as an avocado is.

    I agree. When shark week rolls around, I just go with it. For me, it only lasts a few hours the evening before breaking bad so it's only a few hours. I'm T2D so I can't go bananas, but I do have that square of dark chocolate and some ice cream. My diet's quite restrictive to begin with so my 'treats' probably pale in comparison to a normal person's :blushing:

    PS...becoming more active will allot you additional calories that may make things a bit easier
  • RenewedRunner
    RenewedRunner Posts: 423 Member
    My body would up and revolt if I tried to tell it that avocado colored with some cocoa powder was the same as Hagan Daas chcolate ice cream. I may do some stupid stuff, but I know what ice cream tastes like!
  • My body would up and revolt if I tried to tell it that avocado colored with some cocoa powder was the same as Hagan Daas chcolate ice cream. I may do some stupid stuff, but I know what ice cream tastes like!

    This made me laugh. I had this image of your arms suddenly flailing around, smacking the bowl, screaming "Not the HAGAN DAAS! NOT THE HAGAN DAAS!"

    Thanks for the chuckle.
  • Feisty_one
    Feisty_one Posts: 81 Member
    My body would up and revolt if I tried to tell it that avocado colored with some cocoa powder was the same as Hagan Daas chcolate ice cream. I may do some stupid stuff, but I know what ice cream tastes like!

    giggle
  • candiceh3
    candiceh3 Posts: 379 Member
    IIFYM - go to town!
  • JoRocka
    JoRocka Posts: 17,525 Member
    My body would up and revolt if I tried to tell it that avocado colored with some cocoa powder was the same as Hagan Daas chcolate ice cream. I may do some stupid stuff, but I know what ice cream tastes like!

    This made me laugh. I had this image of your arms suddenly flailing around, smacking the bowl, screaming "Not the HAGAN DAAS! NOT THE HAGAN DAAS!"

    Thanks for the chuckle.

    LOL hey if the avacado works for- I'm glad you worked something out!!

    And yes- the rebelling against it- LMAO. Awesome. Love it. I think it would be like one of those antacid commercials!!!
  • Francl27
    Francl27 Posts: 26,371 Member
    The 1200 cals was the # provided by MFP. I really do well outside of these few days. Perhaps it is something to consider, to up the calories when I know this time is coming with REAL food, and still incorporate some treats so I don't feel like I am depriving myself

    Because you picked 2 lbs a week. You don't have to lose 2 lb a week. 1 lb a week is plenty and makes for a healthier weight loss (and heck, even with the 1 lb a week setting I've averaged 1.5 lb a week so far). Up your calories, incorporate your treats, you'll be less likely to binge and will be much happier, believe me.