We are pleased to announce that on March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor will be introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the upcoming changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

Does anyone OVER estimate what they eat?

narmowen
narmowen Posts: 18 Member
edited February 5 in Food and Nutrition
If I'm logging homemade food (or anything that doesn't have a barcode), I overestimate in my logs because I know I'll tend to go "Well, that wasn't quite a serving of mashed potatoes, so I can still eat a bunch of chips after dinner." By overestimating on things I'm sure I'm mentally underestimating, I'm trying to keep a more accurate account of what I'm eating.

So my one omelet I have for breakfast becomes 1.15, because I add a bit more ham than what it should be (according to my excel spreadsheet I use to figure out calories per serving for homemade things). The homemade muffins? I actually under estimate with those because according to the box, it's 210 for 12 servings (per serving, so each box makes 12) whereas I make 18 out of a box.

Anyone else do this for their log?
«1

Replies

  • JcMey3r
    JcMey3r Posts: 431 Member
    I overestimate on small things but the bigger things I weigh. can't really go wrong with weighing your food.
  • Francl27
    Francl27 Posts: 26,371 Member
    That's why I weigh. If I have to estimate something, because I ate out, or my scale turned off after I put the cream cheese on the bagel (like this morning... bleh), I'll overestimate a bit.

    Muffins and stuff I just divide by 12 and won't bother weighing each muffin. Why can't you divide by 18 if you're making 18?
  • JoRocka
    JoRocka Posts: 17,525 Member
    I do.

    I over estimate food- either volumes or stuff that isn't getting weighed at all and under estimate workouts.

    safer that way.
  • pyrowill
    pyrowill Posts: 1,163 Member
    I just try to be as accurate as possible. Overestimating too much can be almost as damaging as underestimating.
  • DrewMontoya
    DrewMontoya Posts: 77 Member
    Yup. I add a 20% factor of safety on everything I have to estimate; If I think that piece of meat is 8 oz, I log it at 9.6 oz. Of course, at my weight, going under isn't going to hurt me.

    As others have said, I'd much rather weigh everything.
  • avskk
    avskk Posts: 1,787 Member
    I overestimate recipe servings. I'll set a recipe as 4 servings but actually get 7 or 8 servings from it. This is because I'm too lazy to weigh the total recipe, then portion it out, then weigh each portion or the remainder in the pot, etc. I figure it's better to set a larger portion size to leave some wiggle room since I serve homemade stuff by eyeballing.
  • Swiftdogs
    Swiftdogs Posts: 328 Member
    If I have to estimate a portion, I always inflate my first guess by a percentage based on how big a WAG it is. If I have to guess portion size AND pick the closest match out of the database, I may even double it.
  • seilidhe
    seilidhe Posts: 1,042 Member
    I always try to overestimate, but I wouldn't be surprised if my overestimation is actually underestimated... But so far, it seems to be working for me.
  • conniemaxwell5
    conniemaxwell5 Posts: 943 Member
    I enter the recipes and divide by the number of servings and try to measure as accurately as possible. When I start 'fudging' the numbers I'm more apt to cheat them so I try to just put them in as close as I can.
  • JustinePalin
    JustinePalin Posts: 4
    I don't overestimate what I eat, but I do knock off about 100-200 calories that my hrm says, depending on what I'm doing.
  • yogicarl
    yogicarl Posts: 1,260 Member
    This week has been a great teacher. Last weekend I strained a back muscle and any exercise has been out of the question so - no calories to eat back.

    I have eaten my calculated TDEE calories but with no exercise calories to eat back I have been losing around 0.5lbs every day this week.

    So I conclude that I overestimate how many calories I am burning in exercise and possibly have food calories about right; possibly even slightly under what they should be.

    I'll be eating back half of my exercise calories when I am able to work out again to address the balance.
  • Confuzzled4ever
    Confuzzled4ever Posts: 2,860 Member
    I thought I was getting things pretty accurate.. but I was over by a lot! Once I started weighing things I get to eat more now.. and i'm much much happier :)
  • Pooks1n1Schmoops
    Pooks1n1Schmoops Posts: 199 Member
    I do and it doesn't work. There's so many variances in calories, especially on here. Like, how many calories is 1/2 of browned hamburger. Does anyone know?????? Lol it makes me crazy sometimes, but I just try to do my best.
  • ClementineGeorg
    ClementineGeorg Posts: 505 Member
    I over estimate only when I eat what I didn't cook, because I can't really know what goes in. And most day I eat at cafeterias with my coworkers.

    I don't over estimate at home. I don't see the point. I log the ingredients myself. I don't log omelette, I log the eggs and each ingredient separate. And I make every recipies using the tools MFP gives me.

    Why search omelette on MFP and over estimate, when I can log 2 eggs, 35 g of bacon and 35 g of cheese?
  • Pooks1n1Schmoops
    Pooks1n1Schmoops Posts: 199 Member
    If I have to estimate a portion, I always inflate my first guess by a percentage based on how big a WAG it is. If I have to guess portion size AND pick the closest match out of the database, I may even double it.

    What is a WAG?
  • bkyoun
    bkyoun Posts: 371 Member
    If I have to estimate a portion, I always inflate my first guess by a percentage based on how big a WAG it is. If I have to guess portion size AND pick the closest match out of the database, I may even double it.

    What is a WAG?

    Wild A** Guess
  • Ang108
    Ang108 Posts: 1,706 Member
    I almost never do, because I feel for me it would be the foot in the door for cheating myself. I measure everything or weigh it and log accordingly. However if for example a piece of chicken breast is 95 grs, I still log 100grs, because it's easier. But I won't allow myself to eat something extra because of the five grs difference.
    Due to age and height I eat 1200 calories a day and make each and every calorie count. That goes in both directions, because I neither want to under eat, nor do I have a big margin for careless or inaccurate logging.
  • bcf7683
    bcf7683 Posts: 1,653 Member
    If it's something like a casserole that I can cut into exactly 6 (or however many it serves) no. But if it's a heaping skillet full of some kind of concoction that you just take scoops of I usually over estimate how many calories I'm getting. Otherwise, I'll measure out my portions of meat, veggies, etc. so they're close to exact
  • bcattoes
    bcattoes Posts: 17,299 Member
    Well, since I don't weigh or measure anything, I'm sure I do. No doubt I sometimes over estimate and sometimes under estimate, though I don't do either purposely. But since I lost and maintained the loss, I guess it all evens out in the in.
  • cwolfman13
    cwolfman13 Posts: 41,865 Member
    I do and it doesn't work. There's so many variances in calories, especially on here. Like, how many calories is 1/2 of browned hamburger. Does anyone know?????? Lol it makes me crazy sometimes, but I just try to do my best.

    Pretty much everything in the data base can be done by weight...you're just not looking things up correctly. Just look up whatever % your ground beef is....i.e. "80/20 ground beef USDA"...the browning of said beef is not going to substantially alter the calorie content.
  • Pooks1n1Schmoops
    Pooks1n1Schmoops Posts: 199 Member
    If I have to estimate a portion, I always inflate my first guess by a percentage based on how big a WAG it is. If I have to guess portion size AND pick the closest match out of the database, I may even double it.

    What is a WAG?

    Wild A** Guess

    Lol I was way over-thinking that
  • nmpoli
    nmpoli Posts: 17 Member
    I always overestimate... and try to underestimate workouts. I think overestimating is the lesser of two evils.
  • nytrifisoul
    nytrifisoul Posts: 499 Member
    I always over estimate because i like to drink a few beers more then a few times a week, and sometimes i lose count..lol So i always over estimate and i dont eat back my exercise calories. Seems to work great for me. Now that i brought up drinking, anyone else sometimes exercise while drunk?:drinker:
  • bcattoes
    bcattoes Posts: 17,299 Member
    I always over estimate because i like to drink a few beers more then a few times a week, and sometimes i lose count..lol So i always over estimate and i dont eat back my exercise calories. Seems to work great for me. Now that i brought up drinking, anyone else sometimes exercise while drunk?:drinker:

    Sure, I do. Dancing, naturally. But, my husband and I often hike through the woods after or while drinking. We even tote along a softside cooler of beer and/or a bottle of wine to keep the buzz going. I love being in the woods when tipsy.
  • nytrifisoul
    nytrifisoul Posts: 499 Member


    Sure, I do. Dancing, naturally. But, my husband and I often hike through the woods after or while drinking. We even tote along a softside cooler of beer and/or a bottle of wine to keep the buzz going. I love being in the woods when tipsy.

    Glad there someone else out there that enjoys exercise while buzzed/drunk. It may just be me, but I sometimes feel more energetic exercising while drunk, more then my morning exercise routine. I even have less of a hangover the next morning because i think i sweat out most of the alcohol/impurities.

    We are definitely in the minority, and im expecting some critics on their high horse to respond.
  • Swiftdogs
    Swiftdogs Posts: 328 Member
    If I have to estimate a portion, I always inflate my first guess by a percentage based on how big a WAG it is. If I have to guess portion size AND pick the closest match out of the database, I may even double it.

    What is a WAG?

    Wild A** Guess

    Lol I was way over-thinking that

    Sorry :tongue: If there's some sort of support (e.g. "That bowl looks like it's about a cup.") then it may be a SWAG - Statistical Wild A** Guess
  • narmowen
    narmowen Posts: 18 Member


    Muffins and stuff I just divide by 12 and won't bother weighing each muffin. Why can't you divide by 18 if you're making 18?

    I do. ;)

    I just have NO interest at all in weighing my food. None at all. And I really can't be the only one (according to some responses here, I'm not.)
  • _EndGame_
    _EndGame_ Posts: 770 Member
    If I don't know the weight of something, I always overestimate.
  • sumlo30
    sumlo30 Posts: 1
    I do overestimate on my portions. I may add an extra tbs of creamer for my coffee or the milk in my cereal. I am sure there are small things I eat that may not get logged and do count. I feel it helps keep a more accurate count. I would rather over than under!!
  • LaLa482
    LaLa482 Posts: 82 Member
    I also am an over estimator. I also underestimated my workout calories. It just makes me feel better...I can't explain it.
This discussion has been closed.

Categories