We are pleased to announce that on March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor will be introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the upcoming changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

Stationary bike or elliptical?

KintsugiCurlyQueen
KintsugiCurlyQueen Posts: 68 Member
edited February 5 in Fitness and Exercise
So, my shins are screaming at me to take a long break from pounding the treadmill. I'm gutted (especially after forking out for running shoes!), but I know it's not the end of the world. Something needs to go in its place, though. Something low impact. Something ideal for HIIT workouts. I already lift 3/4 times a week - this is just for a small cardio workout on a couple of non-lifting days (on which days I can't make it to the gym to use their equipment).

My main contenders are the bike and elliptical, I guess. Could somebody help me come to a decision, please? :)

Replies

  • DiKoehler
    DiKoehler Posts: 65 Member
    love my elliptical but if you are looking for higher intensity go with the bike. I get shin splints too and have to be pretty careful. great exercises out there to get over them--don't neglect them.
  • lucan07
    lucan07 Posts: 509
    Its a personal preference which do you prefer using, I prefer the Elliptical but have both and a rower all quality items purchased in new condition from Ebay for less than a fraction of the price of any one new, if you have the room look for the bargains otherwise I rate the Rower as best workout Elliptical 2nd and Exercise bike last.
  • losing4799
    losing4799 Posts: 83
    bike can hurt my back... I like the ellip.
  • KintsugiCurlyQueen
    KintsugiCurlyQueen Posts: 68 Member
    Thanks! When you say great exercises to get over them, what do you mean?
  • Leeann1979
    Leeann1979 Posts: 1,090 Member
    I have both in my living room, and I get a better workout with the elliptical. I've always found I can get my heart rate higher and get a good sweat on from it better than the bike. But that's just me :)
  • thegilly6
    thegilly6 Posts: 137 Member
    While I love my real bike and would use it over the elliptical, I would still prefer the elliptical over the stationary bike due to the upper body movement. I love it when my shoulders and/or chest are sore. It warms them right up and relieves the pain. I vote elliptical.
  • BethAnnC448
    BethAnnC448 Posts: 45 Member
    I am doing my stationary bike..the elliptical gave me a strain in the groin area...hurt like hell for a few weeks..I was told that I was not relaxing my upper legs (according to my brother who is a weight lifter)..may try it again but will have to do it alot slower.
  • KintsugiCurlyQueen
    KintsugiCurlyQueen Posts: 68 Member
    Thank you ladies and gents - at the moment it's looking like the elliptical! Although more personal opinions are welcome :)
  • KintsugiCurlyQueen
    KintsugiCurlyQueen Posts: 68 Member
    Interesting! http://voices.yahoo.com/elliptical-machine-vs-stationary-bike-weight-loss-8400167.html?cat=50
    I just can't imagine HIIT on an elliptical, that's the thing.
  • kaz159
    kaz159 Posts: 1
    I prefer the elliptical over the stationary bike. I never feel I've pushed myself on the bike (got rid of it yonks ago).

    I like cycling so hoping for a road bike for Christmas :)
  • lucan07
    lucan07 Posts: 509
    Interesting! http://voices.yahoo.com/elliptical-machine-vs-stationary-bike-weight-loss-8400167.html?cat=50
    I just can't imagine HIIT on an elliptical, that's the thing.


    It simple to do HIIT on the Elliptical one of my workouts:

    Warm Up 5:00 min:sec 40 to 45 spm
    Repeat 3 Times
    Interval 0:15 min:sec 50 to 55 spm
    Interval 0:45 min:sec 40 to 45 spm
    Repeat 3 Times
    Interval 0:15 min:sec 55 to 60 spm
    Interval 0:45 min:sec 40 to 45 spm
    Repeat 3 Times
    Interval 0:15 min:sec 60 to 65 spm
    Interval 0:45 min:sec 40:00 to 45spm
    Repeat 3 Times
    Interval 0:30 min:sec 55 to 60 spm
    Interval 0:30 min:sec 40 to 45 spm
    Recovery 2:00 min:sec None
    Repeat 3 Times
    Interval 0:30 min:sec 60 to 65 spm
    Interval 0:30 min:sec 40 to 45 spm
    Cool Down 5:00 min:sec 30 to 40 spm

    Adjust resistance etc as required to make it work for you
  • april1445
    april1445 Posts: 334
    My heart rate goes higher and I can maintain longer on the elliptical compared to the bike. I would vote elliptical every time. Plus it's easier to "dance".
  • AmyMgetsfit
    AmyMgetsfit Posts: 636 Member
    I have a treadmill, elliptical, stationary bike and a water rower. I use these in the winter since I am a wuss and don't exercise outdoors when it is below 30. I love the elliptical and the water rower because I can use my arms. A stationary just isn't the same as a real bike since your arms are just sitting there. At least on a real bike you have to control it. The water rower also gives my abs a good workout and it is very low impact. I can do HIIT on all 4 of them.
  • Michelle_dirtracer
    Michelle_dirtracer Posts: 245
    I prefer the bike. But my favorite is the Arc trainer for lower body.
  • kt2007
    kt2007 Posts: 302 Member
    ELLIPTICAL!!! the only way to go. If I am getting on a bike its going to be for a real ride.
  • jonathandavid_t
    jonathandavid_t Posts: 107 Member
    Which do you prefer in the gym?

    HIIT on an elliptical isn't difficult; I just turn resistance up and down and change my speed at the same time.
  • bmqbonnie
    bmqbonnie Posts: 836 Member
    I find HIIT to be easier to accomplish on an arc trainer than elliptical. I can't get my HR up very high on the elliptical but going hard on the arc trainer I can make it skyrocket.
  • theloftlady
    theloftlady Posts: 74 Member
    The rower hurts my back and the bike hurts my kness, so I have to us the elliptical trainer....and I love it. Low impact and a great calorie burner, sweat maker!
  • heatedarrow
    heatedarrow Posts: 9
    While most have a personal preference of one over the other (elliptical for me), I found its always good to change it up once in a while. I found I plateaued a bit after doing the same elliptical program for ~1.5 months. I've now switched from the traditional elliptical to the total body crossramp, and it seems to be giving me a more intense workout with the preset "fat burn" program.
  • msf74
    msf74 Posts: 3,498 Member
    Doesn't really matter. Intensity is intensity be it on the bike or the elliptical.

    Do the one you prefer and you feel comfortable using.

    Personally, I think the bike is the better option for ease of control when doing HIIT but that's just me.
  • VeroniqueBoilard
    VeroniqueBoilard Posts: 71 Member
    Do this, it will change your life: http://www.gizmodo.com.au/2012/04/banish-shin-splints-forever-with-one-magical-exercise/

    Do it everyday for a week or two and then twice per week is enough... Good luck ;)
This discussion has been closed.

Categories