PALEO: pros, cons and whatever else you may think?
Replies
-
Because there is no logic. Of course folks like johnny think "iffym" is some how not a diet....
So, say there is a way of eating that masses of people follow for generations. It's healthy and sustainable. Then, someone comes along and gives this way of eating a name, say for example, the Mediterranean Diet. Now this time proven healthy diet is suddenly silly? I don't see the logic there.0 -
I couldnt go strictly Paleo and cut out everything! BUT, about 9 months ago I did a modified version of it, limiting dairy, sugar and carbs but not eliminating it all together and it was a good kick start for me. Am literally about to do the same thing. I don't like to say I am doing any particular "Diet" ... rather I am changing my diet up since I have been sitting at the same number for a while now!
I would ignore the Haters comments, focus on what you think will work for you. Best of luck in whatever you choose.
This is where I'm at with Paleo as well. I honestly just FEEL better when I'm not eating wheat, grains, and dairy. I'm not 100% Paleo, but I do try to stick fairly close to it because of how I feel when I'm eating within the Paleo lifestyle.
There are tons of good recipes out there that I've found taste pretty darn good. It can get expensive...but the only time I notice it's expensive is when I'm buying the almond flours, grass fed beef, and coconut stuff (oil, palm sugar, flour, and butter). I've even made cupcakes that were Paleo-friendly.
My biggest frustration is making trips to multiple stores when shopping because it seems I can never get everything I want in one store. Darn smaller town life! 0 -
Yes, it's silly because "The Mediterranean Diet" doesn't accurately capture how any actual individual, let alone an entire culture, eats. It's a silly condensed list of "eat this not that" that doesn't allow for the flexibility and variation found in "the real thing."
If you took "The Mediterranean Diet" and applied it to how anyone living around the Mediterranean actually eats, you'd see that they don't actually follow "The Mediterranean Diet."
The Mediterranean Diet does not have a "don't eat this" this. It's more like eat plenty of this, and not too much of this guidelines. And it is based on how people in the Mediterranean region have historically eaten. Certainly not all of them, because we are talking about people here.0 -
Because there is no logic. Of course folks like johnny think "iffym" is some how not a diet....
Very good point.0 -
It's really stupid and illogical to think that what one eats has anything to do with one's health.
(PS. Go to the Primal/Paleo support group forum and ask this question.)0 -
The same folks who say "eating clean" is vague, but don't fret over "lifting heavy".
Very good point.
Your point about mediterranean diet is fabulous. And funny thing, my eating most closely fits it or South Beach. It seems logical, til you label it, then folks get weird about it. (And I started eating this way before SB was published.)0 -
It's really stupid and illogical to think that what one eats has anything to do with one's health.
(PS. Go to the Primal/Paleo support group forum and ask this question.)
Yes, be sure you only get your information about a fad diet plan from the people who follow it. Don't ever listen to anyone who decided not to follow the fad diet!0 -
Yes, be sure you only get your information about a fad diet plan from the people who follow it. Don't ever listen to anyone who decided not to follow the fad diet!
Yes, be sure you only get your information from people who have NO experience with the lifestyle.0 -
It's really stupid and illogical to think that what one eats has anything to do with one's health.
Um .. what? Certainly food alone does not determine health, but what we eat can certainly have a significant impact on our health.0 -
You state Grain Fed beef / Meats.... I always thought it was supposed to be GRASS FED meats? Because Grain causes the same problem in animals as they do in humans. So I thought... not an expert by any means and not saying you are wrong, you seem to be way more experienced in this than me, just a question.
What problems? Are you suggesting that a lot of cows have celiac disease?0 -
Yes, be sure you only get your information from people who have NO experience with the lifestyle.
That doesn't make any sense. When deciding whether to adopt a fad diet, it makes sense to get the pros and cons and other information from both people who have adopted the diet and people who have not adopted the diet.
Would you base your decision on whether to become an evangelical Christian by only talking to people at the local evangelical Church?0 -
So, say there is a way of eating that masses of people follow for generations. It's healthy and sustainable. Then, someone comes along and gives this way of eating a name, say for example, the Mediterranean Diet. Now this time proven healthy diet is suddenly silly? I don't see the logic there.
But there is no such thing as the "Mediterranean Diet" in real life. It only exists as a marketing concept in books and diet programs.
Hell, there are at least three distinct "Italian Diets" alone, never mind all the other ethnic groups ringing the Med.0 -
woops! did i post in the wrong spot? ive been a member for about 18 months and never posted before...rookie mistake.
ive already cut out bread for the most part, my boyfriend is into powerlifting so we tend to go through phases of him eating 0 carbs for a few weeks and then transitioning, etc.
every time i've tried to cut out carbs entirely the first week is brutal. thats why i was thinking maybe paleo would be a bit easier and more sustainable.
Be sure to eat plenty of sweet potatoes, squash...etc. to keep your carbs up if you're doing intense exercise (like CF)0 -
You state Grain Fed beef / Meats.... I always thought it was supposed to be GRASS FED meats? Because Grain causes the same problem in animals as they do in humans. So I thought... not an expert by any means and not saying you are wrong, you seem to be way more experienced in this than me, just a question.
The irony is that CAFO-raised animals more closely resemble those that our ancestors would have actually been able to catch than do grass-fed animals.
The grass fed mantra provides no nutritional benefits to the meat - and I make that statement as someone who free-ranges his own heritage breed pigs and chickens.
And sweet potatoes have no place at all in any diet with the word "Paleo" in the title, as they are an extremely recent, post-agrarian addition to the human diet. If they are allowed, there is no rational basis to keep *anything* out.0 -
looooove me some paleo. ive been primal/paleo for a year and a half. i love how the food tastes and how great i feel. check the primal/paleo group on here.0
-
The whole idea is to sell books.
Right from the Whole30 (registered trademark) home page:
"LET US CHANGE YOUR LIFE. $14.95. SIGN UP NOW."
Except that the information on their website was (and still is) free for years before they ever published a book.0 -
But there is no such thing as the "Mediterranean Diet" in real life. It only exists as a marketing concept in books and diet programs.
Hell, there are at least three distinct "Italian Diets" alone, never mind all the other ethnic groups ringing the Med.
Exactly. The "Mediterranean Diet" just doesn't exist as a natural thing anywhere. It's a fad diet.
IIFYM is not a diet. It's a general nutrient intake strategy. Just like "counting calories" is not a diet with "good" and "bad" foods. IIFYM is literally "make sure you consume nutrients in the quantities supported by science."0 -
Except that the information on their website was (and still is) free for years before they ever published a book.
Again, doesn't matter.
Endomondo is free for use. However, the site doesn't exist for your personal benefit. It's a business designed to get you to purchase Pro subscriptions.
Whole30 is a business. Their business is selling books and website subscriptions. That's their reason for existence. That's their business model.0 -
Having a diet similar to Atkins/Paleo/Primal has literally changed my life. I think I have a sensitivity to foods with yeast, sugar and/or gluten in them, so obviously this is the diet for me. I have done a lean protein/veggie diet on and off for about 15 years. In college, it was hard (and I really didn't stick with it), so that's when I was at my highest weight - too much beer & pizza. As soon as I got serious about it, I started to lose, and then my WLS kept me from consuming such massive quantities of food.
Try it for a month (you really need to do a whole month for all of the benefits). If you feel good, go with it. If you don't, then change it up. But I know that for me, I feel and look my best when I do protein (especially beef) and veggies. Fruit to a lesser extent, but it's great in smoothies.
Caution: you may become cranky when you cut out soda and sugar. I was awful to be around for about days 2-5, but after that... felt SO much better. I think once you get with it, you really won't crave anything sugary.
Good luck!0 -
I don't consider myself Paleo, but I like a lot of the Paleo recipes and the general concepts. I still eat some cheese and I do eat legumes.0
-
Exactly. The "Mediterranean Diet" just doesn't exist as a natural thing anywhere. It's a fad diet.
IIFYM is not a diet. It's a general nutrient intake strategy. Just like "counting calories" is not a diet with "good" and "bad" foods. IIFYM is literally "make sure you consume nutrients in the quantities supported by science."
definition of Diet - the kinds of food that a person, animal, or community habitually eats.
Whenever someone discusses their "diet", this is the definition I assume because it is the definition I think about my own diet. Yes, IIFYM is a diet.0 -
definition of Diet - the kinds of food that a person, animal, or community habitually eats.
Whenever someone discusses their "diet", this is the definition I assume because it is the definition I think about my own diet. Yes, IIFYM is a diet.
Derp. Calling IIFYM a diet while also calling Atkins/Mediterranean Diet/South Beach Diet/Paleo/Primal/whatever a diet is pointless.
IIFYM is not a diet by your definition because it does not have anything to do with the foods a person, animal, or community habitually eats. It doesn't prescribe or recommend any particular food, and it doesn't ban or discourage any particular food.
It's just a saying that means (and comes from) "you can eat whatever you want as long as it fits your macros."0 -
definition of Diet - the kinds of food that a person, animal, or community habitually eats.
Whenever someone discusses their "diet", this is the definition I assume because it is the definition I think about my own diet. Yes, IIFYM is a diet.
To be pedantic: IIFYM is a plan or philosophy around which your diet is based.0 -
Your probably going to get a lot of flack here on the main boards, but I eat mostly Paleo (actually more Primal) and I love it. To be truthful, I've just cut out grains for the most part. I came to the diet because I wanted to drop about 8 lbs and was tired of being hungry. By cutting grain, I actually lost 10 lbs, no longer have cravings, am rarely hungry, and am leaner and lighter than I was in high school.
Pretty much identical story here- I was at a plateau-ish phase, cut out grains and added sugars, and promptly dropped another 5-10lbs. That weight came off in about six weeks, as opposed to the strict calories in-calories out model that I was following previously, where it took me much longer to lose the weight, even with the same 500 calorie deficit every day.
In my body, I've definitely come to the conclusion that a calorie is not just a calorie. When I ditched grains and added sugar, which was terrifying at first.. I was thinking WHAT THE HECK WILL I EAT?! Well, honestly it was pretty easy to replace bread with avocados. And tastier in my opinion.
Also, I no longer have crazy sugar cravings. I can eat a Fuji apple and consider it a dessert, and it tastes awesome with cinnamon sprinkled on it :-)
The only things I consider to be cons of my eating switcheroo is the cost of decent meat and all the people on this site that tend to attack anyone who doesn't think carbs should make up 40% of your caloric intake for the day.0 -
To be pedantic: IIFYM is a plan or philosophy around which your diet is based.
Exactly. You can employ IIFYM in the context of any diet. You can do IIFYM while following the Mediterranean Diet. You can do IIFYM while eating paleo. You can do IIFYM while eating a raw food diet. You can do IIFYM while cutting, maintaining, or bulking.
It doesn't matter. IIFYM is not about any particular foods. It's just a saying that encourages people to eat whatever they want to eat as long as it fits their nutrient targets.
It's not a diet by any definition of the word diet.0 -
To be pedantic: IIFYM is a plan or philosophy around which your diet is based.
Well, not my diet, but yes.
I like pedantic.0 -
IIFYM doesn't work for everyone - especially those with lower calorie needs or those who are trying to use food to assist healing health conditions.0
-
Or maybe better said a lot of foods blow my macros out of the water in a hot minute.
One reasonably healthy typical Subway sandwich can be a half a day's calories.0 -
Or maybe better said a lot of foods blow my macros out of the water in a hot minute.
One reasonably healthy typical Subway sandwich can be a half a day's calories.
IIFYM works for everyone. You seem to be under the impression that IIFYM encourages people to eat pizza or something. It doesn't.
Eat whatever you like, as long as it fits your macros. Obviously things like preference, caloric density, satiety, etc will play a part in whatever foods you decide to eat.0 -
Great article on livestrong about paleo snacks:
http://www.livestrong.com/slideshow/1008207-18-paleo-snacks-under-200-calories/0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 395.6K Introduce Yourself
- 44.1K Getting Started
- 260.7K Health and Weight Loss
- 176.3K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.7K Fitness and Exercise
- 446 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153.2K Motivation and Support
- 8.2K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 4.3K MyFitnessPal Information
- 16 News and Announcements
- 1.3K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.9K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions