Will my fitness routine help me lose weight?

erickaaf
erickaaf Posts: 18
edited February 6 in Health and Weight Loss
Please help fitness friends! I just started a workout routine 3 months ago and enjoy focusing on strength training and some light cardio. 1-2 times a week I also incorporate a metabolic workout similar to a crossfit routine. I started training with hopes of losing weight and toning but so far I have gained 8lbs. Am I wrong to think my body will eventually cut fat with these type of workouts? I've thought about increasing the cardio but would have to sacrifice some strength training to make time for it (which I want to avoid) I would greatly appreciate any feedback, thanks!
«1

Replies

  • XTSH
    XTSH Posts: 129 Member
    Actually, you should start thinking about changing your diet first.
  • Whoops I should have mentioned that too! I've cut out alot of my carb intake and increased my lean protein consumption with lots of veggies. I still have my cheat days but I try to stay at around 1300 calories. Days I workout, I allow a little more. Hope to start seeing results soon. Maybe I should eliminate cheat days altogether or cut more calories?
  • And I'm also using usana meal replacement as well.
  • samrockrocks
    samrockrocks Posts: 251 Member
    I'm told by my trainer that it's 60% diet and 30% exercise. Stop the cheat days. His advice to me was to allow three "cheat" meals a week. It's all about the quality of food you eat. Are you basing that 1300 calorie goal on your TDEE? You should. There's a bunch of calculators online or figure about 10-12 calories for each pound.
  • Thanks, I'm not familiar with the TDEE but I'll look into it! I was just doing 1300 cal based on my gender, weight, height, and goal weight. It was provided by the app.
  • samrockrocks
    samrockrocks Posts: 251 Member
    I followed the app guidelines for a long time. They aren't working for me! You should look into the right settings for your carbs/proteins/fats ratio. I had to change those default settings as well. I was just told this week to start aiming for .7 grams of protein per pound a day. For me that's 100 grams a day! Definitely not what I was shooting for before! We'll see how it works, but the past three days I've gotten up to about 70 grams a day and have only managed to eat about 1300-1400 net calories each day because I'm so full!

    Good luck :)
  • melaniecheeks
    melaniecheeks Posts: 6,349 Member
    Diet will help you lose weight, exercise will help you look and feel good.

    Im not sure what meal replacements will do for you.
  • Thanks so much! I'm definitely going to look into that!:)
  • SuperCrsa
    SuperCrsa Posts: 790 Member
    I would agree with most posters that its about diet first. Get that nailed and you will lose weight.
    Calorie deficit = Weight loss.

    With strength training I only started 2 months ago and the scale is not my friend. All girls who are weight training experience the same thing. Look at measurements and how your body looks (progress pics!)

    Good luck! :smile:
  • Makes sense:) I guess I was just hoping working out would create a big enough deficit in calories lol stricter diet it is!

    The meal replacement shakes I'm using are high fiber and protein. I drink them in the morning because I was skipping breakfast before I started working out. I'm not a breakfast person, so I just have them to start my metabolism in the morning.
  • heybales
    heybales Posts: 18,842 Member
    Are you following the MPF method correctly?

    You should only be trying to lose 1/2 lb weekly since only 10 lbs to lose.

    More than that you are just stressing your body out too much, and it'll fight against fat loss.

    Also, you should be logging your lifting and other workouts and eating back those exercise calories, to maintain that reasonable 1/2 lb weekly loss.

    MFP strength training is about right for calorie burn, it may seem low to cardio of same time, or compared to a HRM, but it's more correct.

    You need to log those and eat them back.

    When you have a lot to lose you can do a bunch of stuff wrong and still see results of weight loss (of course, done wrong it's some muscle mass too).
    But when you have little to lose, you better do a bunch right or it'll be a bad battle, with your body losing.
  • Thank you! That's so true, my scale has been stuck on the same number the past 2 months! I do think I've lost inches from my pics tho, should have measured!

    Thank you for the advice:)
  • SuperCrsa
    SuperCrsa Posts: 790 Member
    Can I suggest that you dont create too big a deficit, try and make sure that your nett calories (total left after a days food minus all calories burnt in exercise) is not less that 1200.

    I noticed that by upping my eating I lost more than I did by creating the big deficits :)
    I like the TDEE method that some posters suggested, I switched over from MFP calories (and a LOW calorie diet) to that and I am seeing much more progress.

    If you would like to check out your food a good site to calculate your TDEE (Food you need for a full day) and BMR (what your body needs in calories if you were to lie in bed all day) my favourite site is : http://scoobysworkshop.com/calorie-calculator/
  • Thank you! I calculated my TDEE (woo!) and after a usual workout I would still be below my BDR! If you don't mind me asking, did you eat the 6 meals a day it suggested for your weight loss?
  • I'm actually trying to lose 20lbs total, but 10 is my first goal:) I tried to log some of my workouts in the app but noticed for most of the lifting workouts I do, they did not have a calorie burn for!:( I calculated from my friends' body bug that I was burning about 600 cal per hour during our workouts. So I just keep that in mind:)
  • SuperCrsa
    SuperCrsa Posts: 790 Member
    Nah I dont worry about how many meals, just make sure I get all my meals in my calories.
    I sometimes skip breakfast and have a shake only, then eat a huge lunch and a small dinner, or no breakfast no lunch and a big dinner. Its calories in vs calories out. Some people do a thing called intermitant fasting.

    Ive now learned since joining this site that meal times dont matter, I cant eat breakfast early else I get hungrier. Its all about the calories in vs calories out :)
  • Thanks! I'll remember that! It's great to have advice from another girl that focuses on lifting too, I really appreciate it!

    I've heard that before too, good to know times don't matter because that's hard to manage!

    Thank you for being so helpful! Best of luck on your fitness journey! :)
  • If you really were in a calorie deficit, you would lose weight.
    So you are either over estimating your calorie burn or you under estimate what you eat.

    Do you weigh everything you eat?
  • darrensurrey
    darrensurrey Posts: 3,942 Member
    Read this: http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/654536-in-place-of-a-road-map-2-0-revised-7-2-12

    (There may be a more recent version - anyone?)

    Looking at your photo, you don't need to lose weight. I'd focus on strength training looking to get stronger by one of the established routines. I wouldn't even bother doing cardio or eating at a deficit. Eat at TDEE and let the changes in your body deal with the fat. Watch in the mirror as you get leaner but OMG you don't lose weight! ;)

    As for food, keep protein levels high eg minimum 140g. No need for supplements/shakes.
  • I have a food scale but never use it! Lol I just started watching calories so I'm expecting some results soon. I've had significant muscle gain in my biceps, triceps, shoulders and back. Legs are catching up from a month long injury. I think if I was solely doing cardio I would definitely have lost weight on the scale, but I do a lot of weights, pull-ups, push-ups, deadlifts, squats, etc. with the purpose of gaining muscle. So I'm not sure if that's affecting my lack of results on the scale. Not gonna lie I could clean up my eating habits a bit more, but I'm still eating healthier than before I started working out.
  • darrensurrey
    darrensurrey Posts: 3,942 Member
    Sounds good. Don't worry too much about eating healthily. Just keep your calories and protein levels right and the food you end up eating will have a tendency to be right (basically you don't get high levels of protein in junk food like cookies so you tend to end up eating healthier anyway if you have a particular goal of developing strength but that's not to say you can't eat cookies).
  • I have a food scale but never use it! Lol I just started watching calories so I'm expecting some results soon. I've had significant muscle gain in my biceps, triceps, shoulders and back. Legs are catching up from a month long injury. I think if I was solely doing cardio I would definitely have lost weight on the scale, but I do a lot of weights, pull-ups, push-ups, deadlifts, squats, etc. with the purpose of gaining muscle. So I'm not sure if that's affecting my lack of results on the scale. Not gonna lie I could clean up my eating habits a bit more, but I'm still eating healthier than before I started working out.

    You are not in a calorie deficit then.
    Weigh EVERYTHING you eat.

    If your main goal is to build muscle, you'd be better off with the advise darrensurrey gave you, though. But even if that's what you're gonna do, weigh your food. You can't log accurately with only "guesstimating" your intake.

    The impulse for weight loss is not if you work out or not - it's the calorie deficit. Cardio isn't needed, you can create that deficit only through your diet. Lift heavy weights & get enough protein in to keep your lean body mass and eat in a deficit - that's it (if you want to lose fat - if you'd rather focus on building muscle, darrensurrey is right).
  • Honey, I never said I was at a deficit. And my goal is not solely weight loss, it's muscle gain with fat loss.
  • Honey, I never said I was at a deficit. And my goal is not solely weight loss, it's muscle gain with fat loss.

    Well, the thread name is "Will my fitness routine help me lose weight?".

    No, it wont.
  • Thank you Darrensurrey! That makes sense (even though it got me thinking of cookies now lol) and don't let the pic fool ya. I got plenty to lose lol
  • Lol well there's a few people in this post that think otherwise. Why don't you go eat a cookie, you sound hungry. @drop_it_like_a_squat
  • Thanks gustaaf85, gonna shift my attention away from the scale! Getting a BF measurement this weekend, so at least I'll know where to go from there
  • danofthedead1979
    danofthedead1979 Posts: 362 Member
    Please help fitness friends! I just started a workout routine 3 months ago and enjoy focusing on strength training and some light cardio. 1-2 times a week I also incorporate a metabolic workout similar to a crossfit routine. I started training with hopes of losing weight and toning but so far I have gained 8lbs. Am I wrong to think my body will eventually cut fat with these type of workouts? I've thought about increasing the cardio but would have to sacrifice some strength training to make time for it (which I want to avoid) I would greatly appreciate any feedback, thanks!

    You need to focus on diet to lose weight. Exercise can help, but you need to maintain a calorie deficit first and foremost to lose weight effectively. You don't need to bust your *kitten* in the gym.

    Diet - to lose weight
    Exercise - to be fit and healthy
  • Lol well there's a few people in this post that think otherwise. Why don't you go eat a cookie, you sound hungry. @drop_it_like_a_squat

    It's not my fault you're obviously lagging some communication skills. If you ask in the title if this or that will help you frickin' lose weight of course I assume that's what you want.

    Good luck with your fat loss/muscle gain/maintance/bulk. Not sure what's en vogue right now.
  • mitchiemo
    mitchiemo Posts: 61 Member
    Hi - I posted a similar thread a few days ago because I too started strength training about 4 weeks ago in a gym and like you have put on weight (3kg,about 6.6 pounds). I said I thought I was doing everything right and was shocked at the results of my hard work (I've been lifting heavy). Lots of people commented that it was all down to diet because I admitted that I'd not been completing a log. BUT...I've now logged 4 days and as I expected I've not been over eating and have had a calorie deficit. I've logged honestly and it is no different to what I eat normally because, you see, I logged back in May/June and consequently changed my eating habits. Some of the people who commented on my thread were a little demoralising towards me so I did some research of my own. Weight gain can be caused by other factors besides extra calories - stress, lack of sleep, medication, menopause, menstrual cycle, eating too little, not eating often enough, water retention, and medical conditions. Admittedly I've not been sleeping too well recently so I'm going to see if that is actually a factor. But, I also think there is something in an initial weight gain once you start out with heavy lifting, especially if you're not over weight like you and me and are just wanting to tone up. I'd be interested to see how you get on in a few more weeks. Good luck!
This discussion has been closed.