Why am I not losing Weight?!!!!
Replies
-
-You're incorrectly logging food
-You're not in a caloric deficit
-You're not eating the proper foods so that your body wants to burn fat (I'm not say there are fat burning foods, but you can't build a fire with no wood)
She's said that she is logging her food, being honest about it and coming in at her 1200 calorie goal. What you just said is in effect calling her a liar - that's kind of rude, don't you think?
Sweetie - there are many things that prevent weight loss or cause weight gain - stress, not enough sleep, medication, not eating enough, not eating often enough, medical problems, menstrual cycle, water retention, fat being replaced with muscle tissue. When someone is not over weight it is also much much harder to lose weight. My advice keep doing what you are doing because it is a healthy lifestyle thing, throw out your scales and concentrate on the tape measure and what you look like in the mirror. Good luck!0 -
First, you eat a lot of sodium. Second, do not eat all of your exercise calories because mfp overestimates them. Try to eat half to 3/4. Increase your protein % and decrease the carbs. Your body is also adjusting because you only recently went from eating under 1000 calories daily to your current level.0
-
When I first joined, I worked out for 2 months straight before I started to lose. People said something about my body realizing that this was not a fight or flight situation, but regular activity. Don't eat too little or else you get overly fatigued and hangry. Stick with it. Also, if you are having a hard time at 1200 calories, realize that in order to stay 120-130, you have to make a lifestyle change, or else a year or two down the road, you'll be back at 150. I started out much higher than you, but keep with it and you will notice a change soon.0
-
From the looks of your diary, you aren't eating the right foods and you aren't eating 1200 calories many days. Some days you aren't even meeting the 1200 calories, other days you are going super far past it. Try to reel in the eating and stay more consistent along with exercise and see what happens. It sucks but you gotta sacrifice some things if you want to get to a goal, then slowly reintroduce those things back into your diet in moderation.
For me, 1200 never worked, I felt like I was starving myself and I wasn't losing weight, upped it to 1500 and I started to lose weight. I work out 6-7 days a week for at least an hour every time, so I wasn't giving my body back what it needed at 1200. At 1500, I feel I am not starving and the weight started to melt off.
I suggest weight training as well. I didn't start really seeing some difference in the way my body looked (not just the scale) until I started picking up weights and putting them back down, repeat.0 -
After looking at your diary...It looks like you eat alot of packaged foods. Have you thought about changing to clean eating for most of your diet. It does take some planning, but I bet you would see amazing results.
I think your body is just craving to have you give it the right kinds of foods.
I would love to share some food ideas with you. Isent you a friend request.0 -
-You're incorrectly logging food
-You're not in a caloric deficit
-You're not eating the proper foods so that your body wants to burn fat (I'm not say there are fat burning foods, but you can't build a fire with no wood)
She's said that she is logging her food, being honest about it and coming in at her 1200 calorie goal. What you just said is in effect calling her a liar - that's kind of rude, don't you think?
That is not necessarily calling her a liar. She may think she is logging correctly, but maybe is not weighing her foods properly or there could be other factors that make the logging not accurate. Or perhaps the caloric burn logged was not the actual correct burn, unbeknownst to her. All Of Which could affect the deficit/surplus balance.0 -
Wow thanks One Throne. I will check it out. I do eat alot of carbs...been trying to cut back on that.
carbs do not make you fat...you do not need to eliminate them or cut them down..
unless of course you have some underlying medical condition ..
If you are not losing weight then you are more then likely under estimating how many calories you are actually consuming..
Do you log everything? Weight your food (yes I am going to be that guy)?
if you have only been doing this four weeks, then I would give your current program another four week and see how it goes..it takes your body 4-6 weeks to adjust to a new regimen..0 -
You're not building muscle but if you've upped exercise recently, you could be retaining water for muscle repair. Make sure you're drinking lots of water. That's helped me.
Why do you say she's not building muscle? Muscles repair is muscle growth!
you can't build muscle in a calorie deficit...
and OP said she is sometimes only eating 1000 cals...., which will not leave enough emerge for building muscle...0 -
After looking at your diary...It looks like you eat alot of packaged foods. Have you thought about changing to clean eating for most of your diet. It does take some planning, but I bet you would see amazing results.
I think your body is just craving to have you give it the right kinds of foods.
I would love to share some food ideas with you. Isent you a friend request.
calorie deficit leads to weight loss...not "clean" eating...0 -
you said you are eating 1200 a day but I looked over your diary and it looks like for the last week you are netting around 1600..
Also, you need to be careful with what MFP says you are burning...they tend to over estimate..
I would say only eat back half of your exercise calories and see how that goes...
you are pretty high on sodium, so drinking a crap ton of water to help flush that out would not be a bad idea...0 -
I"m wondering if you are eating enough each day. If you are only eating 1200 calories and working out where you are burning a lot of calories, then you will not lose weight. You must eat your full amount of calories without exercise and then if you exercise you should add healthy protiens to your meal. Let me know if that helps.0
-
Some things I noticed about your diary. You really are not creating a deficit, in fact a lot of days you are over. To lose weight you must create a deficit of 3,500 calories a week ( that's what creates -1lb) so split over 7 days, that is a 500 calorie deficit a day. Also, 1200 calories is really low if you are working out hard. The best thing to do is to purchase a heart rate monitor and wear it all day for 3 days of inactivity. Record each calorie amount and average it to determine your base cals. Then, going forward wear it for workouts to determine actual calories burned to know an accurate reading. I found that my base burn was actually around 1600 - 1800 calories, not 1200 and then I was burning between 800-1100 calories a workout. So at a minimum I would need to eat at least 2,000 calories on active days.
You should also be measuring all your food, not estimating. I think it might surprise you how much you are actually eating. Also re-balance your foods. The mobile app provides a pie chart of carb/fat/protein breakdown that you should adhere to. 50% of your day should be made up in carbs, the rest fresh veggies and protein. Its all about balance. Another big tip is to pack or cook all meals possible - you remain in control of what you are eating and are not able to make poor decisions in the moment. It also stops you from eating out and not truly knowing what is in your food. If you have a busy week, prep in advance. Clean and wash lettuce, chop veggies and fruit, and pack lunches on Sunday.
Often people misunderstand that losing weight entails a lot more than just "eating less," They focus on calorie count as opposed to what they are actually consuming and how to make life changes that are effective and sustainable.0 -
I don't think she needs to worry about not eating enough, I think she needs to worry about over eating because MFP told her she burned "such and such" calories. I basically take what MFP says about how many calories I burn with a grain of salt.0
-
-You're incorrectly logging food
-You're not in a caloric deficit
-You're not eating the proper foods so that your body wants to burn fat (I'm not say there are fat burning foods, but you can't build a fire with no wood)
She's said that she is logging her food, being honest about it and coming in at her 1200 calorie goal. What you just said is in effect calling her a liar - that's kind of rude, don't you think?
That is not necessarily calling her a liar. She may think she is logging correctly, but maybe is not weighing her foods properly or there could be other factors that make the logging not accurate. Or perhaps the caloric burn logged was not the actual correct burn, unbeknownst to her. All Of Which could affect the deficit/surplus balance.
Mmmm - I wouldn't say that the MFP food database is exactly accurate anyway because most of it is user input. Everybody is an individual and their body has different needs. What someone may advise, even in good spirit, may be completely wrong. Like all those people who think that cutting carbs is the way forward - maybe it worked for them but whose to say it will work for others. Plus, does she have a food intolerance that makes her digestive system function differently?. I think that becoming a logger of absolutely everything (unless you're a professional athlete) is a bit extreme, verging on OCD, and somewhat unrealistic. The point is that she is doing an important and healthy lifestyle thing. She should be getting support, positive comments, and encouragement, not someone being blunt and implying that she's not being honest.0 -
This is why I love iifym and scoobyworkshop calculators. I got sick of guessing burns and just calculated my exercise level on there and it gives me how much I should eat without having to muddle through what I really burned. Though, even that's an estimate. It's trial and error.0
-
-You're incorrectly logging food
-You're not in a caloric deficit
-You're not eating the proper foods so that your body wants to burn fat (I'm not say there are fat burning foods, but you can't build a fire with no wood)
She's said that she is logging her food, being honest about it and coming in at her 1200 calorie goal. What you just said is in effect calling her a liar - that's kind of rude, don't you think?
That is not necessarily calling her a liar. She may think she is logging correctly, but maybe is not weighing her foods properly or there could be other factors that make the logging not accurate. Or perhaps the caloric burn logged was not the actual correct burn, unbeknownst to her. All Of Which could affect the deficit/surplus balance.
Mmmm - I wouldn't say that the MFP food database is exactly accurate anyway because most of it is user input. Everybody is an individual and their body has different needs. What someone may advise, even in good spirit, may be completely wrong. Like all those people who think that cutting carbs is the way forward - maybe it worked for them but whose to say it will work for others. Plus, does she have a food intolerance that makes her digestive system function differently?. I think that becoming a logger of absolutely everything (unless you're a professional athlete) is a bit extreme, verging on OCD, and somewhat unrealistic. The point is that she is doing an important and healthy lifestyle thing. She should be getting support, positive comments, and encouragement, not someone being blunt and implying that she's not being honest.
why be on a calorie counting and logging site if you are not going to log everything? If you eat a piece of cake and don't log it, does that mean it does not count towards your calorie count?
If you want to hold yourself accountable and have long term changes and success then you should log/weigh everything; other wise you are just cheating yourself.
< Not an athlete and not OCD and I log everything because it makes me accountable as to what I am putting in my bod.0 -
-You're incorrectly logging food
-You're not in a caloric deficit
-You're not eating the proper foods so that your body wants to burn fat (I'm not say there are fat burning foods, but you can't build a fire with no wood)
She's said that she is logging her food, being honest about it and coming in at her 1200 calorie goal. What you just said is in effect calling her a liar - that's kind of rude, don't you think?
That is not necessarily calling her a liar. She may think she is logging correctly, but maybe is not weighing her foods properly or there could be other factors that make the logging not accurate. Or perhaps the caloric burn logged was not the actual correct burn, unbeknownst to her. All Of Which could affect the deficit/surplus balance.
Mmmm - I wouldn't say that the MFP food database is exactly accurate anyway because most of it is user input. Everybody is an individual and their body has different needs. What someone may advise, even in good spirit, may be completely wrong. Like all those people who think that cutting carbs is the way forward - maybe it worked for them but whose to say it will work for others. Plus, does she have a food intolerance that makes her digestive system function differently?. I think that becoming a logger of absolutely everything (unless you're a professional athlete) is a bit extreme, verging on OCD, and somewhat unrealistic. The point is that she is doing an important and healthy lifestyle thing. She should be getting support, positive comments, and encouragement, not someone being blunt and implying that she's not being honest.
why be on a calorie counting and logging site if you are not going to log everything? If you eat a piece of cake and don't log it, does that mean it does not count towards your calorie count?
If you want to hold yourself accountable and have long term changes and success then you should log/weigh everything; other wise you are just cheating yourself.
< Not an athlete and not OCD and I log everything because it makes me accountable as to what I am putting in my bod.
100% agree. I keep my diary private, but you'd see that last night I went over my calories because I had 4 beers. I could have very well not logged those and made it look as though I stayed under my calories but the whole point of me being on here is to hold myself accountable for the things I am putting into my body.0 -
-You're incorrectly logging food
-You're not in a caloric deficit
-You're not eating the proper foods so that your body wants to burn fat (I'm not say there are fat burning foods, but you can't build a fire with no wood)
She's said that she is logging her food, being honest about it and coming in at her 1200 calorie goal. What you just said is in effect calling her a liar - that's kind of rude, don't you think?
That is not necessarily calling her a liar. She may think she is logging correctly, but maybe is not weighing her foods properly or there could be other factors that make the logging not accurate. Or perhaps the caloric burn logged was not the actual correct burn, unbeknownst to her. All Of Which could affect the deficit/surplus balance.
Mmmm - I wouldn't say that the MFP food database is exactly accurate anyway because most of it is user input. Everybody is an individual and their body has different needs. What someone may advise, even in good spirit, may be completely wrong. Like all those people who think that cutting carbs is the way forward - maybe it worked for them but whose to say it will work for others. Plus, does she have a food intolerance that makes her digestive system function differently?. I think that becoming a logger of absolutely everything (unless you're a professional athlete) is a bit extreme, verging on OCD, and somewhat unrealistic. The point is that she is doing an important and healthy lifestyle thing. She should be getting support, positive comments, and encouragement, not someone being blunt and implying that she's not being honest.
why be on a calorie counting and logging site if you are not going to log everything? If you eat a piece of cake and don't log it, does that mean it does not count towards your calorie count?
If you want to hold yourself accountable and have long term changes and success then you should log/weigh everything; other wise you are just cheating yourself.
< Not an athlete and not OCD and I log everything because it makes me accountable as to what I am putting in my bod.
I log every so often to make sure I'm roughly eating enough. I'm also on here to get support and encouragement although sometimes people seem happier to criticise rather than give support - and that was my point!0 -
I don't think she needs to worry about not eating enough, I think she needs to worry about over eating because MFP told her she burned "such and such" calories. I basically take what MFP says about how many calories I burn with a grain of salt.
I completely agree, her recent diary shows her at no deficit. But I also don't think she actually knows what she's putting in her mouth and what she's actually burning. I think a heart rate monitor would greatly help in that are or a fit bit, it helped me a lot.0 -
-You're incorrectly logging food
-You're not in a caloric deficit
-You're not eating the proper foods so that your body wants to burn fat (I'm not say there are fat burning foods, but you can't build a fire with no wood)
She's said that she is logging her food, being honest about it and coming in at her 1200 calorie goal. What you just said is in effect calling her a liar - that's kind of rude, don't you think?
That is not necessarily calling her a liar. She may think she is logging correctly, but maybe is not weighing her foods properly or there could be other factors that make the logging not accurate. Or perhaps the caloric burn logged was not the actual correct burn, unbeknownst to her. All Of Which could affect the deficit/surplus balance.
Mmmm - I wouldn't say that the MFP food database is exactly accurate anyway because most of it is user input. Everybody is an individual and their body has different needs. What someone may advise, even in good spirit, may be completely wrong. Like all those people who think that cutting carbs is the way forward - maybe it worked for them but whose to say it will work for others. Plus, does she have a food intolerance that makes her digestive system function differently?. I think that becoming a logger of absolutely everything (unless you're a professional athlete) is a bit extreme, verging on OCD, and somewhat unrealistic. The point is that she is doing an important and healthy lifestyle thing. She should be getting support, positive comments, and encouragement, not someone being blunt and implying that she's not being honest.
why be on a calorie counting and logging site if you are not going to log everything? If you eat a piece of cake and don't log it, does that mean it does not count towards your calorie count?
If you want to hold yourself accountable and have long term changes and success then you should log/weigh everything; other wise you are just cheating yourself.
< Not an athlete and not OCD and I log everything because it makes me accountable as to what I am putting in my bod.
I log every so often to make sure I'm roughly eating enough. I'm also on here to get support and encouragement although sometimes people seem happier to criticise rather than give support - and that was my point!
if you do not want to log that is fine..but don't make a blanket statement that everyone that does is either a professional athlete, extreme, or bordering on extreme....0 -
-You're incorrectly logging food
-You're not in a caloric deficit
-You're not eating the proper foods so that your body wants to burn fat (I'm not say there are fat burning foods, but you can't build a fire with no wood)
She's said that she is logging her food, being honest about it and coming in at her 1200 calorie goal. What you just said is in effect calling her a liar - that's kind of rude, don't you think?
That is not necessarily calling her a liar. She may think she is logging correctly, but maybe is not weighing her foods properly or there could be other factors that make the logging not accurate. Or perhaps the caloric burn logged was not the actual correct burn, unbeknownst to her. All Of Which could affect the deficit/surplus balance.
Mmmm - I wouldn't say that the MFP food database is exactly accurate anyway because most of it is user input. Everybody is an individual and their body has different needs. What someone may advise, even in good spirit, may be completely wrong. Like all those people who think that cutting carbs is the way forward - maybe it worked for them but whose to say it will work for others. Plus, does she have a food intolerance that makes her digestive system function differently?. I think that becoming a logger of absolutely everything (unless you're a professional athlete) is a bit extreme, verging on OCD, and somewhat unrealistic. The point is that she is doing an important and healthy lifestyle thing. She should be getting support, positive comments, and encouragement, not someone being blunt and implying that she's not being honest.
why be on a calorie counting and logging site if you are not going to log everything? If you eat a piece of cake and don't log it, does that mean it does not count towards your calorie count?
If you want to hold yourself accountable and have long term changes and success then you should log/weigh everything; other wise you are just cheating yourself.
< Not an athlete and not OCD and I log everything because it makes me accountable as to what I am putting in my bod.
I log every so often to make sure I'm roughly eating enough. I'm also on here to get support and encouragement although sometimes people seem happier to criticise rather than give support - and that was my point!
if you do not want to log that is fine..but don't make a blanket statement that everyone that does is either a professional athlete, extreme, or bordering on extreme....
Please re read what I said - you have missed the point !0 -
What is your height and exercise level currently?
Also, I would add some veggies into my diet...
0 -
1200 and exercising daily - EAT MORE0
-
Well, I've been seriously doing this for a month now. I lost 2 lbs in the beginning and have not been able to lose since. I've been working out ALOT more though, so maybe I'm building more muscle? I still want to lose the weight though. I'm supposed to be 135 for my height and I'm 153 right now.
((
Hey, I have several friends that have had the same problem. We are now working out together, and using a specific program, and it is working out amazing. Send me a message and we can see if the program we are doing will work out for you as well
0 -
-You're incorrectly logging food
-You're not in a caloric deficit
-You're not eating the proper foods so that your body wants to burn fat (I'm not say there are fat burning foods, but you can't build a fire with no wood)
She's said that she is logging her food, being honest about it and coming in at her 1200 calorie goal. What you just said is in effect calling her a liar - that's kind of rude, don't you think?
That is not necessarily calling her a liar. She may think she is logging correctly, but maybe is not weighing her foods properly or there could be other factors that make the logging not accurate. Or perhaps the caloric burn logged was not the actual correct burn, unbeknownst to her. All Of Which could affect the deficit/surplus balance.
Mmmm - I wouldn't say that the MFP food database is exactly accurate anyway because most of it is user input. Everybody is an individual and their body has different needs. What someone may advise, even in good spirit, may be completely wrong. Like all those people who think that cutting carbs is the way forward - maybe it worked for them but whose to say it will work for others. Plus, does she have a food intolerance that makes her digestive system function differently?. I think that becoming a logger of absolutely everything (unless you're a professional athlete) is a bit extreme, verging on OCD, and somewhat unrealistic. The point is that she is doing an important and healthy lifestyle thing. She should be getting support, positive comments, and encouragement, not someone being blunt and implying that she's not being honest.
why be on a calorie counting and logging site if you are not going to log everything? If you eat a piece of cake and don't log it, does that mean it does not count towards your calorie count?
If you want to hold yourself accountable and have long term changes and success then you should log/weigh everything; other wise you are just cheating yourself.
< Not an athlete and not OCD and I log everything because it makes me accountable as to what I am putting in my bod.
I log every so often to make sure I'm roughly eating enough. I'm also on here to get support and encouragement although sometimes people seem happier to criticise rather than give support - and that was my point!
if you do not want to log that is fine..but don't make a blanket statement that everyone that does is either a professional athlete, extreme, or bordering on extreme....
Please re read what I said - you have missed the point !
"I think that becoming a logger of absolutely everything (unless you're a professional athlete) is a bit extreme, verging on OCD, and somewhat unrealistic. " < that is word for word...0 -
You're not building muscle but if you've upped exercise recently, you could be retaining water for muscle repair. Make sure you're drinking lots of water. That's helped me.
Why do you say she's not building muscle? Muscles repair is muscle growth!
you can't build muscle in a calorie deficit...
and OP said she is sometimes only eating 1000 cals...., which will not leave enough emerge for building muscle...
I was merely pointing out the contradiction! Plus what you said is a myth.0 -
You're not building muscle but if you've upped exercise recently, you could be retaining water for muscle repair. Make sure you're drinking lots of water. That's helped me.
Why do you say she's not building muscle? Muscles repair is muscle growth!
you can't build muscle in a calorie deficit...
and OP said she is sometimes only eating 1000 cals...., which will not leave enough emerge for building muscle...
I was merely pointing out the contradiction! Plus what you said is a myth.
what myth are you referring to?0 -
-You're incorrectly logging food
-You're not in a caloric deficit
-You're not eating the proper foods so that your body wants to burn fat (I'm not say there are fat burning foods, but you can't build a fire with no wood)
She's said that she is logging her food, being honest about it and coming in at her 1200 calorie goal. What you just said is in effect calling her a liar - that's kind of rude, don't you think?
That is not necessarily calling her a liar. She may think she is logging correctly, but maybe is not weighing her foods properly or there could be other factors that make the logging not accurate. Or perhaps the caloric burn logged was not the actual correct burn, unbeknownst to her. All Of Which could affect the deficit/surplus balance.
Mmmm - I wouldn't say that the MFP food database is exactly accurate anyway because most of it is user input. Everybody is an individual and their body has different needs. What someone may advise, even in good spirit, may be completely wrong. Like all those people who think that cutting carbs is the way forward - maybe it worked for them but whose to say it will work for others. Plus, does she have a food intolerance that makes her digestive system function differently?. I think that becoming a logger of absolutely everything (unless you're a professional athlete) is a bit extreme, verging on OCD, and somewhat unrealistic. The point is that she is doing an important and healthy lifestyle thing. She should be getting support, positive comments, and encouragement, not someone being blunt and implying that she's not being honest.
why be on a calorie counting and logging site if you are not going to log everything? If you eat a piece of cake and don't log it, does that mean it does not count towards your calorie count?
If you want to hold yourself accountable and have long term changes and success then you should log/weigh everything; other wise you are just cheating yourself.
< Not an athlete and not OCD and I log everything because it makes me accountable as to what I am putting in my bod.
I log every so often to make sure I'm roughly eating enough. I'm also on here to get support and encouragement although sometimes people seem happier to criticise rather than give support - and that was my point!
if you do not want to log that is fine..but don't make a blanket statement that everyone that does is either a professional athlete, extreme, or bordering on extreme....
Please re read what I said - you have missed the point !
"I think that becoming a logger of absolutely everything (unless you're a professional athlete) is a bit extreme, verging on OCD, and somewhat unrealistic. " < that is word for word...
So - you picked out one sentence out of the many that I wrote and chose to take offence. Well I'm sorry that you took offence at me saying that those who log ABSOLUTELY everything, are athletes, professionals, and maybe a little obsessed, as being derogatory. That isn't what I was implying. If you don't want to consider yourself as an athlete or professional then fine. I like rock climbing, I'm obsessed with it and I don't mind admitting it. Logging everything isn't realistic for many people. I'll stress my point again - the girl needs support not blunt criticism.0 -
You're not building muscle but if you've upped exercise recently, you could be retaining water for muscle repair. Make sure you're drinking lots of water. That's helped me.
Why do you say she's not building muscle? Muscles repair is muscle growth!
you can't build muscle in a calorie deficit...
and OP said she is sometimes only eating 1000 cals...., which will not leave enough emerge for building muscle...
I was merely pointing out the contradiction! Plus what you said is a myth.
what myth are you referring to?
You can build muscle on a calorie deficit its just much much harder. And mate, why are you all guns blazing at me tonight? Chill! I'm just trying to give the girl some support.0 -
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions