When do you know when to stop? *pics*

My original goal weight was 125 lbs. I'm 5'5" and at 133 lbs, now. I am happy with size, except for some areas that I would like to improve. I know you can't spot reduce and calorie deficit is the best way to lower BF%, but at what point does one get to where they should maintain and do recomp? I've been weightlifting my whole weight loss and I'm so glad I did. I don't mind losing the final 8 lbs but would it be possible to lower BF% at my current weight? I guess, I'm confused about recomp vs deficit. Obviously, deficit would probably be quickest, but you can only take weight loss so far. I want to look strong and fit, not skinny/fat, I guess that's my concern. I've put pics so you can get an idea where I'm at currently. Sorry if I sound kind of stupid, I'm still learning.


30i80np.jpg

Replies

  • I'm sorry I don't actually have an answer for you but I wanted to say your muscles look fantastic! I agree you look great the way you are. And if you do reach a lower bf hopefully without losing too much LBM your definition is going to be great. You are a great example of why losing weights with lifting is so much better than a deficit alone.
  • my advice is cut or lean down to a point at which you are trimmer than you want to be all the time and then move to maintenance. that way, you have wiggle room over the next few months if bodyfat increases you won't be immediately unhappy.

    i would recommend doing the fat shredder diet ratio from p90x, even if you don't do p90x. i have leaned down many times, and this is by far the quickest leandown i have down by using the ratio of 50%protein, 30%carbs, 20%fat. the fat is melting off.
  • cafeaulait7
    cafeaulait7 Posts: 2,459 Member
    I think it would be a fine time to go on to maintenance calories and keep up the progressive lifting, so it would work out to more recomp than now. It depends on what you want :) Are you planning an actual bulk at all? That would be different, then.

    I like a recomp idea more than anything for myself, personally. It has slower changes, but I like the simplicity and routine of it. I feel like I'm done now that I'm in the habits, and my body will just sort itself out and I don't have to bother with that part at all :) I did it before and had great success. It takes a ton more patience, however, lol!

    edit: Oh, I track everything, though! I just mean I'm done as in done trying to figure out what to do next. I just do what I do... forever :)
  • Phoenix_Warrior
    Phoenix_Warrior Posts: 1,633 Member
    Shateyn- Thank you so much! Heavy lifting rules!!

    Parisallez- Ya, I definitely need to work on some of my ratios. Ideally, would like my protein a bit higher. I tend to be a carb fiend ;). My assumption is at 125, I might have wiggle room and option to gain, as I would love to do a bulk cycle down the road.

    Cafeaulait7- You totally helped me remember an important mention. I do want to eventually do a bulk cycle, as once I'm decently happy with recomp or cut, I would love to try to add muscle. It's all so daunting and confusing!
  • fivethreeone
    fivethreeone Posts: 8,196 Member
    It depends entirely on your body fat percentage.

    If you are 135 lbs and 23% body fat, you have more fat to lose than someone 135 pounds and 17% body fat. In the first instance, you would need to lose 9 pounds in order to be the same leanness as the second person. Women should not go below 15% body fat, as they risk hormonal disruption in doing so.

    Women interested in bulking are generally encouraged to do so once they dip under the 20% body fat mark, so that is the metric you should use to determine when to stop and when to reverse.
  • Phoenix_Warrior
    Phoenix_Warrior Posts: 1,633 Member
    It depends entirely on your body fat percentage.

    If you are 135 lbs and 23% body fat, you have more fat to lose than someone 135 pounds and 17% body fat. In the first instance, you would need to lose 9 pounds in order to be the same leanness as the second person. Women should not go below 15% body fat, as they risk hormonal disruption in doing so.

    Women interested in bulking are generally encouraged to do so once they dip under the 20% body fat mark, so that is the metric you should use to determine when to stop and when to reverse.

    This was incredibly helpful! Thank you so much! I'll have to look up accurate ways to determine BF% and go from there. Also, love your screen name!!
  • wheird
    wheird Posts: 7,963 Member
    It depends entirely on your body fat percentage.

    If you are 135 lbs and 23% body fat, you have more fat to lose than someone 135 pounds and 17% body fat. In the first instance, you would need to lose 9 pounds in order to be the same leanness as the second person. Women should not go below 15% body fat, as they risk hormonal disruption in doing so.

    Women interested in bulking are generally encouraged to do so once they dip under the 20% body fat mark, so that is the metric you should use to determine when to stop and when to reverse.

    Pretty much this.
  • slywon
    slywon Posts: 85 Member
    Bump for more info on the subject!
  • mustgetmuscles1
    mustgetmuscles1 Posts: 3,346 Member
    Yep body fat is a good indicator to use instead of weight on the scale.

    It is still possible to lower body fat with a recomp instead of a cut though. So the method of lowering body fat is still up to your goals. If you want to do a bulk later on then it is probably better to cut to a lower body fat then start but either method will work.

    If you are not in any real hurry and you are happy with your current weight and size then the recomp might be a good way to go.
  • fivethreeone
    fivethreeone Posts: 8,196 Member
    Shateyn- Thank you so much! Heavy lifting rules!!

    Parisallez- Ya, I definitely need to work on some of my ratios. Ideally, would like my protein a bit higher. I tend to be a carb fiend ;). My assumption is at 125, I might have wiggle room and option to gain, as I would love to do a bulk cycle down the road.

    Cafeaulait7- You totally helped me remember an important mention. I do want to eventually do a bulk cycle, as once I'm decently happy with recomp or cut, I would love to try to add muscle. It's all so daunting and confusing!

    One other thing: based on what you have said, you may need to consider the possibility that you don't actually have the body that you want, currently hiding under what little you have left to lose. If you lose 5 more pounds, you may not look substantially better. In that case, and especially if your body fat is under 20%, you probably would want to just move into a reverse and bulk now.

    Bulking builds your muscles up-- so when you lose the fat over the new muscle, you have to lose less fat in order to look like what you want , as your muscles have actually grown.

    The most accurate way to measure body fat percentages is with a hydrostatic "dunk" weighing test or a DEXA scan. Google hydrostatic weighing in your area, it's usually around 50 bucks. The next best method is calipers, which can be off by a fair bit, depending on technique, but they can give you a decent approximation. Any other method (like online measurements or bioelectrical impedence) is usually significantly flawed and can have a margin of error greater than 10%.
  • erinkeely4
    erinkeely4 Posts: 408 Member
    I think you look great, and look healthy. But the question is how do you FEEL?
  • astronomicals
    astronomicals Posts: 1,537 Member
    Sounds like a long cut has you burnt out and eager to lift at maintenance or a surplus.

    Id suggest a week or two at maintenance calories (full diet break). From there you can decide whether you'd like to continue cutting for a bit or go another route. The time at maintenance will be beneficial no matter what you shoose. Make sure you get the cals right. Your maintenance has changed.
  • hedgiie
    hedgiie Posts: 1,226 Member
    maybe the question is changing your goal. such as a critical obese, an athlete in off season and a body builder preparing for a competition do have various goals in mind
  • jackielou867
    jackielou867 Posts: 422 Member
    love this thread, thanks for posting. your pictures are pretty much me. I have reached goal weight and at 23% body fat have hovered between cutting or bulking. so basically I have lifted fairly heavy but only eaten at maintenance. I haven't had my stats checked, but my weight has stayed the same, so I really need to decide which way to go. Fat sits most stubbornly in my belly, arms and legs are starting to look quite toned. I just can not bring myself to eat more at the moment, so maybe I will go withthe suggestion of dropping below 20%, since I am in Australia and heading into summer. Then try a proper bulk in Winter.:smile:
  • basillowe66
    basillowe66 Posts: 432 Member
    You look great!! It is all up to you as to how much you lose. If you just continue what you are doing you will get to where you want to be.
    I've read where your body will lose, where you have to lose !!

    Basil